Member Reviews

Kristin Hannah can seriously do no wrong. I love her writing so much and the storytelling is amazing. I already love Historical Fiction but hers are seriously one of the best.

I haven’t read any Historical Fiction books about the Vietnam War so this was definitely new for me and I learned things about the war I didn’t know about, including how the women were treated when returning from war, and even the men too. It’s sad that so many Americans volunteered to risk their lives for their country and ended up being treated like crap when they got home, which just made the state of their mental health deplete even more.

There were a few character dramas I wasn’t a fan of because I felt like it was just added just for the heck of it but at the same time, so much of it was pretty historically accurate for what took place between soldiers during the war.

Overall I’m so glad I got back into Kristin Hannah with this book and I can’t wait to get back into her backlist!

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah manages to floor me every time (and I should stop being so shocked by this) with her ability to draw the reader's into the story, no matter the time period or situation. She clearly does her research to be able to pull us in to a time period we may know nothing about or even have not been alive during.

My dad was in the Navy for Vietnam. I've heard a few stories, but fortunately he was never in any major fight zones. In this book, I could clearly picture Frankie's bunk, the hospital spaces, the bar. I felt her anguish and loss when her patients didn't make it or those she cared about died, or left Vietnam. And honestly, Vietnam almost paled in comparison to Frankie's experience being back stateside. Not only did Kristin Hannah get the descriptions of places and experiences in Vietnam so seemingly accurate, she obviously equally researched PTSD to give the readers such a in depth portrayal in Frankie's struggle.

This book gutted me multiple times, slowly pieced my heart together again and then pulled the rug out from under me to fall into devastation for Frankie again. The Nightingale has been my undisputed favorite by Kristin Hannah for years, but The Women definitely gives it a run for it's money. It's informative while also bringing so much emotion by giving us someone to connect with and feel empathy toward her experience.

Was this review helpful?

What an incredibly moving and powerful book. I don't know much about the Vietnam War, except what we were taught in school and as I read The Women, I found myself googling about the different groups, what the news was putting out, and about the women who did serve in Vietnam. While the story mainly follows Frankie as she joins the Army Nurse Corps, we meet a lot of other important characters that play major roles in Frankie's life.

When the story is set in Vietnam, it's intense, as it should be. What I particularly liked with The Women was that Kristin Hannah didn't portray a happy homecoming and that these women went back to life as normal. They all had battles they faced when reacclimating to civilian life.

And, as with all of Kristin Hannah's books, this one broke my heart into a million pieces multiple times over, before putting it back together again. She truly is a master at her craft.

Don't miss The Women. It's phenomenal.
Thank you, St. Martins Press and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This the most powerful book I’ve read in years. Although historical fiction covers the world wars in great detail, Vietnam was a new take, and was covered masterfully.

Possible spoiler - at least one character suffers from PTSD (I mean, it’s a story about military members going to war, it can’t be that surprising), but the description of it and the way it impacted life choices is the closest I’ve ever read to my own struggles with PTSD. This helped me to understand myself better, and I could never thank Kristen enough for putting this story out to the world.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah takes us on an incredible journey through the Vietnam war depicting Frances McGrath as an army nurse. Growing up privileged, Frances decides to enroll in the military to be close to her brother. She will experience love and loss in this coming of age historical fiction story. This is also an excellent audio narration by my favorite Julia Whelan.

Was this review helpful?

Did not love this. Parts were excellent and learning about Vietnam was very eye-opening. But man- so much happened to the MC that is was overkill.

Was this review helpful?

The Women by Kristin Hannah is a sweeping saga about one nurse's experience in Vietnam. Frankie McGrath wants something more than glittering parties and becoming exactly what her parents expect her to be, a wife and a mother. On one wall in her parents' lavish home, every soldier in the family appears in a photograph or portrait. Frankie wants to be on that wall and not as a bride. She wants to join up just like her brother Finley has done and serve as a nurse. It's a noble thing to do and feels like a calling, so, after a few false starts, she flies to Vietnam and that's when her life begins amid the chaos of war and intense aftermath when she must pick up the pieces.

If you ever wished to learn more about Vietnam and a woman's experiences in the war, this book has it all. At times, the scenes where Frankie tends to fallen soldiers and Vietnam residents caught in the middle of the Vietcong and American conflicts are incredibly harrowing. These scenes are not for the faint of heart, but they capture the overwhelming barbarity of the injuries that soldiers sustained. It paints a striking and realistic picture of what was going on in the sometimes primitive medical facilities--this is no MASH, the TV show from the 1970s and 1980s. It's more like China Beach but much more graphic. The pace feels hectic and hopeless, and you're right there with Frankie.

Another thing I realized--and this is a major part of the book--there were women in Vietnam. Many served in multiple ways, but no one seems to believe Frankie and the other women who returned and needed support from other vets and therapists to get over or, at least, come to terms with their PTSD and other difficult to shake feelings. It was beyond frustrating to hear how they were rejected by their own comrades. It was as daunting and aggravating as hearing about how soldiers who were drafted barely out of their teens and didn't know what they were getting themselves into were treated so harshly for serving their country.

While I love a good soap opera, the plotlines involving Frankie's relationships and romances sometimes seemed implausible, rocky, and ridiculous. Could she ever find someone who respected her and put her first? I found myself saddened and then groaning over the preposterous storylines. Believe me, they were intriguing and heart-rending but silly, too.

I appreciate how much time the author devoted in this book to the real ravages of war and the aftermath of it. So much research and thought went into this book. Apparently, this story resided in the author's heart since 1997! She felt that she wasn't mature enough or strong enough as a writer at that time to conquer this original and necessary topic. I'm still so shocked at the lack of recognition and support for women during the Vietnam war. It's worth reading if you can handle the sometimes challenging and harrowing scenes in the book.

Was this review helpful?

This is not my normal genre but I really enjoyed The Women. I did a combo of kindle and audio and I really loved the audio. I enjoyed everyone's stories and just how badass these ladies were. I couldn't believe how the country treated them after all they'd sacrificed. This was just a really good story. So, if you love historical fiction and even if you don't, I definitely recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

I know by now that Kristin Hannah is going to make me cry. That I'll spend the pages waiting to be kicked in the stomach and fearing when something good happens to the characters. But I will ALWAYS read them. Hannah is such a good writer. This book hit me particularly hard as I lost family members to the consequences of serving in Vietnam. Painful and wonderful book

Was this review helpful?

A moving story of historical fiction, which is not my usual genre. This story however, had me engaged and captivated by its detail. I felt like I was over I. Vietnam, experiencing everything also.

Kristin Hannah delivers another well executed novel that is a great mix of fiction and nonfiction. A definite must read, for anyone. Even if you don’t like historical fiction, give it a shot. It was a quick, engaging book.

Was this review helpful?

It's easy to say "Kristin Hannah" has done it again. I don't hesitate to recommend her books for anyone looking for historical fiction and with "The Women" she's added another era.

Was this review helpful?

This was a well done historical fiction by Kristin Hannah. I appreciated her ability to have me care about the characters and portray the critical importance of female friendships. This book certainly opened my eyes to the women who served in the Vietnam war.

I went back and forth between the audio version and kindle ebook. 4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

Kristin's books are always phenomenal! They make you laugh and cry, all while teaching you about part of history the reader never got to personally experience. Somehow I think The Women is her best book yet (unbelievable, right?!). I've been recommending it to everyone I know and just "re-read" it myself over audio. The audiobook is amazing too, the best narrator. I highly recommend to everyone!

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah does it again. This book was heartbreaking, eye opening, and beautiful. I was so invested in the story and couldn’t put it down. It will definitely be one of my favorites of the year.

Was this review helpful?

I have read every novel that Kristin Hannah was written and loved each and every one. This one was so hard as this war I could relate to. My husband went to Viet Nam. He was 12 years older than me so he shared some stories but not many, It was a emotional time that left so many scarred. Beautiful writing and the descriptions helped you to imagine the time and background. Thank you for writing of a time that was hard and making it assessable to the public.

Was this review helpful?

Such an emotional story and brilliantly told. You really feel Frankie’s pain. Frankie is a young woman who wants to be a hero so she enlists as a Vietnam nurse. She witnesses unimaginable horrors of war and creates beautiful bonds with her fellow nurses. She returns to the United States to misunderstanding and judgement not only from other Americans but especially her parents. This book was tough to read but at the same time I could hardly put it down.

Was this review helpful?

Another winner from Hannah. Makes me want to read some non-fiction accounts of women who served in Vietnam.

Was this review helpful?

Amazing story about the forgotten women who served in Vietnam. People didn’t believe there were women serving in combat areas. Recalls the war protests, veterans being treated like “baby killers”, campus protests that turned violent, and riots led by the Black Panthers. Frankie lost her brother to the war and now she is fighting to stay sane in a confusing world.

Was this review helpful?

Really enjoyed reading about the perspectives of women in Viet Nam during the war, definitely not one I had considered or previously read about. I've read my fair share of books based on the war, mostly because of how much the war directly impacted my family. The Women was a bit middle-of-the-road as far as Viet Nam War historical fiction. Though I appreciated Hannah's research and detail into aspects of the war and returning veterans, the romance really fell flat for me and I was honestly rolling my eyes a lot.

Was this review helpful?

The Women by Kristin Hannah is a historical fiction novel set during the Vietnam war. We meet Frankie McGrath, a young, idealistic nurse who enlists in the Army in 1965. The story is told in two parts. The first part tells of Frankie’s experiences in Vietnam, caring for the injured and dying soldiers. The second part continues the story after Frankie is discharged and goes back home to California.
.
The story focuses on the horror of the war and its aftermath through the eyes of the nurses who served in Vietnam. It is a compelling yet difficult read. The main character goes through traumatic events, especially when she comes home from her service in Vietnam. Thank you to St. Martin’s Press for my NetGalley ARC.

Was this review helpful?