Member Reviews
I read up to 25% before setting this aside. The storyline of a character no longer being able to do what she loves really resonated with me as I have been in Tess's shoes. As the story progressed, I was frustrated with the horrible decisions Tess was making and how she was putting her health in danger. I also was appalled at how her dad blatantly didn't care about her health and pushed her to go back to swimming asap. With those two things, plus the friend issue and a love interest, I did not feel invested in the story as I predicted where the plot would go. Thank you for giving me the chance to read this.
2.5 🌟
Beautiful cover and promising premise. Unfortunately, it fell flat for me. Tess gets a seizure attack, which jeopardizes her entire swimming career and future, and throughout the book, she has to navigate and adjust to the uncertainties of her epilepsy. It started off intriguing, but after a few chapters, I got bored. I feel like the characters could have been fleshed out more. Like other reviews have pointed out, Tess as a character is only limited to swimming. This is pitched as slice-of-life, so I understand the focus on Tess’s swimming career, but other than that, we don’t find anything else about her. The other characters felt one-dimensional as well. Overall, this had potential, but the story was simply telling with little showing.
Breathing Underwater, a contemporary young adult novel by Abbey Nash was a slow read for me, at first. It revolves around Tess, a competitive swimmer who is set to go to Nationals with her high school team when tragedy strikes. At a party with friends, Tess experiences a seizure and nearly drowns. Afterwards, she finds out that it was more than a fluke. In fact, she is diagnosed with epilepsy, something that could put an end, not only to competing with her team, but to her swimming career entirely. Even worse, her seizure costs Tess her summer job lifeguarding, to new guy Charlie, and puts a strain on her relationship with her best friend Mackenzie (Mac). A wedge that only continues to grow as Mac seems more interested in hanging out with teammate and popular mean girl, Rachel, than with Tess. Even though the inciting incident that changes everything in the story happens early on, Tess's singular focus on swimming and nothing else made it hard for me to immediately empathize with her. I did feel bad that she and Mac seem to be having some trouble even before Tess has her seizure. However, as she faces one hurdle after another and gets to know Charlie, her new neighbor, I felt myself being pulled into this story.
I found the characters to all be well drawn and Tess's reaction, to what she sees as her body's betrayal, very believable and genuine. I appreciated that Nash does this with sensitivity and heart. A story like this one could easily become an angst ridden one with a main character that either lashes out at everyone in anger or wallows in self-pity. But Nash creates a realistic three-dimensional character in Tess, who fluctuates between fear, uncertainty, anger and the pain of disappointment, feeling like she won't ever live up to her full potential or achieve her dreams. Likewise, Tess's interactions with Mac, her family and with Charlie all add layers to the story making it a compelling read. The more I got to know her and the other characters the more I found myself unable to put it down. I especially loved the banter and flirting that goes on between Tess and Charlie as their romance develops. Not only does he become a good friend to her, but the attraction between them has a slow sweet build as their first love blossoms. Charlie also carries some secret pain and disappointments of his own that add intrigue to the story. In the midst of all of this, Nash gives us a nice time clock that intensifies the pace as the Nationals approach and we are left wondering if Tess will still be able to achieve her dream of competing and securing a scholarship at the college she has always hoped to attend. All in all, I would give this 4 out of 5 stars since it did take me a bit longer to be drawn into the story. However, that could also be because I am reading it from an adult perspective.
Overall, I would highly recommend this book if you enjoy contemporary young adult fiction that has a slow burn style element of romance. It is a stand alone book as well, which may appeal to some readers who prefer that to series fiction. Breathing Underwater also has a premise I haven't seen a lot in YA fiction since it involves a character who is struggling to adapt to having a serious disorder that could throw all of her aspirations completely off course. Added to that this cover design is gorgeous. If any or all of these things appeal to you as a reader then definitely put this one on your want to read list.
<i>Thank you NetGalley and Holiday House for the ARC.</i>
*3.75
Tess Cooper is a 17-year-old swimmer who has her future planned. Get a college scholarship through swimming. However, things suddenly change direction when Tess has a seizure, forcing her to rethink her future and choices.
Even with the first-person point of view, it seems that at no point do we get to know the MC. We know that she likes to swim, the job she has every summer, and a few other superficial things, but hardly anything about her inner thoughts and her character.
Some things that bothered me – besides the lack of depth in the characters – it was their relationships. It felt like Charlie and Tess ended things as fast as they started, and Mac and Tess, who could have a beautiful friendship throughout the book, were apart for most of it and then they apologized like nothing really happened.
I think the conflict between them could have been better worked on, as could Charlie's complicated relationship with his father (which was mentioned a couple of times and forgotten in the end).
Overall, it was a quick and interesting book that could have better character development, but it was an okay read.
(3.25) Breathing Underwater is a short, slice-of-life story, following Tess, a swimmer, after her diagnosis with epilepsy.
This is a classic storyline with sports, and the author explores Tess’s love, sister, parents, and friends, all quite quickly in the novel. While the story is easy to read and quick-paced, the focus on Tess’s emotions and reactions meant that the rest of the characters weren’t that built up. I didn’t really feel the chemistry between her and her love interest. I didn’t see the rivalry between her and a swim mate. I didn’t see the break up and replenishing of her friends. That would have made the story for me.
Thank you to NetGalley and Holiday House for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Breathing Underwater is a lovely little slice of life story with a strong cast of characters and important message, that I think would be a great addition to any young teen's shelf.
I found myself completely engrossed the entire time and the writing itself was very clear and concise, at no point did I feel like parts of the story were unnecessary. I was also very impressed with how fleshed-out the characters were. At first, it bugged me that Tess' motivations seemed one dimensional, but when I look back at how my thought process worked at 15/16, the 'this or nothing attitude' was actually quite endearing. Despite the story clearly focusing on Tess, it was nice to see that the supporting characters also accomplish little things and lived their lives in the background, without the need to bring it to the main plot and focus of the narrative.
The book had me captivated from the beginning and I want to know more about Tess' story. That is not to say that I felt the story was unfinished, but rather that I would absolutely pick up a hypothetical sequel to this story.
Overall, if you are looking for a light, charming read, Breathing Underwater should be noted down as something to check out once it is released in March.
Okay, so I'll be as nice as I can while reviewing this book since it has a lot of the author's personal experiences with epilepsy.
There are three things that I didn't like about the story, and they're about as major to the book as they're intertwined: lack of character deepness, their relationships with each other and lack of lore.
I don't know Tess. Like, I know swimming is her life and that she's diagnosed with epilepsy and that she's going to Nationals and her future depends on how they go... but what else? I have nothing. I don't know what she likes beside swimming, I don't know how she spends her time when she's not swimming/sleeping, I don't know what she thinks period.
When doctors suspect she might have epilepsy her world crumbles for sure, but it's like... I don't know how to express myself on that one. Like her feelings are not really deep. She focuses on what that means to her swimming career and her future, sure, and I get since swimming is the most important thing for her right now the focus is on that, but I don't think she really thinks about her health realistically. Like, yeah, it sucks and you might not be able to swim in a competition ever again, but *also* you could like... die.
I didn't get Tess because of that. Her lack of deepness as a character made me realize I couldn't ever get her feelings towards the fact that epilepsy made her think only about her future in swimming competitions and not in like... the rest of her life.
But Tess isn't the only I didn't get. Charlie went from being the only one she could rely on, the only one that didn't tell her that everything's gonna be fine, that it's just a phase and she'll move on, etcetc to... exactly that. Literally. And it's super sudden because again, we don't know *anything* about Charlie. Sure, we know he just moved here since his parents got divorced, that he doesn't talk with him and that he got the job that was supposed to be Tess' at the pool. That's literally it. We also know a couple of things (like he's living with his aunt and that he likes rock music) that don't really mean anything to the story.
Tess and Charlie's relationship feels void because we don't know them. They go out for like two weeks and suddenly, when she sees him again, feels a lot of feelings as if she couldn't live without him. And that could 100% be a natural reaction to a teenage, new relationship, but feels fake because we don't really know these people.
The relationship with her family is also weird due to lack of deepness. I understand her relationship with her dad, also an athlete; I also understand the mother, worried sick for her daughter's health; and I also get her relationship with her sister, kinda the black sheep of the family... but I don't understand the family dynamics.
The only normal one is the mom: she's worried, she wants her to quit but when she doesn't she decides to support her even if she doesn't approve, making sure she's safe anyways. The dad's super weird; I get you're super supportive of her swimming career and that you're frustrated your own sports-related career ended early, but like... dude?? Your kid might have epilepsy?? Stop with the jock thing and like start to act like a supportive but responsible parent as your wife does?? Even when he cleans up his act it's still super weird and still pushes her daughter to swim. And I get it, okay? But at the same time I don't.
Ali (the sister) is another thing on its own. And with this (alongside Charlie's story and Mac and Tess' story) I open the whole lack of lore thing. Why is Ali there for? It could've been any other character and it'd have been the same. She's there because she apparently quit her job and went back to her parents' house, not wanting to go to college either. She gets an earful from her mom when she first appears and she drives Tess when she can't plus a couple of scenes in which she's there during family time, but that's it. She also doesn't get an ending... she's just there. Why did we have to know about her and her story? It doesn't lead to anything and that makes the character feel even more blank. If she were to stay and NY and FaceTime Tess all throughout the story (when the fist seizure happens, when she kisses Charlie for the first time, when she has to decide wether to stay on the team or quit forever, etc) she could've provided sooo much more to the story! Even more if she confessed to Tess that her job wasn't the best and that it's hard out there but she was following her dream and that's what counts yadda yadda... instead we got a watered down character that lacked lore and didn't get a proper ending.
Long story short: I really liked the plot but couldn't really enjoy the story due to these things. I'd still love to read more from Nash because I feel like she had a great idea to develop but the execution on this particular book wasn't my thing.
Thanks to Holiday House and Netgalley for the eARC!
✰ 2.75 stars ✰
“I’m a swimmer. I don’t know how to be anything else.”
Tess has always had one lifelong passion - swimming. It's in her blood, her soul, her entire life has revolved around swimming competitively and honing her skills. She doesn't have much time for anything else when she has only one goal in mind - winning Nationals in her senior year so she can get into the prestigious college offering her a scholarship - 'every win matters. Even a few added seconds can mean shattered dreams.' 🏊🏻♀️ But, when she's afflicted with an unprompted and unexpected seizure whilst in the water, she's not quite prepared for how difficult her life would suddenly become, and how she has to relearn what it's like Breathing Underwater.
“You’re going to get through this,” Dr. Cappalano says. “It’s hard, but it’s not hopeless.”
The writing was very clear and concise and the story solely focused on one thing - how Tess' swimming career faced a dramatic and drastic upheaval due to this sudden shift. I appreciated how the author showed the care and concern that her doctors and parents and Coach were treating it. 👍🏻 It's a gentle and soft reminder that it shouldn't be taken lightly, to be regarded with a lot of sensitivity and responsibility, especially when there's a risk of epilepsy happening in the future. It was not treated lightly and as much as it hurt them to see their star swimmer suffer, her health was their top priority - her safety was their utmost requirement. 😟
It was tough seeing how hard it affected her relationship with her best friend, Mac - how having her adjust to the changes made her cut off from her respective teammates and seen more as a burden rather than the spirited swimmer she was. It was a healthy and heartfelt portrayal of how friendships can suffer by it, but the way Tess fought to maintain her friendship was something that I respected and admired. I’m learning that so much about epilepsy is waiting and hoping and doing your best.' 😔 As she learns to cope with her new way of life, she starts to not see it as a burden, but as a part of her - and not let it defeat her dreams.
“I’m a swimmer,” I blurt. “Or I used to be. I guess my first seizure could’ve killed me, but instead I lost the sport I love.” A tremor creeps into my voice, and the room blurs.
“Sometimes, I’m not sure which one is worse.” It’s quiet for a moment. I stare at my hands, thumb away my tears.
“Dying,” Lisette says.
I look up at her.
“Dying would definitely be worse.”
Tess' thoughts and emotions were believable and valid; the frustration of not being part of a team again, the anger at missing out on practices, the embarrassment of the special treatment required at pools to guarantee her safety - 'the fastest you’ll ever see a fish swim is when it finally realizes it’s free.' 😥 The description of her swimming and her drowning - her time in the water and out of it - was compelling and alluring. It shows how viscerally swimming is ingrained in her system so much that she doesn't want to have a life without it - 'no dates, no real social life. Just swim, school, repeat.'
Her feelings emanated realistically enough for me to believe that this was a young girl - whose entire future plans were being flushed down the drain, and she didn't know how to stop it - how to control it or prevent it from slipping from her grasp. 'A seizure disorder is literally the worst possible thing that could happen to me. I want out, I want out, I want out.' 🥺 But, just as suddenly everything changed, just as slowly, the author gives her a chance to face the challenge head-on. She fought to cope and adjust and re-align her situation so that she could still swim and still not deny that she did have special needs, but she can learn to accommodate herself with treatment, medication and careful consideration of her health. That it's not entirely hopeless or necessary to give up the dream - that she shouldn't lose hope or faith that her dreams can still come true. 🙏🏻🙏🏻
“As I ease into a familiar workout that leaves my heart racing with joy, I remember that the human body is 70 percent water, that we’re basically breathing underwater all the time. ”
Charlie, the love interest - the “non- athletic regular people” was alright, I guess - nothing too outlandish or significant about him that made his appeal any different than your typical YA love interest, complete with his own painful past that made him even more appealing. ' Messy, unmotivated, and clearly doesn’t care what people think about him' he was so very kind and sweet to her, someone Tess was immediately drawn to, that despite how she's never had time for a social life or boys, she's comforted by him and was happy that he cared for her, even after their small-lasting breakup. ❤️🩹❤️🩹
'You’re definitely a swimmer,” he says. “But you’re more than that, too.' I know it makes me sound bitter about their romance, but, maybe it would be an interesting trend where a guy can be introduced and they can just be friends till the end of the book - no boyfriend needed! I think it just made me feel that it took for her to come to a bad place to find a relationship with someone - something that she's never attempted to have because of her swimming career. 🫶🏻 Something like a hopeful belief that you really can have it all - the dream and the guy while still learning to cope with her new change of life. So, I guess, it is a nice hopeful note to end on for those who may have to face similar situations as Tess'. ☺️
And, on a last note, can I just say that if there were annual book awards held, I would totally nominate this as the most beautiful cover of the year. I'm honestly in awe of how visually striking it really is. 😍😍
*Thank you NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I usually don’t read slice of life books, but occasionally I do and once again I was not disappointed.
I’ve been having trouble focusing on a book and actually being reeled into it but, this was really easy to get into, and so this is my first read of the year! I’m sure I would have read this in one sitting had I not started it so late.
It was nice to read how every one of the characters developed their personalities, ambitions and thoughts. I would definitely recommend everyone read this!
The protagonist Tess is a competitive swimmer and the best in her team. She has a secure future with a sports scholarship on the horizon, but all of that seems to be on the brink after one night. Tess is diagnosed with epilepsy after multiple doctor visits and examinations. For the seventeen-year-old, a time filled with doubt begins - can she ever swim her best time again or compete in swimming at all?
The book had me captivated from the first page. Not only is the writing style light yet profound, but Tess is described in an incredibly relatable way, capturing her thoughts and emotions. I found her to be so likable and passionate about swimming. Since I have no personal experience with epilepsy, I learned quite a bit while reading. The author manages to describe in great detail, which might not be easy for some readers. In my opinion, it's just right, as the book also mentions that epilepsy can be an "invisible disability," and raising awareness is crucial to learn the right approach and to think and act more inclusively.
Furthermore, Tess's story provides so much courage and strength to pursue all goals! A clear recommendation from me.
Breathing Underwater is a slice-of-life novel with a solid disability plot focusing on epilepsy. The main character has to deal with the struggles of becoming sick right in the middle of training for Nationals for swimming, knowing that her entire life won't ever be the same again.
This book is a good book if you're looking for a well paced, not too heavy book about overcoming problems out of your control. The main character not only has to tackle her own feelings, but also those around her, some of who understand and some who don't.
I cannot put this book down. I'm glad I get to read it because it's my cup of tea: a young adult tale about resilience, dreams, and always giving your best. Everything that has potential to be cliche takes a satisfying turn. I almost like every character—yes, even Rachel—because of how supportive they are to Tess. The writing style is concise, kind of deep-POV and can be perceived as distant for readers who like blatant 'tell' description, but for me it works elegantly. The cover art is also beautiful even though I'm not really a fan of typeface choice/layout.
I just don't get why it is marketed as slice-of-life because what I had in mind are stories like Spy X Family or Yuzuki Family's Four Sons. This story feels solid, there are causalities and stake that's not low (after all teenagers do worry about their future, especially ones with talent and passion like Tess), and the vibe is not oneshot-like mundane. It does read easily, but it doesn't mean it is a light read. Maybe because it is written in such sensitivity that it feels like a breeze slowly tugging your heart. If you adore stories like Wendelin van Draanen's The Running Dream, you'll like this one too. P.S. We need a Charlie in our lives 🥹
Thank you Holiday House and NetGalley for the digital ARC. Reviews are my own.
Tess is a character who sparkles with hope and humanity. A delicate story about what it means to overcome, and become more yourself along the way.
I liked this one! As someone who has had quite a few friends and families with epilepsy, I found Tess' story incredibly moving. It was a great coming of age novel that anyone could relate to as we've all been at a crossroads when it feels like something is getting in the way of the things we love. I liked Tess as a character, but felt that her development fell flat and needed some more backstory. Other than that, I enjoyed the quick pacing and representation that this novel brings to the YA genre. Thanks so much for the ARC!
The cover is beyond beautiful and the title just makes me want to grab the book!
Overall this was a great quick and fast paced read. I enjoyed the storytellling from the author a lot and the characters were quite sympathetic. The idea was great as well and it seemed really unique to me!
I was originally drawn to this book because of the stunning cover, but I really enjoyed it. Tess is a swimmer who puts her sport before everything until she unexpectedly has a seizure. The seizure if effecting all aspects of her life as it has jeopardized the swimming career she is depending on for a scholarship, and has cost her her summer job life guarding.
Her replacement is Charlie, a boy who has moved to her neighborhood recently and is the polar opposite of Tess. He is laid back, goes with the flow and is exactly what Tess needs during this time of uncertainty.
A touching story about living with epilepsy and chasing your dreams.
Tess Cooper lives to swim, and with a college scholarship on the line, she needs to stay focused now more than ever. Tragedy strikes when she has a seizure while swimming, and her whole world is turned upside down. She has to give up her lifeguard job, and maybe even her dreams. Tess is determined to stay in the water, no matter the cost.
This is a great quick read, the writing is smooth and the plot is fast paced. Despite the YA tag, it's more suited as a middle grade book, seeing as it has simple characters and a “puppy love” like highschool romance.
I love seeing disabilities like epilepsy written in positive heartwarming stories on acceptance and resilience. I hope more books, on all grade levels, can include more disabled characters just like Tess.
Thank you to Netgalley and Tor Publishing Group for this ARC.
This slice of life book was very well written. The main character has a good balance of trying to fight for what she wants and has the fear of the unknown. I highly enjoyed reading about her journey to acceptance.
The author did a great job expressing the medical concern and and the complications of teenage love. I found that the author was very good at expressing the ups and downs of finding your self during a hard.
Love the end and that the situation was cared for but left it open to interpretation. Way to Rock it!
The story is interesting enough; there's so much potential, but I desperately wanted more from the narration. And while I get that delving into a character's emotions isn't easy, it's so important since that's what gives more depth to the story and the characters. Without it, everything that happens feels sort of bland, underdeveloped, and unimportant.
I don't think I've ever known so little about the main character. Tess is a goody-two-shoes who loves swimming and… well, that's it. Where are her other interests? What are her thoughts on everything happening around her? What about her deeper worries regarding the diagnosis or her feelings about potentially losing her best friend? We barely saw any of it, and it drove me crazy.
On the other hand, Charlie is slightly more developed as a character and a main love interest. However, due to the limited insight into Tess's thoughts, I'm not convinced that she likes him as much as she says. Even their first kiss lacks the expected spark. Where's the slow build-up, the anticipation, the music swelling up in the background?
All in all, I just think if you're going to write from a first-person point of view, don't forget to include their point of view. Simply put, Breathing Underwater felt more like reading a screenplay than a novel.
This was a great read especially as it coupled the relatability of growing up woth the uncertainty of a diagnosis!