Reading The Phoenix Bride was an experience. I felt as if a hush fell and the book whispered out the heartaches of the characters to me, slowly and steadily. A beautifully written book!

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for giving me the opportunity to review this book. All opinions are my own.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an e-arc in exchange for an honest review! I was really excited for this book, as I thought the premise sounded fascinating. I liked the setting, and a couple of the characters, but ultimately I found Cecilia to be such an unlikable character. David was a much more well-developed character in my opinion, as we saw more of his intrinsic and extrinsic motivations. Although Cecilia was grieving and that is very valid, I thought her actions were incredibly childish and immature. While David was well aware of the consequences that could come from their actions, Cecilia appeared quite selfish.

the phoenix bride: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ my favorite of this odd little collection [of recent reads]! i adored solomon’s crown, and i was so glad to be back to natasha siegel’s delicious prose. the setting is immersive and a character all its own. i enjoyed following david and cecilia’s story, and pleased with the endgame they got. plague and fire and disaster can’t keep love from blossoming here. i highly rec this for anyone looking for a more literary historical romance.

This was a beautiful story which showcased two people exploring and helping each other through grief. The imagery and setting were immersive, and I could imagine myself walking the streets of seventeenth century London. I was rooting for Cecilia and David, individually, and that they would find their happiness throughout the story. This was a captivating and enjoyable historical fiction story. Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Ballantine for an advanced copy! All thoughts and opinions are my own!

First, thank you Netgalley and Penguin Random House for the chance to review this book!

I enjoyed this book, however I thought it needed to be more focused. I found myself wanting more development in the story, especially in the beginning. I also found the dialogue taking me out of the novel a little bit. I just wish this was stronger than what it was. I rated it a 3.25 on storygraph!

The Phoenix Bride is a historical fiction novel set in 1666 England. After suffering the unexpected loss of her husband, Cecilia Thorowgood moves to London to live with her sister. She is strongly affected by grief and struggles to eat, socialize, and go outside. Finally, her sister enlists the help of a more alternative source. She employs David Mendez, a Jewish man who fled Portugal from persecution. He also recently experienced a significant loss and has alternative ideas of how to treat Cecilia. Through this, the two become closer.

I'm always interested in historical fiction that goes into medicine from the time period. This is also my second book by the author. I enjoyed Solomon's Crown and excited to read this one!

This book completely hooked me from the beginning. I think I read half of it in one sitting. I was just totally drawn in by the characters and setting. 1666 is such an interesting time period that I haven't seen many books cover! This book has dual POV and I think it worked really well here in establishing David and Cecilia's characters. Howeverrrrr...

David is Cecilia's doctor and later former doctor. As a psychologist, I just really cannot get behind relationships with power dynamics like that. This book tries to make it very clear that David removes himself from being her doctor and there was a (small) gap in time in between the dual relationship. I also know that professional ethics like this were definitely not as clear during the time period. But I'm a professional in this time period with a different frame of references. The efforts still wasn't enough for me and gave me the ick.

Like Solomon's Crown, this book just felt a little unfinished to me. I really enjoyed the beginning and as the book went on it just seemed to get a bit more scattered. I feel like it would have benefitted from a few more rounds of editing. I feel badly saying this as I did have a good time reading this book, but it's something I noticed in Solomon's Crown and then recognized again here. This may be a stylistic choice that but just my impression!

Despite having some reservations, I generally really liked this book and rate it a solid 4 stars. I would definitely read if you are interested in historical medicine! Thank you to Random House Publishing Group and NetGalley for the eARC, my thoughts are my own!

This was a slow start for me--the flowery/poetic language threw me off--but I ended up enjoying David and Cecilia's love story. The realistic queer rep is also fantastic (would pledge my life to Sam Grey).

“She is ivory and gold. She is Granada; she is the mezuzah on the doorframe. And someday, perhaps, things will change: the fire will end, a new summer will come, the linden will bloom again.”

I'm going to be honest...I requested this book simply because I loved the title and the cover a lot, but wowwww I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed the journey of this book! Natasha Siegel really knows how to write captivating historical fiction. The main reason I give The Phoenix Bride 4/5 stars is because I felt like even though I loved learning about these characters, there just wasn't enough detail for me sometimes to make me feel fully invested in them.

Massive thank you to Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine & NetGalley for this lovely eARC!

I really wanted to love this book, but I dnf'd at around 54%. I just was not buying into the relationship between the two lead characters. I didn't feel any chemistry between them, and their romance made no sense to me. To be fair, I didn't realize going in that this was going to be a romance novel and that is entirely on me. I did enjoy elements of David's perspective chapters, but I needed more than that to continue reading.

David is a Jewish physician expelled from Portugal living in London with his father. Cecilia is a recent widow having lost her husband to the plague, living in London with her sister. When Cecilia seems like she'll never get over the heartache, melancholy, and loneliness, her sister calls upon every doctor in the city, finally resorting to hiring Jewish doctor for help. While David and Cecilia have opposite circumstances, they both help each other heal. A true, will they wont they kind of story.

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC. Opinions are my own.

I enjoyed this one even more than Solomon's Crown. This historical fiction is set in London just after the Plague. It relates the story of a young widow grieving the loss of her husband and a Jewish doctor who has fled Portugal in order to be able to live openly as a Jew. He is also grieving a loss: that of his best friend, for whom he had deeper feelings. I liked the healing from grief each experienced, helped by the other, and the love that slowly developed between them. I also liked the historical setting.

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for a free e-ARC of this book.

3.5 stars. The Phoenix Bride by Natasha Siegel was an intriguing read. I loved the historical setting and the lyrical prose. I struggled with the slow pace of the book as well as the relationship of the main characters. David and Cecilia were pleasant characters, but forgettable for me. I wanted to care more about them and for some reason I didn't. The ending left me dissatisfied.

This was truly a surprisingly pleasant read for me. Oh yes, it had its hurts, delights, and nuances about grief and mourning, but it was also about two people who work through this together and separately in a world that doesn't want to see them together. It's a wonderful story of a slowly budding friendship that turns into a romance with all the right people and parts to make it work.

I loved both Cecilia and David, and the friends they made throughout their journey. I loved the background of 1660s England, and I can't say I've read a lot of historical fiction that takes place during this time period (I'm more of a Regency or Victorian era girl myself). I thought it was a bit of an interesting choice to choose this time period but I think it perfectly sets the scenes and considers the restrictions and allowance of both Cecilia, as a women during this time period, and David, as a foreign Jew during the time period, but also the important role he plays as a doctor, as someone who actually cares about his patients and learning.

I was a bit worried there for a second though, that Cecilia and David wouldn't have their happily ever after. They're both fragile and not very outspoken about their feelings for one another. I enjoyed how the author brought these two together through two of their close friends, respectively, and how everything just seemed to work for them. I love when there is a cast of supporting characters. I think it commends the author who was able to write such well-rounded characters that really make you feel deep within you.

What an unexpected book! Cecilia and David meet when he is brought in as her doctor to treat her for melancholy but she is not the only one grieving. In the short amount of appointments they have, they each find in the other someone who can truly see them and make them feel alive. What follows is the struggle of two souls trying to find a way to live with grief and forging a relationship during times of religious prejudice and the Great Fire of London.

Natasha Siegel is a beautiful writer. She describes the setting in such a way that the reader can feel the atmosphere. However, this book is maudlin and I struggled to read this love story between twin sisters and between one of the sisters and a forbidden lover. The storyline of Cecelia and her twin Margaret is a realistic portrayal of what happens when sisters marry and must create their own lives, especially in 1666. Cecelia loses one husband, falls in love with another man, and then marries for convenience. The angst she feels is not what I needed to read right now, but it was masterfully crea;ted.

“I shouldn’t say this,” he says, “but you look beautiful – as if you have risen from the flames.”

Image courtesy of British Library on Unsplash
Natasha Siegel’s The Phoenix Bride is a romance set in a historical moment that you don’t see often think of when you think “romance”: London, 1666. Bubonic plague. The Great Fire. Yet this narrative fascinated me from beginning to end.

One year after the peak of the bubonic plague in 1665, main characters Cecilia and David meet. Both are suffering under the weight of grief and the uncertainty of their futures. Cecilia Thorowgood is a widow transplanted from the country to her sister’s townhouse after the plague killed her beloved husband. David Mendes is a Jewish doctor who fled Portugal in search of freedom and safety in London. He spent the previous year watching his patients, as well as his own loved one, die from the plague. They meet when Cecilia’s sister hires David to treat Cecilia’s lack of appetite, nausea, and nervousness. David, though generally unaccepted as a Jewish man, is known for more unconventional means of curing illness and so is hired as a last resort.

Cecilia has been kept under strict supervision by her sister and the multiple doctors she lined up to “cure” Cecilia of her grief. She hasn’t left the house since she arrived. She spends days only going as far as the garden in the back to walk around the linden tree. David, who recognizes that she is severely depressed, earns her trust over the course of a few weeks. He never forces treatment on her and slowly exposes her to more autonomy in her own care.

Mendes says, “Then this is my final prescription to you, Cecilia: freedom, in as large a dose as you can manage. Leave this awful house and go into the city. Find somewhere you enjoy being. Drink coffee, make friends, visit theaters. Live.“

“You say that as if it is easy.”

“It isn’t easy,” he says. “But it is possible.”
Siegel’s writing is breathtakingly beautiful. It felt like a weighted blanket; when held in only your hands, it seems too heavy to feel comfortable. Yet when spread out over your body, it’s like a balm to your soul. I let this story and Siegel’s writing drape over every part of me — my heart, my mind, my soul — and, as a result, I was soothed.

What I like better than anything else in this story are the depictions of mental health and neurodiversity. When Cecilia meets a neighbor, Sir Samuel Grey, they strike a unique and tender friendship because of their shared difference. Siegel writes an exchange between the two that I don’t think I’ll ever forget because of this vivid imagery:

“The physicians I have spoken with say I am afflicted with a permanent restlessness,” he tell me, apologetic. “My thoughts are like bees, swarming in my skull. Sometimes they fly out of my mouth without warning, and sometimes they buzz so loudly I can’t hear anything else at all. I fear afflicting someone with such madness without warning would be cruel.”

“It is not madness, surely,” I say with a flash of sympathy. I understand what it is to fear your own mind. “Only…difference.”

…

“You said your thoughts are like bees. Do they ever sting you?”

He cocks his head, eyes wide. He looks very much like his spaniel. “Why do you ask? Do yours sting you?”

“Yes, quite often.”
The romance between Cecilia and David was not the highlight of the story for me. I enjoyed Siegel’s descriptions of London and its history and Cecilia’s journey through her grief more than I did of the relationship between the two main characters. The story calls into question norms of sexuality and marriage in 1666 London. I just don’t know enough about that time period to make a call on accuracy, but I did find myself wondering while reading. My interest in these norms, as well as the extent to which the group of main characters found each other in their alterity, captured my attention more than the romance did.

The Phoenix Bride is a beautiful novel and one I would recommend to anyone who is looking for an atypical historical romance that is richly told and cuts right to the soul.

I received this book for free from Netgalley. That did not influence this review.

The Phoenix Bride by Natasha Siegel is a gentle yet gripping historical novel. Set in London amidst plague and the Great Fire of 1666, the novel follows Cecilia Thorowgood, a young widow who lost her beloved husband to the plague. She grieves so deeply that her sister is worried for her health and sanity. After a series of doctors fails to cure her melancholy, her sister takes a bold step, bringing in David Mendes, a Jew.

David understands obsessive grief. He has also lost a loved one, a longtime friend. Because the friend was a man, David never confessed his love. As a Jew and a bisexual, David has to take great care in all he does. Falling for an aristocratic Gentile is perhaps even more perilous than falling for another man.

Gentle and understanding, David is able to reach Cecilia in a way no other physician could. They grow dangerously close. But David learns a secret. Cecilia’s sister’s concern is not as altruistic as she wants it to seem. She wants Cecilia cured so that she can be advantageously remarried. She even has a second husband picked out. And when Cecilia learns what David knows, the fragile band of trust is broken. Can it be restored?

The novel is beautifully written. The setting is richly rendered. And readers will find their heartstrings pulled.

I really wanted to love this one😭. The synopsis was intriguing, but the cover truly sold me. This book started off promising, but it became very repetitive. I was immediately interested in the fact that David was bisexual and had just lost his best friend (who’s also the man he loves), and how he was able to provide some kind of companionship for Cecilia at first. But once we got to the “romance” part, that’s where it went downhill.

********SPOILERS past this point*********


Let me prefix this by saying that this is marketed as a romance, but to me it’s more a story on grief, with a sprinkle of romance in it. Now that said, I was annoyed by all the back and forth Cecilia and David were doing. One moment it’s yes, let’s be together, and the next, it’s no, you’re a Jew, we can’t. I was so over it. I skimmed the last 100 or so pages, and the ending felt very rushed and unfinished ? To me. We go from almost a year apart, to all of a sudden, deciding to choose each other, and that gave me whiplash. I enjoyed the dealing with grief aspect of the book, but the execution of the story could’ve been better in my opinion.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher but an eARC in exchange for my honest review.

I adored this novel. The characters and the lush writing were both so lovely. The story is so redemptive. I had to take my time reading it, because the emotion in the pages was overwhelming. So many times I read lines out loud to my partner because it was so delightfully sad.

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for a copy of this book. Opinions are my own!

This book was so beautiful and engrossing! I went in thinking it would be more of a historical fiction novel, so the lack of a traditional HEA wasn't an issue for me. I loved the setting and time period and found the relationship between David and Cecilia to be completely captivating.

I enjoyed the medical aspects of the story and thought that the way Cecilia described her feelings was so superbly handled. The diversity in the story played such an important role and touches on subjects of mental health, sexuality, and religion.

The characters were all vividly written, and I particularly loved Sam. He was an amazing side character and brought much needed humor and lightness to the story. The friendship and support he offered Cecilia were absolutely delightful.

Overall, this was beautifully written and emotional. It's something that will stay with me for a long time to come.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are my own.