Member Reviews

The use of color to convey emotions and changes was very well done. This is a quick read that will catch many graphic novel readers' eyes.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the relationship between Mei Ying and her Nai Nai, the fear that you won't be able to connect because of a language barrier but having the grandparent love you all the same was really heartwarming.

Was this review helpful?

A more subtle exploration of culture and identity than we often see for this age group. There's a lot of subtle racism and bullying, the insidious sort that is difficult to get help for. The plot and art are both loose and meandering, so not a thrilling read but an interesting one.

Was this review helpful?

FAKE CHINESE SOUNDS introduces readers to Mei Ying, a Taiwanese American girl who loves soccer and hanging with her best friend. During the summer before fifth grade, Mei Ying’s grandmother comes to visit from Taiwan for the first time. While there is a language barrier between the two, they find ways to connect and bond, including cooking and practicing tai chi together. This leads Mei Ying to a much deeper understanding of her heritage and an increased awareness of the microaggressions she experiences. Her discomfort persists, especially when school starts, and she is the target of bullying by another student.

I especially liked the relationship between Mei Ying and her grandmother. The growth that Mei Ying experiences from their relationship serves as the catalyst for the story’s resolution. Themes of family, community, and culture make this graphic novel an engaging and heartfelt read.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an eARC to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

Mei Ying is excited to be starting fifth grade with her friend and fellow Soccer Diva Kirra. After her grandmother comes from Taiwain for a short visit, Mei Ying is more interested in cooking with her mother and Tai Chi. A new kid in school, Sid, makes fun of Mei Ying. She waits to see if anyone else notices the slight jabs he makes at her food, her name, he volunteering in class, and even her Chinese (which he has overheard her family speaking in the park) Mei Ying tries to approach the teacher, who brushes it off. Finally Mei Ying speaks out and she is surprised by the results. Based in part on the author's own experiences growing up.

Was this review helpful?

I just finished reading this super cute middle grade graphic novel called "Měi Yīng" and it’s totally worth checking out. It’s all about a Taiwanese American girl named Měi Yīng who's going into 5th grade.

The first half of the book is set in the summer before 5th grade, and Měi Yīng's Năi Nai comes to visit for the first time. Even though there’s a language barrier, they bond in the sweetest way. In the second half, Năi Nai goes back to Taiwan and Měi Yīng starts 5th grade, where she faces bullying and lots of racist microaggressions. It’s pretty real and relatable.

There’s also soccer, and Měi Yīng goes to Mandarin Chinese school, which adds another cool layer to her story. This book is such a great slice-of-life read that really captures what it's like to be a Taiwanese American kid dealing with all the ups and downs of growing up.

If you’re looking for a heartfelt and relatable graphic novel, definitely give "Měi Yīng" a read!

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful story about a young first generation Asian American girl finding her place in-between her 2 worlds. The use of her grandmother's visit to help inspire her interest in her culture as well as the story of friendship and accepting/understanding others is a beautiful highlight in this book as well.

Was this review helpful?

A graphic novel about a young girl dealing with changing friendship, inter-generational family, bullying and how to discover one's authentic self. Mei Ying has got her life together. She's got a best friend, a loving mother and is the star of her soccer team. Things get interesting when her grandma, who only speaks Mandarin, comes for a visit and finds it difficult to communicate. But things really get thrown off when the new kid at school, Sid, decides to make her the butt of all his "jokes". Mei Ying must learn to speak up and speak out when those around her don't.

A perfect book to teach students about the impact of their "it was just a joke", and how our choices affect others.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this graphic novel! It was a great window into the main character's culture and the challenges of navigating growing up. We watch her navigate a bully, work through tough moments with friends, learn more about her culture, and experience her sharing that with others. There are also wonderful intergenerational connections and role models throughout the book. I think the look at different aspects of racism and microagressions was well done and it gave me an opportunity to talk through those with my own child. We got to see the impact on the main character and the impact it had when others were silent. The story also features repair between the protagonist's friends and ultimately the bully. This is a great story and I highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

The story of Mei Ying (a Taiwanese American middle schooler) is told in the beautifully illustrated graphic novel Fake Chinese Sounds. In this graphic novel, there is a powerful dialogue that, along with the illustrations, illustrates the obstacles that different generations encounter in America. I enjoyed the message that was provided. I wish more schools held ethnic fairs. As a result, children have the opportunity to become more familiar with other cultures, their food, music, clothing, etc. in a fun and respectful manner.

Was this review helpful?

Fake Chinese sounds was an interesting graphic novel. I loved the interplay of generations trying to connect over language.

Was this review helpful?

I am absolutely LOVING the trend of second generation kids writing graphic memoirs. The discussion of identity, community, culture, questioning where you belong in the world is so universal for so many of us that it will always need to be spoken.

Was this review helpful?

Interesting story, but the narrative was all over the place and I didn't really like any of the characters much. Not as strong as similar titles like Alterations or Uprooted.

Was this review helpful?

FAKE CHINESE SOUNDS (written and illustrated by Jing Jing Tsong, published by Kokila) is a middle-grade graphic novel about Mei Ying (nicknamed Spark for her seemingly endless energy), a nearly fifth-grade Taiwanese American girl who juggles her busy soccer practices, Chinese school, and spending time with her Nai Nai, her grandmother who is visiting from Taiwan. Mei Ying learns a lot from Nai Nai: Mandarin words for the delicious Taiwanese food Nai Nai cooks, tai chi, the fascinating history of the Taiwanese dialect (it was against the law to speak it in public when Nai Nai was growing up!), and most importantly, the importance of “inner strength”. By the end of the summer when Nai Nai returns to Taiwan, Mei Ying has learned so much about her heritage that she decides she wants to be called by her full name, “Mei Ying” from then on. But when school resumes, Mei Ying faces daily microaggressions and blatant racism from her classmates. Will Mei Ying be able to call upon her inner strength that Nai Nai and Mom have taught her to navigate through all of this? But what DOES “inner strength” even mean here? Quietly tolerating all the “fake Chinese sounds” she is constantly taunted with or fighting back by speaking up?

This book, is just, WOW. So poignant, so relatable, and SO important. Mei Ying’s navigation with racism and microaggressions, and her identity as a child of an immigrant resonates deeply. There is simply not enough space here in the captions to express how much I appreciate this book, and how much EVERYONE including educators, needs to read it.

Even though this book mostly served as a mirror for me, I also learned things I didn’t know before, like the differences between the Taiwanese dialect and Mandarin Chinese. The Chinese language is incredibly diverse with many, many dialects— something for all of us to know remember!

Was this review helpful?

Part 1 — Did You Eat Yet?

This is a very important question, and I love how it’s basically a show of endearment.

Měi Yīng’s grandmother, Năi Nai, is visiting from Taiwan. Although Měi Yīng’s Mandarin isn’t the best and Năi Nai doesn’t speak English, they find other ways to connect, like cooking guōtiē together and doing tai chi in the mornings. It was really sweet to see them bond.

Part 2 — Fake Chinese Sounds

Měi Yīng is excited to start fifth grade, but she starts getting bullied by the new kid Sid. Her best friend, Kirra, says to ignore him, but Měi Yīng doesn’t think that will put a stop to his racist jokes. This starts to affect her attention in class, her friendship, as well as soccer, where she was once the Spark of the team.

Part 3 — A Little Bit of Heart

I love that her school does International Week, where each student brings in food or shares something with the class about their family’s heritage. Měi Yīng, with her mother’s help and Năi Nai’s recipe, makes diǎn xin (dim sum) for the class. I loved how this was a special way to get to know everyone, and embrace everyone’s differences too. We also get to understand Sid a little more, and see his side to the decisions he made.

Overall, I really enjoyed this graphic novel. The story touches on very important and relevant themes, and I found myself rooting for the main character. The key message is how to stand up for yourself, while also showing an adolescent learning to be confortable in her own skin.

The art style wasn’t my favorite, but I think it fit the story really well. I really appreciated how each section had its own color scheme. Part 1 was yellow, part 2 was red, then part 3 was orange. I’d like to think that part 3 is where the two other parts of Měi Yīng’s story — her family and Taiwanese heritage, and her soccer and school life — merged, hence the creation of a new color. The random watercolor pages were my favorite because of how vibrant and colorful they were.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed Mei Ying’s story and the integration of Chinese into the dialog. It felt like I was learning while reading.

Mei Ying struggles a bit when she starts middle school and she’s seemingly the only Chinese kid. At first she is bullied and embarrassed by her family and culture, but grows to love what makes her “different.”

I think this is definitely an idealistic story, with the bully becoming Mei Ying’s friend at the end, but it is so important that kids read stories that reflect what they might be going through and give them hope for a better experience. I wish I had stories like these when I was younger!

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely love this. It's nice, leaves you feeling good, and really speaks to the second-gen American experience.

Was this review helpful?

Fake Chinese Sounds is a very well-crafted graphic novel with an excellently written coming-of-age story. I very much enjoyed the art and the writing style.

Was this review helpful?

When I started reading this book and read that Mei Ying's grandmother was coming to visit from Taiwan and Mei Ying didn't speak much Chinese and her grandmother didn't speak English, I thought it was going to be just another book about the two generations failing to understand each other, but eventually coming to a happy ending. Because there are plenty of those stories.
So, I was very happily surprised to see that Jing Jing Tsong chose NOT to use this trope for her story. Instead Mei Ying instantly hits it off with her grandmother and is open to learning cooking and tai chi. Mei Ying is a tough cookie and she tackles challenges in her life thoughtfully for the most part. And when she screws up, she owns her mistakes. The story twists and turns and continues busting stereotypes in a way that should appeal to many young readers. Also, it is one of those books that will make you hungry.
The format is great and will appeal to even the most reluctant readers, so that is a big plus.

Thank you to NetGalley for an advance copy of this book. There are kids out there who are really going to appreciate it!

Was this review helpful?

Mei Ying is on a mission to learn Mandarin so she can chat with her grandma, who's not big on English. Grandma's coming to visit, but Mei's soccer buddy Kirra is all hyped up about hitting the fair and doing all sorts of stuff. Thing is, Mei's got some hurdles.

At first, Mei struggles to understand her grandma, but then she starts picking up all kinds of cool things from her, like nailing a dish just right. But then, Mei notices some seriously uncool stuff going down—racist comments when Grandma speaks Mandarin, and some shady vibes while shopping for school threads. It's like she's suddenly seeing the world through a different lens.

And then, middle school rolls around, and Sid and his crew start throwing shade at Mei, while Kirra just stands there. No backup from anyone, so Mei's gotta fend for herself and finally lets loose.

I dug this book 'cause it gives us both sides of the story—the one getting bullied and the one doing the bullying. We get why Sid acts the way he does, and we see how Mei handles it all, including her so-called bestie not having her back. There's only so much crap one person can take, right?

I reckon this story speaks to any kid who's been on the receiving end of bullying, whether it's about their grub, their looks, or their background.

Big shoutout to Netgalley for hooking me up with this read for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?