Member Reviews

First of all, thanks to Netgalley and Pantheon for letting me read an eARC of Whale Fall by Elizabeth O'Connor. The novel was an amazing read that I was able to get through rather quickly due to the characters and worldbuilding. Both of which had me absorbed and enthralled from the first sentence, as you follow Manod's journey after the arrival of the strangers. I loved how, through their arrival and interaction with them, Manod realized more about herself, her world, and what she was truly capable of. Whale Fall is an easy recommendation for readers who love historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

I finished this novel in essentially two sittings over the course of two consecutive nights. I couldn’t stop reading. WHALE FALL follows the story of Manod, a young woman living on a remote Welsh island with her family when a dead whale washes onto the shore in 1938. The arrival of the whale is accompanied by that of two English ethnographers, whose motivations, methods, and morality are at first opaque, and then harrowingly apparent.

This novel is striking and succinct, deeply sad yet beautifully written. It’s incredible how much is packed into just over 200 pages, even though it all seems to unfold slowly and organically, with no urgency. I’d absolutely recommend this one. Fingers crossed that O’Connor writes more fiction soon.

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautiful story of self discovery and moving with grief. Taking the dead body of a whale washing up, our main character takes this as a bad omen.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. It was quiet and meditative, very subtle and beautifully constructed. Its handling of the very tricky and complex ideas surrounding someone coming to the notion of moving past their small upbringing was delicately woven.

This is also a deeply English book, but not based in extravagance, but more in the beauty of its simplicity. I wasn’t surprised to learn how this manuscript was the subject of a 10-agency bidding war for publishing. It deserves the love it will inevitably get.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

This is a lovely little book, set on a fictional British Isle before WWII. Two anthropologists arrive on the heels of a beached whale, and spend a couple of months collecting stories and pictures of island life (and embellishing them inaccurately for their own ends). The protagonist is an 18 year old girl whose abilities exceed the opportunities she has on the island, and these two visitors are the spark for her pursuit of other options.

The writing is beautiful - it's especially good considering it's a debut. The descriptions of the natural world, in particular, are vivid and contemplative, giving a really strong sense of place. It's not a very big or fast-moving plot, but the characters and setting leave a lot to reflect on.

Was this review helpful?

This was a beautiful little novel. I was left wanting more. This would be good for the reader wanting a good novel to read by the ocean for the day. Quick and easy. Would definitely recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

Whale Fall first pulled me in because of its unique format of writing. Each scene is broken up into its own few pages, like the whole book is a bunch of short stories (or even poems) of the main character's thoughts. Weirdly enough, this makes you feel like a complete outsider AND like you are right there on the small, harsh island. The characters feel very human and beautifully flawed, and the daily-life plot feels very simple and calm (even through all the main character's turmoil). And despite it feeling simple and unexciting (it's anything but), the poetic writing creates such an atmosphere and deep feeling of the islander's life that you just keep reading.

Was this review helpful?

Really, really enjoyed this book. My main gripe would just simply be that I wanted more. I think it worked well for what it was, but definitely could have been expanded in areas just to bring through some more character depth. Would highly recommend this book.

I'm still getting used to ARC's but the formatting of this seemed a bit off, but I'm sure by release date it'll be touched up.

Was this review helpful?

What a beautiful little book. Living inside Manod’s head for two hundred pages or so is an experience I want to go back and revisit. I know I didn’t get all of the poetry available on my first read (though the longing is heartbreaking and unmissable). It’s a moving account of a young woman on the cusp of adulthood. Born on a Welsh island with a dwindling population, she’s beginning to see possibilities for herself elsewhere, but can’t see how to free herself of her ties to her home. The world is on the cusp of war (it’s 1938), and comes in on the tide in the form of two researchers. The short sections in which the book is written kept me turning the pages, as did the tension between what Manod thinks is happening and what may be the truth as she interacts with these newcomers. The ending is brilliant and perfect. Manod is a character who will stay with me.

I rated the book a 4.75 because I was a little confused at first about who was who in Manod’s family. It took me a while to get my feet, so to speak, in her world. But maybe that’s deliberate. Thank you so much to Pantheon for allowing me to read an advanced copy! I will be looking for O’Connor’s next work with anticipation.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This is a book that will likely stick with me for a long time. It’s a quiet tale about a young girl living on an isolated island, who realizes she wants more in life when two young writers come to her village. While this seems simple, I really found myself lost in the complexity and the layers of storytelling. I think there’s some really beautiful commentary on people who look down on those who inhabit the places they are only visiting.

Was this review helpful?

I adored Whale Fall. Elizabeth O’Connor’s prose is stunning—I could not put this one down. The depictions of earnest, human emotions and experiences through Manod’s eyes were so descriptive. I could envision the fictional island in Wales the family lived on, could see how Joan might find it beautiful while Manod would find it plain, could feel and understand her longing to see what was beyond the only place she’s ever known. This one was short and succinct but not lacking in anyway. An incredible debut, in my opinion, and I hope Elizabeth O’Connor releases more in the future, because I would love to read more from this author.

Thank you to Pantheon and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Whale Fall is the story of a teenage girl, Manod, whose longing to see the rest of the world conflicts with her loyalty to her homeland and family. The book is set on a remote island off the coast of Wales and is centered around two main events, a dead whale washing ashore and a team of English researchers who have come to write a book about the island’s folklore and traditions.

From the first page I immediately felt like I was transported to the island. The language is simple but not a word goes to waste in building this gloomy yet homely atmosphere. O’Connor uses elements of nature - the rotting whale, migrating birds, mounting storms - to build tension and give you the sense that the land is bracing itself as the world closes in.

And what a profound protagonist - through Manod, I could feel the restlessness of being a young woman unsure of what the world holds but sure that she is ready for it. She noticeably matures throughout the book as she grapples with crossing the boundary to the mainland and into adulthood.

Manod attempts to create her own narrative as the ethnographers construct a literal narrative of her home, which is tinged with the exoticism typical of the documentation of ‘untouched’ foreign lands. O’Connor asks, how much of our understanding of the world is stained with this bias? And who ultimately gets to tell the story?

Overall a stunning read full of dignity, sorrow, and defiant hope. I would recommend this to anyone, but especially to those who enjoyed watching the Banshees of Inisherin last year! There were many similarities in terms of setting, mounting conflict both on and off the island and a strong, restless female character.

Was this review helpful?

A good read, Id recommend this to anyone looking for a casual read that is good at keeping your attention.

Was this review helpful?

poignant debut historical fiction novel which worked extremely well. the entire vibes of it were just?? great. and the sense of isolation. thanks for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

Man vs. Ocean.. but it's really a Man vs. Man story. It's beautifully written and the story is great! It's not a typical read for me and took me longer than usual to finish it. Overall 4 stars!

Was this review helpful?

Good book that is overall well written. Did not grab my attention, perhaps because it does not seem to be plot driven as much as immersive into person and circumstance—this particular book is just not quite a good fit for this reader., although Inwill be looking for future work.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and Knopf for an advanced reader copy of this novel.

This was my first Elizabeth O'Connor novel and I have a wonderful time reading it.

This is a short, poetic book about a young woman and her desire for a life outside of her remote Welsh Island.

Only about 50 individuals are hearty enough to rough the conditions and the population declines yearly. Islanders are secluded from news of the world (the time frame is just before WWII) and clothing is decades out of style.

A whale washes up on shore one day and the island folk gather to observe and deal with it in their unique way. Not long after, two ethnographers show up to study the lives of the islanders. Manod, who speaks English, works with the scientists translating the islanders’ Welsh. She is fascinated by the glimpse of life offered her through these two individuals and works out a plan to leave the island for the larger world outside.

The book unfolds through a collection of snapshots, blending Manod's journal entries with the ethnographers' perspectives and transcripts of islanders' folktales and songs.

Despite its subdued nature, the novel possesses a compelling force. It immerses readers in the characters' lives, their challenges, unrealized aspirations, the looming war, and the desolation of their limited choices. Devoting time to this book will undoubtedly be a rewarding experience for many readers.

Was this review helpful?

A quiet but moving story about a girl living on an island rooted in tradition and folklore, and her dreams of moving to the mainland after meeting two writers.

I love quiet little stories like this where there isn’t a heavy amount of plot. This was more of a character study, and the author does a fantastic job at making it feel so real. For a debut novel, this is highly impressive and I found it so engaging despite the lack of action. The main character feels so relatable and the island is beautifully descriptive. Definitely recommend if you’re into slower stories about different ways of life.

Thank you to NetGalley and Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was a beautiful book, unlike anything I had read before. Besides the gorgeous prose and the vignette-esque glimpses of these island characters, Whale Fall took me to a place I had never been nor knew existed.

The scenes were harsh yet cozy. The glimpses into the island inhabitants left me wanted more. I loved Manod, and her sharp knowledge—a sense of intellect that obviously outweighed her more "wordly" visitors.

Was this review helpful?

This is one of the most atmospheric books I’ve ever read. I’m personally usually bored by setting/nature descriptions in books, but they were so vivid and purposeful here since the whole story depended on and centered around this remote island setting. Whale Fall offered interesting commentary on the practice of privileged outsiders from “modern society” traveling into a space that they deem “backwards” and “too traditional” and exploiting it, exoticizing it, overly romanticizing it in a way that’s baffling and offensive to the locals. Joan and Edward are two English people who travel to the island to write a book on its people, but they often fabricate details of these people’s lives to make them seem more appealing and exotic to the English audience of their book, using and manipulating the main character Manod along the way. At first she is dazzled by their opulence, the tales they tell her of life on the Mainland and the freedoms women have there, but she begins to feel protective and guarded of her people once Joan and Edward start romanticizing their way of life to the point that it’s more fiction than fact, taking advantage of Monad and the other locals physically, sexually, etc., while also exposing them to and recruiting them for “the Great War.” I found it very interesting to know that this story is based on real events with people fabricating the way of life of people in the British Isles, but I’m also not surprised. It was very frustrating to read Joan and Edward taking advantage of these people, but it did a good job pointing to the power and privilege that they held and their colonizing, imperialist attitudes; just leave these people alone!! I loved the scenery descriptions in this book, especially with the whale slowly rotting on the beach for the entirety of the story, which felt so reminiscent of Joan and Edward’s presence tainting the island. The interactions between Manod and her sister were also so caring and lovely, and I appreciate that Manod wasn’t hard on her for being a bone collecting, superstitious kid that does weird things sometimes. I was also a fan of the folktales interspersed throughout the story, and I almost would have liked more of them. I think that the explorations of Manod’s budding sexuality are intriguing, especially with her masturbating to the thought of Joan in one scene, but I almost would have liked a little more, especially if this is meant to suggest repressed queerness. It doesn’t seem that Manod particularly enjoyed having sex with men so much as she enjoyed having their attention, which she says herself at one point, suggesting comphet, but I think the story didn’t quite get that far, not that it has to. I also would have liked to understand Manod’s relationship with her father a little better because he didn’t have much of a character other than his occupation defining him. Overall, this was a very quick and enjoyable read that has such beautifully vivid descriptions that drip from the pages.

Was this review helpful?