After a freshman year spent mourning her best friend who passed away the previous summer, Margot is invited to live with mysterious Lucy and her two other friends. Lucy search to come out of her shell, but things are soon shattered. When one of the frat boys next door is murdered.

I thought this was a good thriller book, though the first half is a little slow. The ending is filled with twist that you probably would not be able to figure out. At least I couldn’t.

Thanks to NetGalley, Stacy Willingham & Minotaur Books for the opportunity to read this book.

Thank you Netgalley for the advanced copy of this title! I absolutely loved it. I was completely shocked by the ending of this book and I highly recommend.

First off, thank you to NetGalley, St Martin’s Press/Minotaur for the ARC in exchange for my honest review! Only if You’re Lucky is a thriller about college girls with a mysterious past. I wouldn’t consider it dark academia personally, because it mainly follows the girls partying with the frat next door. Because of this, I’d recommend the target age group for this novel between 16-24 years old.
The first 50% of the story builds up the plot, but I did find this slow and difficult to get through. The second half gets a little more interesting leaving the reader with cliff hangers from chapter to chapter. While there was so much detail in the first half, I felt like I didn’t connect to the main characters as much as I would have liked to. The ending felt abrupt and unbelievable.
Overall, not a memorable thriller. 2.5/5 stars rounded up, simply because of the twists taking place in the second half of the book that finally grasped my attention.

I freaking LOVED the first two books by this author and just about lost it when I got approved for this arc! Unfortunately, this one fell flat for me and I couldn’t help but compare it to the first two epic mysteries by Stacey.

Margot is entering her second year of college with a gang of brand new friends. Her first year started rocky since she started school just 2 months after her best friend died. Now, Lucy seemingly saved her from another year of going through the motions. Margot has friends, has fun, and even has secrets now. The only thing is… so does everyone else.

This just read like a college drama for most of the book and there were few likeable characters throughout. Kinda felt like Tell Me Lies, so if you like that book I recommend this one! I loved the way it wrapped up but not my favorite overall.

Thank you to St. Martin's Press, Minotaur Books and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy to read and review.

This novel is a slow burn with a few surprising twists as it nears the end…but with enough breadcrumbs dropped along the way that they tie together without being out too far in left field.

Another great read from this author.

Only If You're Lucky by Stacy Willingham is another beautifully-written thriller by an incredible talented author. It feels like I only just devoured her debut, A Flicker In The Dark, that blew me away. But her third novel is every is just as powerful, maybe even more. I raced through the pages even though I wish I could have slowed down, lingered over every beautiful paragraph. Can't wait for her fourth! Highly recommend!!

A dark academia that reminded me of a cross between Pretty Little Liars and How to Get Away with Murder. I loved the college roomies who live next door to a fraternity house take on this book. Lots of lies and secrets that unfold, which always make for an interesting story. I especially enjoyed the friendship dynamic between Margot and Lucy, one who’s malleable and one who’s bigger than life.

This slow burn does take a bit to ramp up,
and the middle could have used a bit “more” but I’m a fan of an academia thriller.. so I was invested. Each of the characters are flawed which really added to the intriguing female friendship dynamic that’s at play. Willingham knows how to build up a story and the ending was packed with twists. I binged the second half of the book in one sitting. A very well executed and memorable ending.

This book was decent. I enjoyed certain parts of it and others I didn’t. I’ve definitely read worse.

Stacy Willingham is soooo good at keeping you guessing until the very end of her books, I honestly had no idea where we were going for half this story, but in a good way. The only thing I wasn't a huge fan of was a majority of the characters, for being in college they were written in a way that sounded like they were still in high school or younger. Eliza and Lucy were by far the most annoying of the bunch, but I did love Nicole and Sloane. The endless twists kept me going and of course this author continues to be an instant buy for me.

Wow. What a wild and haunting ride this book was. So many twists and turns, it was quite haunting actually and I really enjoyed it. I don't want to say too much and spoil the story, but it has a bit of everything- friendship, lies, secrets, envy and betrayal. I highly recommend!

Huge fan of this author, but this book fell short for me this time. Definitely too slow of a start and while the ending made up for that with the twist, it’s still not what I was hoping for.

Margot is off to college without her best friend, Eliza. After tragedy struck, Margot, had to move on without her. While at college, Margo meet some new friends, one being Lucy. Lucy has friended Margot, who is intrigued as she reminds her a lot of her friend Eliza. As they become friends and the roommates Sloane and Nicole become some of her friends, things do not appear as they seem. When one of the frat boys next-door gets murdered, and Lucy disappears, there are a lot of unanswered questions. Margot is determined to figure it out.

This book is a good read, just not one of my favorites this year. And definitely not as good as the first two books by this author. Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press/Minotaur Books for the ARC. This book comes out in January!

Psychological and chilling. Stacey always has you on the edge of your seat. The mystery wasn't quite as thrilling as in her previous works, but the relationships between the characters were so raw and real and entrancing. I would definitely recommend this to fans of psychological thrillers!

I loved A Flicker in the Dark and All the Dangerous Things so I had to pick up Only if You’re Lucky!

This is the story of Margot’s exploration of friendship that is laced with themes of belonging, loyalty, envy, and betrayal.

Oh boy y’all I’m on the fence with this one. The set up was amazing and the end was twisty! BUT getting there was a slog. I think there was just way too much detail on the relationships and atmosphere that I was bored. I did love how it all came together in the bed and will read any book Stacy Willingham writes!

Only if You’re Lucky follows Margot in her second year of University as she navigates new “cool” roommates while still trying to accept her childhood best friend’s death. Just as she begins to get comfortable, a face from her past shows up and makes moving on all the more difficult.

This story is told both in past and present and moves very slowly for the first 60% of the book. The story is also a bit all over the place and felt like it could have been tightened up quite a bit, which may have helped with the predictably of the twist(s).

Thank you to Netgalley and Minotaur Books for an advanced copy.

3 stars

The last quarter of this book was good, it just felt like it took us too long to get there. Thank you for the chance to read and review this book.

Margot is a college Freshman who doesn't know what to do with herself after the death of her somewhat toxic high school BFF. The only reason she had even applied to the college she attends was to follow her BFF. After one year at university having only one friend but a friend who seemed to be both genuinely good and psychologically sound. So our girl Margot decides that the best thing to do with her grief and foggy mental health is to take up with a a trio of college age wonder girls who's "leader" is one big giant red flag. Out of absolutely nowhere Ms. Leader invites Margot to move in with them., she agrees. At which point everything goes downhill, like downhill to hell. After moving in Margot learns that their landlord is a frat... Yes, four girls with a fraternity for a landlord, sounds safe, right? One of this frat's incoming pledges happens to be a dude who had a fling with Margot's now passed BFF and was the last person seen with her before her tragic and suspicious death. No bueno. This book is a thriller that deals with personality shifts, power dynamics, morally grayish characters, a plenty of plot twists.... also a weirdish obsession with a sort of version of truth or dare.

I have read all three of of Stacy Willingham's novels ( I think she's only written three if I'm wrong talk to Goodreads) of the three this book was my favorite. It's a fast easy read, the plot pulls you in. Although the main characters are young this novel does not read like a YA or New Adult novel and can easily be enjoyed by most adult readers. This book was a solid 4/5 stars for me. Thank you to NetGalley & St. Martin's Press/Minotaur Books for providing me with this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

This one is landing at more of a 3.5 for me. Read on Kindle.

This is my first Willingham book and I did enjoy it! This story follows Margot through the summer after her freshman year of college and her new friendship with three other gals. Margot has a past that she's not really willing to share but she soon finds out her new friends have secrets as well...and secrets that might be connected to hers.

To make matters even more complicated, for the summer these four gals are living next to a fraternity and their properties are connected by a shed...

We go back and forth between chapters to the Before times and After. We know something terrible has happened and the pages will turn until we finally learn what happened that night.

I liked the suspense in this one, I wanted to keep coming back to it. I didn't totally connect with it being in my 40's and college being quite a while ago, but I did feel like it was well written and was a good (not GREAT) but good thriller that kept my interest. I would for sure be interested in giving another Willingham book a shot!

Minimal language and adult themes/spice.

Thank you to NeGalley for this advance copy in exchange for an honest review!

I thoroughly enjoy Stacy Willingham's writing and was excited to be approved to read an ARC of Only If Your'e She has a talent for introducing twists and suspense into her stories that are exhilarating. While this book also has Willingham's signature surprising turn of events, it takes it's time in coming. The story moves at a very slow pace for the first 70% of the book - I checked where I was once it started to pick up. The biggest plot twists that I love are the one that you can see breadcrumbs of in the story before the reveal. The, "why didn't I see that before?" moment for the reader. This one relied more on characters and information that arrive late in the book. Overall, I felt the story needed whittled down.
While I am still an eager reader of Stacy Willingham 's books, this particular venture was not my favorite work of hers thus far.

My thanks to NetGalley and St Martin's Press, Minotaur Books for the ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.

I love Stacy Willingham’s writing and love the twist/suspense she writes into her books. This twist was too late in the book for me and I wish she put it earlier like her other two books. Overall great writing and story.

Thank you to Stacy Willingham, St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for the ARC!

Wow! Overall loved this book. I was so excited to be approved for this ARC. I give this 4 stars - I love a good psychological thriller and the plot and suspense was great throughout the novel. The only issue I had was keeping track of all the characters. They were all introduced in the beginning which left me a bit confused. It is a bit of a slow burn, so it takes a little bit for the pace to pick up. Overall, another great thriller from Stacy Willingham!