Member Reviews

An interesting magical story about a coven trying to protect their school from a Witch hunter.

Rose transfers to Livingston boarding school after her affair with a teacher became public. But Rose's beautiful new roommate Charlie seems like a mean girl until Charlie invites Rose to join a coven and learn magic. When a threat comes from the nearby boys school, Rose and the other girls have to find a way to defeat the witch hunter before another person dies.

This is one of the few instances where I enjoyed the first half of a book more than the second half. The first part felt emotional and real with Rose's loneliness and desperation to fit in. But the second half felt rushed with trying to tie up all the pieces of the plot and the emotional story. There were parts that didn't make sense either - like why Charlie's sister had committed suicide. I do enjoy a Sapphic magical mystery, and this isn't a bad one by any means. I just wish the last third would have been a little more developed.

Was this review helpful?

I had a really tough time with this one, and just couldn't get into it. I love dark academia and stories with witches, but unfortunately the writing in this one just didn't work. Not sure if there is going to be further edits as this was an ARC, but even so it was not well done. I did appreciate the bisexual main character and her development of her identity, to me that was the best part of the book.

Was this review helpful?

I was really excited about this book, from its concept and the summary I was interested, but everything fell flat. The characters didn't feel shaped well, the story was all over the place, and I really struggled with the dialogue, which made the whole book feel choppy. There's probably an audience out there for this but it did nothing for me.

Was this review helpful?

Livingston Girls is a brilliant queer YA witch story. It's fast paced and the characters are great to read. Briana Morgan's writing style is so enjoyable and she always grips me straight away!

Was this review helpful?

Livingston Girls is a story about a 16-year-old girl named Rose. She ends up at Livingston Academy after a troubling relationship with her teacher is revealed. The school has a secret: it was founded by descendants of Salem witches, and they still practice magic. Rose joins their group and becomes part of a hidden world of spells and sisterhood. But trouble comes when a witch hunter threatens them, and Rose is distracted by her feelings for her roommate, Charlie.

I really liked this book. The romance parts are sweet, and the magic system is interesting and easy to understand. The action scenes with magic are exciting, and the characters have great chemistry, each girl has a unique personality that you'll come to love. The conversations between the characters feel real and make the story more believable. The book also leaves a lasting impression with its romantic moments. I recommend it to anyone who enjoys a mix of magic and romance in a well-written story.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to enjoy this. I’m always here for sapphic witches. But in the end, too much of this just did not work for me.

The writing style is under-developed and needs a much heavier edit. I know this isn’t a finished copy, but it still feels far too unpolished to be going out to ARC readers. So much of the dialogue feels awkward and stilted and a lot of the descriptions are clunky.

I also feel vaguely uncomfortable about the way race is treated. I’m not sure if this is just a me thing, but pointing out characters are black or “Latina” or Asian or whatever while not describing the white characters as white kinda gave me the ick, as though white is the default. I highly doubt this is the authors intention but the more it kept happening, the more uncomfortable I felt.

Was this review helpful?

Briana Morgan writes such beautiful books. And this is no different. There are some issues with editing in this ARC. But I’m sure it will be fixed by the time the book is released. I loved every moment of this. It’s different and relatable compared to most books like it.

Was this review helpful?

"Livingston Girls" is a delightful and haunting coming-of-age tale centered around a coven of witches navigating the intricacies of their boarding school.

The novel boasts an intriguing and well-structured magic system that strikes the perfect balance between excitement and comprehensibility, seamlessly integrating the supernatural into the fabric of the story and making it feel realistic in the world. The fight scenes involving the magic were gripping and exciting.

One of the standout features of this novel is its representation of a bisexual protagonist, Rose. Her journey of self-discovery is portrayed with authenticity, capturing the essence of a teenager coming into her bisexuality. The identity that she comes into by the end of the novel is strongly based on her coming to terms with the experiences leading up to her arrival at Livingston School, as well as the friendships she forms there, which play a significant role in this compelling character arc.

The characters had genuine chemistry, which can't be said for many novels. Each girl introduced in the story possesses a distinct personality, and as readers, we have the pleasure of getting to know and appreciate each of them throughout the book. The dialogues and banter among the characters are refreshingly convincing and enhance the book's believability. The romantic scenes are equally well-crafted, radiating charm and tenderness, leaving a lasting impression.

While the pace of some portions of the story may seem accelerated compared to the overall flow, it doesn't detract significantly from the overall reading experience. "Livingston Girls" is, on the whole, an entertaining and captivating read that will enchant those who are fascinated by witchcraft, value female friendships, and appreciate the magic of poetry in storytelling.

Was this review helpful?

If you like The Grimrose Girls and A Lesson In Vengeance vibes, you will love this one.
It's dark academia + angst + magical coven + witches. I love all the drama and the gang! It was a nice read and I loved it. Rose and Charlie stole my heart haha love themmm

Was this review helpful?