Member Reviews

Book 2 of The Alamaxa Duology delivered everything needed for an excellent sequel! Just wow, I loved this book, and I could not put it down! It picks up right where book one leaves off and takes us on a wild ride to the very end. Every moment I felt on the edge of my seat, the stakes were so high for all of our beloved characters.

I loved Nehal and Giorgina's character growth throughout the book. Their relationship with each other, as well as their friends, warmed my heart. Female empowerment, deep connections, and friendships are at the core of these books, and I loved them so much!

Honestly, I could read a whole other book just based on these women living their lives and how they adapt and move forward in the future.

Thank you so much NetGalley and Harper Voyager for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Much like with the first book in this series, I could not put this down and basically read it all in one sitting. Loved this world and these characters and this particular system of magic. This was a really well done and satisfying ending to the story. I look forward to reading more from this author and I hope to see something else set in this world!

Was this review helpful?

An excellent follow up to the first book, The Weavers of Alamaxa further delves into the ethics of revolution and it's impact on all types of people. The growth of all the characters was impressive and natural. The magic system was really fun and well thought out.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Harper Voyager, Avon, and Netgalley for the complimentary ARC. All opinions provided are my own.

Hadeer Elsbai blew me away with her debut novel, The Daughters of Izdihar. It was a gorgeous expression of feminist rage through magic. I had high expectations for the sequel, The Weavers of Alamaxa, and am glad to say it exceeded them.

Early on I was concerned because the author set up many new conflicts and I wasn't sure how things would resolve. The scale of the conflict and the scope of magical powers is much greater in the sequel while feeling authentic to the characters.

The book moves along with a fast pace thanks to short chapters and excellent plotting. I was impressed with how much plot was packed into the book without ballooning to double the size. There are multiple large climactic battles that are executed well. The ending is well earned and satisfying.

Was this review helpful?

What an ending! Thanks Netgalley and Harper Voyager for letting me review an ARC of this Book!

The Daughters of Izdihar are in trouble- after a disasterous protest at parliament turns deadly, Georgina and Malak are behind bars, and Nehal has been kidnapped by the neighboring country of Ziriana- an oppressive monarachy that hates Ramsawa and Weavers, and has a plan to destroy both, if the Daughters cannot stop them.

I liked the first book of this duology, but I found myself enjoying this one SO MUCH more than the first- with the world building/character background complete, the reader is able to jump right into the story. I love the decisions the author made about how these cahracters evolved, getting stronger and softer in ways, and how the Daughters leaned on each other to get through their hardships and meet their goals. We lost some key characters in this book and that hurt but I think it was worth it in the end.

Fun read, recommend.

Was this review helpful?

The Weavers of Alamaxa by Hadeer Elsbai is the second in a fantasy novel duology (after The Daughters of Izdihar) following two women, Nehal–a noble waterweaver–and Giorgina–a working class earthweaver. The two women were bound together by their connection to one man and their involvement with the Daughters of Izdihar, fighting for the women’s right to vote in Alamaxa and their right to exist as weavers, or elemental magic users.

This was a book I was highly anticipating and wow, did it deliver! I had a fear of a second book slump, but that did not happen at all. Elsbai picked up right where she left off in the first book and brought us right into the action. Seeing the greater world was intriguing and I still think the elemental Tetrad of power is interesting, especially with what gets introduced in this book.

For the characters, I liked both Nehal and Giorgina’s growth, particularly how they both changed to overcome their unique failings. There was a certain point towards the end that it clicked for me how the characters were perfect for their roles, because they were so wrong for them–that overcoming their shortcomings is why they work so well. Sisterhood is a strong theme in the book and I love that it took precedence over the romance angle for the characters.

I also love that the author wasn’t afraid to shy away from hard themes and having difficult things happen. The only thing that bothered me was that the author felt the need to state the social justice themes at certain times, such as a character stating out loud “All police are bad” right after the POV character came to that conclusion. Great message, but I felt that it was clearly articulated by the author throughout the book and the duology, and to me it seemed that stating it like that took away from some of the effect. Luckily, the instances I can think of happened early on and luckily the author moved away from being so hamfisted and instead wove her themes into the story as a whole.

Overall, I absolutely adore this duology and thought it was wrapped up beautifully, without any issue. I don’t know what Elsbai has in the works, but I am so excited to find out.

Favorite quote:
“But she suspected that she would, for the rest of her life, have grief as her unwanted companion, no matter how much time passed.”

Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and publisher for allowing me to read this book as an ARC so I could give an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A truly satisfying conclusion to an excellent duology, The Weavers of Alamaxa fulfilled all expectations set by The Daughters of Izdihar and then some, broadening the world and complicating the characters in ways I didn't see coming. The ending was spectacular.

I received an eARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

Broadly speaking, this succeeds as the second half of a duology; the stakes, which were already high in the previous book are raised and executed on, there's a fantastic wrapping to the series that I wasn't quite expecting and came a bit suddenly for my personal taste, but still manages to wrap incredibly well, and we get to see more of Nehal and Giorgina developing as characters and as foils to each other through their experiences and solidarity. (I do feel like Nico being fridged is a bit ultimately amusing but honestly, go Ms. Elsabi, that's a wonderfully ironic inversion of the fridging trope as its usually used!) I do feel like the pacing could've used another book to breathe, but unfortunately in today's market and with Daughters of Izdihar getting hyped but not sales, she likely wasn't given the room of an extra book to let it fully breathe, and it still manages to wrap well, even if it feels a bit cramped and slightly deux ex machina-ish towards the end.) If you loved the first book, definitely pick this up to see how it all ends.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed reading the conclusion of this duology! The character development was very intentionally and gracefully executed, and the plot was exciting and easy to follow.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review.

3.25/5

A solid conclusion to the duology, at the same level the first book was in my opinion.

This book had a decent amount to like about it, but also a few major flaws.

Starting with the good, the world and setting remain quite unique in the current fantasy landscape, though some aspects were... simplified to suit the needs of the plot in this book(will get into this later).

Nehal's character continues to be a highlight, her journey in this book is quite compelling and she faces a lot of consequences for her actions in that journey. Some of her character realisations felt more tell rather than show on occasion, but I ended up liking them nonetheless. I also liked the general arc of Giorgina's character, even if the execution fell flat for me in some aspects. There was also more of Malak in this book, who is probably my favourite character in the series and I really liked the very understanding relationship that developed between her and Giorgina. Honourable mention to Etedal who also shone in this book despite her limited page time.

There's a major character death, which while plot necessary, really took me by surprise. Elsbai continues to impress me with how brutal she can get despite the overall tone of the series not being quite that dark.

I also really liked the ending. A lot of fantasy books or series tend to end quite abruptly nowadays, but this took its time to deliver a satisfying conclusion.

As I've mentioned, however, the book had some major flaws. The politics in this book was vastly simplified, which while made sense for the plot, resulted in some of the goals being achieved a bit too easily. The stakes in this book, despite being higher somehow felt less significant than some of the the personal stakes of the last book.

The new characters introduced were not explored as well as they could have been. Hali and Rasida came off as fairly one-dimensional antagonists, partially due to the limited page time. Even the Zirani rebels were not that well explored, outside of Athar who was a rather frustrating character. There is a certain scene, where everyone just goes with her plan, even Malak, despite being against it and having no reason to really do so. It leads to about as a bad result as Malak could expect. That felt like that happened just because it was needed for the plot instead of a logical conclusion the characters arrived at.

There were also a few scenes in the book that really led nowhere, so it was not really clear why they were in the book in the first place. The mythology and the lore of the book were also not quite well foreshadowed for what it turned out to be, which was not that interesting. I expected more from the Edua story in particular.

All in all, The Alamaxa Duology is a solid but flawed story with some interesting characters and very timely themes. The Weavers of Alamaxa, like the first book, is fast-paced and easy to read. If you liked the first book, I think you will enjoy the second.

If you are new to this book, these books feature an Egyptian-inspired republic, with suffragettes and a magic system similar to the one in the Avatar series. If any of that sounds interesting to you, I'd recommend picking this up.

Was this review helpful?

I read the first book earlier this year and fell in love with the characters and the setting. This is a good follow up, the characters actively grow throughout and that was wonderful to see. There was a little emotional rollercoaster in this, which was well done. As a sequel, I enjoyed it, but I thought it wasn’t as tight as the first. Still a great read with a great message!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC!

3.5/5 stars

Same as with The Daughters of Izdihar, there were aspects of this book that I really liked and there were parts I wish Elsbai had done more with.

Things I really liked:
The worldbuilding and the conflict - the war between the 2 nations was really interesting and added a good level of conflict and tension throughout the book. The rivaling governments were interesting, as were the different rebel groups.
Some of the character development - I really appreciated that we saw actual growth and critical thinking here from Nehal, especially. She was still a bit spoiled by the end (my biggest gripe about her in book one is she never stopped being a spoiled Noble) but she had definitely grown a good bit because of what happened to her. Giorgina had some good growth too, but I'll talk about her more in a moment.
A death at the end I wasn't expecting, but was needed - I won't spoil, but there is a character death I didn't expect her to follow through with but I agree was necessary for the plot and I love that she didn't pull the punch.
Other stuff, these were just the stand outs - for any complaints, this is a really good duology!

Stuff I didn't love:
Missed opportunities - there is a big reveal at the end that just felt like it had a lot of missed opportunities for foreshadowing. Meaning, it isn't that it doesn't fit or make sense, but nothing happened in either book that really laid a good groundwork for it to come about. There were tons of places that really good hints could have been given without being obvious, but they weren't taken advantage of.
Giorgina's character development toward the end - there was a lot I loved that happened with Giorgina in this book, but there is a critical point at the end where she just....she hesitates and goes against the plan she made and it causes havoc and it leads to the a big development but it still was super frustrating.

So final thoughts: I think Elsbai has a really solid start here and handled a lot of hard topics well; however, I think she has some maturing to do in the depth with which she handles some topics (granted, this is YA) and with her character development and foreshadowing. I did really enjoy the story and her writing is good, I just didn't love it as much as I had hoped.

I still highly recommend this duology to any YA Fantasy reader!

Was this review helpful?

A fantastic conclusion to a duology that is definitely on my list of favourites now. There was just so much about this book, and especially reading it right now, it hit hard. I cannot recommend enough.

Was this review helpful?

A fantastic conclusion to a duology that is definitely on my list of favourites now. There was just so much about this book, and especially reading it right now, it hit hard. I cannot recommend enough.

Was this review helpful?

I loved book one in this duology and this is a solid but not extraordinary follow-up. While I love the world of Alamaxa and the political intrigue, parts of this one moved rather slowly. However, I still loved the Egyptian-inspired fantasy world and the suffragettes as the main characters. Definitely a good end to the story.

Was this review helpful?

When I reviewed Hadeer Elsbai's Daughters of Izdihar, I called it "fantastical, feminist rage." The second book in her Alamaxa Duology is all those things elevated. Which is to say: I absolutely loved it. And, frankly, I can't think of a more timely read. My main worry when I started reading Daughters of Izdihar was that it was going to turn into a love triangle pitting Nehal and Giorgina against each other. I could not have been more wrong. They have one of the most fascinating companionships between two women I've ever read in any novel. In Weavers of Alamaxa, their relationships to their Weaving grows and evolves, as do their relationships with their lovers, and with each other. They grow to care about each other, deeply, as they see each other in new ways. They save each other, over and over!

In Daughters, they were fighting for the right to vote. In Weavers, they're fighting for their lives and the promise of democracy for their entire country. They're fighting for their collective freedom and their personal agency. They're fighting for oppressed people everywhere, in every way, because all our liberation is tied together. Weavers finds a remarkable balance between action, relationships, and character interiority that moves the entire story along at such a clip I couldn't put it down on. My only complaint about this entire series is that I wish it had been a trilogy. I wish the first third of Weavers had been a second book, and the last two-thirds had been the third book, just a little expanded. My only complaint is I wanted even more of Giorgina and Nehal's story!

The Weavers of Alamaxa is empowering and devastating, and I'll be thinking about it for a very, very long time.

Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Voyager for the opportunity to read this book and provide and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

oh. my. fuck.

i hope to come back to this when i'm more rested and can edit in a better review, but i am just. SCREAMING. and athar!!!!! athar!!!!!!! athar i am in LOVE with you do you have any time available where i can just listen to you talk and agree with anything and everything you say.

nehal, you were incredible and strong and brave, and i love her still like. using her connections and they still *work* which is just so? objectively hilarious but fits so well for her. hurting and hurting and forcing her way through as she learns and grows. and giorgina!!!! giorgina!!! *damn*. malak you were there and ibcredible and worshipful too.

holy fuck. thank you. hopefully will edit in a better review below.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

I was excited to receive this ARC, as it is a sequel to a book I also read an early copy of and loved. I really enjoy mythology inspired works from other cultures and this duology is quite masterful. Also, the sequel stands up to the first book rather than being a sophomore slump! The author has gotten even better in writing in this story and I enjoyed the action-packed pace.

Was this review helpful?

Following up on one of the most exciting fantasy debuts, The Daughters of Izdihar, Hadeer Elsbai concludes her Alamaxa Duology, inspired by Egyptian history and myth, with a tale of magic, war, betrayal, sisterhood, and love.

Just as good as the first book if not better. Well done!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a great conclusion to the Daughters of Izdihar series, and I really noticed how Elsbai's writing has grown and developed since writing the first book. This book has a lot more action than the first one, so while it was quite a different tone than TDoI, I loved it. Nehal and Giorgina both grew so much over the course of this book and really came into themselves. I also really liked seeing the world develop a little more as we learn about other countries and politics.

Was this review helpful?