Member Reviews

Gorgeous noir which def earns a 4.5 from me. The entire idea is great and I really think it deserves more attention. Thanks for the arc

Was this review helpful?

Detective Max Elliot has been specifically requested to help on a mysterious homicide case. One that resembles a gruesome unsolved crime from six months earlier. Although a loose cannon, Elliot just happens to be the best investigator in San Francisco. Unfortunately, Max is personally linked by the cold case and the tragedy surrounding his daughter. Will this investigation finally bring peace and justice to his life or will it be his final case?

S.C. Mendes’ The City, is a puzzle solving narrative where inner demons are explored among an underground city of non-human creatures and skin puppets. Inside this unearthly metropolis lies a place where you can find anything within a world of sinister taboo lifestyles. Mendes brings his writing style to a multi-layered story that flips the world of reality on its head. His ominous creativity carves up flesh and bone within an unforgettable evil environment of pleasure and pain. With the purchase of this book, you have been allowed entrance to Mendes’ dark environment.

I love this original creation of a horror-noir novel. It successfully creates a nitty-gritty ambiance within an unsettling true-crime element. The author is able to capture monstrosities and bizarreness to a new level. Believe me fellow bookworms, there’s plenty of skin crawling moments to satisfy the most morbid reader.

The City is one heck of a mind trip. And by that I mean the extra-dimensional characters were a creepy representation of an unearthly order. Wait till you see the “demons to some, angels to others” aspect that Mendes has assembled. Ya know, mysteries were destined to remain hidden. A Horror Bookworm Recommendation.

Was this review helpful?

In The City we follow homicide detective Max Elliot for one last case as he hunts down serial killer and murderer of his wife, The Chinatown Surgeon. As Max begins to look into this case, things continue to unravel and lead him down a supernatural path unknown to most people, where sex, drugs, and especially violence prevail.

S.C. Mendes delivers a classic detective noir story made unique by the added, incredible elements of extreme horror. If you're a fan of films like The Big Sleep but also a fan of authors like Duncan Ralston and Kristopher Triana, this book will be right up your alley. It's almost like the game L.A. Noire, but with way more violence and gore and its own spin that makes the story much, much darker.

I can't stress enough how well-executed the noir elements of The City are. From the crime-ridden streets of San Fransisco, to the seedy underbelly of the titular city, to the well-writen perfectly juxtaposed pair of detectives doing their best within the confines of a politicky department, every aspect feels deliberate and effective.

Again, the extreme horror elements of this book are also remarkable. There were several times I found myself with my lip curled in disgust, as is to be expected in extreme horror. If you are more sensitive to things like violence, gore, and assault I highly recommend checking out content warnings before diving into this book. That being said, I didn't find any of the violence or gore to be there simply for shock value; it is there to drive home the atmosphere and norms of The City, in which they take place.

It looks like The City is going to be a series, and I personally can't wait to see what happens in the next installment. I do think this book can also be read as a standalone though!

Was this review helpful?

Noir detective fiction and dark fantasy at its best!

Max Elliott is a detective in 1909 San Francisco. Max has very personal reasons for being on the case of a sadistic killer, and during his investigations he discovers the worst in human, and non-human, depravity.

At first I was a little reluctant as this is considered extreme horror but I really enjoyed this medium paced noir horror novel. Parts of this are extreme but not in anyway near as some extreme horror novels. There wasn't so much as to take away from the story.
My only critique is about the time period to which it pertains; Supposedly set in 1909, the characters come across as living in a later time period. The speech is closer to something from the 1940's or '50's and had to remind myself that it was 1909 many times.
However, that said, I did not think it takes anything away from the story itself and I highly recommend.

I think this would appeal to Gaiman fans, fans of dark fantasy, and noir.

I received a free copy of this from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The City is a horror novel with a great gritty noir-ish detective vibe and these two elements work seamlessly to create a frightening twisted world.

Set in San Francisco in 1909, our protagonist, Max Elliott, is a detective with a painful past. His wife was brutally murdered and skinned alive and his daughter was kidnapped. He's taking some time off but spends that time mired in alcohol and opium dens.

When another case with the same MO happens, he decides to rejoin because he hopes this will help him solve what happened to his family.

An informant has some interesting information but it's a lot to take in. Under the city, far below in the earth, is another city. This one is run by the Mara, a group of lizard like creatures. Max decides to take a chance and this is where this novel turns bizarre and absolutely terrifying.

The city below is real and it's basically a playground for adults to indulge in their every sick degenerate fantasies. It's a brutal place where absolutely everything is available for a price. Some of the scenes from here are bloody, perverse, sickening, and horrifying. But if it helps him maybe find his daughter, Max is willing to suffer for it.

Along the way we'll meet other humans from that city. From truly sick individuals to the closest thing he can find as friends. With twists and turns, this book moves along like a locomotive. It's fast paced narrative and perverse imagery will stay with you for a long time.

I highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?