Member Reviews

I loved this book from the very first page. It was so engaging and kept my attention the entire time. We get flashbacks throughout the story that slowly tell us what really happened to Ellie and it left me on the edge of my seat. There were parts of her story that were hard to read.

The storyline was gripping and this was such a binge-worthy book! The twists blew my mind. I would have never guessed where the story was going and one shocking reveal in the end made my jaw drop. For a girl that has almost given up on thrillers, this one was great! Thank you so much for the gifted copy!

Was this review helpful?

I could not put this book down. This isn't necessarily a fast-paced thriller, it was more of a character driven suspense novel but I could NOT STOP READING!

I have read Emiko Jean's YA novels in the past so it was exciting to see her veer into a new genre and she didn't disappoint.

This novel starts out with a bang - Ellie Black, who went missing two years ago, suddenly reappears. The small town detective, Chelsey, in charge of her case, who also has a personal connection to the case after her sister went missing years ago, is wondering what more there is to this story since Ellie isn't talking. She isn't saying what happened, who took her, how she got away, none of it. Chelsey thinks there is more to the story and slowly starts uncovering details as to what happened.

Emiko Jean did an amazing job keeping me incredibly invested in the characters - there were multiple narrators (I heard the audiobook is a full cast and is amazing!) and I thought she did a great job really developing each character and making me care so much about each person and kept me turning the pages because I just HAD to know what actually happened to Ellie.

There were a few big twists and turns - one that didn't quite work completely for me, but that didn't deter me from really loving this book. This is one I definitely will not forget and I can't wait to see what this author does next! Bravo!

Thank you to Netgalley & Simon and Schuster for this advanced reader's copy in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Ellie Black has made a miraculous return, after being missing for over two years. Coldwell cop Chelsey Calhoun is the detective assigned to Ellie's case. Detective Calhoun has been mired in a tragedy of her own for nearly 20 years, and Ellie's case brings everything to the surface for her. Something isn't quite adding up with Ellie's story about her captivity, though, and it will be up to Detective Calhoun to unravel the threads of deception to uncover the truth. Before it's too late for another girl.

It's incredible that this is the debut thriller by this author, because she set the hook perfectly. I was snared by this story and raced through the pages to get to Ellie's truth. There's a good pace and plenty of mind blowing revelations. Do yourself a favor and check out The Return of Ellie Black. Thank you to Netgalley and Simon & Schuster for the review copy.

Was this review helpful?

This is quite a captivating mystery that will keep you wanting to turn pages. It is full of exciting twists and turns until the very shocking end.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this one!! I thought the mystery was really interesting and I never saw the plot twist at the end coming. I wasn’t the biggest fan of Chelsey & there were times when she got alittle annoying. There were a few small things at the end that I didn’t really care for, but overall, I enjoyed this one!

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars. This book was captivating from page one. I had to force myself to put it down to do things like work and sleep.

The characters are so strong, especially Ellie and Chelsey. The dual POV & timelines (Ellie’s experience running concurrently with Chelsey’s investigation) are so interesting. An amazing thriller.

Thank you to NetGalley, Emiko Jean, and Simon & Schuester for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Return of Ellie Black by Emiko Jean starts off with a compelling premise that had me hooked right away. The mystery surrounding Ellie Black's reappearance after two years in the wilderness, coupled with Detective Chelsey Calhoun's personal quest to solve her sister's long-standing disappearance, creates a strong narrative drive.

However, I found it challenging to keep track of the characters and some of the storyline's intricacies. It could have been a problem with my listening experience, as I had the audiobook, or maybe the book's pacing and structure contributed to my confusion. Despite these hiccups, the plot takes a dark and intriguing turn, keeping you guessing.

As the story progresses, the twists and turns become more intense. Unfortunately, by the end, it felt like the plot went a bit too far, losing some of its earlier focus. Despite these reservations, the book's feminist themes and gripping mystery elements make it a worthwhile read, especially for fans of thrillers with strong emotional undercurrents.

Was this review helpful?

Man, talk about a book hangover. This one is going to be hard to get over.

In The Return of Ellie Black Detective Chelsey Calhoun gets a do over when Ellie, who has been missing for two years, has suddenly reappeared in the woods near their small town of Sid;lfkjas;dlkf, Washington. Physically malnourished and obviously terrified, Ellie is reluctant to speak about her time with her captor, and Chelsey must tread a fine line if she has any hope of solving this case.

Chelsey is determined to not let another girl vanish. She is driven to the point of neglect to her marriage and disregard for precinct rules. Ellie’s case haunts her and brings back her own trauma of her sister’s disappearance many years ago. Her character has selfish tendencies, but her heart and dedication to helping makes it easy to disregard her flaws.

This book is a slow burn that puts the reader into the mind of a monster. Many parts are tough to read, but Emiko Jean handles them delicately. The alternating points of view gives a full picture of everything and everyone and makes the book hard to put down, in particular the last quarter of the book, which has one heck of a twist that will leave the reader reeling. If you are a fan of psychological thrillers do not miss this one!

Thank you to NetGalley, Simon & Schuster, and of course the author Emiko Jean for the advanced copy of the book. The Return of Ellie Black is out now. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Oh man. This was dark. That being said, I was beyond engaged the entire time. The writing was beautiful and the storytelling was done incredibly well. I definitely felt an emotional connection to our characters.

With multiple POV’s and first hand accounts, this book will take you for a ride- you won’t be able to predict what comes next. There were a number of times I had to pause because it got dark, disturbing, and descriptive, but that final reveal? Smh. How 😩

I really enjoyed this!

Was this review helpful?

Talk about a page turner. This book had me HOOKED! I don't read a ton of thrillers, but I so appreciate a well-paced thriller with compelling characters, and Emiko Jean's newest book absolutely delivers both.

I always get so nervous as I approach the end of a thriller, because I feel like everything hinges on the resolution. (Has the author laid enough groundwork for the reveal to pay off? Does it make sense? Is it realistic?) The resolution of this book was arguably my favorite part of the entire story. The foundations and backstory were there, and the reveal was believable (and honestly shocking without feeling like it came out of nowhere).

I think this book is best if you don't know anything at all going into it, so I'm not going to elaborate much on the story or characters here. I do have a couple additional thoughts, though. There were a few aspects of the book that I wish Emiko Jean could have dug into a bit more. Throughout the book, Detective Chelsea Calhoun, one of the protagonists, is deeply immersed in her job. And while Jean addresses some of the problems with the white male cop culture that is an inherent part of this job, I felt like she could have explored this/pushed it further.

Additionally, this same protagonist is also a Japanese woman who was adopted as a child by a white family. Emiko Jean is an Asian-identifying author who often writes Japanese characters, and I was quite excited to see how this would play out in the story. While she references it a couple of times (mostly in the context of feeling like a bit of an outsider, particularly at her job), I also would have loved to see Chelsea's identity play a larger role in the story.

Content warnings: kidnapping, sexual assault of a minor, murder, gun violence, domestic abuse, emotional abuse

Thank you to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for my advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

The Return of Ellie Black by Emiko Jean
.
After being missing for two years, Ellie Black is found as a shell of her former self. Detective Chelsey Calhoun takes back up the case, eager to find who held Ellie captive, and where are they now?
.
What I liked:
-This was a great mystery book. We mostly follow Detective Chelsey as she tries to unravel what happened to Ellie. At the same time we are learning more about Chelsey and what drives her in her police work.
-Ellie was such a mystery herself. She was a tough nut to crack after everything that she went through. I loved the chapters where we learned more about her.
-The last 20% of the book was crazy, and I loved every minute of it!
-The second to the last chapter in the book was very emotional and made me cry.
.
4 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ What an excellent missing person story. I am very impressed and definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This is Emiko Jean’s first foray into thriller territory and she certainly nailed it. Ellie Black went missing two years ago. She suddenly shows up, on a hiking path, and is found by two hikers. Detective Chelsey Calhoun worked Ellie’s missing person case. She’s elated that Ellie has been found and is eager to speak with her so she can find who took her. Ellie is evasive, though. She isn’t cooperative and this leaves Chelsey to wonder if it’s PTSD or something else.

I absolutely loved this one. I was hooked from the beginning and loved the multiple POV. Chelsey also has secrets and the twists were great. It’s definitely a page turner and I couldn’t put it down. I read it in two days.

Was this review helpful?

If you're looking for a new page-turner to add to your TBR, THE RETURN OF ELLIE BLACK deserves to make your short list at the very least. I read this novel in one long sitting because I just couldn't put it down. There were definitely some references to types of content I don't love to read about, but nothing happened on the page that was too graphic. Please heed the CWs.

Was this review helpful?

Seventeen year old Ellie Black leaves a party in search of a bathroom and disappears without a trace. Two years later Ellie is found wandering the woods in Washington state.

Detective Chelsey Calhoun has followed her dad’s footsteps into the police force, she is driven after the disappearance and murder of her sister when she was a teenager. She was assigned Ellie’s case when she originally disappeared and she is determined to get the man who kidnapped Ellie.

Something seems off with Ellie, and when she stops cooperating with the investigation, it makes detective Calhoun that much more determined to get to the bottom of this mystery.

There really isn’t much I can tell you about this book, there are so many twists and turns. The book is primarily told through the POV’s of Chelsey and Ellie with others sprinkled throughout. Just when I was confident I knew where the author was going, she would throw a twist that sent me in a completely different direction. This book was impossible to put down.

Some of the descriptions of Ellie when she was kidnapped were difficult to read so please check TW before reading.

If you like fast paced thrillers I think you will love this one.

Was this review helpful?

Detective Chelsey Calhoun is awakened by a call late one night: Ellie Black has been found after missing for two years. This news launches Chelsey in a fast paced mystery thriller of trying to figure out who took Ellie and where she’s been all this time. To make things more complicated, Chelsey is still haunted by the loss of her sister whose murder twenty years ago broke her family apart.

Let me just say that overall I enjoyed this book. It was a page turner, and I was desperate to know how it ended. However, as I read, there are several things that pulled me out of the thrill of the story, and I found the ending pretty disappointing.

Let’s start with the positives.

Positives:
1. I thought the characters were fun. Even though they were very stereotypical (loner small town copy, bland supportive spouse, every man is violent and dismissive, every woman is angry and unsatisfied) this actually made it easy to follow the story because you didn’t have to think too much about their motivations. I know that doesn’t sound like a good thing, but I think the plot was twisty enough without having to also question what the characters were up to. It makes for a good mystery thriller to read for someone who’s never read one before.
2. I loved Danny and Ellie’s relationship. I thought they were sweet and their problems and interactions before and after her abduction felt so realistic. Ellie’s parents were also written really well. The way they handled their daughter's disappearance felt very true.
4. The switching POVs were a little jarring at first, but it was easy to understand who was telling the story, and I thought it made for an interesting story format.
5. The description of Ellie’s abduction and her time with her captor was absolutely chilling, and some of the things that happened to her will definitely haunt me for a while.
6. I really loved seeing Chelsey’s internal monologues and doubts as she went through the case and how much she cared about the people involved.

Cons:
1. I really thought we were going to get a bit more about Chelsey’s Japanese heritage, or her trying to learn about her heritage.
2. I love police procedural shows, and I understand you just have to ignore some of the science because it won’t make sense. But the part with the DNA? I’m pretty sure that’s not how DNA works, though I might be wrong.
3. I didn’t mind the repeated comments about the violence towards women, because it is true especially for the mystery thriller genre, but why not go louder with it? Why not have Chelsey make an impassioned speech to her husband or boss about why she has to do certain things? Why not have her talk about this to Ellie?
4. All the reveals were so unsatisfying. One of the reveals was easy to guess, and the other one was such a blah moment because there was no emotional buildup for the surprise. The reveal at the very end was silly and so out of the blue. To make it effective, there should have been some hints scattered throughout the book so that the reader could revel in that moment of connecting all the dots. Or we should have met more of the characters involved so we’d feel a connection to what’s happening on the page.


I hope I didn’t spoil anything for those who still want to pick up the book. And it is definitely a fun book to pick up, especially if the things that bothered me don’t bother you. I’d recommend it for an easy summer read.


Thank you Netgalley and Simon & Schuster for this arc in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Crazy thriller that kept me interested in the story and how it was going to be resolved. Did not expect the ending and all the connections to the twist.

Was this review helpful?

Let’s start with the fact that I finished 70% of the book in one day alone - once it gets going, it was hard to put down! I loved the way that the chapters were put into two different perspectives as well, I think it helped me keep the pages turning. With mysteries and thrillers, especially those with a “whodunnit” type of vibe, I always try to guess the ending and who is involved. When I tell you that I SO did not see that twist coming!!! I absolutely love that in a book, I was totally stunned. And I’m glad the author leaned into the details and background after the reveal at the end, but I think I wanted more from that development.

Was this review helpful?

For more than twenty years, Chelsey Calhoun has been plagued by the disappearance of her younger sister. In an attempt to aid others in escaping peril, she follows in her father's footsteps and joins the local police department. A girl is discovered by two hikers while they are exploring the Washington State forests. The girl? Ellie Black vanished two years ago. Ellie stays silent and declines to cooperate with the investigation, despite Chelsey's tireless efforts to bring Ellie to justice. Chelsey finds that Ellie is still silent when she looks more closely at the evidence. Ellie must act quickly to save the other girls because time is of the essence for Chelsey. This compelling narrative cleverly switches from Ellie's point of view and the third person. You can truly feel and sense how frail Ellie is and how driven she is to complete the tasks at hand when you see the world through her eyes. The more that is learned about Ellie's experiences, the darker this story becomes. Nevertheless, despite everything Ellie has been through, there are moments of gentler, quieter tone scattered between the high drama, high intensity chapters that give us a glimpse of optimism that her life may return to normal.

This book's twists and turns are astounding, but they also provide readers—as well as Chelsey and Ellie—closure. I'm eager to read more writing by Emiko Jean because this was written so well..

Thank you netgalley and Simon & Schuster for the advance readers copy. This is my first book by this author and i look forward to more to come.

Was this review helpful?

When Ellie Black disappears, the hunt for her seems all too familiar. Young women have been disappearing from the local area for many years and never found. But after two years missing, Ellie is found wandering and returned to her family. After two years, this is not the same Ellie that disappeared and it's up to the police to investigate her disappearance and where she has been while missing.

The story has elements of previous thrillers, but Emiko Jean has given the story over to the women involved, a twist on most police procedurals, a welcome twist. Multiple POVs try to fill in the blanks while showing the courage it would take for Ellie to survive her captivity and the dedication of the young deputy who will not stop until the mystery is solved and the criminals punished. THE RETURN OF ELLIE BLACK may be fiction but is all too sadly based on the sensation headlines we see too often for comfort.

Was this review helpful?

Pretty cool mystery... Didn't think of it as great but it wasn't bad. Overall, A solid book. Had couple aha moments that were really nice

Was this review helpful?