Member Reviews

"Shanghailanders" is a captivating and insightful exploration of the Chinese community in Shanghai during the 20th century. The author weaves together rich historical detail with personal stories, creating a vivid portrait of the city's complex cultural landscape. The characters are multifaceted and their experiences deeply resonate, offering a unique perspective on identity, survival, and resilience. The pacing is generally strong, though some sections could benefit from a tighter focus. Despite a few predictable moments, the storytelling is immersive, and the blend of history with personal narratives makes it a thought-provoking and rewarding read for fans of historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

Successful as individual parts, but not as a whole.

The story progresses in reverse chronological order starting around ~2040 and ending ~2010's. The chapters read like interconnected short stories. Each vignette centers an event, large or small, in the life of one family. The father is Chinese, the mother is Japanese but was raised in Paris. They have three daughters. Wealthy.

If I had to pick themes, I'd say: identity and struggle for connection. It very much portrays how one can be surrounded by family, duty, and activity, but still feel isolated and alone. For a book set primarily in the future, and that has a place in the title, I was disappointed that it wasn't more atmospheric of time and location.

When viewing this as a novel - something with a trajectory of beginning, middle, and end - it fails for me. There's no rising or falling action. There's no overarching problem in search of a resolution. There's nothing to create intrigue. I kept waiting for the element that would make it make sense, the string that tied it together, but it never emerged.

When approaching each chapter as a short story, there's a lot to like. However, as a novel, I found it to be a pretty flat experience. That said, I would read more by this author based on the strength of the writing. I think the structure of the book, and these characters, just weren't for me.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the Publishing Company for this Advanced Readers Copy of Shanghailanders by Juli Min!

Was this review helpful?

This is a multi-generational novel that follows the story of a married couple, their three girls, and a few others in their near orbit. It traces the ups and downs of life as a well=off, multilingual--the mom is from Japan and France, and the rest of the fam is from China--family moving in reverse from present day (2040) when two of the kids are in college and high school in the US to their parents' wedding day..

I enjoyed the writing and pacing of the book. The characters all had depth, and there were definitely some twists and turns. They were particularly interesting learning about them as time moved backwards in the story. It was disorienting at times--also because of the change in characters and perspective--but it was definitely compelling. At the end of it all, I found myself wondering what the point of it all was, but I suppose it's reflective of life. There's no main plot points. It's not your typical three-act structure and picks up and drops off tangential characters in short bouts. Points for creativity and exploration of national identity, but it's not my top choice of the year.

Was this review helpful?

Juli Lin's ShanghaiLander is an imaginative and heartfelt story told in a unique reverse chronological order that keeps readers hooked and invested. I thoroughly enjoyed this structure, which gradually unveils the motivations and secrets that shape each person.

One of the elements I particularly loved was the "what happened to them now.”" This thoughtful addition gives readers a peek into what makes us. Lin's vivid descriptions and rich character portrayals make ShanghaiLander a genuinely engaging read. It prompts reflection on how our past choices shape our futures.

Was this review helpful?

Shanghailanders subverts the well-known family saga narrative in an ingenious way to create a brilliantly executed story of a family spanning generations living in the whirlwind city of Shanghai, telling the story backwards, rewinding through time to weave the tale. First we meet Yumi, Yoko, and Kiko, in their adulthood, coping with the various hardships that adult life brings. Each section slips a few years into the past until we're reading Eko and Leo (their parents)'s story. The prose is compelling, and the story immersive; the depiction of Shanghai breathes life into the city, so much that at times I felt like I knew it. A beautiful novel, I would recommend this highly!

Was this review helpful?

Goes backward in time. The side characters' narratives were surprisingly more compelling than the family, but all in all an interesting read.

Was this review helpful?

Shanghailanders by Juli Min offers a unique family saga told in reverse, starting in 2040 and moving backward to 2014. The novel brings together the lives of the Yang family, exploring their secrets and struggles through different perspectives. I appreciated the beautiful writing and the intriguing format, but I found the reversed timeline made it harder to fully connect with the characters and understand the consequences of their actions. Still, a very engaging and interesting read!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book, but it is told going backward in time. I liked learning how the characters got to where they got to. The book takes place in multiple countries, which I also enjoyed. . I liked the multi culturalism of the characters and all the different languages. I don’t understand how the driver fit into the book.

Was this review helpful?

Shanghailanders by Juli Min is a captivating family saga that takes readers on a journey through time, from 2040 back to 2014, following the lives of the wealthy Yang family. Leo Yang, a successful real estate investor, his elegant wife Eko, and their three daughters—Yumi, Yoko, and Kiko—each face personal challenges that unfold over the years. From Kiko’s risky pursuit of fame to Yumi’s crisis at Harvard, Min explores the complex dynamics of marriage, ambition, and family secrets. Set in a futuristic Shanghai facing environmental threats, the novel is told through multiple perspectives, including the Yangs’ loyal nanny and a daring driver. Min beautifully captures the way love, identity, and family ties persist, even as the world around them changes. Shanghailanders is a powerful and emotional look at the struggles and connections that define us.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you @netgalley for the Advanced Reader Copy of Shanghailanders by Juli Min. It’s the story of a family in Shanghai, going from 2040 to 2014. The family is very wealthy, and the daughters spend time at boarding school and college in the US. We learn a lot about the family and their interactions and controversies. This did not really draw me in all that much, even though I am a fan of family stories. #shanghailanders #julimin #bookstagram #lovetoread #netgalley

Was this review helpful?

Shanghailanders is a story in reverse. Starting in 2040 and progressing backward toward 2014, the family saga begins (ends?) with a reflection of the past -- both partners in the marriage between Leo and Eko regretting their decision to stay with the other but finding the barriers to leaving too great to manage. As we move backward in time, we come to understand how and why things unfolded the way they did. We also come to know the daughters of the family -- Yumi, Yoko, and Kiko. Adding more color to the story are side characters whose stories we learn as they intersect with those of the family members.

I'll preface my thoughts by saying that the writing in this book was absolutely lovely. I applaud the unique approach to storytelling, as well -- reversed timeline, multi-POV. It felt fresh and interesting and always kept me wondering more about the characters. That said, I think the overall plot ARC fell a little flat due to the structure. There's a reason plots move forward in time! Starting with the conclusion, the takeaways fell less grand because we don't appreciate them, and ending the the inciting incident (in this case, Leo and Eko's courtship), the final pages of the story feel small and unresolved. I found myself more drawn to the small side stories of peripheral characters whose entire story resolved within their own vignette. For our main characters, I found myself always wanting to know what happened next (chronologically) while also knowing we'd never revisit that time period.

But it's character-driven, not plot-driven, you might say. Why can't it be both? I think we could have experienced a character-driven book where the events revealed in a reversed order lead to a similar arc of character growth that we see in other books. Or, even the same plot but with a final chapter in the future so we know what ultimately happened to everyone. More difficult to pull off, sure, but I think more satisfying to the reader.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting timeline to write - backwards. It doesn't jump back forth, it just foes backwards.

A fun family drama with lots of potential. There were a few things missing that I can't put my finger on, possibly depth of a few characters, but this is a great novel and I look forward to more.

Was this review helpful?

There was something really compelling about this book. It’s a story about a family with three girls in Shanghai, and goes backwards in time. There was were many different perspective shifts between the characters which could have been frustrating or confusing, but it was elegantly done. It made me reflect over the passage of time in my own life, and the mundane moments that make up our days.

Was this review helpful?

Reading this novel told in reverse was both entertaining and enlightening. There's nothing I enjoy more than a family drama told from multiple perspectives, and Shanghailanders delivers exactly that. Knowing the characters' futures as you read each one's backstory added an intriguing new element. I look forward to reading future books by Juli Min.

Was this review helpful?

This was a bit of a disjointed novel for me--I wanted to like it and the premise, but the reverse chronological order didn't do it for me. I think it's because I wasn't fully invested in these characters, so going all the way to the beginning wasn't as fulfilling.

Was this review helpful?

Published back on May 7th, I've been picking away at this @spiegelandgrau title, wanting to give it my full attention since I grabbed it on @netgalley.

This multicultural family of a Chinese father and Japanese-French mother, is first introduced in 2040 as the parents are sending their older daughters back to boarding school and college in Boston. It has a tenuous atmosphere, and what follows is a collection of what feels like short stories that go back in time and some go to the periphery of the Yang family to understand them in the "present."

This was indeed, a fascinating format. I did feel like I was trying to make the connections until I just relaxed and let the story unfold as it would. I am sure I missed some of those connections, but I did feel the "aha" moments frequently as a particular trait was explained. Some stories felt very loosely connected, so it was helpful to enter each chapter fresh.

I think if you enjoy loosely connected short stories, this will be a fantastic book that will feel like an organic meeting of the Yang family. This is how we get to know people as the current person is slowly revealed over stories that, in trust, are given over time, reminding me that what we first see is never the whole story.

For me, this book was a bit harder to follow, but as I think back it is growing on me. 3.5 Stars.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book for what it was. The family is incredibly fascinating, and each of the members are crafted with a lot of depth and care. I also liked that it started in the future. The book had a speculative edge that went seamlessly into the overall story. But there were two things that kept taking me out of the story. The first was that I kept wanting to know what happened next; which is a compliment if anything, but because the story moved backwards it got frustrating. I wanted to know the consequences of their actions, the build up of their lies, but instead we kept going to where the lies began. It felt like I got so close to answers that kept slipping out from between my fingers. It's good that as a reader I'm so curious and desperate to know what happens next, but annoying that I can't see what happens next.

Was this review helpful?

Shanghailanders was a really interesting and well-written read. I appreciated the character study and exploration of identity. I'd read more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

Cleverly conceived and often quite engaging, Shanghailanders draws readers in with detailed descriptions of family relationships. It's an enjoyable, if not profound, read. You want to know more about the characters and the reverse chronological order accomplishes just that. It helps you to care about them and you do.

Was this review helpful?