Member Reviews

I appreciate Garvin's efforts and outlook here. It was a helpful human take on ancient and fairly modern spirituality / wisdom. 4 stars for the material and perspective, but this was not an easy book to read, and not because of the complicated ideas, but rather in their expression.

Garvin gives a broad philosophical, spiritual, and ultimately experientially based exploration of how we make sense of our existence, and recognize we are One with the Self, ultimately building off Meher Baba and Aurobindo Ghose, but not mentioning them until 40% into the book. Before then, the first part of the book is somewhat of a slow redundant slog as he tries to set up definitions and views, but while using the word penumbra way too much. 31 times total in the book, including "penumbra-bits", "penumbraness" and "unpenumbraed." Despite my best efforts, and repeated exposure, the word never settled into making any sense and always took away from whatever point he was making. After the first part of the book, he hits a much more readable stride.

Perhaps it was due to the ARC, but the text I read, could use more definitive breaks and transitions. There were no chapter breaks, only headers every so often, so it felt more like reading a very long essay, than a book with clear divisions.

These are mainly editorial-type criticisms of a book that I mostly enjoyed and found helpful, especially after the first 30%. I appreciate this ARC through NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

This is not an easy read. It’s not a short read either. It has taken me a while to get through. But not because of the academic nature of the text, so much as the thought provoking insights. It’s the sort of book you read, then you pause because you have to think about what it says and how that impacts your own life or thoughts. Then you go back to the book, then a few pages along another insight. I will be filing this under "read again" as I know I’ll get more out of it on a second read through.

Tim Garvin considers consciousness to be a topic belonging to many disciplines and by taking a ‘close notice’ approach, we can try to explain what it is/what it means. I’m not sure I understood some of his premises but I’m very glad I’ve been exposed to his ideas.

I was given a copy of the book by NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

"Everything Makes Sense" by Tim Garvin is like a bridge built between the seemingly disparate worlds of science and religion. Garvin eloquently breaks down the barriers that often divide these realms, inviting readers to join him at a table where wonder serves as the common language.

What struck me most about this book is Garvin's ability to foster a sense of unity between scientists and seekers. Rather than pitting them against each other, he suggests that both groups are exploring different facets of the same cosmic reality. It's a refreshing perspective that encourages collaboration rather than conflict.

As I delved deeper into "Everything Makes Sense," I found myself captivated by Garvin's exploration of knowing and existence. He doesn't just scratch the surface; he dives into the depths of human understanding, revealing a profound interconnectedness that transcends traditional boundaries.

One of the most compelling aspects of the book is Garvin's integration of the philosophies of Aurobindo Ghose and Meher Baba. By drawing on their insights, he constructs a compelling explanation of existence that resonates deeply with readers. It's a testament to Garvin's skill as a writer and thinker that he can weave together such diverse perspectives into a coherent and enlightening narrative.

Overall, "Everything Makes Sense" is a thought-provoking read that challenges readers to expand their minds and embrace new ways of thinking about the nature of reality. Whether you're a scientist, a seeker, or simply someone curious about the mysteries of existence, this book offers a compelling invitation to explore the deep purpose of creation.

Was this review helpful?

I appreciate NetGalley for providing me this book in exchange for my thoughts.

The author Tim guides us through a contemplative journey, employing a keen observation method that encourages us to focus on the present moment and draw insights from our personal experiences.

As someone who enjoys sparking thoughts, this style of phenomenological storytelling resonates with me and really enjoyed this
New writing subject and made a change from my normal choice of book.,

Was this review helpful?

The author takes us onto a thoughtful, reflective journey.
He uses a close noticing approach, what brings you to look here and now, from experience.
By thinking we try to explain our surroundings, all that is visible and invisible in life.
Being a thought instigator myself, this is my kind of phenomenological storytelling.

Was this review helpful?