Member Reviews
you know what? i've waffled back and forth but i'm sticking with it.
✘ the never-meet-your-heroes to i-can-fix-him-no-really-i-can pipeline is not my usual fare
✘ straight hair is not the express lane to LA beauty anymore like it might have been in 2006
✘ everyone is insufferable, one-dimensional, or both
✔︎ the dialogue and banter make all of the rom-com story beats sparkle
✔︎ the characters are just shallow enough for the reader to project depth onto - in a good way!
✔︎ i'm a simp for late-20s/early-30s level life shit getting in the way sometimes and still making for a good romcom
many thanks to st. martin's press and netgalley for the advance readers copy.
Katherine Center has done it again! This is an enjoyable romance. I found the focus on writers fun, as well as the focus on writing (and defending) romance and rom-cons. The protagonist was a bit of a martyr, which did get grating at times. Overall a really quick and good read.
Okay so I almost DNF this book because the beginning was a hot mess. I don't know if it was just the ARC and it wasn't through editing or if it was Center trying to find the MCs voice it honestly felt like bad AI writing. It's also weird because I feel like this is par for the course when it comes to Center for me. I either love it or I'm like what the heck who wrote this?! BUT BUT BUT about 1/3 of the way in everything settled down and started to flow and make sense and feel good and I really enjoyed the rest of the book. So 3 stars hopefully it was an ARC issue and the final copy was 5 stars for everyone else
Well if this wasn’t one of the most delightful rom-coms I’ve ever read I don’t know what is! @katherinecenter in her brilliant little way wrote this book like a movie. This was so vivid I could literally SEE it playing out scene by scene on the screen. The main character broke the fourth wall from the get go and told us about her romance. This will sound weird but just go with me… it’s like if Ferris Bueller was a rom-com (hence the song). Brilliant.
This was a different kind of romance. Their connection seemed unconventional and the MMC especially seemed different. He’s not your typical hunky guy you swoon over but he’s got something else about him that you can’t help but be attracted to. And the MFC is one of the most resilient characters I’ve ever read. They brought out the best in each other which is probably one of the highest compliments you can give to a couple. And leave it to Katherine Center to give each character such grace as they work through their stuff.
I did often find myself wishing I could feel their romance a bit more. It’s one thing to read about their relationship on the page but it’s another to literally feel the butterflies and lovey feelings yourself as you read. So that is my one and only hang up. It’s just a personal thing you can’t really gauge until you read it. Other than that, it’s perfection.
The story was adorable, funny, insightful, and just down right too cute for its own pages. Oh and we get a Jack Stapleton cameo from The Bodyguard! Can we get this adapted into a movie asap please?! It would be criminal not to.
I was blown away by this book! I’ve always been a Katherine Center fan, but this one is by far my favorite. I laughed out loud so many times, and the ending had me wiping away tears. Charlie and Emma’s banter was fun, flirty and frustrating, and I loved every second of their developing relationship. Emma has a huge heart for others, and Charlie is confident and driven. They made each other better and it was really fun to follow their romance.
Thank you so much for sharing this book with me! It’s going on a bunch of my recommendation lists and I can’t wait to tell my reader friends about it!
Katherine Center hits it out of the park again! I LOVED Emma and how adorable she was. She had this perfect level of goofiness that didn't feel like forced quirkiness, but she was also so perceptive and smart. I teared up multiple times at one point (you'll know which scene if you read the book ;) ) and felt so much hope throughout the ending. I will definitely be rereading this one ASAP. Also, I started listening to this book as I headed out for a two-hour run and ran a PR for my ten-mile. So the current evidence suggests that listening to a new Katherine Center book while running will make you run faster. You're welcome in advance, fellow reader-runners.
Thank you to NetGalley and St Martin's Press for an advance copy of the audiobook in exchange for my honest review.
I struggled with rating this book and writing my review because I really like Katherine Center's writing style, but I couldn't connect with the characters in this book. Emma is hired to help Charlie rewrite his rom com movie script. He is known for writing other movies, but he has never written a rom com. Emma and Charlie are opposites, but they have to work together and live together for six weeks.
I didn't like that Emma tried to make Charlie face his fears. It felt like she was forcing him, and I didn't like that. I also struggled with all of the miscommunication between Emma and Charlie. As a character, Charlie's inconsistencies really got in the way of my ability to root for him. If I were Emma, I don't think I could ever trust him.
I also struggled with Emma's relationship with her sister. Emma had to be caregiver for their father, and she also helped to raise her younger sister.
Overall, I have mixed thoughts and feelings about this book, and it makes me sad to feel that way about it.
Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for an ARC.
I adored Katherine Center's "The Rom-Commers". Charlie and Emma's banter and grumpy-sunshine relationship was so freaking good. Their romance was slow yet somehow delicious - and this is from someone who doesn't always enjoy a slow-burn. Their story made me cry as well as giggle, and I highlighted numerous passages that I could not help but identify with. This story leaves you feeling hopeful and happy. 5 stars,
Thank you to NetGalley and SMP for a complimentary ARC of this book. These opinions are my own.
The Rom-Commers 4⭐️ 2.5🌶️
Contemporary Romance
Hollywood/celebrity romance
Workplace romance
Unwilling allies to lovers
Grumpy sunshine
Grief
Strong family
🏳️🌈Side Character
Injury disability rep
This was a very cute rom-com about a pair of screenplay writers writing a rom-com. It was cliche in the best ways, but also packed a punch when it came to a dressing trauma and serious topics.
I thoroughly enjoyed this story. The characters were complicated and dynamic. I found my self wishing that there was a little bit more vulnerability from the MMC for the big gesture, but he was also a silent but strong type... so, I don’t know. I’m conflicted. I was absolutely charmed by the epilogue.
The plot was a fun spin on a Hollywood insider’s romance. I appreciated that the boom wasn’t over-run by pop culture and real celebrity references. The pacing was perfect.
Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the eARC of this book. All opinions are my own.
Overall a super cute beach read. My issue was it felt like the plot dragged and there was no real development for the male character. He truly was mean and gaslighting the main female character. He needed therapy that is for sure.
I was so excited to read this book, and I was getting along fine (about a 3.5 read) until roughly the 95% mark. Immediately, this book became a 2 at the most. And I am so mad.
This is going to be a spoiler, but I think it's definitely needed so readers know what they're getting in to.
WHY WOULD AN AUTHOR USE A FUCKING CANCER FAKE OUT AS A PLOT DEVICE.
Please excuse my language, but I am BIG mad. Two of my grandparents had lung cancer and died due to complications from it. THAT IS NOT SOMETHING YOU USE TO EMOTIONALLY MANIPULATE AN AUDIENCE. It is insensitive and callous and plain lazy writing. Also, no self-respecting good doctor is going to give a patient a cancer diagnosis ON THE PHONE. As someone who has been through a cancer scare, the doctor will say there is something "concerning" on the scan/biopsy/etc and ask you to come in for more testing. When you get to the office and are face to face with the doctor, THAT'S WHEN THEY'LL TELL YOU. Not on a damn phone call. And they're definitely not going to tell you they fucked up and misdiagnosed you over the phone. Wtf even was that? Lazy writing at it's finest.
*deep five point five second breath* IYKYK.
I wish that was all that was wrong with this book. But sadly, it's not. I have a whole list of notes I took while reading. Which I'm usually not able to do, but I kept getting pulled out of the story.
Also, yes, there will be spoilers ahead.
“I fell in love all the time. Just… nobody fell in love with me back.”
This perfectly describes our main character Emma. Her feelings are finnicky, and her personality is all over the place. She has zero common sense, no backbone, overthinks every tiny thing, and is constantly eavesdropping on conversations she has no right to listen to.
Charlie is a terrible love interest. He constantly criticizes Emma, is always talking down about her, and doesn't seem like a good guy, even though everyone says otherwise. He never apologizes for the disgusting things he says about and to Emma. He hurts her over and over to "protect her from herself" and says he would do it again. What a great guy!
Also, they had absolutely no chemistry. It was like putting two dolls together and saying "now kiss".
This author has an issue with time management. A 15 minute walk is apparently equivalent to a 20 minute car ride. And a 10 minute waiting period was long enough to divulge entire life stories. (This is probably just nit picking, but it really stuck out to me.)
At one point, Emma fell on top of Charlie. Then she just laid on him, sprawled in the middle of the kitchen floor. She started waxing poetic about his eyelashes, and Charlie had to explicitly tell her to get off of him, because it was obvious she was never going to. Yikes!
The café scene with Donna Cole was so awkward. It made Emma seem clueless and kind of pathetic. Charlie had to rescue her and not for the first time.
When Emma is telling us what happened to her parents, we get 2-3 pages of “stick with me” and “we’ll get through it”. Okay… We don’t need pages upon pages of coddling and inspirational life quotes. This kind of writing really took me out of the story. It was like the author had a word count to hit and added in so much unnecessary fluff, which would also explain why her sentence structure throughout the story was horrendous.
When drunk Emma fell in the pool, Charlie took her to his own room so she could change out of her wet clothes. Why? She lives there; she has an entire room filled with her own clothes she could’ve just as easily changed in to. Why was it necessary for her to change into his clothes? Was it so she could point out how she was wearing his hoodie three or four days later? Because she mentioned it constantly, as if we needed to be reminded.
What is with everyone saying each other’s whole names? Donna Cole is not going to refer to her FRIEND as Charlie Yates. And Charlie is not going to refer to his VERY CLOSE FRIEND as Jack Stapleton. He’d just be Jack. And I swear, Emma said Charlie Yates more than she just said Charlie. She beat us over the head with his full name, and I wish it could be scrubbed from my brain.
There HAS TO BE more words in the English language you can use to convey speaking instead of "said". It appeared 1,111 times in this book. (I searched it on my kindle.) That is an absurd amount of times! And, just as a reference, I also searched the word "Charlie", and it appeared 1,244 times. Wow!
This whole book was written like a stream of consciousness. Why is Emma talking to the reader all the time? Just another point that takes me out of the story. Also, we're continuously being told things and not shown, which leads me back to the unnecessary fluff added.
Overall, the book was okay. But the faking cancer plot gave me the major ick, and I can't recommend a book like this.
My rating is for the first 80% of this book. The third act becomes a little too much to handle, and the “twist” is unfair. But more on that later.
Things I loved: the witty banter, the premise of screenwriters working together and falling in love, exploring past traumas and achieving personal growth, family loyalty, and callbacks to Jack from The Bodyguard.
I loved Charlie and Emma’s working relationship and watching it bloom to something more over time in all the little cute romcom ways; stolen glances, grocery shopping together, forced situations “for research”, all of it. I loved their subtle tells and their quiet support. Otherwise, to be honest I didn’t feel the chemistry between Charlie and Emma.
The writing was cute and I loved the breaking of the fourth wall. In true Katherine Center fashion, heavier themes are included and explored including history of cancer, death of a parent, illness and caregiving, divorce, and others. This makes her books and characters more relatable, which I certainly felt in this book as well. She covers these topics with grace and compassion, and sneaks in eloquent commentary. [Please review trigger warnings; I’ve mentioned a few above, but they are not all inclusive].
HOWEVER she added a “twist” that, to me, was unforgivable. I won’t put a spoiler here, but I feel it is wholly inappropriate to use this circumstance for “entertainment”. I understood it being a means to an HEA, but it could have been achieved differently. In truth, the end of this book went off the rails a bit with a lot happening all at once and was a bit messy, then throwing this in was the final straw. Hence, my overall rating is based on the majority of the book but not the end.
I do wish to thank St. Martin’s Press, NetGalley, and the author for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
As I've come to expect from Katherine Center, this book made me laugh out loud and shed a few tears. I love the way Center fleshes out even her secondary characters. The Rom-Commers feels a bit like an enemies-to-lovers story; though enemies is too strong a word to describe two people who are bringing a different set of values and expectations to a shared project. Center layers romance with family issues, guilt, old friends, and her usually snappy banter. In bringing together a hopeful believer in true love with a grumpy cynic, the entire novel allows Center to explore, and expound upon, the value of a happily ever after. Fans of Center's won't be disappointed and readers who discover her through this novel should go running to her other books.
The Rom-Commers is a solid well written rom-com with likeable characters. Emma has put her dream of being a screenwriter on the back burner to take care of her father. Charle is an accomplished screenwriter, except he has written the worst romance script there could be. Emma is brought in to help him and of course he isn't the most willing partner. A slow burn romance with fun witty characters, a great novel for those that like the love interest to bloom gradually and most happen behind closed doors. A great book to read while sitting by the pool or on the beach.
I read and reviewed a copy provided by the publisher and netgalley. All opinions are my own.
Thank you to Macmillan Audio for the ALC and St. Martin’s Press for the ARC of The Rom-Commers by Katherine Center. All opinions are my own.
I’ve read a few books by Katherine Center, but this is definitely my favorite book of hers! It’s so good! I ended up staying up way too late just so that I could finish reading it.
The Rom-Commers is about forgiveness, growing, not giving up on your dreams, and making the most of the life you have. It was such a beautiful story.
I loved the characters in this story. While Charlie Yates started off a bit rude and arrogant, he quickly became such a sweetheart who’s thoughtful and maybe not as confident as you’d expect him to be with the fame and awards he had.
Emma was an absolute delight and so funny and charming without even trying to be. She was constantly putting others first, which was lovely, but I also liked the moments when she did things that she enjoyed. She learned to let others help even when it’s hard to give up that control.
The friendship that formed between Charlie and Emma was so wholesome. They got along so well and really complemented each other. Their conversations were entertaining, and I just loved how quickly they became comfortable with each other.
Emma’s family was really sweet, but I loved that they weren’t perfect. They didn’t always say or do the right things, but it was clear how much they loved each other. Emma’s dad was a total sweetheart, and I loved that he didn’t let grief and his health hold him back from life.
The premise of this book was also so interesting and unique. I haven’t read any other books about screenwriters, and I thought it was fun to learn more about that. It was also adorable to see Emma teach Charlie all about rom coms (especially the kissing!).
Also, I read this book as an audiobook, and it was fantastic! Patti Murin did an amazing job with her character and with her dialogue with Charlie. She fit Emma perfectly, and I definitely need to read more audiobooks that she narrates.
Overall, I would recommend this book to anyone! It was an easy five star read for me, and I can see myself re-reading this book many times in the future.
4.75 - Thank you so much to St Martin's Press for an advance copy of this book!
This book will be out June 11th.
This is my 3rd summer of reading a Katherine Center and this may be my favorite one of the three.
I just enjoyed the book from start to finish. The way that Katherine writes just always sucks me in. I really need to go back to read her backlist.
"I fell in love all the time. Just...nobody fell in love with me back. Fiction really kind of was all I had in the romance department."
I just loved the dynamic between Emma and Charlie. Emma was a talented writer who just needed the write opportunity to strike to hit. And the opportunity came from her former ex who manages a very famous screenwriter and he needs help reworking a romcom. But the catch, Charlie doesn't believe in love nor has never seen a romcom!
Even though I loved this book, I am so surprised how many reviews are saying how much they love Charlie. I felt like Charlie was unlikeable through majority of the book. We do find out why this was the case but it made it hard to like him. Day by day Emma just chewed away at Charlie's hard exterior. And while doing this he slowly began to warm up and a different side to Charlie began to shone through. He would do small gestures to show he was paying attention.
"I get it now."
"Get what?"
"Why we're rewriting this story."
A major storyline that is woven throughout the book is Emma's role as a caretaker to her dad. We learn what happened that caused his Ménière's disease and what her daily life is like taking care of him. She is entrusting her younger sister Sylvie (and her boyfriend) to take care of her dad while she is away in LA. I did feel bad because Emma had taken on the brunt of his care for the last 10 years and it was just something that she made her full responsibility. I really feel like she was so passionate about his care after feeling responsible for their mother's death. The climax came towards the end when things came to a head.
I really enjoyed this but I know a lot of peers have had mixed reactions to this so please take in consideration my thoughts but also others as well.
I love reading whatever Katherine Center writes. Unfortunately, this story about two writers didn't land for me. Charlie Yates is grumpy and Emma is a bit of a pushover with a martyr mentality. Logan, their mutual agent, tricks Emma into showing up to work with Charlie who doesn't want to be helped. The writing was in Center's usual style with quick banter and amusing conundrums. I think my issue is that I don't deeply relate to the quirks of writing and it was difficult to showcase those quirks with action rather than descriptions of messy tables and talismans. I wish we had learned even more about Charlie's family and that Emma had had one friend other than Logan and her sister.
Overall, it's a quick and fun read if you're interested in or relate to writers.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC.
I’ve said it before, but Katherine Center just has that storytelling magic . You don’t have to worry when picking up a book of hers… it always delivers. This story solidifies that statement. What a treat it was to escape into the world of Emma and Charlie:)
Emma is a writer. She has been caring for her father since a life altering accident years ago, which also left her raising her little sister. When her agent (who happens to be her ex) calls, he shocks Emma by offering her the opportunity of a lifetime. To rewrite a screenplay for the Oscar winning writer, Charlie Yates. The romcom he wrote is awful and since it’s not in his regular genre he could use some help. Emma is encouraged to take the job, be the ghostwriter, and fix it. She is hesitant to go and leave her dad because the job requires her to be in L.A. Her sister Sylvie who just graduated is taking over care and so Emma heads to L.A.
This begins the journey that will change both Charlie and Emma’s life. It’s a slow slow burn and at its core it’s a story about family and sacrifice and forgiveness. It’s tough to read in parts because this book gets raw and real. It’s also funny and it’s a heartwarming love story too. The scene at the end has the most grand gestures of grand gestures and I adored it!!
Katherine Center never disappoints… I am obsessed! This book had me feeling all the emotions! I couldn’t put this down! The characters were so likable. Her writing style is just amazing. I don’t want to spoil anything but this is a MUST read! I love how the author always incorporates positivity. All the things can be going wrong but she has a way of focusing on the good out of the situation and I love that.
“I have a theory that we gravitate toward the stories we need in life. Whatever we’re longing for – adventure, excitement, emotion, connection – we turn to stories to help us find it.”
Emma Wheeler has always wanted to be a screenwriter, but when her life went off script unexpectedly, she was forced to accept a rewrite. Still, she’s never completely let go of the dream, or of her love of all things romance. In fact, when she isn’t writing her own, she’s obsessed with soaking up the works of others.
So when she’s contacted to ghostwrite for when one of her all time favorite screenwriters, Charlie Yates, she panics. As much as the proposition is “pinch me I must be dreaming” true, Emma feels like can’t leave behind her familial obligations. Luckily her father and sister feel differently and they force her to go to California for the six week project.
But when Emma reads Charlie’s introductory attempt at romance, it becomes clear why the genre has never been in his repertoire before- he’s awful. An even bigger problem? Charlie never agreed to getting another writer’s help, much less one with no street credit, or actual credits, period. Charlie changes his tune, however, after he reads some of her work. The pair ultimately agree to work together, even after Emma realizes the romantic cynic has no real intentions of making his love story better. And thus begins Emma’s descent not only into a romantic rehab of a script, but one of the jaded Charlie himself.
The Rom-Commers is the latest release from one of my favorite romance writers, Katherine Center. Attempting to write an original love letter to love is no easy feat, and yet Center manages to just that time after time with her silly yet swoon-worthy take on love. She also manages to do all of this without cheesy or graphic love scenes. I can only hope that this book will be turned into a real romcom one day as it’s a genre that desperately needs on screen resuscitation.