Absolutely obsessed with this book from beginning to end. Marcela and Theo are the kind of characters you're constantly rooting for, to the point where whenever Ben was on the page, I felt like I was going crazy. It's hard for me to finish any book if I'm not 100% into it, but I was 150% into this one, eating it up in less than a day.
I really loved the plus size and Latina rep in this one. It was so authentic, but it wasn't dragging, or treated like a novelty the way I've seen so many other romances do. Marcela's insecurities were valid, were real, and her passion as a librarian for more diverse reads was inspiring. Loved loved loved this one, can't wait to read it with my bookclub at the store!

I’m leaning towards a 3.75 for this book. I will say the it was easy to read and I definitely enjoyed it over all! I was only frustrated sometimes with Marcela and the way she would get in her head about things but honestly with her background it did just make it more realistic. I loved Theo and how much of a sweetheart he was! The scene where he planned on their date and intertwining their interests was super cute! I also loved how I know the author is Mexican and included tid bits of the heritage in the book such as the food and the relationship with the FMC and her mom. Overall this was a good read and again I really enjoyed it, love it all wrapped up really nicely.

WOW! This book was a fantastic debut. Marcela is in love with her best friend, Ben, but he's engaged to Alice. Theo is in love with Alice who is his brother's fiancée. Theo has plans to confess, but Marcela intervenes and their story begins.

This is exactly what great rom coms are made of and I loved every single page of this book. I absolutely loved Marcela and Theo, their friends with benefits relationship, the banter, spice, their dates.. ALL OF IT- it was soo good! I also loved that the FMC was a plus sized Latina and a book lover. The character development and emotional growth was fantastic and I have to admit that Theo Young has become one of my new favorite book boyfriends.

Gabriella Gamez did such a great job and I'm so excited for the next book in the series.

This was such a cute fake dating story of going into a fake relationship to get over someone.

Marcela is trying to be supportive of her best friend's (who she is secretly in love with) engagement. Well turns out his brother isn't too happy about the engagement as he is in love with his brother's fiancé. I mean who doesn't love a love square?!

The two decide to fake date for a nice little rebound. Lots of messy things happen but it was great to see Marcela find her voice and confidence.

Thank you Netgalley, publisher and author for an advanced copy!

Some of the back and forth and miscommunication made the pacing in the book feel uneven, but it was very cute and charming despite this. I absolutely loved Theo- he's beyond precious. Solid debut!

I was a little skeptical about a romance in which both parties had feelings for someone else. However, I'm happy to say that Gabriella Gamez made it work! It was really interesting to watch Marcela's perceptions change as she got to know Theo better.

I loved the connection Marcela and Theo had. He paid attention to her and was vulnerable with her. I liked watching her learn to do the same. While their beginning made everything complex, I felt like sometimes people don't meet in perfect circumstances and it was fun to watch it all get untangled.

It was also really fun to read about how much Marcela loved books. I liked reading about her work at the library and liked that Theo supported that.

If you love stories about book lovers or a steamy romance with some emotional complexities this one is for you! I am interested to see who will be the next couple in this series! There are a couple of characters we got to know who I really liked! A wonderful debut overall!

Read if you like:
💪🏾Strong FMC
👯‍♀️ Best Friend’s Brother
💋 Fake Dating
🔺 Love Triangles

Marcela is in love with Ben, and Theo's in love with Ben's fiancé…. So of course we have DRAMA! And what’s the solution… obviously to fake date to make them jealous and see what they are missing, right?!

If you love tropes and drama and swoon worthy fake dating where he falls first, you really need to pick this one up!

Thank you so much to Forever for the ARC & Finished copy in exchange for my review.

Getting over your first loves with a no-strings attached relationship should be fun!

The Next Best Fling was such an incredible debut novel. I had so much fun reading about Marcela and Theo.

Marcela, our gorgeous plus size, Mexican librarian fmc was incredibly relatable to read. Being secretly in love with your best friend for over a decade is already hard enough, add in the fact he’s been with his girlfriend for years and they’re now engaged to be married, yikes! Marcela is patient but she had such precious character growth. Healing herself, realizing the toxic environment around her. I adored her friendship with Angela!

Theo is an ex-football player who has daddy issues. He’s been in love with the same girl since they were children, waiting in hope she’d feel the same way someday. Theo is incredibly mature and I loved seeing how he treated Marcela and how easygoing and loving he was. Adored his character growth as well!

I also wanted to point out the amount of appreciation Gabriella wrote about libraries as a whole. As a weekly library goer, libraries are so so so important and deserve much more recognition than solely for books. They offer so many resources (free) that one can access. My library offers services like passport, printing/copy, classes, children time, a mini bookstore, study rooms, computers with specific applications (like Adobe), and of course books! A feature I adore is the bookstore of course, as I have found over 50 books for prices I can afford. Another feature is the suggest feature where you can literally request what book you would like them to order and they almost always accept within a few weeks/months!

If you enjoy library love, a man who is an act of service king, a woman who loves reading, and some angsty characters, then this is a must read! Thank you NetGalley and Forever for the arc in exchange for my review! <3

This was a lovely debut by Gabriella Gamez! I was hooked from the beginning, and could not put it down until I finished it.

🩷 Plus Sized Rep
📚 Librarian FMC
🩷 Latina FMC
🏈 NFL MMC
🩷 Romcom

She wants the bride, he wants the groom...what are these two to do other than fake date each other to get over their feelings! 😅 Marcella hasn't gotten over her love for her friend Ben who is engaged to another woman. While Ben's brother Theo has always wanted to be with the woman Ben is engaged to and it is just the perfect storm for a disaster...but in a fun chaotic way 😏

I instantly fell in love with Marcela, who is a plus sized, Latina woman who works as a librarian. I loved her bookish qualities, and how well written her passion for books was. Theo was hot and such a sweetheart as well! He was very swoon worthy from the beginning, but it did take me a while to trust that he wasn't going to be foolish and make some dumb decision. (Which both characters did at some point or another by the end 😅)

This was a very quick and easy read for me. I devoured it in less than 24 hours, which is quick for me! Which does say something about the quality of the writing to keep my attention for so long.

However I will say the first half was a lot more enjoyable than the second half. There was a lot of flip flopping, miscommunication, self sabotaging going on that sort of all dragged out for no particular reason. Along with the pacing at the end was just not great, all of which sort of ruined the ending a bit for me.

With all that being said this was a solid debut by this author. I would have no problem reading more from her work in the future 🤗

Thank you to Forever & NetGalley for the ARC of this one in exchange for my honest review.

Thank you to ForeverPub and NetGalley for the eARC!
4.5 stars
This was such a fun romcom! I absolutely loved the plus size representation - I could relate all too well to the feelings Marcella experienced about her body and how she was affected by the reactions of past love interests. What I particularly loved is that Marcella was confident in herself (including her body) while being aware of how others had hurt her in the past. It was refreshing to see a plus size character who hadn’t internalized negative perceptions of their body, even if she was still affected by it (what human is immune to others judgments?!)

I adored Theo. What a cinnamon roll. The way he loved Marcella was just *chef’s kiss* I won’t spoil anything, but his actions, words, and gestures had me kicking my feet and squealing.

I loved this story, all of the characters felt dynamic and I appreciated that the author called out that CW love triangle (square?) and being torn between two brothers, so funny! I’d love more in this universe!!!

The Next Best Fling follows Marcella and Theo as they use each other to get over their unrequited feelings for another couple. I'm not usually one for too much drama, but I absolutely loved it in this book! The messy and chaotic energy worked so well with the romance and how Marcella and Theo fell in love. I loved that once Theo got over his feelings for Alice, he was 100% in with Marcella, the man was so sweet and willing to do anything to make her happy. The story flowed so well and while there was quite a bit of back and forth, I think it worked out so well in the end with how Marcella came to realize her feelings.

Read For:
📚Fake Dating📚
📚Friends to Lovers📚
📚Best Friend's Brother📚
📚Librarian FMCs📚
📚Grand Gestures📚
📚Fake Dating📚
📚Plus Size Rep📚
📚Cinamonroll MCs📚
📚Friends w Benefits📚

This book was messy AF and I LOVED it. I’m not usually a fan of love triangles/squared and heavy angst, but this book just worked for me. There was just the right amount of angst for me. I really liked the writing style, it flowed really nicely and I flew through the book! I loved all the characters (except Ben, he can go right in the garbage). I really liked the relationship between Marcela and Theo, and how their relationship evolved from a rebound fling to something deeper. Also, Theo is peak book boyfriend material. We stan a supportive cinnamon roll hero. All in all, I really enjoyed this book. The only real complaint is that we only got Marcela’s point of view, I personally prefer dual P.O.V when reading romance. I will definitely pick up whatever the author writes in the future!

Thank you to NetGalley and Forever (Grand Central Publishing) for providing the ARC.

This book was sweet and also a tad painful, but in a really good way.

Marcela has been in love with her ex-boyfriend turned best friend for over 10 years, hoping for the day when he would realize that he wanted to be with her instead of his longtime girlfriend. When Ben ends up engaged, she finds herself in a very compromising position with Ben's older brother, Theo, who has a destructive secret of his own. In an effort to help each other move past their respective feelings, they end up in a not-real-at-first fling that might actually be the best thing that ever happened to both of them.

The tension in this book is immaculate. Everything about this story is wrapped up in this blanket of who the reader is able to trust, which version of the story is the truth. You have Marcela, who has been hurt for years over her father's abandonment and has been in a somewhat twisted co-dependent relationship with Ben. You have Theo, who has has harbored feelings for Ben's fiancée for most of his life and a not so great relationship with his brother. They come together and realize that there's chemistry and honesty, because neither one expects anything from the other. And if it helps them get over their feelings, then that's just a cherry on the cake.

But it's messy. It's complicated. Despite their honesty with each other, there are still many secrets kept close to the chest. Feelings still get hurt even when it's unintentional. Relationships end just as new ones are beginning. Everything comes to a head and true motivations are revealed. And all of it feels so real. This is not a clear-cut romantic comedy, where everyone gets a happy resolution. Even the main characters lose something in favor of gaining something else. The emotional nature of this book hits you hard, and you're not sure who it is you want to root for until the very end.

Excellent read, especially if you're into something that has a bit more emotional depth than your average rom-com.

Thank you NetGalley and publisher for this audio.

I really enjoyed this book. I wasn’t sure in the beginning if I would like it but I did. Such a cute love story. The narrators did great!! Just the right amount of humor romance and spice!

I just… wow! I can’t believe it’s done, I feel like I want to go back and read it all again!

The Next Best Fling was sweet and is one of those books that makes you feel just a little bit different when you’re done. I could have read 10 epilogues.! I just want to keep seeing Theo and Marcela happy.

Both characters had a lot to work through before they got to that HEA. Abandonment issues, family resentment and unrequited love were all challenges for Theo and Marcela to overcome. I really appreciated that Gabriella Gamez didn’t make it easy for these two to come together and that the progression of their relationship felt natural. Bent but not broken is how I would describe them!

Theo was the best golden retriever MC and must be protected! He was thoughtful, honest, kind and didn’t hide his feelings from Marcela - if they were good or bad.

Marcela had a lot of history to work through and was a great example of how you have to keep putting the work in even when you think you’re ok. She was a fantastic FMC! The plus size perspective and representation was handled with care and I thought was very realistic. You can be confident and still have insecurities, but Marcela also didn’t dwell or fixate on the insecurities.

I’ll be recommending this to any romance reader and can’t wait to check out Gabriella’s next release!

Thank you to NetGalley, Forever (Grand Central) Publishing, and Gabriella Gamez for an early copy. These are my honest thoughts.

We all know how this story goes, but it doesn’t take any enjoyment away from reading the journey! The premise of this one is interesting— the two embark on a rebound fling because they are each in love with a half of a soon-to-be married couple.
Marcela has been in love with Ben for years after they dated, and he has kept her close. All this time, he has been dating Alice, who used to be close with Marcela. She keeps hoping that one day the two will end.
Theo is Ben’s brother and former NFL player, and in love with Alice. Has been since they were kids.
So this marriage hurts for both Theo and Marcela. But while the two embark on a fling, they find that what they have with each other is…a lot better.
I wouldn’t necessarily call it miscommunication, as the two did talk out their feelings quite a bit and Theo was actually more forthcoming about things than I expected. But Marcela has some insecurities about her weight and looks and also that he might try to go for Alice if she ever became available. Which fair enough. As a curvy Latina myself, and lover of books, I really related to this main character and it was wonderful to see her find a love that was perfect for her. Being strung along, especially for a decade, hurts and I completely understand where she was coming from. But honestly… Theo was the better catch anyway ;)

Thank you Forever and NetGalley for the e-galley!

This was cute! It wasn't crazy groundbreaking for me, so I wouldn't say it was fantastic but it was a solid, classic romance book. Characters were good, plot was fun. I wish there had been more librarian elements in it, which might just be me, but I find it so interesting. I would've liked to see more of that.

wow umm I am conflicted with the main character Marcela in the beginning she was not very likable the way she spoke about body images and ect did trigger me and then her catching feelings for a male character that is in a relationship is sort of ew. But after reading more and more I did fall in love with her character at first our girl Marcela was struggling finding solutions to certain things no spoilers but again (conflicted) then again putting yourself out there is not an easy solution to give to a mc. But again the character growth was spectacular.

now this is AN AMAZING DEBUT and the cover has been all over my socials and i am happy to say the BANTER, the smut was good, the crazy work environment while crazy and ALL over the place it is in some ways realistic, and lastly the ended was good to was it 100% how i wanted it to pan out for some characters no but i am happy with it. lastly i liked that the women involved were not too argumentative (regardless of the situation and at play)

overall good debut

Marcela has been quietly hoping for a second chance with Ben, even though he’s been with someone else for years.
Similarly, Theo has been secretly pining for Alice - his brother’s now fiancé - for even longer.
Ben and Alice have eyes only for each other - good thing for them, since they’re about to be married.

Less good for the broken hearted Marcela and Theo, but after stopping him from making a drunken declaration at the couple’s engagement party, she gains some clarity of her own.

When the general assumption is that Theo and Marcela hooked up, they decide it’s better to go with that than risk people realizing the truth of their feelings about Ben and Alice.
Leading to an old favorite trope - fake dating!

I like a book that grabs my attention from the start, and this one did! The fake dating being less entirely fake and more of a hot fling is nice too. It made me cheer harder for the relationship to turn real, even if there were rocky patches.
Overall I was interested in all the characters, which is great when the side characters are so important to the story. I can’t say I *loved* all of them because there was toxicity with Ben that gave me the ick (and frustrated me that he wasn’t called out for it each time) but they were all compelling in their own ways.
I did side eye Marcela for being a librarian who takes home bags of books without checking them out first (why??!!) And maybe I wish we had some of Theo’s POV? I was desperate to see inside his head at times.
The way things wrap up though? So satisfying! Loved it

Thanks to NetGalley and Forever for the ARC!

Okay omg this book..

It's hard for me to rate this because some of it was heavy on the internalized fatphobia and clear projection of her insecurities. I'm fat. I live it. I don't want to spend 300 pages inside the head of someone that's constantly worried about whether or not people will care about her weight.

On the other hand, soooo many romance books with fat leads written by fat authors read as like fan-fiction the author wrote about themselves (if that makes sense), AND THIS WAS NOT THAT!!!!! One example in particular that I can think of off the top of my head is Amy Award's The Cock Around the Block. It just sounded like she was fantasizing about what she wishes men would say to her to the point that it felt like the MMC was fetishizing the FMC's fatness. That sounds so mean, but it's just how I felt while reading it.

The Next Best Fling, though, felt much more realistic in terms of how a partner will look at one another in a HEALTHY relationship. Plus I just love me a big, sexy football player. I do wish we got to see more of him at his new job as a coach at the school, but the author would've had to put his POV in the book to make it happen, I think.