Member Reviews

I really enjoyed the nostalgia of the early aughts pop scene and public love triangles reminiscent of Britney, Justin, and Christina. It held a mirror up to the way we, as a society, both love and love-to-hate celebrities, and the way women are often held to impossible standards in contrast to their male contemporaries. I felt that, despite the celebrity aspect of the characters, so many of their feelings and experiences were relatable to anyone who has been a young woman and had to come to terms with trying to balance sexuality and desire against society’s Madonna-whore complex. Honey is an interesting look at womanhood and hunger, and the prose has an almost lyrical quality that made the reading experience very enjoyable.

Was this review helpful?

Honey is the journey of Amber Young, a late 90s-early 2000s pop star. For anyone that was a fan of the Britney/Christina era, this book reads like a backstage view into their lives. Honey is about more than just pop stars though, it is about the struggle to find oneself at a young age and the beauty of friendships. Thanks to NetGalley and Celadon Books for the copy!

Was this review helpful?

Include a quote from a Britney Spears song? Say less. I adored the line comparing mother’s and daughters to Russian dolls, so poetic when referring to young daughters getting their big break and mother’s living in their shadows- much like the show Gypsy. So I hope that line stays in the final copy of the book once released.

Amber’s journey includes many things expected from a wannabe pop star- Star Search, a troubled family with an alcoholic mom, and the failure of the beginning with a girl group. A little too played out at times. From the girl group she meets Gwen, who also begins a solo career very much mirroring a Christina vs Britney vibe. A little too on the nose. The men are all pretty much creepy and cringey in this one. Amber and the first love interest are so excruciating to read and awkward, I was prepared to skip all those parts. The story is so much better when focusing on Amber coming into her own and her career.

Even though the story lacks quite a bit of depth, maybe that’s the point in reflecting teen pop in the early 2000s, Amber’s transformation was the real “star” of the book. Even lacking points for me for creativity, this could be a good book for you if drawn to any stories of Hollywood and follow girly pop idols of the 90s and early 2000s.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Celadon books for the digital galley of this book!
90s pop stars, boy bands, drama, publicity, and more! This book gives me very much 90s, Britney Spears vibes when it comes to what happens when you have the spotlight, who you can count on, and how to find yourself when everyone else has already formed opinions about you. It tackled how media treat women, women treat other women, and how women treat themselves.
Did I agree with the lifestyles of these characters? Not really. Did I really like how different it was and impulsively readable it was? Definitely.

Was this review helpful?

I felt like I was slipped right back into the early 2000s. At the time I never would have said I was a fan of Britney or Christina and definitely not Jessica Simpson but reading this made me look back on the emergence of their genre in a much different way. The epilogue was chefs kiss. Pure creativity and I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

Man oh man did I LOVE this book! I read it in one sitting I just could not put it down. This is what I imagine all pop stars to experience and I’m so here for it. I loved this!!!!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, this was not the book for me. The synopsis was promising, but I just did not enjoy the book like I thought I would. It bored me and it didn't encourage me to continue reading. I also found that there was a lot of unnecessary descriptions that seemed like it was trying hard to be "flowery".

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars rounded up. If you were a teenager in the late '90s or early aughts, you will recognize many of the characters in this book. Britney, Jessica, Xtina, *NSYNC, even the acclaimed producer Max Martin -- their counterparts can all be found in the pages of Honey: the story of iconic pop star Amber Young, her rise to fame, and the scandals and achievements that shaped her career.

Isabel Banta gets a lot right in her debut novel. She perfectly captures the culture of the late 1990s and early 2000s, largely defined by the feverish, meteoric rise of girl groups and boy bands. Through Amber (who reminded me of both Britney and Xtina at different times through the story) and her counterparts, Gwen and Savannah, Banta explores the artifices of fame, the never-satisfied need for recognition and success, the struggles of being cast in a public persona that doesn't quite fit, the role of public opinion in shaping a career, and what it feels like to live your dream while also lacking anything real and true. There's a lot of interesting commentary surrounding the ways these pop icons were exploited and oversexualized -- but also how they were underestimated, denied agency and often respect in the industry. I loved the multimedia aspect of the book, which includes web articles, magazine articles and quizzes (man, those quizzes were nostalgic!), and song lyrics.

All that said, however, the plot of Honey largely felt like a missed opportunity. I felt like there was a more interesting story to tell about these characters, rather than just casting them as players in a love affair that was supposedly "scandalous." I felt that Banta got to the heart of who Amber was, but never quite excavated the complexities of her relationships with the other characters.

But wow, was Honey ever a fun trip down memory lane for me -- and also a book that made me think about those back-in-the-day pop icons in a completely different light than I was capable of as a 15-year-old girl obsessed with the Backstreet Boys. Thank you to Celadon Books for the early reading opportunity.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so nostalgic to me, growing up in this era. It was an easy read and good story but lacked a bit of depth to me.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a different read than I was expecting! It had incredible 90’s/00’s vibes throughout, which brought me right back. The writing was lyrical (literally), beautiful, and confusing at times.

I enjoyed the plot and concept of the book, but was sometimes needing to read a section over again because I felt I missed something that would logically link it to the next section.

The themes were clear and I loved the characters. They felt interesting and young and dramatic. It was a bit of chaos, but welcomed chaos.



Thank you so much to Celadon Books and NetGalley for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

A pop-star coming of age fiction debut set in the late 90s. This was perfect for fans of singers like Jessica Simpson and Mandy Moore and was fantastic on audio narrated by my FAV, Brittany Pressley. Heartfelt and interspersed with fun news clips that really enhanced the audio experience. I will definitely keep an eye out for more by this new writer. Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an early digital and audio copy in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This book feels like an iPod mini and Hubba Bubba gum and summer camp. Beautifully nostalgic of the late 90s and early 2000s pop craze, we get to follow a character as she gets swept into a current and then plants her feet firmly on the ground. For anyone who loved boy bands and solo girlies as a kid, this book will feel like coming home.

Was this review helpful?

At 17 Amber Young gets the opportunity of a lifetime when she joins Cloud 9, a pop girl group. This allows her to launch her very successful solo career. The novel follows her as she comes of age with every aspect of her life being scrutinized by the media.

I’ve seen very mixed opinions of this novel so I didn’t know what to expect and I was very pleasantly surprised. I really enjoyed following the Amber’s story and never wanted to put it down.

Thank you to NetGalley and Celadon Books for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Celadon Books for providing this book, with my honest review below.

I read Honey understanding the blurb but unsure what kind of story I’d be getting into. Would it be tragic? Hopeful? Romantic? Triumphant? Rageful? The story of someone who is ultimately flawed, damaged, maybe even pathetic? All of these things are coming up in retrospectives of various famous pop artists during the time the book took place. Ultimately Honey was a little bit of all of this, which various characters who represented each of these things or had elements that spanned the range.

This is not a look into the world of pop stars that tries to imagine how a Britney Spears would have navigated her experiences per se. It’s a frank look at a pop star who could have been anyone, a few pop stars really, during that time. Amber’s experiences are her own though they seem familiar to those who grew up during that time reading gossip or looking in. Gwen, her best friend, and Wes, her lover, also carry the same type of feeling. While I wish Honey would have gone a bit deeper, brought more in of the obsessiveness of fans and press, and spoke more to the advantages the industry took, this sucked me in and was fascinating all the same. Really, I just wish the story would have continued further into the 2000’s as the culture of celebrity and obsession reached a distasteful peak during that time. Instead we were left with the beginning of a young pop star who was flawed and tragic and a bit pathetic. Who had buried rage but was hopeful, experienced romance - both the toxic and healthy types- and who emerged triumphant, even though we may not have seen her fully breakthrough to that healthy end.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

This is the perfect summer read in our nostalgic era as we follow the rise of the members of a 1990s girls group. Banta is deft at writing metaphors that jump off the page alluding to the sexism that these characters face at the hands of fellow celebrities, producers, and fans. It is difficult to believe this is a debut because the author is wholly in control of her narrative. You will be thinking about these characters long after you turn the final page. The finale is so richly earned, I was cheering while reading.

The cover art is also perfect hinting at the many layers of this stunning novel. Banta is definitely an author on the rise!

Was this review helpful?

I will admit that this was a stretch for me and there were things that I appreciated about it. I thought that the author was very good with language; there were parts that seemed lyrical, which seems appropriate given that this was about a young girl in the music industry. There were times that I was mesmerized by the author's arrangement of words.
This novel follows the rise of Amber, a young girl from a working class background who enters the music industry and rises outwardly but loses herself in the process. She meets people who take advantage of her and experiences inner turmoil as she wants all of the things that success can give her but suffers consequences from it. The premise is strong. I wanted a bit more, though. It is fine, good even, for Amber to want the things that fame brings especially given her background. However, in some ways Amber was not very likeable because as much as some others may have taken advantage of her, she seemed to react in kind and she also seemed to lack self respect. All of this is fine, and perhaps this wasn't the book for me, but I feel like I wanted this to be a story with a feminist angle to it and it wasn't. I wanted Amber to discover things about herself, but I feel like she didn't.
Also, this book had a very young adult feel to it, which is not a bad thing. I don't read a lot of young adult books so I am not as familiar with the landscape as some. At the same time, there were times that Amber seemed hypersexualized and the text became very explicit with her sexual encounters. I am not a prude but this is a book that many young adults might want to read, but I don't think that the level of detail about sex would be appropriate for that audience. While this was done well (again, the author is good with language), I am not sure it was necessary. It is fine and even good that Amber had sexual agency (and it appears that her decisions were her own and not forced upon her), this could have been conveyed without the level of detail of her sexual encounters that were in the book.
That said, I liked the writing style which felt very tied into the music aspect of it. I would love to see where the author goes with her next book.
Thanks to NetGalley and Celadon Books for providing me with the opportunity to read this book in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC.

3.5 rounding up to 4.

Honey is a surprisingly sweet coming of age story about a young singer in the often-brutal popscape of the late 90s and early 00s. I liked the interspersed interviews, song lyrics, and articles as it brought dimension to Amber’s world. I do wish we had more character development - it doesn’t feel like we always know what Amber actually wants or cares about - but this was a fun summer read.

Was this review helpful?

This coming-of-age story focuses on Amber - a young teen trying to make a career in the music industry. I thought the premise of the story sounded very promising, but unfortunately the story didn't work for me; it felt very disjointed with not enough character development to make me care of Amber. I think it did do a good job highlighting the medias obsession with famous people and how people are forced to create an image of themselves just to placate the masses.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 rounded up
Overall, it’s a fun summer read but felt unrealized. I never felt I fully knew Amber and I can’t put my finger on the reasoning. I also felt like the book needed more of a struggle or theme. Everything seemed relatively easy overall, and the only thing Amber seemed to struggle with was her dating life— even her family struggles seemed glossed over for me.

Was this review helpful?

Honey capture the life of Amber Young, a pop-star on a rises in the late 90’s and early 2000’s.

This reads like an autobiography, giving you a glimpse behind the scene of what your favorite females artists might have went through during those times. Showing how cruel the media can be toward young girls and applying pressure on them to be something they’re not.

Since a young girl, Amber was always desperate for praise. Not having the confidence and looking for everybody approval beside herself, she tend to get push to things she wouldn’t do. We’re following her journey through fame, friendships, relationships and self healing.

I love the writing style, how she describes some scenes and her metaphors was incredible. Although , I wish she didn’t rush through some plots. Diving into her relationships more or even seeing her living her famous life when she finally made it would had made me care more.

Overall, I enjoy this book and is looking forward of more Banta books.

Was this review helpful?