If you’re looking for filthy smut and no plot just vibes, this book is for you. It’s a quick read, which is actually favorable for the book given that there’s not much that goes on in it. The pace was too fast for me and the writing too casual and curse word ridden. The writing also tended to be list-y and stunted – it took me out of the story frequently. I wish that the story went beyond the surface level, but it never did. I think the idea was there, but it just needed some depth. This book wasn’t for me, but it could definitely be for someone else.

This is a why choose erotic story about 3 brothers reverse harem. It lacked a bit in actual story line and I enjoyed the totality of it but it definitely could have had a stronger story and cleaner sex scenes. As a woman, the visuals let me wishing these characters learned a bit of hygiene at some point. But if you like it dirty this is a simple quick read, as I whipped through it in two hours.2.5 or 3 ⭐️⭐️⭐️.

This was a very quick read; which is nice. I usually read a lot of “Why Chooses” and Dark Romance so this is right up my alley! The one thing that I couldn’t get past is that it felt like insta-love to me and that’s one thing I, personally, do not enjoy but I can see people enjoying this book!

2 Stars from me on this one! I am a big fan of Reverse Harem romances, so I figured this was right up my alley, but this was a little too simplistic for me. I like a better balance of smut with plot and there just wasn't enough going on here to enjoy. I felt that the connection between the characters was way too fast, with no lead up building tension or rapport with one another, which felt inauthentic.

While I like how each brother had his own personality and brought something different to the relationship, it just didn't feel believable at all, and I found Georgia's "southern" stereotype a little cheesy and annoying.

I'm sure big fans of erotica heavy books with low plot to smut ratio will enjoy this, but it just wasn't for me!

For sheer smut factor, this book is a 10/10. Definitely a one handed read. But if anyone is reading for the story, there’s a lot to be desired. There isn’t a ton of believable storytelling and a lot of the dialogue is forced, but it IS an erotica for a reason. And they’re Scottish??? Beautiful.

I want to thank you for sending me this ARC.

This book was disappointing though, there was no distinct difference between each male character, the timeline was at a super speed, there were times that the sex was unhygienic and I couldn't focus on anything besides that fact and it just felt gross.
i feel bad for giving an ARC such a low rating but I had such high hopes and was let down.

From what I can tell this is Lily Manning's first RH and so far so good! This is a quick read, three Scottish brothers, and the FMC is a self proclaimed "nerd". There is essentially zero plot, a lot of spice, and some cute moments sprinkled throughout, but this was totally worth reading if you like those things.

I've read a few reverse harems so I knew what I was getting myself into. At just over 130 pages, this was a pretty quick read. And because it's so short, there isn't a lot of time to develop a plot or any character development. Straight to sex it was. The spice was there but not much else.

The three brothers situation was not for me. But if you like RH, instalove, and erotica you may enjoy this one.

My first time reading RH I didn’t love it but didn’t hate it, the spice level was mind blowing although I would have loved at bit more story.
This book isn’t my cup of tea, but if you are into RH & brothers id say go for it, was a quick read

Thanks to Netgalley for the arc in exchange for a honest review.

Apparently this is Lily's Manning first RH book and I like it.
I swear after reading this I want to jump on the next plane to Scotland and find me a Scottish hunk one or two or three ? 🥵😉
The book was fun , there was a lot of s*x like lot! No other plot tbh. But I'm down with it I don't mind 😜 I like the FMC smart girl that know what she wants and just takes it. The guys were also fun and umm hot 🔥 so I understand that whole #whychoose coz how can you if you can have them all ? #teamFinnKnoxLachlan .

Fave conversation in the book 😄
“You’re very cute and funny and …”I leave him hanging.
“With a huge schlong, an enormous ball sack, and supercharged sperm. That’s what you were going to say.”He spoons more deliciousness into my mouth as I laugh.
“Schlong?”
“Yeah, you know, my ‘silent flute,’‘Philly cheesesteak,’‘the pleasure pump.’”I choke.
“You did not just call your cock those names.”I blink through the tears of laughter.
“I’m never going to look at a Philly cheesesteak sandwich again.”

I wish only the book was longer... The whole story happened so fast 😭 I really wish it was longer. Can't wait for next book 😁

Book reviewed via NetGalley ARC.

‘Making Her Theirs’ invites you into a world where three Scottish brothers have their kilts in a twist over one woman. It’s a whirlwind of passion and love, but be forewarned, it’s got some explicit curves and controversial detours that might just raise an eyebrow.

It starts with Georgia Presley Henry who thought she was just headed to Scotland for a wee bit of work. Little did she know:


Knox, the eldest, is a force of nature, a man whose dominating presence is rivalled only by his desire to love and be loved.

Finn is all sunshine and rainbows, hiding a stormy past behind that million-dollar smile. He's the guy you warn your friends about... but secretly hope they date.

Lachlan speaks the universal language of "intense staring." No decoder ring needed. His gaze says it all, especially when words fail him (which is often).

It's straight to the point. And by point, I mean the bedroom. Definitely more heat than heart. Expect a lot of sizzle, a sprinkle of character depth, and a straight-shot to the, ahem, action.

The premise is enticing, who wouldn’t be intrigued by one woman navigating the affections of three brothers? Plus, Georgia’s got that charisma that ensures she isn’t overshadowed by the trio of testosterone around her.

The story sometimes raced towards the climax (in more ways than one) with the rapidity of a sprinter. The ‘insta-love’ phenomenon seemed to occur, well, instantly.

These scenes felt more microwave than slow-cooked. A longer format could’ve been the saving grace. Depth, connection, development – everything feels better when given time, right? Who knows, maybe the sequel will be ‘Making Her Theirs: The Extended Edition’?

This book is not aiming for a Pulitzer, and that's okay. For you like your romance novels with extra spice and unexpected (and slightly questionable) plot twists, this one’s up your alley. If you’re a fan of slow-burn romance and believable scenarios, you might want to keep browsing the bookshelf.

Reflecting on “Making Her Theirs,” it wasn’t my cup of tea (or dram of whisky), but in the grand library of life, there’s a shelf for every story, and this spicy Scottish saga will undoubtedly find its passionate readers. Here’s hoping they enjoy the rollercoaster!

Thank you to NetGalley and Innes Field for the DRC!

Based on the blurb I was expecting much more story and character development than I got. I didn’t actually make it all the way through as I realised at 70% that not only was this a novella (I’m not sure this came across in the description) but that the whole book was 10% story and 90% spice. If you’re looking for erotica then this might be for you but there just wasn’t enough plot for me.

I LOVED this Book.

Georgia is in Scotland for a business trip. She has given up on finding love because she can never be satisfied. She has sacrificed her happiness for others, but all the men she has tried to love still leave her even when she molds herself to be everything they wish for.

Things change when she meets three brothers on her first night in town that flip her world upside down. Knox is a brooding male, Finn lights up a room with his smiles, and Lachlan is thoughtful. The brothers show her what it means to be heard, loved, and cared for unconditionally.

The clear communication had me on my knees from the beginning. I was captivated by the story. It had my attention from the start, and it was never released. I was invested in the story, and the fact we had no 3rd act break-up made me so happy!

This was so spicy and I loved every minute. I am a fan of why choose. This one did not disappoint. I enjoyed the story and all the spice. I will definitely be reading more by this author. Thank you to NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for the arc in exchange for my honest review.

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/5800816822

For those who haven't read this, if you're not into SMUT and downright Book porn, do not read this!!!!
Its a mood read, and you better be in the mood and have a companion on standby lol

I enjoy a break from the serious and had a good giggle with this book! My Hubby also enjoyed it! lol

Was the book non-realistic? yes! Did it lack a little more story and relationship building? also yes! but did I enjoy it for what it was? ABSOLUTELY

Look, I'm from Texas and all the information was accurate and I've met my fair share of Georgias so I relate to her personality...just not so much with her wanting 3 men at the same time.

If you go into this read with a open carefree mind, you should enjoy it too!

Exactly what I expected - minimal plot, lots of gratuitous sex scenes with multiple partners. I didn’t really find all the character descriptions accurate - for example the oldest brother was repeatedly described as dominant but I never really saw anything showing that. Also first time anal without lube? Ouch. All in all fine for what it was. Read if you’re looking for reverse harem, brothers sharing style book with lots of sex.

I enjoy a good RH but this one just missed the spot.
There were lots of hot moments but no story. It all just kind of fell together without learning how they got to that point.
I enjoyed the spice but just wasn’t enough story to make me feel connected to the characters. Very rush.

Thanks to the publisher for providing me with the ARC!

I don't get why people who don't read RH erotica read these books and then complain.

Anyway. The book was 'no thoughts, just smut' - little to no character development, no plot, insta love etc. I always say, less is more when it comes to erotica, it's easy to overflow the pages with smut and nothing else, so it's a pity.

This is a short read, but I think it is too short, making it mostly just a raunchy type read. If that was the sole purpose than it succeeded on that front.

While the premise was interesting, I wanted more character development and more build up in getting to know each of the men. I felt like it was more like just telling us their personality types without really letting them develop through their voices and actions.

I think I needed more of a balance of plot and steamy scenes to have it more enjoyable.

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me a copy of this ARC for my honest review.

I really enjoyed see how each brother opened up to her, each with a different personality which made the book so good. I did find myself wishing I was the the FMC take me and keep me.