Member Reviews

I didn't know what to expect when I started this book. It was a page turner. Every chapter is gut wrenching. I was too young to remember the Vietnam War.

I read this very quickly. Great characters. Fantastic plot. This is my first Kristen Hannah book. I will be reading more.

Was this review helpful?

📚📚 BOOK REVIEW🌟 🌟 💫

Rating: ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

“The women had a story to tell, even if the world wasn’t quite yet ready to hear it, and their story began with three simple words. We were there.”

Thank you St. Martin's Press, Netgalley and Kristin Hannah for a copy of “The Women” in exchange for a fair review.
A poignant tale of the young girl’s growth to a women, with the backdrop of the ill fated Vietnam War- The Women was one of the most anticipated reads of 2024 and Kristin Hannah flourishes with her skillful storytelling.

“She’d joined the war to find her brother and found herself instead. In war, she’d found out who she really was and who she wanted to be.”

When 20 year old Frances McGrath decides to enlist herself in the Army Nurse Corps to make her father and brother proud- little does she realize the perils of war she had signed up for- be it the invisible monsters flooding the battlefield or the divisiveness of her country to the act itself.

“Life over here is short and regret lasts forever. Maybe happy now, happy for a moment, is all we get. Happy forever seems like a shit load to ask in a world on fire.”

The first half of the book flashes by at breakneck speed with the author giving her readers a bird’s eye view of the terrain and hardships through Frankie- what impressed me the most is the aloofness of the author from any political beliefs and rather focusing on the viewpoints of all affected. Be it the friendship she develops with Barb and Ethel as she learns her trade amidst the bloodshed and protecting soldiers hurt fatally in combats or the heartbreaking tryst with romance- the first half will leave you thirsty for more.

“War was full of goodbyes, and most of them never really happened; you were always too early or too late.”

What follows though is a transformation as the author takes us through a darker phase in Frankie’s life upon return- a battle with her inner demons, the survival against PTSD, lack of support and recognition amidst a country battling with communism. The 2nd half was a tough read but never does the author slip in her command on narrative. This one is EPIC in every possible way and Frankie, as a war hero will be a memorable character for the rest of 2024.

“We were forgotten, all of us Vietnam vets, but especially the women most of all.”

Was this review helpful?

I know this take is going to be ~controversial~:I did not love Kristin Hannah’s latest novel, THE WOMEN.

Before you throw tomatoes at me, hear me out. I largely enjoyed my reading experience with this one, but it was predictable, and elements were verging on Lifetime movie territory. Let’s unpack.

THE WOMEN follows Frankie McGrath, a nurse who decides to enlist as an Army nurse during Vietnam. While she is at first out of her element, she saves soldiers and creates lifelong friendships. Little does she know that the real battle begins when she comes home and learns that Americans are not in favor of the war, which has begun to wreak havoc on her mental health.

Prior to reading this, I had seen nothing but glowing, 5 ⭐️ reviews about this book. I know Kristin Hannah has a strong legion of fans, but I’ve always been so-so on her books. While I find most of her work enjoyable, it always errs on the side of melodramatic soap opera for me, with the emotional touchpoint of her work feeling implausible due to the sheer volume of moments written to make you cry.

THE WOMEN suffers from this. SO many bad things happen to Frankie. While I’m not saying that bad things don’t happen to ordinary people all the time, the way they were crammed into this book felt like too much. When it’s one traumatic event after another, it gives the reader emotional whiplash. This was also SO predictable, to the point where I could guess almost every plot point before it happened. From a technical standpoint, I found a lot of this to be cheesy — the “Women can be heroes” line was eye roll-inducing — not because it’s not true (!) but because no one actually talks like that.

This review isn’t designed for me to bash this book. I landed on a perfectly respectable 3.75 ⭐️, and really enjoyed both the level of Vietnam detail and the focus on women during the war. The discussions of PTSD were an important inclusion. I wish this book had pared down on some of the over-the-top drama in order to allow these themes to flourish.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah's The Women may be her best work yet! I read this book in 2 days as I simply could not stop reading. Housework can wait!

Was this review helpful?

Do you have any must read authors? Authors that you must immediately read their new releases? Kristin Hannah has become that kind of author for me after I read The Nightingale around ten years ago for my Rogue book club.

The Women is an intense story of a nurse, Frankie, who served on the frontlines of the Vietnam War only to return home to a changed America that does not welcome home its veterans. How can Frankie find peace and a way forward in her civilian life?

• The Women was an intense and immersive story that made me feel like I was experiencing the changes that the Vietnam war brought to America in the 1960’s and 1970’s. I loved in the author’s note at the end of the book Hannah lists her extensive research list and also explains that she had real Vietnam War nurses and veterans review the rough draft of the novel to critique it and provide real world details. That really shines through in this book.

• I really liked that the book didn't end with Frankie’s return from Vietnam, but went through her struggles, PTSD, and treatment after the war.

• I enjoyed learning about the nurses that served during the Vietnam War. I had never really thought before of how they had experienced the trauma of the war and that they were not recognized as veterans when they returned home.

• This book NEEDS to be a movie. I have read that the movie rights have already been sold. I hope it actually does become a movie. I am still waiting for The Nightingale to become a movie.

• This book made me cry. Kristin Hannah is good at making me feel the emotions of a story.

• While I loved the historical fiction aspects of the story, the romance story fell flat for me. I don’t want to ruin the story, but I loved it all until the very end. SPOILER ALERT: I could believe one dead great love being alive miraculously, but two was too much for me. SPOILER END. As with The Great Alone, sometimes Hannah has problems ending a great book with a believable ending.

• I find it interesting that while most people really love Kristin Hannah, there are some that really don’t like her books and hate her for being a popular, best-selling author. If you didn’t enjoy her other novels, you will probably not enjoy The Women.

What has been your favorite book of 2024 for far? While I did not enjoy the ending, The Women was my favorite book of 2024 so far. I learned a lot about the Vietnam War and the men and women who served. It was an intense story.

Book Source: Review copy from NetGalley. Thank-you! Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

This book left me speechless. I’m still not sure I have the words to give this book justice. There are not enough books out there about Vietnam, so I jumped at the chance to read this. And considering Kristin Hannah is a must read for me anyway, I couldn’t get a copy of this one fast enough. Kristin can do no wrong in my eyes.

Frankie signs up to go to Vietnam as a nurse, because she feels like that’s the only way to gain any respect from her father. She had no idea what she’s getting herself into. She forms everlasting friendships with her fellow nurses. There’s graphic detail about battlefield hospitals and what they see and do. She sees people she loves die, she can’t save many of the soldiers she sees.

When Frankie returns home she experiences a whole different kind of trauma. It amazed me to read about what Frankie went through. I know that a lot of veterans don’t get the treatment and help that they need, even today, but it really showed me that it was an issue even back then.

I had the opportunity to read this book with multiple book clubs and it was amazing to talk to people about it. Some who lived during the time period, and hearing stories about people’s family members from that time, I even remember my father’s experiences during that time.

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for my ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Rarely does a book impact me to the extent that this one did.

The Women follows the story of a young woman in the US during the Vietnam war. In hope of making her family proud, she enlists in the Army Nurse Corps to serve and is shortly shipped out. We are given a glimpse into her life in Vietnam and then how she copes with coming back to the US.

This novel could easily be classified as an epic. The reader is quickly swept up in the story and is cheering with the main character and heartbroken with her. I easily cried multiple times while reading this book.

Parts written by another author may have felt trite or commonplace, but Hannah writes with such grace and mastery that it all made sense. This nearly 500 page book flew by.

I am so grateful to have picked up this book and been able to share Frankie's story, if only for a moment.

Was this review helpful?

QUICK TAKE: If you like Kristin Hannah books, you'll like THE WOMEN. I liked it…fine. I’m not a big historical fiction reader, so maybe don’t trust my opinion here, but there’s enough to lean into here with Hannah’s story about a wartime nurse and her rough reentry into society after coming home from Vietnam in the 1970s. The book burns through a LOT of story, and MC Frankie basically goes through every possible trauma one could experience (miscarriages, alcoholism, neglectful parents, cheating boyfriend, etc). I will say, having not read a lot of books about the Vietnam War, I thought Hannah did a nice job educating readers on a dark time in US history while managing to keep the story fast-paced and entertaining.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve been putting off this review because I always find it hardest to review books I loved & man oh man did I love this one, y’all. 🥹

Anyone who has read a book by Kristin Hannah knows how wonderful of a storyteller she is & I think this may be her best work yet. The character development, plot, setting, imagery - it’s just all so incredibly well done.

Although historical fiction is easily my favorite genre, I tend to gravitate towards WWII HF, solely because I’ve always found it most interesting & complex. For that reason, I put this one off & dismissed it (Vietnam? No thanks!) until FOMO got the best of me (thanks bookstagram!) and I finally gave it the shot it deserved. I’m so so glad I did & I’ve been recommending it to anyone & everyone I know.

I found the Vietnam content way more engaging & interesting than I expected & felt transported to the front lines thanks to Hannah’s detailed descriptions. Frankie was such an easy character to cheer for & man did she face some adversity. I really felt for her multiple times in the book. KH also nailed writing a few unlikeable characters (IYKYK). I think weaving love stories into historicism novels can often be a little difficult to do, but Hannah features plenty of romantic drama without taking away from anything else. I also really loved the representation of Frankie, Barb & Ethel as badass nurses & especially loved their friendship.

When I finished this book in early February, I expected it to easily be my fav of the year. While I’ve since read two others I loved just as much, it’s up there. Please please pick this one up if you have the chance, but please know there are trigger warnings galore.

Was this review helpful?

I won't lie I went into THE WOMEN, very excited but I was a little disappointed. Kristin Hannah did a great job at telling a story about a group of women history seemed to forget: the women helping in the Vietnam war.... the women who were also there for the bombings, the death and destruction... the women who also had to deal with PTSD and the consequences of the war, but without the shining glory of being called a hero.

THE WOMEN explored Frankie, a war nurse who truly finds her true self while serving in Vietnam, but when she returns home, has quite a hard time assimilating back into the world she left. Her parents do not understand her anymore, but still expect her to be the obedient daughter and do exactly what good daughters do: go to dinner, dress up and get married. Frankie seeks help but doors are closed: women aren't veterans, women aren't heros and to many, women weren't even "in" Vietnam. Hannah's exploration of this isolating world is important and fascinating. A truly wonderful piece of literature for those that connected to it.

I personally found the text a little slower paced than Hannah's usual stories and I wasn't quite as captivated. All in all, its my problem and not the books as many found this to be a thrilling piece of literature & I still cannot wait to read what Hannah writes next.

Was this review helpful?

I fell asleep within the first two chapters. I'm sorry. I know she is great, but her writing is just way too descriptive for me. It was a DNF.

Was this review helpful?

I couldn’t put this down. Hannah’s writing, even when describing horrible atrocities, is mesmerizing. My heart bled for Frankie, and all the forgotten women of Vietnam. May we never forget - and thanks to Hannah, I know I won’t.

Was this review helpful?

What an amazing story from start to finish. I always love how much time Kristin takes developing her characters. It makes you feel like you know them personally. One of the standout themes in this book was that our trauma changes us. We can never go back to the person we were before that. And lastly, our trauma is uniquely ours.

Was this review helpful?

Probably my top book of 2024. WOW. Kristin Hannah has done it again with another gutwrenching, emotional historical fiction. Going into this story, I truthfully didn't know too much about the Vietnam War, and KH really sucked me into the time and the story. This story was filled with so many twists, so much pain, so much emotion - but I really could not put it down. This story is extremely inspiring and empowering - it will certainly stick with me for a long time.

Was this review helpful?

I have no notes. This book shook me to my very core and will live in my soul until the end of time. I don’t know if it is because I am a nurse myself or the fact that I am married to an Army Combat Medic Veteran who wears his own invisible scars of a different war fought years later. I had literal full body goosebumps, many audible gasps of surprise, and plenty of silently shed tears. This one touched me in ways I didn’t even imagine. It’s brilliant on so many levels.

Kristin Hannah is a master of her craft and in these pages is everything you have come to love about the stories she tells. She’s one of the best. I will forever be reading anything she writes.

My only regret is I didn’t read this one sooner. If it’s on your TBR, move it up friends. Don’t wait. It’s an educational, gut-punch of a story that will stick with you for a LONG time.

Was this review helpful?

Talk about a book hangover! I love the books that Kristin Hannah writes, especially her historical fiction. The Women was no exception!

Like many people, I've heard about how veterans were treated after coming home and it always makes me so sad. But I've never really considered especially now the women were treated. I laughed and cried during Frankie's story. I can't imagine giving up your life to serve your country and then being treated so horribly on your return. Kristin's storytelling ability immerses you into life during and after the Vietnam war so well that I felt like I was hearing the songs and sounds of the times. This will probably be my favorite read of the year.

Was this review helpful?

Heartbreaking story about the women of Vietnam. It’s so hard to fathom how they could serve their country and see the evidence of war but not be recognized or supported for their efforts. I felt such a connection to the characters, their struggles and moving past the nightmares that haunted them. Kristan Hannah just has an amazing ability to tell a story.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was really well written and I look forward to reading more from this author in the future. I think it will find readers at our library, so we will definitely be purchasing for the collection.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah has such an incredible gift for sucking readers into her stories. As someone who usually does not gravitate towards historical fiction, I am still fascinated by her characters and the time periods they inhabit. I loved that this was told from a nurse perspective and was so intrigued by Frankie’s story both during and after her time in Vietnam. So impressed by this book!

Was this review helpful?

This is an amazing book. It personalizes social commentary on the Vietnam War in a way that has the experiences of combat nurse, Frankie McGrath, speak to all women, regardless of age and whether they have any personal connection with the war at all. I found it impossible to hold back the tears throughout the last 10% of the book, and much of what came before that also brought out the tissues. Even so, the book is hopeful and a testament to Frankie's, and all women's, core strength in the face of decisions that we look back on with disappointment in ourselves and the way that society sees as women and passes judgment upon us. The book is about finding oneself and being seen and heard in a world that wants to put us in our place. It also deals with the experience of being lied to, both on a personal and political level, and I can't imagine a woman who hasn't been affected by that.

Kristen Hannah manages to take us to Vietnam and place us right in the middle of a hospital where the damage Frankie sees and deals with is overwhelmingly horrifying. Although the sections of the book that take place in the U.S. are equally transportative, Hannah's talent really shines as she places us in an environment most of us have never come close to personally experiencing. The war story she immerses us in turns into an exploration of American attitudes toward the war and its warriers as Frankie returns home, and then into a love story that takes place in the midst of personal and societal misogyny. The book works on so many different levels, each of them compelling. Despite its length, THE WOMEN is so readable and engaging that is nearly impossible to set it aside. In the time spent not reading, I found myself thinking about the book, and even dreaming about it.

Was this review helpful?