Member Reviews

A moving story of the love, strength, and courage of women who put themselves in harm's way to help others told from the viewpoint of a young woman of the 1960's. This was especially moving since I lived through a war that only politicans seemed to benefit from. We lost so many good Americans and the survivors of the Vietnam War are still suffering in many cases. How horrible to survive, come home (most damaged in some way) aqnd be despised by your own countrymen. An important book because many women have played similar roles in every war with next to no recognition.

Was this review helpful?

Once again Kristin Hannah has knocked it out of the park with her book The Women. Her level of storytelling and historical details create an incredible world that I didn't want to leave. The protagonist, Frances aka Frank, is such a layered and flawed and determined character. I hated having to finish the book and saying goodbye to her. The amount of research Kristin Hannah put into this story is clear and unprecedented. I felt like I was in 'Nam with Frank and the doctors as they worked to save lives. It wasn't only the details and the over-arching story line, it was the horrific and gruesome reality of what veterans experienced during that place in history. And the women ... oh, the women... It breaks my heart that women were pushed to the back and ignored when they experienced war trauma as well. This book got me thinking about things I have never thought about ... the women who served during the Vietnam war and their struggle in the aftermath. Frank's character arc is a long and painful one, but she does finally reach a place of self-awareness and healing that satisfied my reader soul. I commend Kristin Hannah for her depth of work with this book. It's one that should be read by many despite the hard-to-talk-about topics. The more we talk about those things, the more we heal. Bravo!

Was this review helpful?

The Women by Kristin Hannah was definitely a good read.

I absolutely loved her previous book, The Four Winds, and was excited to read this one as well .
My only quibble with this book was the title.
The main character, Frances (Frankie) McGrath is a combat nurse in Vietnam.
While the story does also talk about 2 of her friend and describes a photo of the 3 of them where the caption is "The Women" I really feel the story is not about multiple women, but primarily about the MC.
This could have been titled 'Combat Nurse" or something similar, but I kept expecting the story to jump to center on one of the other women. (like a 3 part book where each woman has a story)

I really enjoyed the book, and it is beautifully written and very powerful, but I felt really distracted by the title.

Thanks to NetGalley for a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Get ready to intensely experience every emotion throughout this fictional retelling of the forgotten women in Vietnam.
This book immediately captured my attention as :
1. Kristin Hannah is an auto-buy author for me
2. I'm a nurse! There are ways in which I'm bonded to my nursing friends that cannot be explained or replicated.
Let's get into it. About 10,000 American women enlisted throughout the various military branches as military intelligence, air traffic control, physicians, but most were stationed as nurses. These women worked tirelessly day and night, through bombings, monsoons, surrounded by death.
While all soldiers returning from the Vietnam war were greeted with hostility and were expected to quickly move on, many of the women were quickly excluded and forgotten, abandoned even by the VA for counseling as they weren't involved in combat". It is truly heartbreaking to read about how all soldiers were treated upon their return and the lack of resources (and understanding ) for treating PTSD. The DSM did not formally recognize PTSD as a disorder until 1980!! &
§ (Vietnam war ended in 1975).
Kristin Hannah reminds us exactly how important these women in returning soldiers home or providing comfort in the last moments of life through the female main character,
"Frankie" and her nurse friends. You'll be alongside the women in the army hospitals and upon return to the US, the journey arduous but ending with forgiveness, redemption, and self discovery.
This book reminds me so much of why I love reading: how it open a lens into another life to experience situations unlike your own, grapple with conflict you've never seen, empathize and walk away with a better understanding of human nature.
The amount of research that must have gone into this book to adequately portray these historical events with what little information is known to the public is enough for a five star review, but really the story speaks for itself and you're going to feel it all.
My sincerest thanks to NetGalley , St Martin’s Press, and Kristin Hannah for the eARC.

Was this review helpful?

The master of historical fiction did it again. The Women has it all - perfectly flawed characters in vibrant settings. From Coronado Island to the Vietnam jungles to rugged Montana, various settings play a true role in The Women.

Frances “Frankie” McGrath decides she wants to be on the “heroes wall” in her dad’s study and enlists to serve as a nurse in the U.S. Army. Graphic descriptions of what active duty did to the soldiers and civilians in Vietnam pepper her tale of finding love, friendship, and her true calling in an unlikely setting. From active bombings to letting loose at the officer’s club, Hannah captured diverse experiences.

What shocked me was that so much of the book took place after the war ended. The reception of soldiers coming home was atrocious, the long-term impacts of chemicals used in battle slowly unspooled, and PTSD became an official diagnosis. However, many women who served in Vietnam faced the retort, “there were no women there.”

The Women includes some looks into how race and class played into who went to war and who was able to avoid it. I would’ve liked to see a bit more of a look into Frankie’s immense privilege and how it impacted her entire life.

It will pull you in and entertain while breaking your heart. I loved the music discussed throughout the book & can’t wait for the Spotify playlist.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for this ARC of The Women. Kristin Hannah did it again, I LOVED every part of this book. I was never taught that much about Vietnam so this book was very enlightening for me. It was heartbreaking and I cried several times, but parts of it also warmed my heart. I will remember this book forever.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah scores again with the story of "Frankie Mcgrath" set in the turbulent 1960's.
Frankie grew up in a wealthy family on Coronado Island, California. She strived to be a good daughter and was raised to become a traditional wife and mother. As her brother prepares to join the unpopular war in Vietnam, a friend tells her "girls can be heroes too" & it changes her life. Frankie gets her nursing degree and follows her brother to Vietnam, totally unprepared for the realities of life there.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book , even as I learned about Vietnam and how Americans reacted to the war there. Hannah does a great job of immersing the reader in the era that she writes about. I was born in 1964 & Vietnam was in the background of every newscast as I grew up. I love how she uses the music & songs of the times to help us dive into the story. She also weaved racial issues, woman's rights, and so much more into the fabric of this book. Definitely read.

Awesome
Thanks to Netgalley and St Martin's Press for the opportunity to read this wonderful book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Omg what a gorgeous novel! I am so lucky to have been able to read it so early! I cried, i smiled, it was breathtakingly beautiful and heartbreaking! Everyone needs to read this!! i learned so much about the Vietnam War i was not aware of!

Was this review helpful?

"There were no women in Viet Nam". Frankie heard it time and again as she relived her time in Viet Nam as a nurse and the aftermath of the coming home to all of us who had no idea of the repugnance of this war. There was no diagnosis for PTSD when Frankie tried to put her life back together as a veteran of a war that was not a war and heroes who were not heroes. This book haunts me, but I am grateful for the story that was told.

Was this review helpful?

Another Out of the Park Home Run for the Rock Star Author we know as Kristin Hannah. No synopsis necessary to encourage reading this piece of history, all but forgotten and yet so recent. I grew up in this era and so much of the story easily transported me to that time in our world and my life, yet I believe no matter the readers' age, it will have a profound effect on their psyche and heart. The creation of main character Frankie McGrath is phenomenal. Just Read it! So appreciate Net Galley and St. Martin's Press for the opportunity to ride this Magic Carpet ARC. Thank You, Thank You, Thank You.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC copy of this book from Netgalley. But all the opinions are my own.

I have read The Four Winds, Nightingale, and Firefly Lane by Kristin Hannah. I loved The Four Winds and Nightingale. Firefly Lane was a miss for me. So, I went into The Women wondering if it was going to be a hit or miss.

Let me tell you it was a hit for me! Once you start this book it does not get your claws out of you until long after you finish. I was entranced by the characters and the plot. I also loved that it was set in the 1960s. I feel a folly of many historical fiction novels is they are set during WWII. I personally have had enough of WWII novels.

Francis “Frankie” McGrath is an Army nurse in the Vietnam war. The things she goes through and sees has left a imprint on my heart. It shows the strength an resilience of women. I never wanted to leave Frankie and her story. I had a hard time finishing the book because I didn't want it to end.

Was this review helpful?

Title: The Women
Author: Kristin Hannah
Pub Date: February 6, 2024

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

READ. THIS. BOOK. Add it to your TBR. Pre-order it. I am begging you. This book was so eye opening for me and I think this one will end up being my favorite book of the year. Kristin Hannah is one of my favorite authors, and The Nightingale has always been one of my favorite books. I can honestly say that I think The Women may be my new favorite! I have never read a book that I loved but has made me so angry at the same time. To be clear, this writing style, storyline, pacing, etc., were all excellent. I found myself angry at the mistreatment of women who served our country and have been essentially forgotten. Never has a book invoked such strong feelings in me as this one did. I know this will be a book that I read again and I will not forget The Women!

Frankie McGrath has always been taught to believe that her job is to be a good housewife, raise well-mannered children, and keep a clean house. Frankie comes from a family of heroes. In fact, her father has an entire wall in his office dedicated to family history and the heroes who served their country. Besides wedding pictures, no women were included on the ‘heroes’ wall. It wasn’t until a going away party for her brother, who was set to ship off to serve in Vietnam, that her brothers’ friend told her “women can be heroes.” No one had ever told Frankie that before, and it never occurred to her that a woman could have a place on her father’s office for doing something heroic or important. On an impulse, Frankie joins the Army Nurse Corps to follow her brother and his path towards being a hero.

As an inexperienced nurse, Frankie finds herself drowning admits the chaos in Vietnam. She witnesses death after death and gruesome injuries, and is often the last person someone will talk to before taking their last breath. With long hours working in horrible conditions, Frankie comes to find Ethel and Barb, two women from completely different walks of life, who end up being the best support for Frankie and one another. While this book is partially focused on Frankie and her time in Vietnam, and all of the love and loss that she experienced while there, it also largely focuses on her time after returning home. The treatment by Frankie’s family, other veterans, members of the VA, and medical professionals was absolutely repulsive. The second half of the book focuses on Frankie and her experience with the lack of support for women veterans after Vietnam. The Women does have a few love stories that are a main focus, but this book is so much more than a love story. It is a coming of age novel that is beautifully written about a very difficult topic. It is raw and bold and it is memorable.

Read If you Like Books About:
🚁Historical Fiction
🚁Female Friendship
🚁Mental Health Representation
🚁Women and Their Role in the Vietnam War
🚁Forgiveness

I love historical fiction, but have not read a lot that has focused on the Vietnam War. I can say that I learned so much from this book and I have found a new time period that I want to read more about. Hannah provides a list of recommended reading at the end of the book, and I will definitely be checking those books out because I WANT to read more.

Favorite Quotes:

“Women can be heroes.”

“No fear, McGrath. You can do this.”

“The war no one wants to remember.”

“You know, I wasn’t afraid to go to war, and I should have been. I am afraid to go to the memorial, and I shouldn’t be. People made us think we’d done something wrong, shameful, didn’t they? We were forgotten; all of us Vietnam vets, but the women most of all.”

“Maybe, like so many things, it began simply with words. Speaking up, standing in the sunlight, coming together, demanding honesty and truth. Taking pride. The women had a story to hell, even if the world wasn’t quite ready to hear it, and their story began with three simple words. We were there.”

Posted on Instagram - Currently Reading - September 9, 2023: http://www.instagram.com/nobookmark_noproblem
Posted on Goodreads on September 13, 2023: https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/144922955?ref=nav_profile_l
**Posted on Instagram - Mini Review - December 2023 http://www.instagram.com/nobookmark_noproblem
**Posted on Instagram - Full Review- February 6, 2024: http://www.instagram.com/nobookmark_noproblem
**Posted on Amazon on February 6, 2024
**-will post on designated date

Was this review helpful?

While reading ‘The Women,’ I learned some things about the Vietnam War: the political upheaval, the war protests, sexism, the pivotal roles women played during the conflict, that nurses weren’t recognized as veterans, and the unfortunate challenges they all faced upon returning home. I love books that not only teach me something but provide an emotional punch! That’s a 5⭐️ read for me. As with her other books, ‘The Women’ is well-researched and well-written…and it just took a hold of me. Besides the beautiful writing, the characters are fully fleshed out and felt real. Main character, Frankie, was relatable, and her friendships with Ethel and Barb were a high point for me. I felt that Hannah showcased the strength of female friendship and how these women supported and counted on each other really well. I couldn’t help rooting for them, and I definitely cried with them. I also enjoyed the references to music; it added another authentic backdrop to the setting!
Going out on a limb here (not really!), this will be THE book of 2024.”

Was this review helpful?

My favorite Kristin Hannah book. Do you ever feel like you need a mental health day after reading one of her books? I definitely did after this one.

There are so many deep subjects in her books. So many discussions you want to have with your book club, veterans, people in your life. I loved this book. I will recommend it to my library patrons. I love that it brings light to those women who served in Vietnam War. The sacrifices our military made and the repercussions from their service. This book takes time to process and think about.


I know that I will read this book again once it is out. I love how immersed you are in the characters and their lives.

This definitely needs to be on your TBR list.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my... this was extraordinary! Hannah knows how to write the most engaging historical fiction books and "The Women" does not disappoint. I was so wrapped up in this story that I felt sad and like I was reading a memoir of my best friends life. It's that personal of a writing style. You don't need to be a fan of history to enjoy this book. You just have to want a great book to read. I'll never forget this book!

Was this review helpful?

I would like to thank St. Martins Press, Net Galley, and Kristin Hannah for this early read.

I have so many emotions going on right now about this book. I will start by saying it was well written. I appreciate an author who researches and uses actual stories to create her own story. I loved learning about the Vietnam War and the hood, bad, and ugly that came with it. (Maybe I am a history junkie after all? Or maybe Kristin Hannah is a queen at writing).

The Women is a book about a nurse who serves in the Vietnam War. The first part tells about her journey to get to Vietnam and while in Vietnam. The 2nd part mostly captivates the horrific return that most women and vets alike faced when returning from Vietnam. It’s despicable at best.

So not only do we get to see that, but we also follow Frances love life through the book as well. Now, this is where I really just wanted to throw my kindle across the room. Not only does this woman face harsh situations but the love life she faces also makes me wanna kick someone (I’ll leave him unnamed so there’s no spoilers) in the face…hard….several times.

I had SOOOOOOOOO many emotions through this book.

Was this review helpful?

The Women by Kristen Hannah is a historical fiction novel that is very challenging to read because the subject is the trauma incurred by the nurses and doctors who served during the Vietnam War. Along with the soldiers returning from the war, the doctors and nurses were also unwelcomed by a country tired of a war that no one believed in and a government that lied to them. The nurses who didn’t technically serve in combat were completely ignored by the country and the Veteran’s Administration. These nurses came home traumatized because they were always in harm’s way in addition to the horror they witnessed on a daily basis caring for severely wounded soldiers.

This is a story about “Frankie” McGrath, a surgical Army nurse, stationed in some of the worst fighting areas of Vietnam. The novel follows Frankie’s time in Vietnam, her dysfunctional family, and her two best friends who served with her as war time nurses. The book highlights the horrors of war, the lives lost, and lives destroyed or permanently altered by the living through a war. It’s a well told powerful story but not an easy read for anyone.

Was this review helpful?

“Women can be heroes.” Kristin Hannah has written another phenomenal story that I couldn’t put down. The Women takes place during the Vietnam War and follows Frankie, a nurse who served in the Army, and her 2 friends, Ethel and Barb. It was an incredible tale of friendship that endured during a war and the aftermath of those experiences in the “real world”. Hannah was able to portray a woman’s experience during the war with so much realism and care. She was able to show the sacrifices of war and the true and often unseen cost of being a hero. If you liked her Kristin Hannah’s other novels, you’ll love this one!

Was this review helpful?

You certainly can't go wrong reading a novel by Kristin Hannah, but this was one of her best. It was of great interest to read about the women of Vietnam and what they went through not only in Vietnam, as nurses, but as veterans. I highly recommend this read. Five stars plus.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah's latest novel tells the story of Frankie, an idealistic young nurse who in 1966 volunteered to serve in Vietnam. Frankie's family valued military service, with her father having his own wall of heroes on proud display in the family home. Her brother volunteered for duty in Vietnam, and when a friend of his casually remarks that women can be heroes as well, she is inspired. As a fresh graduate of nursing school, she believes she can make a difference serving, safely, in military hospitals. She is quickly disabused when she arrives in Vietnam to discover that instead of an orderly hospital, it is a brutally understaffed and grim environment. Yet, in Vietnam she forms fierce friendships with other nurses and finds an inner strength she was unaware of possessing. Hannah does a great job of balancing the horrors of war with the friendships and romances that lighten (an heighten the poignancy) of Frankie's days. When Frankie comes home, not only is she treated badly by civilians who question why she would proudly wear her uniform, she is dismissed by fellow soldiers b, and because there were "no women in Vietnam." A well written, interesting historical novel. My biggest quibble - it's a lousy title,, but Hannah's following will find it. However, a more descriptive title would have served it better.

Was this review helpful?