Member Reviews
After following Genoveva’s path to publication on social media I was so, so excited to finally dig into her Bulgarian-folklore inspired fantasy, and needless to say, it didn’t disappoint!
The story follows our remarkably well rounded MC Kosara as she takes and battles monsters, all who fall to her prowess besides one— the fabled Tsar of Monsters, and, unluckily, her ex. He’s hunting her, and her time is running out. After escaping to a city monsters can’t follow and teaming up with a well-meaning detective, she needs to decide who to trust and if she’s going to be the hunted… or the hunter.
I absolutely adored both the pacing and the characters in Foul Days. The story kept my interest the entire time and I truly didn’t see some of the twists coming. I loved how setting and atmosphere played such a fundamental part in the reading experience and how wonderfully wrought the aspects (especially the monsters) inspired by Bulgarian folklore were. It was a perfect mix of historically inspired and strikingly fantastical— the perfect set up for a brilliant fantasy.
I really loved both Kosara and Asen, it’s clear how much time and thought were put into making them fleshed out characters, both together and separately. Their romance was built very convincingly and I enjoyed how their secrets made up such a fundamental part of their dynamic. Couple that will a chilling and skin-crawling villain, and needless to say I was obsessed!
With her debut, Genoveva has definitely set a formidable start to her writing career! I’m delighted to see the sequel will be out very shortly, as I’m eager to learn of the story’s conclusion. Thanks so much TOR for the chance to read!
Young witch Kosara gambles away her magic during the worst time of year to not have magic- the foul days. While monsters run rampant, Kosara must race against the clock to get her magic back and save her city, if she can manage to confront her past traumas and abusive ex. Well paced and action packed from start to finish, this is a thoroughly enjoyable read inspired by folk tales and full of wit.
Foul Days was an unexpected treat. Packed full of monsters from Bulgarian and Balkan folklore, this novel takes place in the twin cities of Chernograd and Belograd, divided in half by a magical wall. In one city, people live ordinary, safe lives and in the other, the people live amongst monsters year round, but during the 'Foul Days' right after New Years, there are more monsters than ever. Kosara, a witch and our intrepid heroine, has lost her shadow and magical powers during the least safe time of year, Teaming up with a cop from the non-magical city of Belograd, she gets pulled into a mystery that is greater than her own problems. This is the first book in a series, so not everything is resolved by the end of the book. My one criticism is the Monster Guide at the end would work better at the beginning, as it is written as an 'in world' text and knowledge of the creatures in the book is necessary to enjoy the plot fully.
Thank you to Tor for the e-ARC!
I won't bore you lot with a lengthy review but all you need to know is it's pitched as if The Witcher was written by Naomi Novik which, even though I've read neither, I can say it's a fairly suitable pitch.
It has everything you want - a cool setting and flawed but over time loveable characters that you grow fond of despite them getting up to all sorts of shenanigans and not being the most moral people in the world. Kosara, the MC, is a grumpy black cat personified and Asen Bakharov, the police officer she's forced to team up with is your next book boyfriend.
I also enjoyed how the emphasis was more on Kosara growing as a character and the world around her changing and moving and her discovering things than the romance for example. She's flawed and brave and occasionally stupid but it makes you want to root for her even more. Asen is like a golden retriever in human form - he's incredibly loyal to those that help him and he proves to Kosara that trust can be good and can help and not always stab you in the back.
I loved, loved, LOVED the inclusion of various creatures from Slavic, and specifically Bulgarian, folklore. It was so cool to see some terms I know such as rusalkas and Zmey reminding me of Zmey Gorynich from Russian Fairy Tales but also learning about new creatures I hadn't heard of because they're not as popular or don't exist in Russian folklore/fairy tales.
I cannot wait for book two, this was absolutely amazing.
Reminiscent of Schwab's Shades of Magic series with the creature-mystery vibes of the X-Files, FOUL DAYS takes us through a fast-paced, magic-infused race against time to save one witch from the shadow that she will soon become. Kosara's banter is funny, and her demons are more than metaphorical. A little chaotic, and highly enjoyable.
I went into this one expecting it to be a fun monster-hunting romp. A palate-cleanser of sorts. It was that type of book in terms of the writing, which felt a little YA at times, and because it was quick and a little bit snarky. It also ended up being a much more substantial book than I anticipated, containing some pretty heavy themes. A huge focus of the book was the FMC's experience recovering from an abusive relationship, and ,in retrospect, I'm not sure how I missed that from the book's synopsis. The allegory is so blunt and in your face-- the entire book literally centers on the FMC taking her power back from her abuser-- but the topic was handled extremely well. The major characters were all very specific and well-developed humans (or in the abuser's case, an actual monster in human form), each dealing with and recovering from trauma. No token characters (or living tropes) to be found. I thought it was very well-done and a fantastic debut.
The book occurs over the course of 12 days, which made it very bingeable. There is ALOT that happens over the course of those days. A running joke throughout the novel is that the Witches Association has created this monster-hunting pamphlet to help everyone survive, but everyone is too lazy to read it. The pamphlet is included at the end of the book. I think I recommend reading that pamphlet before starting the book because it provided (at least for me) some spoiler-free and much needed monster-specific context that I felt was not fully fleshed out throughout the novel.
I saw someone else mention somewhere that they felt like this book is a perfect fit for people who enjoy YA but are outgrowing it. I definitely agree with that. Definitely check triggers, the author posted some to Goodreads. The book imho is definitely a bit dark.
Foul Days is a great beginning to anew series. It has elements of Shadow and Bone or the October Daye series, but is not li j e either story. The world-building is enriching but efficient and the rension between the characters is palpable.
This is a whimsical, fast-paced fantasy novel. This is the 1st book in the series (The Witch’s Compendium of Monsters). Kosara is a witch that lives in a magically confined city called Chernograd. She is forced to trade her powers to escape her ex, whom happens to be the Tsar of Monsters. The story is a race against time to get them back. She will also face some hard truths and will be forced to face many fears. There is even a “Monster Pamphlet,” at the end of the book (this town literally makes them for the citizens). An enjoyable read overall, I will definitely be reading the next book :)
This breathtaking fantasy begins with a high-stakes card game, and by the end of it I was all in. The pacing is shockingly good. It’s always fast, yet it’s never rushed. I’m not sure how Dimova pulled that off, except ‘with extraordinary aplomb.’
Kosara is a compelling, sly, spiky, sympathetic witch, full of flaws and passions, hurts and hopes. She’s brave and clever==and just terribly, constantly outgunned! She’s such a compelling protagonist that of course she needs an equally-compelling foil. And damn, does she get one. The Zmey is proper monstrous. He’s more terrifying that the upirs, rusalkas, and kikimoras roaming the streets—and they’re all terrifying, particularly during the Foul Days …
The side characters are wonderful. Ruksana is great, and Asen is extremely well-drawn, as is his relationship with Kosara.
This is easily a five-star fantasy novel, and that would be true even without the world building. But holy Lamia the world building! It's brilliant. The magic is chef’s kiss, visceral and commanding. The city within a city is a character in itself. There’s a beautiful depth of culture that shines through every page.
Highly, highly recommended.
This was not the kind if fantasy book I was expecting or necessarily wanting to read. This is very much a case where my expectations did not match the book. I wanted an escapist read and found this version of the world way to similar to our own. This book is compared to the Witcher series but I frankly did not understand the comparison.
I requested this one because it might be an upcoming title I would like to review on my Youtube Channel. However, after reading the first several chapters I have determined that this book does not suit my tastes. So I decided to DNF this one.
In this captivating read, the author masterfully weaves a narrative that is both engaging and thought-provoking. Through a blend of richly developed characters and a meticulously crafted plot, the book offers a unique exploration of its central themes, inviting readers to immerse themselves in the story's depth and complexity. The narrative is paced perfectly, balancing moments of intense action with thoughtful reflection, ensuring that readers are hooked from the first page to the last. The author's ability to evoke emotion and create a vivid, immersive world is truly remarkable, making this book a must-read for anyone looking for an exceptional literary experience.
Beyond its compelling storyline, the book stands out for its insightful commentary on the human condition, weaving philosophical questions into the fabric of its narrative. The author's skillful use of language not only enriches the text but also elevates the reader's experience, offering new perspectives on familiar themes. Whether it's the intricate dynamics of relationships, the exploration of identity, or the confrontation with ethical dilemmas, this book tackles complex issues with sensitivity and intelligence. It's a testament to the power of storytelling to illuminate the nuances of life, making it a valuable addition to any book lover's collection. Regardless of genre, this is a work that resonates on multiple levels, affirming the enduring impact of well-crafted literature.
The premise completely grabbed me. Chapter 1 opens so strongly. But then it falls flat, with world-building and exposition dumps, which continue on into chapter 2 (I stopped partway through at 5%). I think this will be a solid three to four stars with five for the right readers.
Thank you to NetGalley and Tor for the ARC.
This book was fun - a good choice for a beach or plane read.
The protagonist is a witch living in a city that is an enclave within a bigger city. The bigger city constructed the wall surrounding the smaller one to contain monsters, and those who were within the enclave now have to just live with the monsters as the wall cannot be crossed easily. A visitor from the outside world persuades her to give him her shadow in exchange for passage, which she agrees to because her ex (the “Tsar of Monsters”) is hunting her. But having no shadow means she has no power, and is going to become a wraith. Recognizing that she was coerced, she seeks to reclaim her shadow, accompanied by a police officer of the outer city.
The blurb said it was for fans of Naomi Novik and the Witcher - Novik because of the Slavic inspiration, and the Witcher because of all the monsters running around. I’d throw in a comparison to China Miéville’s *The City and the City*, for obvious reasons to anyone who’s read that one.
But I call it a beach read because it was fun, but not a book I’m going to be thinking about when my mind wanders. It felt like the author couldn’t quite decide if she wanted to make it a modern urban fantasy or something more Medieval/Renaissance-ish, and ended up sort of splitting the difference in a way that kind of gave me expectations-whiplash. The dialogue felt stilted, at times, and the characters weren’t as developed as they could have been (a LOT of things happened because the protagonist and/or the cop picked up the idiot ball).
The best done parts were the parts with the “Tsar of Monsters.” Not only was he a good and interesting antagonist, but the author did a *great* job of writing about the difficulties of escaping an abusive relationship when your abuser is a literal monster. It was well done enough that I find myself hoping that Dimova wasn’t writing from experience too much, and if she was, good for her for escaping.
Thank you Netgalley, Genoveva Dimova, and Tor Publishing Group/Tor Books for the eARC!
A solid debut. Definite The Witcher vibes--it's fast-paced, solidly written, and absolutely jam-packed with monsters crawling from every corner. I really enjoyed this. Also pleased to hear that the series will be coming sooner rather than later, because this series will be very binge-able for people. My biggest gripe with this book was the lack of emotion. I can't really pinpoint why--maybe the prose? While flashy, dark, and humorous, I didn't connect with any sort of deep-level emotion. I felt it was laid out to me, instead of actually experiencing it myself. That's nitpicky, however, and I thought this was a fantastic start to a promising duology.
I am not always into witch books, but the Slavic folklore aspect to it made be intrigued. This was fast-paced are very atmospheric. I really enjoyed it. Please read if you enjoy books like The Bear and the Nightingale.
This book ended me. I am flat on my back, no thoughts, just monsters and witches and magic and all the delightful, twisty shenanigans that Genoveva Dimova threw at me. FOUL DAYS is my favorite type of fantasy--it's clever and funny and dark in equal measure, breathlessly ambitious and gorgeously atmospheric. It was a delight to navigate the 12 Foul Days with Kosara and I cannot wait to follow this series wherever it goes next.
Five million stars from me.
Sadly this one didn't work for me. It was a lot of telling and very little showing. We are always being told exactly what the narrator is feeling and why, which made her sound very flat and uninteresting. I think overall this novel just lacked complexity for me. I don't want to be told everything, I want to work to figure out the characters and the world, and that was not the case here unfortunately.
I received an ARC of this book free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
I was so excited to be able to read Foul Days early! The Witcher written by Naomi Novik is 100% spot on as a pitch, and it fully lived up to that lofty promise. An unputdownable, confident debut brimming with character, heart, humor, magic -- and, of course, monsters. So. Many. Monsters.
Dimova's knowledge of Bulgarian/Slavic folklore injects the world with vibrancy and depth, creating a setting that feels both fresh and deeply lived-in. Drawing on historical parallels, the walled cities of Chernograd and Belograd are alive enough to be their own characters here.
And 23-year-old Kosara is a fantastic protagonist who's easy to root for--fiercely independent, pragmatic, and nursing deep hurts behind her prickly, witchy armor--up against a truly chilling villain.
Foul Days is a knockout debut and a hell of a way to start a trilogy, and I can't wait to continue Kosara's story.
My thanks to NetGalley for making an eARC of this book available to me.
Great descriptions of Slavic folklore based monsters. The main characters are quite engaging and the plot easily complex enough to keep us well interested. Expect this book to be featured in 2024's awards nominations. And on top of that, we also get a sequel just a few months after the publication of this book!
Kosara is a witch who lives in the walled city of Chernograd where it's the Foul Days. A brief period of time during the year when all types of monsters invade the city and people do their best to stay alive. Unfortunately for Kosara she just lost her shadow, the source of all her power on a bet. To make it worse The Zmey (Tsar of all monsters) is after her. She defied him by leaving and he wants her back. Her only escape is to get over the wall to Belograd, where monsters including The Zmey can’t follow. When she is there she discovers she has been tricked by someone close to her and the shadow sickness is upon her. She has to come back to Chernograd and face The Zmey if she wants to live past the Foul Days. She gets assistance from a suspiciously kind Belograd police officer who is investigating a suspicious death that is linked to the wall. This book was fast paced with the world building happening naturally throughout the story. Kosara is a great character both fierce and vulnerable. I also enjoyed the slow burn friendship/relationship that started developing between Kosara and Asen. I can't wait for the next book in this series. Thank you #NetGalley for my arc. #fouldays