I’m all for a good smut book and I am so grateful NetGalley gave me the chance to read this! However, the plot while started strong fell flat to me. There was no real lead up before hot and heavy other then bourbon please. Overall. It was a short and easy read, if it had been more plot to it then it definitely would’ve been 4-5 stars!

Not my normal go-to but I wanted to try something new in 2024! I enjoyed that the MC was a math whiz and going after the career she wanted. Loved the idea of a story set in Scotland! Finally, spice factor! Five stars for that. I was entertained by this short book and look forward to other stories from Lily.

If you want to read smut and don’t really care for the plot, then this is absolutely for you! The progression of their relationships and feelings was way too fast, along with the corny dialogue, for me to really get into the storyline (which I do look forward to when reading smut). I would still consider reading the next in the series if there was an interesting, less cringey plot because the spice was definitely there!

Listen I love a good smut novel I do but this is more what you'd find in the group sex area of a written smut site we've all been too. This is a rh with 3 brothers who are Scottish with a visiting American. I wanted something. She lands walks to her flat sees there is 1 chair and decides after her cross country flight to hit a pub and immediately has 2 men after her 1 cocktail... it's giving more of a mental fantasy than what you'd actually want. For me it's a no.

Georgia, a Southern Texas girl, travels to Scotland for 10 days for a work promotion assignment. She rents out an apartment owned by three brothers; Knox, Finn, and Lachlan, who also own and run the local bar. The three brothers meet strong, confident, vivacious, and gorgeous Georgia and fall head over heels in love(and lust).
Knox is the oldest. He takes care of the boys who were abandoned as little kids and have had to fend for themselves all their life. Finn the middle brother is always up for a good time with the ladies and Youngest brother Lachlan is the quiet reserved guy who misses his parents the most and has had separation trauma since; unable to have any relationships due to fear of abandonment.

They say opposites attract, and in this story, they each provide exactly what the other needs and wants. Sexy, hot, sweet light read. Erotic. Yes, it's smut in every chapter and a lil repetitive at times.
This RV, contemporary Romance, Erotic Novella is very entertaining! All. For. It.

Thank You NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for a free copy in exchange for my Honest review.

This is a mostly smutty book that is also quite short, so it's perfect for being a palette cleanser. Since it was so short, the relationships weren't fully developed, which just comes with being so short. However, it was enjoyable and great for reading in between books.

I really enjoyed this book! I enjoyed the characters and the chemistry they all had! It had a lot of spice but a rather sweet story behind it! I am looking forward to the next book after reading the teaser!

2.5 ☆

RH does it for me which is why i was originally so excited to get accepted for this e-arc from netgalley! howeverrr, i love smut as much as the next girl but i also like having a bit of plot sprinkled in & the thing is that this DID start with a plot and i was like okayyyy period, but then it fell short. the smut was good but i also can’t look past the insta love (i’m starting to notice i don’t particularly care for that trope). she had literally known the guys for 2 days and they were basically all in love… like what?? the funny thing is that they would be like she just gets me and knows me & i’m like when did that happen??? cuz all they literally did was talk for 5 mins and do the dirty. AND THENNN (🚨SPOILER🚨) in the epilogue they’re all married & she’s pregnant after 3 (or 6 i’m not sure now) months?? come on now. i also thought that the book was kinda cringey at times. anyways if you just want some RH smut with 1% plot, this is the book for you!

Making Her Theirs by Lily Manning is a addictive book.

This book is perfect for a reverse harem romance fan. This book got high sexual tension, plenty of spicy scenes, less conflict and fast paced. This is my first attempt to read a reverse harem romance and I really like it. It is easy to read since there's not many conflict and issues in the story. This book contains threesome, anal and foursome. Yup, totally spicy.

I'll definitely be looking forward towards Lily Manning and waiting for the 2nd book.

Book Review 📚
Making Her Theirs by Lily Manning - 3/5 ⭐

I was excited to read this one, and don't get me wrong their are some really good aspects to the book but as far as plot goes? It's nonexistent.

There is a whole lot of spice, can't fault that, that was right up my street, but I also require some form of plot to be able to rate it well.

The writing was great, and there is definitely some more books coming from Manning I just hope that the next ones will have some story behind it!

Thank you to NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for allowing me to read this ARC - this is an HONEST review from my own personal opinion.

Making Her Theirs by Lily Manning gives what it promises.
Georgia is a woman visiting Scotland from the US and finds herself entangled with the three attractive Scottish brothers.
Knox gives us the „Who hurt you?“ we all crave, Finn make us love him for his joking self and Lachlan truly sees us.

Making Her Theirs is a rather quick read and delves right into the relationship between our characters and their spicy adventures.
Is there a whole lot of plot if you subtract the spice? No. Did I enjoy what I read? Yes!

It’s important to note, that the book moves rather fast and there is not a lot of space for in depth character building or plot progression.
I’d recommend this book for exactly what it is, a spicy novel to enjoy a few hot hours with.

This was a super quick read!

A LOT of spice and a little plot.

The FMC has been given a promotion, but has to travel to Edinburgh from Texas for a short trip. She meets 3 brothers who fall into lust/love with her.. and I’ll let you guess the rest 😏! If you like a lot of spice then I definitely recommend giving this a read.

Thank you NetGalley and allowing me to read this book!

If you're looking for a super quick and smutty instalove RH novella with no plot or character development, this is it. I generally prefer my smut to have a little more substance, and there was just zero connection between these characters, which made the spice less spicy, personally. It could be a good palate cleanser but I was pretty underwhelmed.

Thank you to the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

This was smut for the sake of smut. No plot, a traumatizingly weird ending.

I have no problem with RH but marrying 3 brothers was bizarre.

Georgia’s finally making her way up in her career path when she takes an opportunity in Scotland for 10 days. She meets three ruggedly handsome, and extremely different brothers. None looking for love but all locking eyes with a beautiful Texan named Georgia.

This book was great until the 90% mark. It went from having the ten days be up to six months later. I wanted more at the end of the book. Maybe a longer ending and a build up to the 6 months later? It has potential to be better. I loved where it took me and I loved the background information about the characters. I just wish there was more to love without a quick cutoff ending.

This short RH read was a fun way to round out the year. It’s not for everyone, but it is for a reader who wants a high spice, low plot ratio at the end of the year. Georgia- a super smart, nerdy girl from Texas arrives in Scotland for 10 days of work at her companies office. She hits the bar on the first floor of her temporary stay and is just immediately smitten with 2 men. She’s thinking that she’s definitely going to get both their numbers… but before she can do that, she’s in the alley with both - insta lust and love! To be honest it was a bit tooo instant for me, but going into it knowing it was RH and a very short book, I did expect this. Over her short stay, Georgia manages to meet 3 brothers and fall in love with all of them, and they her, the ending was a surprise to me, and while that trope isn’t my favorite, I found it was my favorite part of the book. In the end I would have preferred a slower burn, but overall, I did enjoy this book, and I recommend to those who enjoy this genre. Looking forward to more from this author!

Oh Mmmm Geeee!!! So this was my first reverse Harem book and it was DELICIOUS! Manning wastes no time setting the scene and introducing all the seductive characters. *drip, drip*
Georgia is a girl that is trying to make it on her own, climbing a ladder of success and traveling abroad, when she stops at a local bar after her long flight and dives right into her hot and steamy yet uncharted territory of her new life.
I had a hard time putting this book down. It's short but an attention grabber from the beginning.
It also leaves a few things in the dark.... however it does help lead into a possible #2.

This was a sizzling little read - who doesn’t love three hot Scottish men worshiping a curvy woman? There wasn’t a ton of character development, but if you want a fast and smutty read, this will do the trick.

Overall, I really enjoyed the book and can’t wait to read the next in the series.

Georgia is on a work trip. She books a small, furnished room above a pub for the duration of her trip. Emotionally and sexually frustrated she decides to go explore the town. What she finds or who she finds at the pub literally splits her three ways.

Overall I enjoyed the concept of this book. However, it could use more time to develop the storyline. There was a lot of restating the same things. For example, it was stated more than six times how much the brothers loved each other and would do anything for one another. A bit corny and empty.

Character development could have gone so much deeper. Lachlan was my favorite and probably the most explored.

Now for the SMUT, SPICE AND EVERYTHING NICE. It is there. Right smack in your face very early on and throughout. The sex scenes were much more developed than the rest of the book. I imagine this book to be a mini series on cornhub. LOL. Seriously.

Overall, better development of the storyline and characters would improve this book. Loved that it was a fast read. The spicy scenes were good to me.

I would be interested in reading the next book with Darcie and Killian.

Thank you NET GALLEY for this copy in exchange for an honest review.

Unfortunately I was largely underwhelmed by this book. The plot seemed rushed with little to no substance. The character development was pretty non existent and I struggled to enjoy the spicy scenes, which were the dominating factor in this book due to the lacking in character connection and depth. I like to feel connected to the characters as if you are feeling/seeing what they are and, unfortunately I didn't get that from this book.

I really feel this story could have been so much better if more time had been taken on it and we were able to see more growth from the characters and form a better bond with them. It is am RH story so I tend to expect them to be less focused on world building and more on the spice and fast paced side of things but this can be done whilst still creating real and relatable characters and this is where it fell short for me.