This is a sweet reverse harem story, with three brothers, all scorching hot and keen on making Georgia theirs.

The oldest, Knox, is the fiercely possessive and dominant brother who's holding the family together.

Charming Finn is the middle brother who approaches every day as if it's an adventure waiting to be explored to the max.

The youngest one, Lachlan, is the introvert loner who rarely lets anyone close.

They all have something to offer Georgia and together they make all her dreams come true.

As reverse harem stories come, this is rather soft, no heavy BDSM or M/M action, all rather 'mainstream' in a reverse harem context.

⭐️⭐️⭐️
💛 medium spice


Making Her Theirs is a why choose/reverse harem that’s a pretty quick and steamy read with a little more than 150 pages.

A weeklong business trip in Scotland where I meet three brothers and don’t have to choose between them - where do I apply?

I enjoy why choose romances; however, this story fell a bit flat for me. Don’t let this deter you from reading this book.

If you like these tropes, then you’ll definitely like Making Her Theirs.
- Why Choose
- Insta lust/inta love
- Found family
- Forced proximity

The author, Lily Manning, also nicely sets up the next installment in this series.

Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advanced readers copy.

Although I did not LOVE this book, I still enjoyed it. The spice was amazing! I just could not connect to the female main character as I usually would in RH books.
The way she spoke/ described things is what was hard for me.

If you love erotica, rh, all the spice, I thing you should give this book a shot!

First and foremost thank you to NetGalley for the opportunity to give my honest feedback for this ARC.

This was a rough one to finish and I was thanking ‘Jaysus’ that is was a very quick read… I don’t think I would have made it through if it was any longer.

The good: the spice was HOT! and there’s lots and lots and lots of it. Lots!

The bad: the characters all gave me the creeps and the unrealistic s*x acts and romance (if you wanna call it that) made me roll my eyes. Had this been written as a day dream, I would’ve maybe been more into it.

I was kindly given this book as an arc through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher and the author.

« With Lachlan, she’s worshipped. With Finn, she’ll have fun. With me, she wants to be dominated. »

Get your knickers ready for this book, ladies, gents, and theys?

🌸 Why choose romance
🌸 Brothers
🌸 Scottish men and slang
🌸 Insta love

Rating: 3 ⭐️
Genre: Contemporary Romance Erotica
Format: Ebook ARC
Pages: 157
Spice: 🌶️🌶️ light plot, more three detailed on-page scenes
POV: First person, POVs from all main characters
S/S: Standalone
Check trigger warnings for any book

This was a good « no plot, just spicy vibes » type of book. The writing was very easy and enjoyable. The character development was a bit light but sufficient taking into account the length of the book.

The spicy scenes were fun. A bit rushed at times, not gonna lie. They aren’t kinky if that’s what you’re looking for. It did feel as though it would be, but no.

The one thing that I saw coming from a mile was the insta love and love bombing. Not my cup of tea, knowing the timeline is 10 days. The epilogue is soooo unrealistic as well. If we’d had just a glimpse into a good fortified relationship, it would’ve been much more logical than the on we got.

Overall, this book is a fun, quick, spicy read. No complicated plot or relationships.

Leena - Leena.reader review - xoxo

I loved the short length but long story. The plot was not much but still enough to even out the spice. Very good reverse harem romance. Can't wait for book 2!

Talk about making me blush! I personally enjoyed this book, the details and story were really well developed. The ending fell a little short for me but it was one I was looking to pick up and continue. I can’t wait for the second book of the series to be released.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for allowing me to read Lily Manning's spicy spicy SPICY "Making Her Theirs" before its publication! (Did I mention it was spicy? WOWZA.)

Three Scottish brothers in a why choose, reverse harem romance. I think I died and was in heaven for the entire time I read this book. Aside from being hot as hell, I loved how much effort Manning put into making each brother completely different from the others, and showing how the main character manages to bridge the gaps between the three to make all four of them like puzzle pieces. It was hot, sweet, romantic, funny, and everything I love in a romance/erotica book!

if you enjoy reverse harem erotica, you’ll love this. i, however, have learned that i do not enjoy reverse harem erotica..

Thank you to Innes Field LLC for this e-ARC in return for my honest opinion.

Meet Georgia, a sweet but motivated woman from the Lone Star state. She’s a math major and psych minor who has done everything to achieve her goals. When her work trip brings her to Scotland for a big promotion, she meets a set of men that will forever change her life. Knox, Finn, and Lachlan are brothers whose parents have left them high and dry. They share their women, their trauma, and their businesses.

After settling into her rented flat, she goes downstairs to the local pub. She meets Finn, the bartender, then sits next to Knox at the bar. One thing leads to another and she ends up with the brothers in an alleyway. Fast forward to her reaching her door after a mind blowing orgasm, the last brother, Lachlan comes to rescue and allows her to stay with him when they can’t get the door open.

10 days, 3 brothers, 1 Georgia. This book was a wild ride for 144 pages. Within the first 20%, I was already recommending it to my book friends. The book may be a little choppy because it’s Lily Manning’s first novel, but it worked out. This is a reverse harem book and is MFMM. It does end in a HEA but I felt it was rushed. I will still give this book 4 stars due to me sitting and finishing it in 2 hours. And I’m excited to see the next book in the series!

This review will be posted on the @booksbestiesbooze Instagram and our blog at https://booksbestiesbooze.com/

ARC review

I got 10% into this before I knew it was not for me. The writing is juvenile, relying too heavily on stilted metaphors and adjectives that are supposed to be edgy but are immature, instead. Also needs editing; the FMC locks eyes with one of the MMCs and she’s drawn to him, but from his point of view in the next chapter, he sees her when she’s already standing next to him. I had enough when she launched into another monologue - this time external - about how she’s not like other girls. Nope.

I like a good smutty read every once in awhile, but the brother dynamic is not for me. The story moves quickly and doesn't have much of a plot. The ending was too unbelievable for me.

Arc!!! i liked this book alot . this was a classic erotica and i loved it . making her theirs is a reverse harem about a woman who is from america and is only there for 10 days and 3 brothers and its set in scotland . those brothers have never felt love before until they see her . this was a spicy hot romance book. it was also super sweet and i fell in love

If you're looking for a quick and spicy read this one is for you. Usually I can get down with this kind of book, but I had a difficult time getting through this one. I love anything involving even a hint of Scotland and figured I'd feel the same regarding this, but it just did not. When it comes to plot this book starts up with what could lead into an interesting full story, but very quickly becomes solely focused on the erotica. I am in full support of both plot and/or erotica, however, the opening left just enough for me to be curious what direction the story could unfold and then dropped all semblance of plot on the next page. Apparently I need a little more plot or none at all.

This book was wild, spicy and very very hot. Wow !!! As a RH or why choose romance, this was amazing actually. A girl that wants it all - being worshipped, dominated and having fun - finds it all with three brothers taking care of a bar after their parents left them to take care of themselves !!!! Switch Lochlan, Finn and Knox, Georgie got it all and she enjoyed her time while getting her HEA at the end … nothing to complain about! I’m almost jealous !!!

I started this book and found my self instantly hooked from the first few pages!
There isn’t really much of a plot tbh and it’s mostly just smut smut and a bit more smut! But it was just what I was looking at reading!
I love Georgia and the confidence she has in herself, her humorous thoughts had me smiling constantly.
Knox, Finn & Lachlan have such an amazing relationship and I love how they have stuck by each other through everything.
The smut in this book is just *chefs kiss* amazing!
I have to say I really did struggle a bit with them being brothers, especially when they were all together.
This is a quick easy fun read and I enjoyed it!
Was it cheesy? Absolutely!!
Will I be reading the next book? 100%!

Unfortunately could not finish this all the way. I am not a fan of instalove/instalust. I wanted to like it but the female main character was just too self-deprecating for me and the connection between all of them felt forced. I loved when she was confident about herself, but it didn’t match what she was saying about herself and her past relationships.
Just not for me!

Georgia goes to Scotland for a work trip, but she's also figuring out her life. She meets 3 brothers in a rather short period of time –Knox, Finn, and Lachlan. She falls for their charm, but that creates a bit more confusion in her head… and her heart.

Oh, my heavens. As they all set out to woo her, together and separately, Wowsers, the heat off of those hot men, wooeee 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 holy hotness!! This is a rather short read, but oh my dog, there is so much goodness packed in here. ❤️❤️❤️

⭐️⭐️💫

A quick, spicy read set in Edinburgh with three brothers (honestly, why choose?!).

Georgia goes to Edinburgh for work. What she finds is a trio of {seemingly} emotionally unavailable brothers, all broken from their pasts. Each man fills a different part of her soul (and body 🥵) and they fall fast and hard for each other. Spice abounds.

This read more like a novella to me! We got a surface-level glance of each character and the progression of their relationships. I loved the spice and the HEA. 💕

Thanks so much to NetGalley and the author for the ARC of this book!

4****
So I would say that I enjoyed this book but (there is a few buts...). I was not 100% on the way Georgia was balls deep into 1 but then 2 of the brothers from the get go. Then how it was all 3, it just doesn't sit right with me on personal level 1 woman and 3 brothers... Would make interesting conversation with the grandkids 😂
If you thoroughly enjoy erotica this is for 10000% for you. I felt like it was a little bit cringey, descriptively, in places also.