Member Reviews

Read this in the wintertime which is what i implore each and every one of you do as well. As a big fan of Mexican gothic, i was over the moon to hear she was coming out with a short story, and oh my was it gripping. The writing was so lyrical and the romance on top of that was so beautiful. Silvia, darling, you will never disappoint me.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC.

A dark and sensual fairy tale, reminiscent of the Brothers Grimm. Silvia Moreno-Garcia always writes such bewitching, atmospheric prose, and The Lover is no exception. I found the story to be very well-rounded for being so short.

"Love! What a simple word that could not encompass her feelings, so deep and turbulent she feared she'd drown just by looking at him. Her every waking hour was yearning; the nights were sleepless sorrow."

Was this review helpful?

This is my first official review.

This story took a turn I was somewhat expecting but also didn't see coming.

I continued to read it, forgetting that this was a short story and was left with wanting more, though it did have a few bits of boredom in the beginning, it was quick to catch my attention again for me to be more invested in Judith's story.

Definitely would love a better view of the village and the family to understand the circumstances a bit more, but other than that, the world building was okay as it was mainly centered on the plot.

Was this review helpful?

One of the best short stories I've ever read. The feel of a fairytale makes you wonder if this is Cinderella or Little Red Riding Hood only for it to have the most unexpected twists. The story takes you through a long emotional journey of longing and despair in a mere 28 pages. I have loved SMG's work, but this story cemented her as one of my favorite authors.

Was this review helpful?

The Lover has got to be one of THE most interesting short stories I’ve ever read.

Days after finishing this story and I still can’t wrap it around my head what it is I read!

I’m so used to Silvia Moreno Garcia’s gothic style creepy writing and this one more than delivered.

This was like a Cinderella vibes type story where Alice the youngest sister is treated horribly by her older sister Judith & not only does Judith steal the man that Alice had feelings for but forces her wait after them and take care of the inn they run without much pay. When a strange man shows up to town, her sister’s husband suddenly finding interest in her & a wolf coincidently prowling the woods around them.. things start getting a bit confusing for Alice and trust me when I say, you will not be expecting that ending!

Was this review helpful?

This fairy tale novella follows a girl longing to find her lover who she believes will come from beyond the forest to sweep her off her feet. When her overbearing sister marries the hunter she has fallen for, they begin an elicit affair. But is he really the one for her? And who is the mysterious new stranger come to town who insists he can turn into a wolf? The Lover has all the feel of a traditional fairy tale, but fleshed out into a novella. Fans of dark fairy tale retellings and supernatural fantasy will be swept away by this tale of forbidden desires.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this dark, strange fairytale. I typically have a hard time with short stories caring about the characters and wanting more, but I was immersed in this story from the first line and the ending was so satisfying in a way that I always want from a short story, but don't often get. Silvia Moreno-Garcia can really write anything, and I will read everything she writes. This is a perfect spooky, wintery story to sit and read in one sitting on a snowy night with a warm drink. Thank you Amazon Original Stories and NetGalley for an advanced reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

The atmosphere of this story and setting was immaculate. I thought the familial relationships between Alice, Judith and Nathaniel were messy and really well captured given how short the story was and the plot progression and conclusion were very satisfying. A great quick read.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for a fair and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

What a delightful novella but Silvia Moreno-Garcia. I truly adore everything she has ever written and this is no exception. A savage little fairy tale that had me wishing for more.

Was this review helpful?

This is a really nice short story - it was impossible to put down thanks to the intriguing atmosphere and the beautiful writing. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this short story. It was quick, fast paced atmospheric story..one that reminded me of reading one of Grimm’s dark fairy tales. It is wicked, dark and enchanting, and I loved the prose.
I would have loved for this to be a bit longer, but for a short story it still contained depth and mystery and I still enjoyed it as it is.

Was this review helpful?

a wonderful short story from such a brilliant upland coming author within the Mexican community. I love Garcia's writing and can't wait for more

Was this review helpful?

A simple and fairytale-like short story. I was hoping to be a little more surprised or horrified, but the story was still entertaining enough.

Was this review helpful?

a short, symbolic and sexy fairytale...a quick and interesting read!

curious about what I'd notice on the second read-through.

Was this review helpful?

This one was well written and beautiful but just not really my speed, it was different from her more traditional books

Was this review helpful?

Eh. DNF at 40 %. It wasn't written badly or anything. I just wasn't invested in the plot or the characters, and it wasn't for me. Seemed like your basic fairy tale sort of thing!

Since it's a DNF I don't feel comfortable posting this anywhere else.

Was this review helpful?

Wow, this short story packs a lot in its 40ish pages.

The Lover reads like a dark fairytale retelling of Little Red Riding Hood. Judith begrudgingly finds herself under her sister's care and influence as their Grandmother dies and she remains the only unmarried one of the two. Their relationship has always been strained, but even more so when Alice remarries and she chooses none other than Nathaniel, a handsome huntsman whom Judith believed to be her foretold lover. Between this forbidden love and a vagrant come to town during the brutal winter who keeps pestering her, what's Judith to do with herself?

Worth noting that Alice, Judith's sister, is probably the only one-dimensional character in this whole story. She's the epitome of the fairytale evil sister who neglects her sibling but showers herself and her husband in luxuries. Judith herself is a great character who goes through uncertainties, moral dilemmas, heartbreak and ultimately redemption.

Well worth a read of you're a fan of dark fairytale retellings, mystery, forbidden love and a bit of magic!

✨ Disclaimer ✨ I received a free copy of this book and this is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very eclectic tale. It's a gothic tale reminiscent of a fairytale with a dark ending. It's intriguing and a bit confusing.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you netgalley and Silvia Moreno-Garcia for the ecopy. I'm providing an honest review.

I've really come to appreciate short stories in between longer novels so this was a nice break.

I like adult fairy tales, I like dark adult fairy tales. And I love werewolves. I had a lot of fun with this. Sometimes I feel like we lose a lot of connection with shorter stories but I didn't personally feel that way here.

Was this review helpful?

Ok, I fell o love with Silvia's writing at first line when I read Mexican gothic and I everytime I read something new I say: that's my favorite one.
And yes, that amazing short story is my new favorite!
I've been struggling about what to say because I think everything can be a spoiler and you should read this one without knowing anything. Trust me.

Was this review helpful?