Member Reviews

Historical Fiction is my favorite genre and this book did not disappoint. It was so emotional and wonderfully written!

Was this review helpful?

This well researched novel links together three time periods - 1942, 1946 and 1969. The author does a fantastic job of linking together the people in each time period and the result is a story that won't be forgotten.

1942 - Claudette is a seamstress who is disabled and unable to walk to school. She was basically illiterate until a Jewish peddler taught her to read and became her friend. After her grandmother dies, she goes to a French chateau in the Loire Valley as a seamstress. She begins to get very worried as she hears about the German Army invading France because she knows that they often killed invalids. When her friend, the Jewish peddler and his son show up at the chateau, she hides them for a few days and also has an affair with the son. After he leaves, she finds out that she's pregnant but refuses to tell anyone that the baby's father is Jewish. When she escapes to Spain with the Duchess and family, she makes a devastating decision to leave her baby behind with a nursemaid so that he'll remain safe. Will she ever see her son again?

1946 - Youth Aliya, a group of Israeli agents is combing the French countryside in search of Jewish orphans to send to Israel. During the war, Jewish children were often left with Christian families for safety and the parents never returned from the camps to claim their children. Youth Aliya was working to teach these children about their Jewish history and to help them regain their pasts. During this time period, the British were not allowing boats into Israel so the groups had to make secret and often dangerous trips to Israel to take their children to their new homes. Claudette is not aware that her beloved son has been rescued by this group and adopted by an Israeli couple.


1969 - twenty-year-old Israeli intelligence officer Sharon Bloomenthal, still grieving the loss of her boyfriend in a drowned military submarine, is recruited by naval officer Daniel Yarden to assist with the Cherbourg project - an Israeli military action involving the escape of the five missile boats from the French port of Cherbourg. The boats had been paid for by the Israeli government but had not been delivered due to the French arms embargo in 1969. When Sharon learns that Danny came to Israel with the help of Youth Aliya, she tries to find out if he knew her deceased mother who arrived in Israel at the same time. In trying to find out information about her mother, she discovers a secret about Danny and works to solve the mystery of his past.

As with many of the untold World War II stories, many of the people in the story were based on real people and real situations. I learned so much in this book -- I had never heard of Youth Aliya and wasn't aware of their work to find abandoned Jewish children and send them to Israel and I wasn't aware of the escape of the five boats in 1969. The characters were all well written and believable. Be prepared to shed a few tears -- some sad tears for the children that were left behind in France but also happy tears for the new lives they were able to begin. If you read WWII fiction, this is a definite MUST READ!

Was this review helpful?

The Boy with the Star Tattoo by Talia Carner was an excellent piece of historical fiction.
Carner has such a unique ability to combine historical events with character development that makes the characters come alive and all the human ways. She has the ability to evoke the complete range of emotions in her readers.
This story was a page turner and the character development of these characters were exceptional
Our MCs are written with such heart you feel for their every step in life.
The dual timelines really set scene here.
A gripping story of courage, of love and loss this is one not to be missed!

"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own."

Thank You NetGalley and William Morrow for your generosity and gifting me a copy of this amazing eARC!

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of "The Boy with the Star Tattoo from Negalley. This book focuses on two different time eras. The 1940s between 1942-1946. And skips two decades to 1968 and 1969. In the forties in Europe Claudette a teenager with a crippled leg. a kind man taught her to read. She falls in love with a young Jewish man and becomes pregnant. since the baby is born out of wedlock and he is half Jewish the baby is in danger. Claudette fearing for her baby and her own safety she has a tiny tattoo of the star of David put on the baby Benjamin's foot. she is separated from the baby when he is six weeks old never knowing if she will ever see him again.
Flash forward to 1968 a young woman named Sharon is working for causes in Isreal and France. lOst her own mother when she was an infant after the Holocaust. She meets Daniel a soldier. Sharon learns of the baby Benjamin with the Star Tattoo and sets out to find him and hopefully reunite him with his mother if she is still alive. there is lot of going back and forth between the decades slowly intertwining other characters and the what became of mysteries. I liked this book for the most part but found it a bit annoying to go back and forth between the decades. comes together well though. I would give this book a 3.5.

Was this review helpful?

A fan of WWII historical fiction, I was looking forward to reading this book, which focuses much on postwar happenings. It weaves together the story of several people. Claudette, a crippled woman who is afraid of being discovered by Nazis in France during WWII and sent away or even killed for her disability. Claudette falls in love with a Jewish man and discovers that she is pregnant after he has left for safety. Just after the war is the story of Uzi, a young man with Youth Aliyah, tasked with bringing Jewish children from war torn France to rebuild their culture in Ersatz Israel. Twenty plus years later and we have the story of Sharon, a young woman awaiting news on her fiancée whose submarine is missing. She is recruited by Danny, a naval captain from Israel, with a secret mission. Sharon discovers a secret having to do with Danny and does a little sleuthing without his knowledge to find out his background story.
I had known a little about the Youth Aliyah but this book certainly gave me new information on the difficult job and how they often had children adopted by loving families who were not Jewish. I’m sure they often struggled with the decision of whether to take these children away from their new families. I appreciate the author bringing a different story to light.
I did however, feel a lack of connection with the characters. I wanted to feel more of what they were dealing with, whether it be the loss of a loved one, or the feeling of fear. There were also many words that I had to try to figure out via context, either French words, or Hebrew words. When that happens often, I lose the flow of the book. I also struggled when I had to put down the book for a while to remember what was happening and who was who, because there were quite a few people in the story as it was weaving between three different things. I decided to just finish the last 40% today so that didn’t happen again! The ending seemed a little abrupt and I would have liked it to tell more about what happened afterwards.
As I mentioned, I did enjoy learning more about the Youth Aliyah which was, quite possibly, my favorite part of the story.


Thank you to William Morrow for an ARC of this book. All opinions in this review are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A sweet and heartbreaking story of one woman’s quest to find her lost child and another woman’s quest to defend her country.

Was this review helpful?