Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Making Her Theirs is a very short and very steamy poly novella involving Georgia and three Scottish brothers. While this may be for other readers, it was kind of a slog for me. I used to be all about the spice but I find I need an interesting plot to keep my focus and this one - because of the length - didn't have enough of a plot to keep me hooked.

While this wasn't for me, if you're looking for something short and hot, I definitely recommend picking this one up!

A book that connects some of my favorite things (literally)
I felt a personal connection with each brother and could very seriously relate to the feelings Georgia had. I found myself wishing I was her from the very beginning of the story. I am so appreciative that I was able to be an ARC reader for this and can’t wait to see what else is in store with Killian 💦❤️🔥

At 159 pages, this is a fairly short fast-paced funny reverse harem romance with Scottish men which I easily read in one sitting.

In the first few chapters, we learn of the circumstances causing Georgia to travel to Edinburgh for work and some of the issues she encounters with the flat once she arrives there but there's no real character development or plot after this. As soon as Georgia meets the 3 brothers, the story becomes very heavy on spicy scenes and we only have a few scenes with Georgia's coworkers which I would've liked to see more of. I really liked how different and well-developed Knox, Finn and Lachlan's personalities are and how well Georgia seems to be compatible with each of them.

I felt like the spicy scenes were well written and didn't feel repetitive despite the quantity but this book definitely won't be for people who want a lot of plot in the story. Overall, I enjoyed this book and would like to read more from this author in the future.

The book was good but just too quick and short for the premise of reverse harem. If this book had another 200 pages to it I imagine it would be a huge chart topper and very popular. I loved getting to know Lachlan’s character however I felt like the other brothers were just glossed over. The timeframe was also way too quick. I would have loved to see more of the relationships develop and how life between the 4 of them would work. It’s a good starter but I just needed more.

This is a great story. I really enjoyed the characters and their dynamic with each other. There is quite a bit of spicy bits but there is also real emotional bonding that is lovely to behold. This book is great, it turns you on, makes you laugh, and soothes your heart all in one go. The gift of a talented author.

If you love a spicy romance with three breathtaking men who want to meet your every need, this is the book for you. The heroin is from Texas and has arrived in Scotland to train for a new job. She will only be in the country for a month, but it will be one of the hottest months of her life.
This book provides some taboo, besides the reverse harem, that might not sit well with some readers due to the three men are also brothers.
I really enjoyed the book. It had a storyline other than just gratuitous sex and it does have a happy ever after.

If you are looking for a quick and easy read with a lot of smut then this one would most likely be for you. I think this was a great length for a novella but it could have had a little more plot to it than what it had. Before it got to all the smexy things. Overall, it wasn't badly written at all I just think it needed a little more.

Wow. This is a very intense romance. I read it in a few hours. And Jaysus, it's delicious, heavy, really erotic. There is little development of the character aspects, although we manage to define each person's personality well. But because it is well repeated at different points in the book, as if they were repeated excerpts. Honestly, I liked it, but it's not a book that will please the majority of the public. What ended up for me (and thank God it was in the last chapter) was an unexpected pregnancy micro trope. If it had happened before, I don't know if I would have liked it as much. I was very interested to know about the next book in the series with Killian's extra chapter. I have positive expectations that it will be a Reverse Harem with ⚔️. Lol, I'm one of those readers.

This book was a short read full of spice with 3 brothers and Georgia! It moved incredibly fast. If you’re looking for something short and just straight spice and multiple brothers, this is the one.

Thanks to NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for allowing me to read this ARC for my honest opinion.

First off I will say that I've only read a few reverse harem books, so with that being said I'm fairly new to how they evolve but this one seemed to jump right into the action. I felt that there was no lead up, just BAM if you know what I mean! Secondly, the story line didn't really go anywhere.

Three brothers; Knox, Lachlan, and Finn become obsessed with Georgia the minute they lay eyes on her and it's all bets are off after that. I do like the way the characters interact with each other but I felt there needed to be a little more story. It's definitely a great read for someone that loves smut, fast action, and a quick read.

If you’re looking for a book full of spice, then this is it. In fact it’s spice magnified when the reader finds herself with not one but three men, all brothers. Each encounter is instant attraction and lust. It’s a short read, so is enjoyable if you’re looking for maximum spice.

The fast pace of the book kept me engaged, but it is so short, it left me yearning for more plot. I particularly enjoyed the introspective inner monologues of the FMC and MMC, which offered glimpses into their vulnerabilities and desires. The steamy scenes were undeniably hot, but a more substantial plot could have elevated the reading experience. For example, exploring the characters' emotional journey amidst the passion could have added another layer of satisfaction without significantly affecting the length.

Thanks toNetGalley and the publisher for an eARC.

⭐️: 3.5
🌶️: 3/5

This was a quick and spicy read. There’s absolutely zero plot so if you’re looking for that this isn’t the book for you! I loved the spice but the ending ruined it for me. Her family doesn’t question her relationship at all with these men she had just met and just lets her run off into the sunset with them?! I know my realistic expectations for a book are way too high and that’s a me thing but overall I enjoyed the spice and the banter.

Holy moly .. this book starts off with a bang and keeps going until the very end!! Passion and heart between Georgia and her three men are through the roof.

The premise amd setting were what initially intrigued me. However, when I started reading, the interactions between the brothers and our protagonist seemed to make their relationship feel weird. Over time I realised, I might not be much into the multiple lovers being related because it felt really incestuous the way they were referencing each other in a sexual context. I think not much time was given to establish chemistry, though if fast past erotica is what one is looking for, I could recommend this.

Thank you NetGalley for gifting me this title to read and review.

This book wasn’t for me. I’m no stranger to RH romances but in my opinion, this fell very flat and didn’t live up to the potential of the premise. There was very little character development or plot, I think a book like this requires the reader to truly care about the main characters and there just wasn’t enough about who these people were outside of the intimate dynamic, that made you want to root for them.

If you’re looking for something spice heavy then this book definitely reaches that requirement. And as a result, it felt lacking in the romance department. Wish I liked this more.

This was such a good book. It had me tearing up a few times, but also laughing and smiling. Lily really did an amazing job on this RH!

Georgia is a true southern girl who has traveled out of the country to Scotland for a job promotion. She's a hard worker who loves numbers but is very hard on herself who feels she's not worthy of true love. Knox, Finn, and Lochlan are Scottish brothers who own a pug and the apartments above it. They've had a rough life but have come out on top as they've gotten older. They've also sworn off love because of their past. Will they be able to overcome their pain and open their hearts?

I love a reverse harem, but this one didn't do it for me. I don't know if it was because the book felt really short and didn't have much depth to it (when the potential was there to be so much more) or if I lived in Scotland for too long for this to feel "real", but I just didn't love it. That being said, I liked the characters and thought the book was well written. I don't think I'll be looking to pick up any others in the series.

If you want RH then this is for you. Also if you want a lot of smut with little plot this is also for you.

There is very minimal character development which I was sad about - I wanted to know more.

I love smut but I also love a little plot - this had maybe a speck.

Thank you NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for granting me access to this book in exchange for an honest review.

🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🥵

So this is pure smut. The sex scenes are great. Nice steam, very spicy. Is there anything else to it? Is the plot believable, are the characters developed and do I feel invested? Not really. So it’s up to the reader and what they are looking for. I enjoyed the spice!