Member Reviews

A psychological mystery about a girl who is dealing with the death of her brother and feels like she can see and hear ghosts.... and has become the number one suspect in her new coworker's murder. Neely can see ghosts, she's haunted by them, from the little girl under her bed to the man in her closet... and now to her brother who has recently died. Her family has a history of mental illness and when her brother committed suicide, Neely is still reeling from everything. She decides to take a new job as a tour guide in the caverns of Ohio, it'll help keep the ghosts away. There she meets Mila, a gorgeous, strong, and kind coworker who becomes close to her. Yet one day Neely's hallucinations escalate at a staff party after she takes some drugs... only to then find Mila's brutally murdered body. Now Neely is the number one suspect but her memory is vague and her grip on reality is tenuous at best. She has to figure out who the truly killer is, even if it means its her. This was such a unique murder mystery because our narrator is so unreliable and her grip on reality is slipping. She barely knows whats going on and she can't be relied on to give an accurate account, which only makes the mystery so much more fun to try and figure out. I loved how odd and weird this one was, and the mystery was a fun one. Definitely recommend for fans of mystery books with unreliable narrators!

*Thanks Netgalley and HarperCollins Children's Books, Katherine Tegen Books for sending me an arc in exchange for an honest review*

Was this review helpful?

5 Stars! Mindy McGinnis has a brilliant and disturbed mind when it comes to writing.

This story follows Neely as she deals with the death of her mother and brother. She manages to get a job as a tour guide in a cave system where the monsters in her head can't bother her.

Was this review helpful?

I love that YA is getting thrillers that are interesting and not just involving social media. McGinnis created a character who experiences mental health, while also not making it their full identity. Anything with caves creeps me out and I think that just added to the atmosphere.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the author, publisher, and Net Galley for an ARC of this book in exchange of an honest review.

Wow, Mindy McGinnis has done it again with another nail biter, edge of your seat, faced paced thriller. My heart broke over and over again for Neeley. McGinnis knows how to get you hooked and write an unputdownable book. Her characters are memorable and stay with you. Major book hangover after this one. Be sure to be aware of trigger warnings and sensitive content.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Every Mindy McGinnis book I have read has been so delightfully unhinged, all in different ways, and this book is no exception to that rule. I did figure out whodunnit a little more than halfway through, but I put that down to pattern recognition and not it being crazy easy to figure out. The resolution was very satisfying, and the whole thing was just a perfect October read,

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully written, poignant and heart-breaking, "Under This Red Rock" is a dark read both literally and metaphorically. The main character, Neely, has auditory. hallucinations and a history of mental illness in her family. She finds respite in caves, yet her safe place becomes tainted when a girl is found murdered. Mindy McGinnis is an excellent writer and handles this material well. Recommended for young and/or adult readers. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC. #UnderThisRedRock #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Mindy McGinnis is such a dark, twisty writer, and I love seeing where she goes with each new book she writes. Under This Red Rock was no exception to the exploration of dark corners, both literally and figuratively. Neely is not a reliable narrator--she has auditory halucinations and a family history of mental illness. She has secrets she has to keep and memories she can't quite unearth. The only way she can quell the dark voices is when she goes underground in the caves. This book could be triggering for people with depression and mental illness as we are following Neely's confusion and continued breaks with reality. However, there are bright moments such as when she finds friendship, a crush, and the thrill of the cave tours. When a girl is found murdered in the cave, and all evidence points to Neely, we finally begin to unravel the mystery as well as the origin of her hallucinations.

I thought this was an outstanding work of horror, coming of age, and healing. If anyone needs a dark twisted horror, I would recommend this to teens and adults.

Was this review helpful?

This book was amazing. I was on the edge of my seat the entire time, it just drew me in and didn’t let go.

The anticipation of the big bad thing has such a slow burn effect. It’s almost tortuous, and then when it happens, it’s a shock to the system. It’s like the world upends itself and the next adventure starts.

Mindy has this way of describing mental health matters in a way that neither sugarcoats, nor over-dramatizes. I have found that some books offer and romanticized version of mental health discussions and this is the opposite. This is is gruesome without being horrific. It’s honest, without being over-the-top. It’s a necessary discussion and it was necessary to the story.

Overall, amazing. I am reminded over and over as to why Mindy is an autobuy author and I am so happy I was able to read this from NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I don't know why I put off reading the ARC of this. Like...it's Mindy McGinnis, of course I am going to be edge-of-my-seat invested in every chapter.

It's also just very surreal to continue to see so much of my part of Ohio reflected back to me when I read her work. I mean it makes sense, because she grew up and still lives just two counties over from where I grew up, but you don't often see that part of the country in YA lit.

Anyway, another terrifying, beautiful book by McGinnis.

Was this review helpful?

When I tell you I would read anything Mindy McGinnis writes I tell you with my whole chest! I adore every book McGinnis writes and this one is no exception! I read this whole book in one sitting! I can not praise McGinnis enough and this is one of her best works. Do yourself a favor and read this book! It's worth it!

Was this review helpful?

I love a good Mindy McGinnis novel. She's an author that is incredibly reliable, I know I will always love any book she writes. She's incredible at building tension and suspense and Under This Red Rock is no exception. I absolutely could not put this book down, there was not a point in this book I could have predicted. I loved it. I LOVED IT!

Was this review helpful?

This book was CRAZY! Full of ups and downs and twists that you would not have seen coming, and then to find out that that isn't what happened at all over and over? And then the huge plot twist at the end? The book was just so good!

Was this review helpful?

<b>”Sometimes you have to.”</b>

Mindy, wtf?! I want to eat Mindy’s brain and just live there because it fascinates me and terrifies me all the same.

I freaking loved this book! I wish I could just tell you what happens but you wouldn’t believe me anyway bc like I said, Mindy wtf!!

I never thought I’d be freaked out and laugh and cry all in the same book as much as I did in this one. Neely, is so strange and we freaking love that about her. I won’t stop thinking about her and all her people for a while.

She’s gone through so much it’s sad. I just wanted to give her a hug but she would have hated that. Sometimes her thoughts and even the things she actually said are hilarious. Morbid, dark humor. Other times she was alone and scared and… that’s her normal.

She gets a job under ground where her monsters can’t speak. And then everything seems to follow her on a downward spiral from there.

The ending actually took me for a little loop. I felt betrayed! We trusted, we felt comfortable, we dropped our walls and thought this was it. And then Mindy slinks in and twists everything you know.

<b>And can I just say, I hope all my cats are real…</b>

Was this review helpful?

Mindy McGinnis has once again made me feel something. Her books - especially this one - are always so raw and vulnerable and real, and that's what makes them a standout to me.

Was this review helpful?

Under This Red Rock discusses generational mental illness and what can happen when it goes undiagnosed, not medicated, and have a professional to talk to.

Neely hears what she considers monsters, but they have rules and the only place she cannot hear them is in the caverns. So she starts working as a tour guide in the caverns to get away from her monsters. She then meets Mila and soon becomes infatuated with her. One night after a party with alcohol and drugs her monsters are now visible and Mila is dead inside the caverns. Who killed Mila and was it her?

Was this review helpful?

Neely is struggling with severe mental illness, being the last of her immediate family, and having grandparents who care but aren’t sure how to help her. When Neely gets a job at the caverns, she meets Mila; a girl who is everything that she is not. Infatuation borders on full fledged obsession as she gets closer to Mila, until after a staff party, Mila is found brutally murdered. Neely must now try to figure out who would hurt Mila… or if it could have been her.

Mindy McGinnis perfectly handles the severe and heavy topics that make up this book. This book shows how everyone has demons and skeletons in their closet, encapsulating the silent but deadly illness that is mental illness. This a book you will want to stay up all night reading, as you grow more attached to the characters. I wouldn’t suggest this for the faint of heart and to tread lightly when picking up this book, as the themes are dark and disturbing a lot of the time.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure what to expect with this book but I ended up loving it and reading it in one day.
It is intense and unexpected.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't know what to expect going into this book but in the end I did enjoy the story and the overall plot of the book.

Was this review helpful?

Mindy McGinnis never fails to create dark, twisting stories that take us into the minds of dark, twisting girls, and her newest book, Under This Red Rock, is no exception. Despite having loved everything that I've ready by Mindy McGinnis, I went into this book hesitantly because of the subject matter. Themes of insanity, suicide, murder, and violence can be especially tricky to write about. However, McGinnis deals with these topics with a deft touch, not shying away from the difficult details, but not reveling in them, either. She does not pull punches in any of her books, and we experience everything that main character Neely experiences in a confused and painful way. I would absolutely recommend this book, but would also suggest that readers enter into this world with caution; tread lightly, and watch your step.

Was this review helpful?

First of all, thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance copy of this book.

Under This Red Rock is intense and unexpected. Every time I thought I knew where things were headed, Mindy McGinnis took a hard left into new territory, and I enjoyed the ride.

I felt so many emotions throughout the reading of this book, and it's going to be a great addition to my list of books that highlight various mental health conditions.

Was this review helpful?