2.5⭐️ rounded up

Georgia just moved to Edinburgh for a new work position and only for 10 days, luckily for her her new apartment is located above a pub owned by three attractive brothers, Knox, Finn and Lachlan, and Georgia can’t keep away and they can’t keep away from her.

Making Her Theirs is simply put smut with a little bit of plot and little to no character development. I finished it in one day so obviously it was an easy light read but know what you are going into. This is a RH with a happy ending and lots of insta love. If short smutty RH books are your cup of tea, this is the one for you!

I would like to forever repress the line about exploding ovaries, thank you but no thank you.

Thank you NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for an advanced readers copy for an honest review.

This was a pretty short reverse harem with a fair amount of spice. There's not much character development but that's usually not the focus with these types of books. It was nice to see the different personalities of the brothers, I only wish everything didn't feel so rushed. I'm not a fan of the pregnancy trope and I might me outgrowing my insta-love days. Overall, it's a quick intro to smutty RH, so give it a go if you want to test the waters....

I typically like my smut to have substance. This was a very quick read with insta-love and a RH between the FMC and 3 brothers. It contained very little plot and it was straight to the smut - so if that’s what you’re after you’ll love it.

I thought this was a great little steamy novella that you can read in one quick sitting. It takes places in beautiful Edinburgh, and I always enjoy seeing poly representation in literature. I always find works more enjoyable when there isn't any jealousy when it comes to having a poly relationship. I would recommend this book to anyone who needs a little palette cleanser and wants something short and hot!

A huge thank you to Netgalley and Sandra Manning for giving me a chance to read Making Her Theirs as an eARC in exchange for my honest review.

i simply loved it! It was the type of book to read to get you hyped and horny at the same time. Straight to the point ,steamy but albeit short (I'd wish it was longer simply so that I could see more MMMF action) it hit all the right spots with me.
Three hot Scottish men ? check.
Cute, intelligent, horny, girlboss FMC ? double check.
Steamy sexy times all around ?TRIPLE CHECK *pun intended*

If you want a short steamy read to get you into a good mood, I'd definetely recommend it.

*Thank you NetGalley and Lily Manning for this e-ARC*

Okay so this books was a lot. Heavy on the romance aspect, not much plot. I will admit some of this story was cringe, and sometimes-no most of the time- the romance was too much for me lol. I would like to try her contemporary romances, because I honestly think they're not as spicy as this book or at least I'm hoping they aren't lol. Thank you again Lily Manning and NetGalley.

SPICY WOW but also so quick to fall in love. like scary fast. It was intense and very hot but just a bit quick honestly.

This book is a hot steamy read. I couldn't put it down. Being from the DFW area I loved that the main character was from Dallas. I will definitely read more of Lily's books.

It took a bit for me to get into this but I pushed through at it was ok. It was more smut than plot in my opinion which isn’t for me but it’s an easy read for those who need a palate cleanser or something smutty.

It’s got one of my favourite tropes, reverse harem so it gets an extra star just for that.

Overall, I enjoyed it.

A strong independent woman walks into a bar and ends up falling in love with the three brothers who own it and the apartments above. That's it, that's the plot. Still a better love story than Twilight.

Anyway, moving past some very questionable safety choices on the MFC's part, I spent a few enjoyable hours making my way through this short novel. I, as a rule, generally prefer my erotica with more plot, but honestly? I still liked this book. It followed most of the main points I prefer in romance/erotica including...but not limited to.

1.) During spicy scenes, I know where everyone's limbs are. If you can't imagine the positioning, then what's the point? I did know where the limbs were.
2.) If the standard tropes apply, in this case the reverse harem, are they at least done alright? Yes.
3.) Do I regret spending the time reading it? Nah, it was a fun romp.

Making Her Theirs wasn't heavy in plot and felt more like a fanfiction, but overall Lily Manning did well. I can see more build out of this series, I just hope there's a bit more characterization as well.

I couldn't really get in to the book at first. But overall I enjoyed this book. This book is a lot of smut but I kinda missed a bit more character building and plots.
This a RH about a girl named Georgia she needs to travel for her work for 10 days and there she meets 3 handsome brothers. All brothers have very different personalities.
It is a quick read but I didn't enjoy it as much as I expected.

Lots of spicy and very little plot. But that's sometimes just the way you want it 😉 A great reverse harem that can be read in one sitting!

Thank you to Lily Manning & Innes Field LLC for access to Making Her Theirs for my review. Georgia Presley Henry travels to Edinburgh for a work assignment and quickly finds herself surrounded by three brothers, Knox, Lachlan and Finn. Each brother has a something she instantly attracted to and she quickly learns the brothers are better at sharing than most brothers. This book has lots of spice, but also a love story. This is a reverse harem story with a happily ever after… and, did I mention spice?!?

This is a quick and dirty brothers reverse harem. If that's your thing, you'll probably like this. You're got your three typical male types- the serious, the silly, and the recluse that never shows affection. Just note that the spice gets a little "... oh honey, that's not a good idea" at times. There's not really a plot, but sometimes you don't want a plot, ya know? If that's what you're looking for, this is the book for you!

Let’s be honest, this is smut with a dash of plot. And you know what, sometimes that’s what the heart wants! This definitely won’t be everyone’s cup of tea, but’s it’s someone’s. I think some of the logistics of the spicy scenes didn’t make anatomical sense or weren’t entirely realistic, but for the most part they were enjoyable to read. I think the timeline also could have been improved. 9-10 days is not nearly enough time for these characters to fall madly in love. The author could have kept the book the same length but maybe had some time skips so the love felt more authentic and believable. This was a quick read and I would read more from this author. For her first RH, this was a solid start!
Thanks to NetGalley and the author for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

1.5 stars rounded up

spoilers ahead!!

I LOVE RH but this just.. didn't do it for me. I know this is a really short read, but was hoping for a little more plot and character development than what it offered. I'm so disappointed :(

I was ready to DNF this at 67 pages (42%), but I thought it's so short I might as well just continue.

This had a strong start, with a decent starting plot which has a lot of potential but quickly went downhill after the first 20 pages.

We get a decent background of why she's in Edinburgh, about her job, how she rented this room that has no furniture, etc. But when she goes down to the MMC's bar the insta-love hits. At this point, it's just smut, and nothing more.

Georgia was in Edinburgh, for only 10 days, and they all fell in love with each other in literally 2 seconds.


4% into this and insta-love:

My gaze snags on the sexiest smile of what I can say is the hottest piece of man I’ve ever seen, who is staring at me. Dark blond hair, inky blue eyes, tall and lithe and a smile that could light up Jupiter and Mars combined. Like a moth to a flame or Pythagorean to a theorem, I have to get closer. Is he rocking a twelve-pack underneath that vintage Elvis T-shirt? Hello, he’s wearing an Elvis T-shirt? Like magnets, we move toward each other. I swear this man is made for me. I make it to the front of the bar, and stop dead. Man magic stands in front of me.



some parts were kinda funny (in a weird way):

If my balls could sing, they’d be in the Hallelujah chorus right now.



and some parts gave me the ick:

“I’m going to come,” she gasps, her mouth leaving mine. “That’s the plan.”


“That’s the plan.” yuck, yuck, yuck!


and by the 8th, maybe 9th day she's in Scotland:

“We’ve fallen for you, Angel. Each in our own way. You brighten my world. When you smile, my universe lights up. When you’re at work, all I can think about is you walking through my pub door with your gorgeous smile, and when you do, whatever shit day I’ve had falls away, and it’s just you and me."


Also, the fact she is pregnant and MARRIED to one of them after 3 months... anyways...

I don't think there's much more I can say other than, that it had a strong start then it was just ruined by tons of smut.

If you just want a short smutty RH book then this would be perfect for you!

But if you want something with a plot and any type of character development, I suggest passing on this one.


*a copy was provided via NetGalley, although I downloaded the KU version and read that one instead*

Thank you to Netgalley for this e-arc in exchange for an honest review!

Honestly, I won't lie I did want there to be more plot to this one. It started off promising but just turned into smut and never stopped. And it ended up being a bit of a drag because of it to the point where I was just skimming over the last 30% of the book, wanting it to be finished.

I do like the writing style from this author, but I think the book could have been plotted a little better with the timings and over-arching plot.

Wow this was incredibly spicy! I loved the Scotland setting. The brothers were just a dream and this book had my heart racing. The storyline moved a little too fast but it being a shorter book I didn’t mind it too much. Definitely going to recommend to anyone looking for short and spicy.

first off, thanks Lily for making me wish for a trip to Scotland. If I could find not one, but three gorgeous Scottish men, I would definitely be in heaven.

Secondly, this is definitely smut and reverse harem so if that isn’t your cup of tea, be warned. (It is for sure my cup of tea hahaha).

I loved Georgias character. She was strong and resilient. It’s nice to have a woman that isn’t weak or scared to be on her own.

Each brother has their own attributes but as a whole, they created one perfect package for Georgia.

There wasn’t much plot besides just finding love but I still enjoyed this quick read and cannot wait to see the next part.

All in all, a fun read. I give it 3.5 stars so we will round up to 4 as thanks to the author for a steamy reverse harem story.

I had some mixed feelings on this one but overall, it was still pretty decent. I'll start with the positives. The spice was top notch! Like, these men had no right to be so hot. There was a lot of spice and it never got boring. Sadly, that's the majority of what I liked about the book. The plot felt lacking. I would have liked a more significant story alongside the wonderful smut. I also didn't like the insta love vibes. I wouldn't liked to see feeling develope more naturally. But overall this was still a quick, enjoyable, and very spicy romance.

Thank you to the publishers and netgalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review.