Member Reviews

Congratulations Tessa, you’ve done it, you’ve made me like golf… or at least like a golfer 😝

From page one, I was hooked. I can’t believe I’ve had to live this long without having a sports romance book written by Tessa frickin Bailey. Josephine and Wells are the ultimate grumpy x sunshine couple in my book. The way Tessa wrote their love story, it seemed impossible not to fall in love with their chemistry, connection, and intimacy.

My only complaint, is I NEED MORE 😭 I never wanted to stop reading about them. The epilogue was perfect, but if you could just write a really fluffy book of their lives starting from where the ending left off, that would be great. 🤪

“Being around her again was like waking up after a lung transplant and remembering what it’s like to breathe.”

Wells mother truckin Whitaker is my new book boyfriend.

If you love the grumpy x sunshine trope, touch her and die mmc, and 🍑🍑🍑🍑, this book is for you. (Even if you could care less about golf, seriously read this book.)

A big thank you to Avon Books/Harper Collins Publishing and Netgalley for providing this eARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This was really enjoyable. Tessa Bailey is sometimes hit or miss for me, but this was solid. I don’t usually do sports romance but I enjoyed the aspects of it that were related to golf, especially because Josephine was clearly portrayed as a powerhouse in the sport in her own right. And loving it for its role in her life and not just because she’s a fan of a golf player.

I also appreciate how Bailey’s main characters get more and more mature. I think some of her earlier works were criticized for being a little misogynistic, but each book I’ve read since It Happened One Summer shows that she sees that her readers want healthy relationships and mature characters. Or rather, characters that grow and make the right choices, and help each other to be better without fixing each other.

I found the third act breakup to be a little contrived, but it was redeemed for me by the characters coming to intelligent, mature conclusions about themselves and their relationship through introspection. And supporting characters.

I also enjoyed how writing a heroine with T1D was in honor of her daughter, and showing how those who have to deal with a faulty pancreas can and do live lives of fullness and normalcy.

As always, Bailey’s work is full of spice and dirty talk. If that’s not your thing, you’ve been warned. If it is, you’ve been informed.

Thank you Netgalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Tessa Bailey has become my go to author for great laughs and fun romance I can't put down, and Fangirl Down was no different. In fact, this book exceeds the rom com expectations.

The characters were witty and charming with the ideal amount of grumpy to her sunshine (especially with how much I wanted to squeal every time Wells admitted how much he was already head over heels for her basically- love that for both of them).

Definitely one of my favorite books by Tessa Bailey and I can't wait to read more.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars!
Oh I LOVED this one!!!
Now I will say I was a bit hesitant because the mf plays golf and I’ve never in my life been interested in golf or know of any hot men who play golf. However, I now stand corrected because Wells Whitaker the man that you are!!! Oh I absolutely loved him and his grumpy self. And Josephine was such a breath of fresh air and I liked how open and honest she was with Wells! They balanced each other out perfectly. From the way they communicated with one another, their banter (which was hilarious fr I was audibly laughing out loud), and the tension between them?!? Y’all aren’t ready because these two are HOT HOT HOT! I just thought everything flowed beautifully and I really felt the love between both of them. I had so so much fun reading this one and I genuinely think a lot of people are going to be pleasantly surprised reading it. Don’t let it being about golf fool you okay!!! Gosh they’re so many moments I truly adored about this book but as this was an ARC I shall keep the spoilers to myself🤭

Thank you Netgalley and Harper Voyager/ Avon for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

3.75

On the surface, finding out that this is a romcom about golf and especially professionals on the nation tour, I might have immediately recommended this to my mother to read. Fortunately, not only is the book not yet released and, more importantly, I already knew that it was a Tessa Bailey romance and what that meant. In brief, though I enjoy most of them, hers are not books I would ever recommend to my mother. And if my mother has ever read anything like this, I don’t want to hear about it.

To be clear, Tessa’s books, and this is definitely one of them, she writes descriptively about sex, uncensored and sometimes very kinky.

That aside, this is a sweet, touching, inspiring story using a setting not often covered in a romcom. The characters have depth and a lot of it is believable. She has issues. He has issues. Together, they make a formidable pair. There have been other romcoms about golf, but I loved that they came together to make this formidable pair and the setting of the pro golf tour was new to me and interesting (much more interesting than the tournaments my mother watches). It’s a cute story and worth wading through some stuff that is maybe sometimes a bit too raunchy for comfort.

I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for providing an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

Tessa Bailey's foray into the world of sport romance had me in the first half, but fizzled out in the end. An overreliance on tropes, likely inserted on purpose to sate the BookTok crowd, makes this one not up to par. Also a major blow to us ladies trying ardently to convince everyone that we're not working in sports just to fraternize with the male players!

Was this review helpful?

The perfect read!

Now I’ll be honest I was a little worried going into this book that it was going to be information overflow about golf, but I was pleasantly surprised. This book had a beautiful balance of golf and romance!

I loved the dynamic of this book so much, I think the characters got along extremely well and their chemistry could be felt constantly throughout the book.

I loved seeing the romance develop between the two main characters, how they built a friendship and then developed into more!

THE SPICE!? OMG IT WAS SO GOOD!! Sometimes I feel asthough spice can be overdone in books and take over the plot of the book, however in Fangirl Down, it was a perfect balace of spice throughout the book.

Overall this was such a fun read and one I will definitely be rereading once it is released! I can’t wait to get my hands on a physical copy!

Thank you so much to Avon, Harper Voyager, NetGalley and Tessa Bailey for providing me with this e-arc in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Incredibly surprised and pleased to see this book did not browbeat me with heteronormativity and gender essentialism even though it’s the straightest book I’ve ever read. The smut was fun but this was undeniably the weirdest premise ever. A golfer cannot exude a “touch her and you die” vibe because golf does not ascribe itself to violence and scruffiness. The core of the sport lies in having so much free time and wealth that you cut down acres of trees to make empty green instead of using the land for housing and community. Hard to suspend my disbelief but I suppose in fiction anything goes. The diabetes representation was well done though.

Was this review helpful?

When I say I gobbled this book up….gah! I’m a firm believer Tessa can do no wrong, but this book may be my new favorite of hers. I CANNOT WAIT for Au Pair Affair. Do yourself and start this one today. 5 glorious stars.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to @netgalley and @avonbooks for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I really liked this book and can't wait for the rest of the series! Sports romances are my new Roman Empire. Tessa Bailey has always had a great way of making banter and grumpy MMCs the best in her books. But Wells and Josephine def take the award for best banter. They are so well written and developed and their relationship is very real and loving.

Was this review helpful?

I had so much fun with this book; it literally had me giggling and kicking in my seat. Their development from fangirl/caddie and professional golf player to equals/dating was done so well. The banter was so much fun to read about and I love that you can see just how well they know each other, even when they're bickering. Wells and Josephine are so committed to each other and it's obvious how they look at each other as a sign of security/hope. They both make each other better. It's a very wholesome relationship. I really liked Wells' character because we can see how protective he gets and he just wants to be better for her. I love that he was so transparent about his feelings, both to himself and to Josephine. He's so aware of what he needs for both of them to be happy in their relationship and I thought he was a great main character. As for the conflict, I appreciated his thinking and although I can understand Josephine to an extent, I was a little frustrated with her but it was a very quick conflict.

This book was full of humor, precious and heartfelt moments, and I was definitely not expecting to love this book as much as I do. There was a lot of depth to this story and on top of all the wholesome, playful, heartwarming, and utterly cute moments, Josephine and Wells are truly perfect for each other (I will admit though the spicy moments can get a bit cringe-y at times but this didn't really bother me much). This might just be my new favorite Tessa Bailey book!

Was this review helpful?

Tessa Bailey came through and had another big hit with this one. I absolutely loved the writing and the story. Tessa Bailey has been an auto buy and auto read author for me. Thanks for the ARC copy!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book!

Wells Whitaker was golf's darling, until he blew it all up. Josephine is his #1 fangirl until the bitter end, when he walks off the course and rips her sign. After a hurricane, Wells feels compelled to help Josephine turn her life around - and falls for her in the process.

I appreciated that Tessa Bailey did not spend much time of the specifics of golf, as I don't care for it. Instead, we got some very, very steamy scenes and characters that jumped off the page.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Tessa Bailey is truly some kind of magician to be able to make golf HOT.

I wasn’t sold on the premise of this one but I’m a TB stan so I gave it a shot and I should have known better than to question her brilliance. I was IMMEDIATELY sucked into Wells & Josephine and their electric relationship on and off the green. I AM THE FANGIRL DOWN.

From the way that she coached him to believe in himself to the way he loved her exactly the way she needed to be loved it was pure grumpy x sunshine joy. And that grumpy mouth sure can spit some GAME.

Thankfully more time spent on the relationship (🔥🔥) than on the specific details of golf but there was enough in there to make this a true sports romance, enjoyable even if you aren’t a fan of this particular sport.

Was this review helpful?

Dual POV
Golfer x Caddy
Grumpy x Sunshine
Forced Proximity
Bad boy golfer
She’s his #1 fan
Touch her and die
Diabetes representation


I will forever fawn over Wells and Josephine.

Wells Whitaker might be known for his boorish behavior and consistent crudeness, but when he intentionally detonates his career and sends his last remaining fan home for good, he knows he has made the biggest mistake in his life.

After a hurricane destroys her family’s pro shop, Josephine Doyle never expected to find Wells at her door, but he is determined to do anything to help her succeed in rebuilding her legacy — even if this means rejoining the pro circuit with Josephine as his caddy.

Josephine and Wells’s chemistry is truly palpable. But, it’s the respect, honesty, trust, and loyalty that add so many layers to this all encompassing romance. Wells is utterly bewitched by Josephine’s magnetism and Josephine is just as captivated by Wells’s consistent belief in her strength.

Fangirl Down is the cheeky, enchanting sports romance you didn’t know you need!


If you love Fangirl Down, check out Kiss My Putt by Tara Sivec!

Was this review helpful?

I didn't think it could be done, but Tessa Bailey made golf SEXY. And if there was a Wells Whitaker on tour right now, I can guarantee that there would be a huge increase in PGA tour viewership.

I admit that I haven't read Tessa Bailey even though I've been wanting to read a few of her books. I am so glad this was my first because this sports romance was clever, charming, and every fangirl's dream come true.

Josephine is the number one fan of pro golfer, Wells Whitaker. He was once on top of his game but has struggled both on and off the golf course. His latest attempt at making the cut for a tournament has him contemplating retirement so it still boggles his mind when he sees Josephine cheering him on at every hole. That's a fangirl for you; loyal even when the going gets tough. And then he does the one thing that could leave him all alone, he rips her 'Well's Belle' in half not only singling out his one fan but making her question her loyalty. This time it's Josephine who is ready to throw in the towel of being his #1 fan girl.

The following day, he begins to feel bad for hurting her. He finds her at her family's golf shop and makes her a proposition she can't refuse; be his caddie for a few tournaments. She could really use the money for health insurance, her diabetes medicine, and repairs on her golf shop.

Wells is grumpy, sarcastic, and one could even say a jerk but Josephine brings out his softer side. As they are prepping and going over the game plan, they are both enjoying each other's company. They laugh so much at all their inside jokes, stand up for one another, and learn to trust each other pretty quickly. I love how Wells puts her needs above his own. She was scared of him finding out that she had type 1 diabetes. She didn't want him to coddle her and treat her like she couldn't do anything because she has this disease. She wants him to know that she can control her numbers and will take care of herself.

Tessa Bailey's writing is just magical. I can picture her words and see them playing in my head like a movie. The romance was just beautiful to see. because Josephine and Wells are a perfect match. And there are a few spicy scenes for my smut lovers. Get your fans ready because things get HOTT!

Fangirl Down is a must-read sports romance that will make you want to start watching golf if you aren't a fan already! Wells will make you swoon and Josephine will leave you applauding her strength!

Was this review helpful?

Fangirl Down has one of the most unique starts as we meet Josephine who is a fangirl for a golfer named Wells Whitaker. It’s clear from the start that Wells’ career is on a downward trajectory and after choking at a golf tournament, he takes it out on Josephine who is truly one of his last loyal fans.

Josephine leaves in a huff and Wells doesn’t start to feel bad until later. After some reflection, he finds her and asks her to help him get back in the sports good graces. In exchange for being his caddie and much more, he’ll give her a cut of his winnings. Given that Josephine is struggling to pay for her diabetic supplies and fixing up her parent’s golf shop, she decides to agree.

From there, we watch as Josephine slowly but surely changes Wells. He goes from being a complete jerk to being a great and respectable player and man. Of course, things start to get complicated as the attraction between them sizzles. These two are brimming with sexual tension from the start in a way that only Tessa Bailey can write.

While the story does focus a lot on Wells, we also come to love and feel for Josephine. She’s doing so much yet doesn’t get nearly as much credit as she deserves. I honestly felt stressed for her when it came to certain things. Ultimately, these two end up pushing each other in the best way and I couldn’t get enough of them as I read this book in two sittings.

As for the third-act conflict, it felt a bit predictable yet I do think it had to happen to give the story more stakes. Given that I haven’t been loving some of Tessa Bailey’s recent releases, Fangirl Down ended up being a lot of fun and surprisingly sexy. Plus we get some rep for women who like big butts and cannot lie so what’s not to like?

If you’re one of those people who are wondering if Tessa Bailey makes golf sexy, the answer is not really. There’s nothing inherently sexy about the sport yet their relationship is the right amount of sexy.

Was this review helpful?

Fangirl Down is the first novel in the Big Shots series. This is a new Tessa Bailey sports romance series that explores the grumpy/sunshine trope. This type of romance can be very hit or miss, so I was very excited to see Bailey’s take. The story follows golfer Wells Whitaker, who is struggling to become a rising star again. When he finds out that his number one fan who is always cheering him on from the sidelines, Josephine Doyle, needs some cash, he decides to strike a deal with her. She will try to help turn his game around while he will pay her to act as his caddy. The two travel and work together as they begin to get to know each other.

Josephine has Type 1 diabetes, which was a nice inclusion as, so far, I have never read another story that included it despite it being fairly common among the population. I liked that this did not become Josephine’s defining trait and instead was just a part of her. The one element about Josephine that I did not enjoy, however, was her “not like other girls” tendencies. This type of character is not enjoyable to me, so there were a few moments where I wasn’t a huge fan. Since the timeline of the novel is a little shorter (a few months), there is a little insta-love and a lot of focus on the smut. There are some moments where it seems the smut takes over when it could have been reduced and had the same impact. While there were some flaws, this story was a very fun read. There is some great character development and I love how Bailey incorporated her signature style. Overall, there are some changes that I would prefer to make it feel more balanced, but I still look forward to reading more Bailey novels in the future.

**I give a special thank you to Netgalley and the publisher, Avon, for the opportunity to read this entertaining novel. The opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.**

Was this review helpful?

Ok, Tessa Dare is an auto-buy author for me, and no matter what she writes, there's a very good chance I'll read it. That said, while this was a pretty decent book. it missed the mark on a few things.

Short summary: Wells is a professional golfer who is on the decline (he's a bad-boy golfer, which just sounds funny to me). Josephine runs a family golf store, and she's his biggest fan. After he basically gives up on his career, he asks Josephine to caddy for him and offers her much-needed money in return. Of course, sparks fly and there is a swoon HEA.

Here are where I had some issues:

1. This story/plot would have been excellent with another sport. I'm not hating on golf. It just didn't fit to me. If it had been basketball or football or hockey, but golf? It just felt weird. I absolutely love the "fangirl" plot, but the fact that it was golf was something I couldn't relate to in the slightest.

2. Don't get me wrong: I liked Josephine, but something about her reminded me of Hailey from Secretly Yours and she is the worst Tessa Bailey FMC ever. I'm kinda tired of grown women acting kinda...immature.

Here are some of the things I liked:

1. Wells is a perfect Bailey MMC. Dirty-talking, hot, alpha--he's pretty much the whole package.

2. The bargain they struck up was interesting. I thought it lent some believability to the plot.


Once again, this book would've been 5 stars if it wasn't for the golf element of the story. I was hoping Tessa could make me care about it, but it just felt....off.

**A big thank-you to NetGalley and Avon Books for a copy of this book to read and review.**

Was this review helpful?

There is not much Tessa Bailey could right that I WOULDNT enjoy. I wasn’t so sure going into this one because a. I’m not a huge sports romance fan, and b. I hate golf. But I should have trusted Tessa would deliver. This feels like a deep dive into some of her older work, but with a more advanced and honed in writing style. I loved every single steamy second. No one dirty talks like a TB book boyfriend. NOBODY. I’m so ready to read more in this series.

Was this review helpful?