Member Reviews
Helen Phillips is a wonder. Through the eyes of an underemployed, financially distressed mom in the near future, HUM captures both the worst of what's coming and the ethical quandaries we are all dealing with today, from overconsumption (just one more Amazon order!) to everyday digital addiction and consumer choices that are destroying the very world we know we will miss desperately in just decades, if not years. I won't outline the plot--you'll see it summarized elsewhere, and for most readers, I'd say the less you know going into this book, the better. Phillips excels at portraying kids realistically--fantastic dialogue and characterization on every page--and the deep interiority of her narrator creates nearly suffocating tension. While the plot and world are upsetting, the book is enlivened with wit and heart.
HUM feels like a wake-up call. The author's braiding of real news events and poignant quotes (clearly noted in endnotes) reinforces the feeling that this hypothetical future is really now, or even yesterday. Is it too late to choose a different future?
This book is likely to be my favorite of the year.
May loses her job to AI in a city beset with climate change and full of intelligent robots called “hums.” The unemployed May is desperate so she undergoes an experiment where her face is subtlely altered so it won’t be recognized by facial recognition, for which she is paid.
Afterward, and as a treat for her husband, Jem, and children Lu and Sy she buys a three day pass for the city’s Botanical Garden. When they go, the family leaves their devices at home. But while there her children come under threat, a mother’s worst nightmare, and May must put her trust in a hum. And then things get worse.
Oh, I love me some dystopia and Phillips does that well. Plus she does a great job writing small children, “is Jesus made of bubbles?” Throughout the entire book, regardless of what is actually happening, there’s a thin layer of stress, which is the same feeling May must have all the time, living in this crazy, airless world, where she fears for the future of her children all the time.
As to the hums, I don’t know. To its have definitely been done better, for that, see the recently published ANIIE BOT, but, then, they aren’t all equal. I’m still on the fence about the hums, even the one(s) portrayed here.
Overall, a good, satisfying read that I enjoyed very much. I really like May and her family and, and this doesn’t happen to me often, I was actually sorry to see the book come to an end. Recommended….probably 4.4 stars, not in 5 star range because the book is called HUM and I felt like more could have been done with them.
"'Fuck,' he whispered, but not angrily, just with fatigue.
She stopped stirring the pasta and looked over at him, unsure about his tone."
--------------
The writing in HUM was not very musical. At least, for me it wasn't. In fact it was kind of tone-deaf. I didn't understand its rhythms and progressions. It was a little one-note and the one note went on for far too long, in the manner that this music metaphor has gone on for far too long. That’s about all I can say about this novel without descending into purposeless cranky meanness, or reaching for another extended metaphor, except to add that I ever so many people love the books I don't, the way people love Taylor Swift and I don't, and I'm certain that this book will be a very great read for some people who aren't me..
When Helen Phillips puts a new book out, I'm first in line to request it!
Her lastest, Hum, is a creepy peek into a futuristic world in which natural forests and wild animals are things of the past and robots called hums intermingle with humanity.
May is a wife and mother and she's just lost her job to AI. Unsure when she'll land her next one, she decides to undergo experimental facial surgery that will alter her appearance just enough to confuse the ever present cameras throughout the city, but will beef up their bank account with nearly a year's worth of cash.
Only, she can't seem to stop purchasing friviolous things. No sooner does the money clear her account, with her skin still raw and painful from the surgery, she finds herself in line purchasing a weekend getaway for her and the family to The Botanical Gardens - a HUGE financial splurge, but one she's excited to share with the kids and her husband. The perfect retreat from the anxieties of the real world, a relaxing few days spent in an artifical woods complete with waterfalls, flora and fauna, and a much needed break from their cell phones and electronic addictions. But the trip quickly devolves into a mother's worst nightmare as she's forced to put her trust into a one of the hums when her children go missing.
Phillips is a master at threading unsettling, atmospheric undertones throughout her stories. It's a bit foreboding, and feels a lot like stepping through the looking glass: where the horrors of consumerism, climate change, our obsession with technology, and the unrelenting guilt and pressures of motherhood all come to a dark and cryptic head.
What a weird, unsettling, and fun little book.
Hum is the story of May who lives in an unnamed future city with her husband and children. While many aspects of this future are familiar, robotic AI devices know as Hums exist in every aspect of society, from jobs, to store assistants, to transportation, and more. Similar technology is in the homes as well, with children carrying "bunnies" and everyone having a "woom" in their room as a sort of private VR-pod. While the hums do have benefits, such as health scans, personalized shopping, and air quality checks, all of this comes inundated with advertisements that cost money to remove.
May has recently lost her job to AI and is experiencing feelings of depression driven by the polluted and industrial environment. After volunteering for a facial surgery that is supposed to make her unrecognizable to AI she splurges on a family vacation to the Botanical Gardens, a luxury that her husband questions. Desperate to experience nature like she did as a child, May begs her family to leave their phones and "bunnies" at home for an unplugged stay in this tech-centered world. At the gardens, May recalls the freedom she felt growing up in the forest but this peace unfortunately does not last.
Phillips does an excellent job of maintaining a sense of unease throughout the book. Even during the peaceful moments within the gardens there are little reminders of the surveillance and consumerism surrounding the characters in this book. Readers will be able to pick up on the futuristic aspects while still feeling the connections to the increasing levels of AI driven technology in our own lives. The epilogue was unnecessary in my mind and cheapens the story a bit, but not enough to make me regret the read.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC
This book…. Might haunt me.
The execution was phenomenal which, in a story like this, makes for a very painful reading experience. At times I had to put the book down because it spooked me and hit a nerve somewhere deep within my subconscious. All the things that people are ignoring are nestled within these lines.
I wanted so badly for this to be a five star for me but after feeling blown away by the first third of the book, the ending left me a tad bit unsatisfied.
“This book was like looking to a black mirror episode that is a few months away from happening IRL. Helen Phillips excels at building the atmospheric vibes - I can feel the anxiety seeping off of the pages. Because of that it was such a gripping novel that made you want to dive deeper to see if any of your anxiety would quell. The epilogue was a tad bit confusing but I think that is the point - didn’t work as well for me as I’d hoped though”
Hum by Helen Philips captivated me from start to finish; I couldn't put it down. The author skillfully crafts a world eerily close to our own, prompting contemplation on how AI might shape our families, society, and identities. Although the ending didn't entirely resonate with me, I believe Hum would make an excellent choice for a book club, sparking engaging conversations on the profound impact of technology on our lives.
This was a haunting glimpse into a near future. A trip that goes horribly awry and the impact it has on a woman's family who is just trying to reconnect in a world of disconnection. I loved it and will absolutely hand this to many readers.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for providing this copy in exchange of a review.
I would have loved this book. I couldn't stop reading it, the world was fascinating, the characters the same. I was so interested in it. Somewhere around 60% I started thinking, "where is this going?" only to be immediately shown, and then once again I was hooked. It was an easy 5 star rating. Until the ending. I'm not going to spoil it, but it's trash. If you're going to read it, just don't read the epilogue.
With the rise of AI in today's society and conversations, this novel could not have come at a better time.
In "Hum", author Helen Phillips has created a word in the not-so-distant future with technology has taken over an even greater proportion of our daily lives, where facial identification and fingerprint technology are the norms of ID, where "hum" AI machines serve key functions in day-to-day life as well as non-stop advertising platforms, and whereas adults may be glued to their cell phones an extension of themselves, children are raised with "bunnies" attached at their wrists that serve nearly identical functions. It is a jarring and troubling world that is concurrently dealing with the effects of worldwide pollution and climate change, but also startling resembles much of our current time.
The story centers on May, who's been recently fired from her previous employer and struggles to make ends meet with her husband Jem, and their to children Sy and Lu. In an attempt to earn some money, she willingly signs up for an experimental procedure that alters her facial appearance to the point that she is no longer recognizable to the hum machines that run much of daily life. While Jem attempts to take on more freelance work on a Taskrabbit-esque app (putting down mousetraps? cleaning out a deceased individual's closet), May is determined to use some of her earnings on a family trip to the Botanical Gardens, and having her family members leave their technological dependencies (bunnies and cell phones) at home. Her decision ultimately has unintended consequences, however, highlighting just how pervasive and inextricable our daily lives have become from the technologies that we've created.
While relatively short, the novel is dark and troubling, and there's an extensive amount of world building done within just a few chapters. I found Phillips' detail and structure to this new world well done; concepts were introduced over time and presented in digestible, understandable portions. And though there's certainly a focus on the omnipresence of technology and AI, the novel also calls out the pitfalls of parenthood and motherhood, and the all-encompassing desire for parents to want the best for their children - sometimes at the expense of the greater good. I wish there was a little more time that had been focused on the actual characters themselves, as I felt like we didn't really get to know May, Jem, or their children very well (and honestly, sometimes I got annoyed with Lu and Sy) and there wasn't much overall character development.
Excited to hear what readers think when this novel is published in August 2024!
Loved this dystopian look at the intersection of parenting, tech and surveillance culture. It was a riveting read!
Thank you to NetGalley and Simon and Schuster for the opportunity to read Hum by Helen Phillips.
Hum is a quick moving story that takes place in the not so distant future. We follow the protagonist, May Webb, and her family as May undergoes a major sacrifice in order to provide some much needed financial and emotional bandwidth for her family. The writing is crisp, the emotions are real, and the nuance of reality vs. perception is even more highlighted than in our already social media saturated world.
If you are a fan of Sci-Fi shows like Fringe or Dark Mirror, give this one a try!
Thank you to Net Galley and Marysue Rucci/Simon and Schuster for the chance to read this advance digital copy in exchange for this honest review.
What an intriguing, fast paced story. I mostly loved it. The writing is easy to follow, and the short, short chapters keep it snappy. Although, these same short chapters add a lot of white space which makes the book seem longer than it actually is--if that makes sense!
I felt vested in the main character, May Webb, until about midway, then her rather neurotic behavior got tiresome. She didn't evolve or devolve in an arc that I found satisfying. So I ended up not caring much about what she was experiencing. For a while, I thought this was the intent and, small spoiler, that the book was going to take a cool, dark turn where we actually start wanting the hums to take over. In the last 1/8th or so, there's a scene that I found entirely superfluous; it bogged the terrific pacing down.
I adored the tech Helen Phillips came up with. As some reviewers have mentioned, it's very Dark Mirror. I also agree with other reviewers that the end was a let down. There didn't seem to be much purpose to the tension that was building--unless I missed something.
The book is still totally worth reading and I'm sure many readers will feel more bonded to the characters--the flesh and blood ones, that is!
2.5 stars.
Hum was an interesting reading experience. We follow May, a woman who is out of work after being made redundant by AI, after she undergoes a face-altering procedure for quick cash. The world is facing a dystopia based on a global environmental crisis, and we watch the ramifications of May’s procedure quickly catch up to her in a story featuring too many uncomfortable parallels to life in 2024 to count.
First, this book is stressful. While reading, I felt very stuck in the world and with the characters. I like the hums and the concept of the world itself—there’s a very unique tone of existential dread that starts on page one and never really stops. It’s hard to describe, but there’s almost an uncanny feeling going on here, very much like a Black Mirror episode. There’s a strong feeling of plausibility, a what-if?, this constant awful feeling of already being halfway in May’s shoes. The uneasiness and the blurred lines between this version of the future / our present? Fantastic. There are times when the world feels perfectly natural and not so concerning, usually quickly followed by clever moments where everything sort of slaps you in the face. I liked all the times I was able to see myself in May, the further integration of consumerism into society, the real events identifiable in the text (and cited at the end), the whole idea of making yourself stick out more in an attempt to blend in. Seriously, this book has all the cool pieces!
My biggest positive is that the ending is clever, if a bit rushed. I absolutely loved the literary aspect of it. A million yeses for a thematically rich ending that forces you to sit with the book and think for a few minutes after finishing; kudos to Helen Phillips for that. I debated pretty hard over rating this two or three stars. Clearly, there was a lot of love and a strong concept put into this story—so, what exactly didn’t I like about it?
Unfortunately, the writing missed the mark. I get nervous with books around 250-70 pages—I’m almost always left thinking that the finished product should have been either 50 pages longer to fill out the world or 150 shorter/cut into a novella. Hum was no exception. In my opinion, this is one of the ones that would have done better as a novella with a narrower scope. While the synopsis claims “taut” and “urgent” prose, it honestly doesn’t seem intentionally stylistic so much as it seems to be an excuse for the book being extremely underwritten: For the majority of the book, I struggled to find a paragraph longer than two or three sentences, and this is definitely an author who abuses the enter key. Lines should be powerful enough to stand on their own in a paragraph; they shouldn’t need the manufactured emphasis of hitting enter every time you want a beat or a moment of drama. That’s what punctuation and descriptive language is there for, and regrettably, Hum didn’t rise to the challenge. (It also frequently committed the cardinal sin of repeating the same word numerous times within a couple of sentences when there's a common synonym right there.)
Things certainly happen, but there’s very little description of the environment or what anything looks like. We get a brief paragraph at the beginning describing what the hums look like, and then the author never really describes any of them in depth again. We’re told there are fingerprint scanners, we’re told there are hums, we’re told what a bunny does, we’re told what the characters are looking at, we’re told the environment is a disaster, we’re told we’re told we’re told, but there’s very little creative language or visual worldbuilding. This adds to the dismal vibe of the world but not always in a good way; it’s very difficult to immerse yourself in a world that resists construction. It also makes it hard to contrast the Botanical Garden against the outside world when the Botanical Garden really isn’t described in all that much detail aside from listing the types of plants and animals found inside as the characters encounter them. The point of this book ultimately gets lost in the messy, unrefined prose.
It was really disappointing not being able to connect with the characters as much as I wanted to. I think to a point the detached, distressing tone is the point, but I also think there’s a balance that needs to be struck to make the husband and the kids less like cardboard cutouts. Because we’re seeing them exclusively through May’s eyes and anxieties, with no backstory prior to the beginning of the story, I spent a lot of time trying to discern their motives when it didn’t actually matter.
My biggest pet peeve with the writing was the incorrect punctuation heavily present in Sy and Lu’s dialogue; they’re constantly starting their sentences with interjections and the author refuses to put a comma after them, which provides the incredibly irritating feeling of reading an unedited fanfiction and makes it difficult not to trip over the dialogue. “Ugh,” “okay,” “look,” etc, are frequently placed at the beginning of sentences without proper punctuation, which is a pretty inexcusable fundamental grammar issue for an author with five books under their belt.
I really don’t intend to come off as overly harsh, especially as I frequently enjoy books from this imprint, but on the other side of that same coin, I would expect better editing from an imprint of such a major publishing house. Marysue Rucci Books is responsible for some of my favorite titles—only a few months ago they gave us Mona Awad’s new release. Hum just isn’t at the same caliber, and knowing the high quality and careful editing this imprint is capable of curating, I almost felt cheated.
Like I said, I think this is conceptually strong—I genuinely enjoyed the plot despite it being a fairly simplistic arc. The final scene is smart and delivers a taste of what the book could’ve been; Helen Phillips is an author with a clear voice and the know-how to create an enveloping, emotionally charged world. Ultimately, I felt that the book fell victim to the inclusion of too many ideas, too many broad statements on the issues the characters face, and not enough analysis of the admittedly fascinating and all-too-real issues and ideas presented. The final chapter felt like the author was hitting her stride, having laid out all the points she wanted to talk about, and then it just suddenly…ended. Without talking about any of them.
TLDR: I liked Hum, but I can’t recommend it. I thought there was serious potential, and another (intensive) round of editing could have easily made this a four-star read for me. I would certainly try another title from this author.
A sincere thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing an advance copy in exchange for an honest review!
Hum captures the dread, anxiety, and chaos that comes with being a caregiver in an age of environmental danger and pervasive technology. These feelings emerge sharply from May's narration as she attempts to protect her children from a world dependent on AI called "Hum" assistants and the environmental decline. May longs for the unattainable: true nature, not the synthetic recreations of nature the AI presents. This longing feels nostalgic and human, which is contrasted with the unending advertisements, fake niceties, and privacy invasions the Hums bombard the family with. Overall, I enjoyed what this book was doing with its immersive worldbuilding and character voices that captured existential dread. At times, I felt it hard to grasp the other character's traits through May's narration, and wished the other characters had undergone a more complete arc as I didn't always fully understand their motives. However, I applaud Hum for presenting the existential dread we all know from being alive in the 21st century in a new, terrifying scenario. Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced copy.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an ARC for my honest opinion.
I feel that I am fairly critical with my reviews. I try to be vague in an effort to not spoil the story or experience for others.
This book make me feel so much anxiety, dread, unease, hope, love, and laughter. This is why I gave it 5 stars.
Following May’s story was a whirlwind of emotional. You can’t help but be nervous for her as she under goes her procedure and then skeptical of Jem. Constantly waiting for the other shoe to drop. What an experience. Definitely worth the read!
Thanks to @netgalley and Simon and Schuster for the chance to review Hum by Helen Phillips. This was a book unlike any that I’ve read before. May is trying to better the lives of her two children and undergoes a procedure to change her face so that she is unable to be recognized by the intelligent robots called “hums”. She takes her earnings and books a getaway for her family, but everything is not as it seems. She tries to get her family to unplug from their devices. So many themes - AI, marriages becoming distant, and the desperation and lengths that a mother will go to provide and keep her family safe. This was a book that made me a bit uncomfortable, in the best way!
May undergoes a procedure to slightly alter her face in exchange for a good sum of money after being laid off from her previous job. With that money, she takes her family to the Botanical Garden, a place rich with green plants, fruit bearing trees, and animals her kids don't recognize.
This was fast-paced and anxiety inducing. It feels like where our world is heading, the practice of over-consumption and materialism, the regret, and the unhealthy attachment to devices, what mothers have to go through, climate change, and AI. I wish it didn't end the way it did. The creepy appearance of the Hum at their home was my favorite part, but I wish there had been more to it. Regardless, it was a good read.
HUM by Helen Phillips takes a hard look at the possible coming future concerning artificial intelligence and a post-climate change world.