I was aware and had read about the Scopes trial. Science vs. Religion. A very good movie about this as well. The story told through the eyes of a fictional character was interesting in that Annabel herself evolved.

The Evolution of Annebel Craig by author Lisa Grunwald was enjoyable to read. It was based on the true events of the trial of John Scopes for teaching the theory of evolution in the classroom, which was also known as 'The Monkey's Trial.' I had never heard of this trial and it was interesting to find out that Scopes was actually a pawn for religion vs. science. People in the town thought a nationwide trial would have a positive effect on their poor economic town.

The author well-researched the actual trial and told the story from the eyes of the main character, Annabel Craig. Annabel grew up in the Bible belt in the city of Dayton, Tennessee in 1925. She grew up very conservative with a unwavering faith in God and the Word. She was orphaned at a young age and later when George Craig, an intellectual attorney, comes to town she falls in love with him and they marry. She was the typical housewife of the time who catered to her husband's every need. During their first year of marriage, her husband is chosen to help defend John Scopes. Then we enter in a well-known Southern prosecution attorney, William Jennings Bryan, to help defend the Butler Act. How does this change Annabel? Does she stand strong in her faith to God? What is the outcome of this trial? It definitely affects their marriage. Neighbors divide against neighbors and the town is in conflict with one another. Annabel rises up and begins to have a voice in her own home.

I had the privilege to receive an advanced copy from NetGalley and Random House Publishing in exchange for an honest review. I recommend this book and look forward to checking out other books from this author. I hadn't heard of this trial and after reading this book, I went on to read more information regarding the trial, especially since I personally believe in creation and not evolution.

I obviously knew a bit about the Scopes trial but what was wonderful about this book was learning about the town where it took place, it’s people and the background as to how it came to take place in Dalton, TN. I thoroughly enjoyed this read and I am going to now check out the author’s prior books. I’ve realized that I often enjoy first person narratives especially when I like that person! No wonder I liked epistolary novels.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an early release in exchange for a fair and honest review.

Quick-moving and kept my attention, but it was so sad! I found myself rooting for the underdog, but it seemed nothing good was ever going to happen to poor Annabel. The writer did a great job with the historical elements, and this is what really keep the story driving for me. I also enjoyed Annabel's kindness and the way the author made her so relatable and truly believable. I learned a lot of interesting facts from this book--things that I feel may have been buried deep down in history books and are not widely known. For me, learning in this way is always a plus while enjoying fiction. The biggest downside for me was the missing element of hope. On the other hand, this "oppressed" vibe is so reflective of the 1920's.

Annabel Craig lives in Dayton, Tennessee in the early 1900s. She grows up on a farm with her mother and father, an only child despite her parents’ attempt to grow the family. Her mother travels to local communities to lead canning clubs, sometimes taking Annabel along. When the Spanish flu takes her father then her mother, Annabel is left an orphan at sixteen. She moves into the town’s boardinghouse where she also gets a job at the Aqua hotel and attends church regularly. She prays often for answers like having someone to love and one day, while forced to face her fear of water, entrusts her heart to George. A few short months later, they are married as George also embarks on his career as a lawyer. Annabel also takes up photography with her father’s camera she kept after his death. When the Scopes trial comes to her town, her world is rocked by what she learns.

As Annabel transitions from a child to orphan to wife, you see the evolution of her thinking and how your path in life can change who you are and the feelings you can experience. Her eyes are opened to a world outside her small town. We see Annabel transition for a God-fearing, dutiful wife to a young woman who is not afraid to question what she always took as face value. Through her witnessing of the Scopes trial and the characters it brings to town, she blossoms into using her curiosity to not see just one side of a story, but to learn all angles and then deciding her truth. (Side note: There is a lot of talk of religion in this book, but that is due to what the Scopes Trial was all about - God vs. Science.)

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for the advanced copy of The Evolution of Annabel Craig by Lisa Grunwald. Opinions expressed are my own. This book is set for publication on April 15, 2024. ⭐️⭐️⭐️

#netgalley #arc #bookstagram #LisaGrunwald #TheEvolutionofAnnabelCraig #RandomHouse

Set in 1925 in the small town of Dayton, Tennessee, this is a wonderful study of finding one’s true self. Annabel lived her entire life in this sleepy town and her dreams reached no further than marriage and children and living a good Christian life. And it appears all her dreams will come true. She marries George Craig, an attorney who recently moved to town and life is wonderful – for a while. Wanting to bring publicity and national recognition to the town some of the townspeople convince a local teacher to sue over the state law forbidding the teaching of theory of evolution in schools. They succeed in garnering national attention to town, but along the way divide the town into Bible Toting and Science Camps. And Annabel’s husband is on the science side. Like today’s political environment, both sides are so entrenched in their beliefs that they don’t even listen to the other and never discover they aren’t so different after all. Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for giving me an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review. Recommended read.

In 1925, 25 year-old Annabel Craig is a newly married woman living in her hometown of Dayton, Tennessee. After a blissful childhood on a strawberry farm, she was orphaned at 16, but courageously made her way in the world by seeking employment at the Aqua Hotel. On a hot summer day, she meets her future husband, George Craig, at a local pond. He's been watching her for weeks as she stands on the side, never having learned to swim. George coaxes her in and tells her "I've got you," and thus their courtship begins.

George is an attorney who has just moved down from Chattanooga to practice law at a local firm. An orphan himself, he and Annabel seem to be kindred spirits, and George, at first, is a supportive and encouraging husband.

However, after a trial George wins that results in devastating consequences, George retreats within himself leaving Annabel to question the man she thought she knew.

When the Scopes "Monkey" Trial comes to town, George seems to become his old self and secures a spot on the defense team of acclaimed attorney Clarence Darrow.

As the trial unfolds, Annabel will again question her feelings about her husband and begin to see that there is a place for the teachings of evolution and creationism to exist together.

I really liked Annabel's character. She was a woman who realized her worth as a homemaker and in the wake of the trial that upset her hometown, she also realized there was a whole world that she needed to explore. I Iiked that she didn't cower to George or anyone else.

Lisa Grunwald's writing style was lovely as well. One passage I highlighted was: "When you grow up on a strawberry farm, you probably always miss the smell too--the sweetness that, even before the fruit blooms, seems to sit like a mist on the air."

For those of you who like Southern fiction and/or historical fiction, put this on the top of your list!

Thank you to Random House Publishing Group and Netgalley for an ARC ebook edition of this heartfelt novel.

I was asked to review “The Evolution of Annabel Craig” by Lisa Grunwald.

I read a lot of historical fiction but have not read many novels that cover the particular era of the Scopes trials, which examined the teaching of evolution in public schools.

Annabel Craig was able to get through a rough childhood because of her faith. Yet, when her husband joins the team to defend the man (Scopes) arrested for teaching evolution, she is forced to reconcile her beliefs with what her husband is advocating.

As an attorney and law professor, I love a good trial novel and though I enjoyed the legal aspects of the book what I liked the most was Annabel’s own evolution. (Pun intended).

Four out of five stars.

A huge thank you to the author and publisher for providing an e-ARC via Netgalley.

I loved this book, couldn't put it down. Annabel Hayes, born in small town Dayton, Tennessee was orphaned at the age of 16. Four years later, she fell in love with George Craig a young lawyer who came to Dayton from Knoxville. Their love was strong for the first year, but with an incident that occurred among other losses, their relationship began to show signs of strain. In 1925 with the arrest of John Scopes for teaching Charles Darwin's theory of evolution in High School their marriage was falling apart,

The spectacle of that trial with William Jennings Bryan as lawyer for the prosecution and Clarence Darrow as lawyer for the defense brought that small town onto the map. The frenzy of that trial was overwhelming. Religion against science. A town that had congregants that went to either the Methodist North, the Methodist South or the Baptist Church. Journalists couldn't get to Dayton fast enough and the citizens, at first, couldn't welcome them fast enough. But as the trial began, it was clear that the people of Dayton became divided against one another. Along with Annabel's husband who joins the defense team, she starts questioning her beliefs and marriage vows. Will Annabel have the courage and strength to take the path to her own evolution?

As I'm reading this I'm thinking "what is it that people are against about learning about evolution." My own answer was Fear. To learn something new went against all that they understood, the Bible, the pastor, the church. Is there any reason not to learn something new, is there any reason to leave your religion? Certainly, learning doesn't mean leaving what gives you comfort. Fear, Prejudice, Hatred...these are words and actions that should make you tremble. This is what in 2023 we are facing. This book gave me "food for thought" and I had to pause at times, just to think, to put myself in these people's shoes!

This book was well written and well researched. I applaud Ms. Grunwald for taking on this topic My thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Random House for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

A young Southern woman discovers herself, her husband, and the world around her when her faith is tested during the infamous Scopes trial taking on teaching evolution in schools.

My favorite historical fiction is like this book. I learn about an event I knew nothing about, the Scopes Trial, but I also get an engaging story on its own. Annabel has great character development as she learns how science and religion can coexist. The trial was slow at moments for me but it is historical so important.

“People who say they know the Bible from cover to cover but don’t act on it are the ones who cause the trouble. Better to concentrate on this world than spend too much time thinking about the next.”

The Evolution of Annabel Craig comes out 4/16.

Annabel Craig doesn't set out to become anyone's role model. Born and raised in small-town Dayton, Tennessee, she cares about and for her neighbors. She goes to church, reads her Bible and believes in the Golden Rule. She is married to George who believes a woman's place is in the home, full stop. Annabel's caring for her neighbors takes time away from staying home and taking care of George.

With the arrival of the Scopes "Monkey" Trial, her worldview starts to shift. Annabel is a talented photographer and when Lottie, a big city reporter, befriends her, Annabel is allowed to take pictures of all the players in this trial, and attend the trial. Her husband, George, is one of the minor attorneys on this case. As the trial progresses so too does Annabel's vision for herself in the greater world. I learned how the trial came about and the greater importance around it and how it changed the world right along with Annabel. An excellent read, and one that women today should read and take to heart. Who was it said, "Well-behaved women don't make history."

I'm not quite sure what I was expecting, but this book didn't quite work for me. I liked the mix of fictional characters and real people. The author clearly did her research on the Scopes trial. Some plot points were well done and others felt a bit incomplete. Annabel seemed quite sharp, except for where George is concerned, which felt a bit unrealistic. The cover leads the reader to expect a cheerier book than this turns out to be.

I would like to thank Random House and Net Galley for the opportunity to read this book as an ARC. This is an historical fiction book set in 1925 in Dayton Tenn, against the back drop of the Scopes Trial. It tells the story of the town of Dayton, and the effects of the trial on the town, and on one couple in particular. George Craig is an attorney in Dayton and is on the defense team for John Scopes.His wife Annabel, is an amateur photographer , and a deeply religious woman as well as a dutiful wife. Annabel begins to change, evolve if you will, as the trial makes her rethink everything she thought she knew- about her life, her faith and her marriage. I really liked parts of it- it was a skillful blend of fictional characters and "real people". The trial was well researched and written. I was not as happy with the fictional parts- somethings seemed too pat to accept, others not followed through enough. In one instance, one of the reporters is given housing with Annabel and George- would you really take in a news reporter if you are part of the defense team? George seems especially dim and vague, for a lawyer.It was also a sad book in many respects. The cover art is quite cheerful, and the book is not.I have enjoyed Lisa Grunwalds writing, and will read her future books. This was just ok for me.

This is a wonderful story centered around the events of the Scopes Trial in Tennessee in the 1020's. I was intrigued by the historical setting of this piece of history. The quiet little town really stirred up a storm when they decide to charge John Scopes and challenge the Constitution. Annabel Craig is our main character - a submissive little housewife who has been struggling to hold her marriage together and find herself. Her husband is a local lawyer with a past that haunts both himself and Annabel. As the chaos of the trial grows people begin to question their beliefs which in turn turns neighbor against neighbor. The perspective of the story really helps it come to life and gave me a greater understanding of this historic event. A great story. Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing for the ARC.

I enjoyed the premise of The Evolution of Annabel Craig, but ultimately, in execution, the book did not work for me.

Unfortunately this wasn’t my “cup of tea”, which is a pity because I absolutely adored Ms Grunwald’s ‘Time After Time’. I found ‘Annabel’ rather slow going, with more tell than show and Annabel’s character hesitant to realize and react to the world around her, which makes for a bland heroine.

Thank you to the author and publisher for providing me with a digital ARC of this title via Netgalley in exchange for my honest review.

I previously read another title by Lisa Grunwald, Time After Time, and enjoyed it so I looked forward to trying another. The Evolution of Annabel Craig was a completely different kind of story, but equally well done and enjoyed. Annabel Craig lost her parents and is left alone to figure out life and find her place in her small town. She thinks she found true love and purpose in her marriage, but it doesn't go as expected. As a nationally followed trial takes place in her hometown over teaching evolution in schools,Annabel learns truth about her husband and herself. Nice story of personal growth and the importance of being open to new ideas and thoughts instead of prematurely judging without learning.

I really loved this book. I didn’t know what to expect, and I’m not sure I could have even expected what this book was, but it was enjoyable from the beginning to end. While the idea of religion being on trial swirls around the Scopes trial, this book does not put religion on trial. This book looks at enlightenment and the ability to think for one’s self. It embraces religion while acknowledging that you can also embrace science at the same time. While about a long ago time, this book is fitting for today and holds truths that many of today’s readers would benefit from learning.

The Evolution of Annabel Craig was an enlightening book on many levels during the time of the Scopes Trial . First it showed the mindset of people in small towns during that era, especially how woman are seen and expected to act. It also showed how people in a small town at that time respond to important events taking place locally.

Specifically in this book, we have Annabel, who we find out lost both her parents. Within the situation she found herself in, she did meet and find a husband, named George, who happened to be a lawyer. She perceived that he treated her well. And she was like all other women of her town. Things happen and there is some issues, then George is to be on the now famous case!

The story from here on in is about Annabel’s life, the town and the case. It’s fascinating to hear and see it all. However, nothing is as clear cut as it seems and there is the question: who is really the winner of the case at hand?

I wanted to read this novel because I’m from Paducah, where John Scopes of the infamous Scopes Trial is buried. I love doing research on the “residents” of Oak Grove Cemetery (where Scopes is), and he’s been on my radar for a while. In fact, I’m a little disappointed that Lisa Grunwald beat me to writing about it. But, since she did such a fabulous job, I’ll forgive her.

This trial is a fascinating piece of the American puzzle, and I love how the author approached it from a young woman’s point of view. Annabel Hayes, the protagonist, was “born, baptized, and orphaned in the sleepy conservative town of Dayton, Tennessee.” She falls head over heels in love with a passionate attorney, George Craig, and sees him as the answer to all of her problems.

When George has a professional setback, though, he comes undone, and Annabel’s view of him shifts. Then, when he becomes involved in the 1925 Tennessee vs. Scopes case, more volatile ups and downs collide in the couple’s life.

Against the backdrop of the debate about evolution, Annabel begins to figure out who she is as an individual, as a woman who is not solely a wife. Grunwald makes keen observations about religion, sexism, and the American way of life without the reader feeling as if she’s judging or making a case for a particular view.

I loved this book and am so thankful NetGalley and Penguin Random House allowed me to read an advanced copy.