Member Reviews

Loved this book! Honestly I love absolutely everything I read by Kristin Hannah! This book was heartbreaking! It made me feel absolutely everything! The MC was so strong and never gave up through every challenge, heartbreak and defeat she faced. Thank you NetGalley for this Arc

Was this review helpful?

The Women by Kristin Hannah
A phenomenal novel!!! The best book I have ever read about Viet Nam. Read to learn the roles of and the effects on the women vets during this historic war. It is only January, and I can already say this is going to be on my list of the best novels published in 2024. A definite 5-star read! P.S. I also wore a POW/MIA bracelet with a brave soldier's name as a middle school student learning about the war in real time.

Was this review helpful?

What an absolutely remarkable book!

Heart-breaking. Heart-wrenching!
Full of Love, Fear, Trauma, War, Family, Friendships, Terror, Rage, Lies…and so much more…

Frankie McGrath (Frances) is a young woman in nursing school. Her brother enlists in the Navy, and she decides to join up herself when one of his friends suggests that women can be heroes too!

She’s at his going away party, when she hears this…and it sparks something in her. Something she never knew was there!

BUT…Women are not in Vietnam…or so she is told, over and over. Even after she served TWO tours there!

This story tells about the grueling experiences of the soldiers, and of the medical people, Doctors and Nurses, who helped them through it…sometimes getting them home, and sometimes just holding their hand when nothing else can be done.

I cannot even tell you how many times I just broke down, SOBBING, while reading this. It is THAT realistic. It is that emotional. It is that gripping of a story…

Ms. Hannah, all I can say is that you’ve absolutely done it again! This is a true treasure. This one is pure gold…

I was just a child when this war was fought… but my older brother was drafted. Thank God, his number was never called. The war ended just before he was called up to serve…but I clearly remember so much of this. The bracelets sold at school. Saying prayers for those who were MIA, POW or KIA.

But, hearing firsthand of the stark reality that these men and women went through there, and when returning home, that was really tough for me. I can only IMAGINE what it must’ve been like for each of them.

Thank you for sharing this story with the world. It will be long remembered by me!

Thank you to #NetGalley and #MacmillanAudio for an ARC of the audiobook which is due to be released next month, on February 6th.

#TheWomen by #KristinHannah and beautifully narrated by one of my absolute faves, #JuliaWhelan.

5+ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 for me!

Check out all my upcoming reviews and PRE-views on Goodreads, IG @ #BookReviews_with_emsr or my new FB Book Club #BookReviewsWithElaine.

Happy Reading! 📚📖

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Kristin Hannah (author), Julia Whelan (narrator), Macmillan Audio, and Netgalley for this free advanced reader/listener copy of "The Women: A Novel" for an honest review.

After years of hearing about Hannah's work and watching two or three different titles circulate widely as popular and well-reviewed/awarded over the last few years, I decided to take the plunge with this one as my first and was not disappointed at all. This novel is a harrowing, unflinching look at how women's service and work were erased from the ledger of the Vietnam War and how one woman went about refinding herself and her voice.

This book is as beautifully written as it was heartbreaking to read. I absolutely felt for all the characters, and what they went through, for the different people in different generations wrestling with different ways they were raised or acted. I thought it portrayed so well how much truly was changing so fast in America at that time. I absolutely think this book should be read by everyone, and I'll be giving out copies as gifts to close friends next year.

Was this review helpful?

Oh. My. Heart. So many emotions reading this book—happy, sad, frustrated, disappointment, angry, angst, anxious—seriously, all the feels. What an incredible story and way to bring these unsung heroes of the Vietnam War to the forefront of a new generation. The author makes several recommendations for other reads in this genre during the Author’s Notes.

Frankie forever has my heart, respect, and admiration.

I listened to the audiobook and was so excited that my favorite voice actor did this novel. Julia Whelan is the GOAT!

Highly recommend this book, particularly in audiobook format, too.

Was this review helpful?

There will be so many amazing reviews for Kristin Hannah’s latest epic story of the women during the Vietnam war, and I’m adding my praise as well. Hannah is probably the best storyteller of historical fiction we have today and the depth of her characters has us remember them long after the pages have ended. “The Women” is a love letter to the 10,000+ women who served “in country” during a tumultuous time, their service often forgotten or disparaged within months of their return to the United States

We have a main protagonist, Frankie, a 21 year old whose cruel father tells his country club buddies that she’s “studying abroad” in Florence, but who is continually supported by her best friends and fellow war nurses Ethel and Barb through grief, terror, heartbreak, PTSD, addiction, and recovery. As awful as the scenes in Vietnam are, the second half of the novel, Frankie’s homecoming, is as gut-wrenching as the first part.

This excellent story is tempting to put down at times in order to take deep breaths. Julia Whelan, the audiobook narrator, will keep you going when it seems too hard to read. Whelan gives so much life and emotion to Frankie — you get so invested in wanting things to be better for the main character. Without a doubt, 5 stars for the novel and amazing narration. “The Women” will undoubtedly be at the top of all the best books of 2024 lists.

Literary Pet Peeve Checklist:
Green Eyes (only 2% of the real world, yet it seems like 90% of all fictional females): YES Henry has green eyes.
Horticultural Faux Pas (plants out of season or growing zones, like daffodils in autumn or bougainvillea in Alaska): NO The flowers of Kauai and Coronado are deep contrasts to the jungles of Vietnam.

Thank you to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for a free advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for an early release copy to read. I read this book in 2 days, I couldn’t do anything but read it. I love historical fiction, and women in the military during the Vietnam War I knew little to nothing about.
The story captivated me from the beginning. It was very well written, researched and told. It’s right up there with The Nightengale. This is my first 5 star read in a long time.

Was this review helpful?

Easily 5 stars. I was grateful to receive an audiobook and it was done beautifully. A heartwrenching story about the women in the Vietnam War. It will be hard to find someone who doesn't love this book. Thank you Kristin Hannah, for the obvious amount of time, research and emotion you put into this story. It needed to be told.

Was this review helpful?

The Women by Kristin Hannah is an incredible story of the brave women of the Vietnam War. This historical fiction describes the challenges of the era through the perspective of a nurse in the war. We follow the journey from the time she is at war to the struggles she faces as she rebuilds her life after returning. It is well written and captivating. Makes you want to know what happens next and makes you think about the struggles of this point in history.

Kristin Hannah is able to takes us through a great journey through history and takes us back to that time of the Vietnam war through an often untold perspective. This story is informative yet emotional. It is historical, yet also a story about love. Highly engaging and recommended read for anyone.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so unbelievably good. I am still reeling almost a week later. I can’t get my head straight. Easily the best Kristin Hannah book I have read, and the best historical fiction book I’ve read in a long, long time. Hannah has outdone herself, and I’m glad she took her time with this book and made it the best it could possibly be.

The Women is a historical fiction book about a young woman, Frankie McGrath, who signs up to be a nurse in Vietnam, without knowing the full scope of what her life would be like once in country. This is the story of her war experience, and also follows her as she returns home to a nation that is hostile towards not only Vietnam veterans, but in denial that women were even there.

I loved everything about this book. It’s historical importance, the characters, the rawness and naked truths that it deals with, and the ending 🫶🏼 which I was more than pleased with.

The audio, read by the great Julia Whelan, is excellent and I highly recommend it.

This would make a great book club pick, and I couldn’t stop thinking about how good this would be for helping to engage students learning about the Vietnam War in my history class! 👏🏻👏🏻 Thank you @kristinhannahauthor for this masterpiece.

Thank you @netgalley and @macmillan.audio for the early release copy 💕

Look 👀 for this amazing book on February 6th. I’ll be the woman in line buying 20 copies.

Was this review helpful?

I am not a fan of pop fiction, so take this review accordingly.

I ask myself, who am I to criticize a successful author? As a librarian and former bookseller, I know Hannah is extremely popular with female readers, a fact that puts me off reading her books in the first place. I have read only one other, The Nightingale, and thought it was average. For a break from the current flood of WWII women’s fiction, I thought I’d give this a try. I commend the author for putting so much research into this important topic. However, the work as a whole is trite, predictable, and melodramatic. Poor Frankie endured every conceivable experience and aftermath of war. I am reviewing the audio version, and couldn’t wait to be finished. The narrator was good with the women’s voices, but listening to the men was painful.

Was this review helpful?

In the pages of this thought-provoking novel, readers are taken on a poignant journey through the lens of a woman navigating the complexities of life's inherent unfairness. The author's writing is not merely a narrative; it's an immersive experience that intricately weaves together the threads of injustice, resilience, and the relentless fight for what is rightfully deserved.

The detailed prose paints a vivid picture, enveloping readers in the protagonist's world. From the highs to the lows, the author captures the essence of the woman's struggle, making it palpable and relatable. The immersive storytelling allows readers to feel the intensity of her battles and the weight of societal challenges.

Yet, as the narrative unfolds, the sudden shift in the main character's mindset towards the conclusion adds a layer of complexity. The desire for more exploration into her brighter days becomes a lingering thought, a yearning for a deeper understanding of her transformation. The nuanced portrayal of the protagonist's journey creates a sense of empathy, leaving readers contemplating the broader implications of gender-based challenges.

The strength of the book lies not only in its exploration of the harsh realities faced by women but also in its ability to prompt reflection on the resilience required to overcome such adversity. The narrative serves as a mirror, forcing readers to confront the societal norms that perpetuate inequality and the unwavering determination needed to challenge them.

In conclusion, this well-written and detailed novel is a compelling exploration of the struggles faced by women, offering readers a profound reflection on the intricacies of life's inherent unfairness. While the sudden shift in the main character's mindset might leave some wanting more of her good days, the overall impact of the narrative lingers, provoking deeper contemplation on the fight for justice and equality.

Was this review helpful?

Hannah has a way of carrying us into unknown territory of very well known historic events.

Most women in war stories I’ve read revolve around WWI and WWII and more recently, the Outlander series gives us our fictional heroine,Claire, who is a nurse throughout history.

When I think of the Vietnam War, I think of music and hippies, a lose-lose war, flowers and Forrest. At the forefront of The Women is Frankie, a young, high society girl who decides to make her family proud and serve her country. Her experiences there are not unique to what one would expect knowing anything about war but it’s after the war that brings the most unexpected tune. At least for Frankie.

I was shocked and devastated throughout this novel, not so much at things we didn’t know how to diagnose at the time but the complete, absolute denial of what women saw and experienced vs what men in combat saw and experienced. I wasn’t prepared for her post war spiral experience but I can’t imagine it going any other way with the severe lack of support in all directions. An isolating and painful read.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah can draw character like nobody else. Her latest novel, The Women, tells the story of Frances “Frankie” McGrath, a young woman from an upper middle class family that follows her brother to Vietnam, serving as an army nurse. Frankie is a character that will stay with me long after I read dozens of other novels, and this experience is made even more memorable by the talented Julia Whelan, the voice actor that narrates the audio version. My thanks go to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and Macmillan Audio for the review copies. It will be available to the public February 6, 2024.

Frankie is twenty years old when we meet her, and her family is throwing a party for her big brother and best friend, Finley, who is leaving to serve in the U.S. Navy. Kennedy is in the White House, and most Americans still bear an implicit trust in their government. But Frankie is worried about Fin, and doesn’t like that he is about to put himself in harm’s way. He reassures her, “It isn’t dangerous, Frankie. Trust me. I’m a Naval Academy graduate, an officer with a cushy assignment on a ship. I’ll be back in no time. You’ll hardly have time to miss me.”

Frankie completes her nurse’s training, then signs on to join her brother, but before she is even packed, the telegram arrives. Finley is dead; killed in action.

The plot itself is unremarkable. Yes, war is hell; yes, friends die. And yes, a married man that sees an attractive, vulnerable American woman in a place where they are scarce, will lie like a rug in order to get close to her. But in Hannah’s hands, every joy and every sorrow are real and visceral, because we believe.

Frankie serves as a combat nurse at the front, and works in every possible hard situation. Sometimes the lights go out during surgery because a bomb has fallen; at one point her sleeping quarters is bombed and has to be rebuilt. She works for days on end without sleep when it’s necessary. And the trauma follows her home.

My only quibble with this otherwise outstanding story is the emphasis Hannah places on the abuse of returning troops by the public. She brings in the old saw about them being spat upon and called baby killers, even though an easy search confirms what I remember: this is mostly myth. Just as women weren’t really burning bras, most troops were not greeted with abuse. It’s true that the wildly patriotic parades that greeted the troops that returned from World War Two are not there for these men and women, but then, the Korean War vets didn’t see them, either. Historical fiction should honor history, not rewrite it.

With this caveat, I recommend this book to you. Do read it; it’s a damn fine novel. But do so critically, because you can’t always believe everything you read.

Was this review helpful?

I always love a book where the author narrates. This is no exception. Then, in addition to an author narration, you also have Julia Whelan! Chef’s kiss. This novel is right up there with my all time favourite Kristin Hannah book, The Nightingale. The story of Frankie’s, Ethel’s, and Barb’s experiences in Vietnam serve to shatter the falsified narrative that there “were no women in Vietnam”. Further to this, Hannah examines the impact of trauma on the body, mind, and spirit as Frankie returns home to a world she does not recognize. One that does not fully see her, either. It also celebrate, as so many of Hannah’s books do, the important roles that female friendship play in uplifting and healing. I highly recommend listening or reading (or both) to this excellent piece of historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

Kristin Hannah has done it again with The Women; it is a fabulous read with plenty of twists to keep the reader engaged while accurately reflecting history, women’s roles in Vietnam and the soldier’s experience of returning home. The impact of death, familial relationships, PTSD, and the lack of awareness of women in Vietnam are all addressed. I particularly appreciated how PTSD was represented and managed throughout the book as well as mental health care. I feel like this book addressed the Vietnam War and women in a very different way than other books written about these issues.
Narration for the audiobook is wonderful too. Well done!

Was this review helpful?

This extraordinarily fantastic new novel from Kristin Hannah shares the moving and little known history of the women who risked their lives and served as front line nurses in the Vietnam War. Julia Whalen narrates with perfection, and her resonant voices for different characters sweep you along into the lives of brave women fighting to save lives and then coming home to be vilified for being part of an unpopular war and deeply damaged by what they experienced among the gore of the thousands of wounded and dead.

Frances “Frankie” McGrath, volunteers as an army nurse in the Vietnam War during the late 1960’s, idealistic about serving her country to fight off communism as well as earn to her place on her father’s “Hero’s Wall” of men in their family who fought for America across its various wars. Frankie’s a “good girl” secluded and educated in Catholic girl schools, who’s had no exposure to life outside her rarified, privileged social circle on the southern California coast. But after her only, fun-loving, rambunctious older brother Finley gets shot down shortly after getting deployed to Vietnam, Frankie considers taking her nursing training and putting it to use in the war. At age 19 and with little experience, only the Army will enlist Frankie, who joins and then has to contend with the horror of her wealthy parents at what’s she done.

Frankie literally gets air-dropped into a run-down, poorly staffed, rat-infested, moldy war hospital where endless waves of severely wounded and dying soldiers arrive by helicopters. Frankie’s shell-shocked, but a quick learner. She survives thanks to the fierce support and close friendship of two fellow nurses as well as being taken under the wing of a surgeon who teaches Frankie how to be an exceptional surgical nurse. Frankie re-ups for a second year and moves further into the jungle and the front lines. There are romantic entanglements, the dangers of men far away from home looking for sexual flings, boozy officer parties and spontaneous getaways, and the oppressive heat and unrelenting deaths to contend with in the hospitals.

The second part of the novel focuses on Frankie’s return to America, the hostility to Vets by a hippy, peace movement condemning both the war and those served in it. The Vet services don’t recognize or try to serve the PTSD of women who served, and Frankie descends into despair and drug use. It’s so powerful, so poignant and so moving that when Frankie finally gets to touch the Vietnam Vet memorial put up decades after the war in D.C, you’re misting up alongside her.

Like all of Kristen Hannah’s novels, you get immersed in a slice of history you know little about and come away profoundly moved. She’s created such a tribute to women who did not fet the national recognition and thanks they deserved.


Thanks to Macmillon Audio for an advanced listen of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to author Kristin Hannah, Netgalley, and Macmillan Audio for this advanced reader copy of The Women (audio) in exchange for my honest opinion.

We often hear stories of the soldiers of Vietnam, brave boys and men who were drafted or joined to support their country in wartime. We also hear how they were mistreated upon return to the States, spat at and yelled at, disrespected, and ridiculed. We hear about the PTSD and hardships they faced upon returning as well, the repercussions of a Government that failed them. And yes, this is all horrible and horrifying. But we never, ever hear about the women who were there, in combat, healing and repairing soldiers, being their confidants as they lay near death. We don't hear how they were in harm's way day after day to aid these soldiers. Listening to this historical novel on the subject was emotional and heartbreaking and made me so mad in so many ways. I want to thank Kristin Hannah for shedding light on these women, the Vietnam Veterans that are so sorely overlooked.

This book is about a young girl who believes, thanks to the words of her brother's friend Rye, that she, too, can be a hero on her father's wall of heroes, family members who had been to war. Her brother Finley was just killed in Vietnam, and being a new nurse she wants to go over there and make her mark, make a difference in the world. After enlisting in the Army her father can't stand to look at her, her mother is distraught but supportive. So starts the story of Frankie, as she embarks on a journey beyond her wildest dreams - and nightmares. She wasn't prepared at all to see the soldiers coming before her with limbs missing, and gaping wounds in chests and abdomens. She wasn't prepared to close these wounds or perform a tracheotomy, but she learned and became one of the best combat nurses in Vietnam. She also learned a thing or two about being a woman in war: don't trust the men who tell you lies. She meets many men in Vietnam, but two steal her heart, two men who are already spoken for. Once returning to the States after two tours, she finds herself in the throws of trying to find her place in life after all the death and turmoil she witnessed and endured. This story takes you along with Frankie as she rides the roller coaster of mental health illnesses and heartbreaking realizations about her loved ones.

Read this story with a box of tissues nearby. It's an emotional roller coaster, but it doesn't relent, you are sucked in immediately and won't want to stop reading! Hannah has completely taken her readers to the past when the United States was split and people were a danger to themselves, constantly reliving their nightmarish past while they were in a war, with no knowledge of how to treat these veterans with the mental health medicine and practice they so badly needed. She revisits this tumultuous time with descriptions of headlines that we all know and have read before and brings it to life through the eyes of Frankie and her comrades. This was a well-thought-out novel that was delivered beautifully.

The audio is amazing, Julia Whelan (my favorite narrator) is perfect for this story. She creates voices for the characters that are easy to identify and her cadence is spot on, as always.

Was this review helpful?

Fantastic reading experience and absolutely loved, loved Julia Whelan as the narrator for the audiobook. Her way of drawing you into the story is amazing!

Thank you MacMillan audio for the gifted audio copy!

Was this review helpful?

I alternated between the print ARC and the audio ARC of The Women.
Great story that needed to be told. I'm glad I requested both formats and thank NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and listen to this title.

Was this review helpful?