Member Reviews

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC. I was a fan of Moore's previous book, Long Bright River, and while this one is very different in terms of story and structure, it was another hit for me as well. This is a slower paced story, but one that is hard to put down in that compulsively readable way that I love. This is part mystery, part family drama that stems from generations of family secrets and tragedy. The characters are all well-developed and while not equally like-able, they will evoke empathy from the reader. The story is sadly, all too believable. The setting plays a key role in the narrative and the atmosphere/tone of the book pulls you in and places you within the story. There are hard things within the story, but the ending is redemptive. 5 stars for storytelling and payoff.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Riverhead Books and Netgalley for a digital ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. 4.5 stars rounded up!! This was one of the best mystery/thrillers I've read in a while. Set at a summer camp owned by the wealthy Van Lara family, Barbara, the eldest daughter, goes missing while attending the camp. Not only does this send a shockwave through the camp due to her last name, but also because her brother went missing fourteen years prior and was never found. The novel proceeds to follow the search for both Barbara and the previous efforts in the past to find her brother through the point of view of family members, campers and staff, police detectives, and other community members. I loved the dual timeline and multiple POVs throughout this book. They wove together such a great story that kept me turning the page. There was a few POVs that felt unnecessary/out of place and added a bit of confusion for the reader, but otherwise I would highly recommend picking this up next time you're in the market for a mystery that feels original and has depth.

Was this review helpful?

It's been a long time since I was so compelled to keep tearing though a book as this one! It didn't feel nearly as long as it was because of the mini-reveals spread throughout it, all intricately woven together to reveal the final puzzle. This novel was extremely well-plotted and kept be continually guessing. There would be lots to discuss in a book club and I've already chosen it for one of mine. A juicy summer read with a lot of substance, larger interesting themes and a great setting-- I was so excited to read this one and enjoyed it even more than I expected.

Was this review helpful?

A mystery set in a summer camp in the Adirondacks in the 1970's. I loved the setting and the description of the camp as well as how the divide between the wealthy and the workers played out. The switching time periods and narrators was a bit much at times. Ultimately, the plot kept me guessing in this atmospheric tale.

Was this review helpful?

This was a page turner!

The story is told from multiple points of view and during multiple timelines. Although you are bouncing between these timelines, the writing is very well done and reads without confusing the reader.

There are two mysteries you are trying to uncover. A teenage girl has gone missing from a summer camp that her family owns, the same camp that her brother went missing 15 years prior. It’s mystery and family drama all wrapped in one.

Even with a large cast of characters, they are well developed. You are rooting for some and hoping others get their due.


Thank you NetGalley and PENGUIN for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

wow!! what an excellent novel. this book was intriguing, heartbreaking, infuriating, yet satisfying all at the same time. i will for sure be buying a physical copy and reading Long Bright River ASAP.

i read this book in less than a week, while reading other books as well—which says a lot since this is almost 500 pgs. this is not necessarily a fast paced book and is more character-driven, but something about Liz Moore's writing is so captivating. i was never bored while reading this, and the structure was a little unconventional yet easy to keep up with. it follows a nonlinear timeline with different perspectives (written in 3rd person), but it was easy to tell who was who. this book is a compelling mystery and family saga which also examines the privileges of the rich, secrets of a strained yet close-knit community, and how young girls are sexualized yet grown women are infantilized. Moore incorporated the 50s-70s time periods well and attitudes surrounding women at those times without it being stereotypical or contrived. the themes were able to come across to the reader in a subtle way, without being preachy or hitting the reader over the head.

the characters were all so vivid and felt real—not caricatures. Moore delves into the important players’ inner thoughts and backstories, yet still makes the reader question who to trust. it’s easy to root for some characters and hate others, yet feel unsure about many of them. Moore also parallels similar feelings in certain characters in order to connect them to a common theme, forcing the reader to think about the thematic threads that bind different characters.

this book also took me by surprise with the ending and reveals. i feel like this would be a perfect book for a discussion! the setting in upstate NY was also impeccable. i could picture everything as i was reading, and there is even a little map at the beginning. however, i didn’t need to refer to it much because of the atmospheric descriptions.

i would recommend this book if you like:
⁃ character-driven books
⁃ subtle commentary on wealth, class, and the female experience
⁃ unconventional structure
⁃ summer camp/outdoor woodsy settings

thank you to Riverhead Books, Liz Moore, and Netgalley for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This was a really well done, slow burn, thriller/ drama. I loved the upstate NY setting as well as the dual timelines and multiple POVs .

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to LOVE this, as it's a literary thriller set at a summer camp! I would say I really enjoyed parts of this, but as a whole literary thrillers are still hit or miss for me. I feel like sometimes they need to "pick a lane", so to speak. This one felt a bit flip floppy between a thriller and a family drama. Anyways, like most thrillers, this is the story of a girl who goes missing. But at summer camp! She's the daughter of the founders of the camp, and her brother also disappeared from the camp years ago. We have multiple POVs from another camper, a counselor, a detective, and family members. At its core it's mostly an examination of a really messed up family. There was a bit too much going on at times, but it still made for a great summer read.

Was this review helpful?

A summer camp in the Adirondack mountains is the setting for a mystery when a young girl goes missing. In a frightening coincidence, her brother went missing over a decade before and the suspected murderer has recently escaped from prison. A story filled with twists and turns, strong character development, and red herrings had me turning the pages. Well done.

Was this review helpful?

So good! It didn’t feel like 500 pages at all, the pacing was great. The multiple POV chapters and timelines weren’t confusing. Definitely recommend this. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Semi-mystery, semi-campfire scary story that follows the generic outline for these kinds of stories. The only way this works is to set it in the era before cell phones and over-connection (although using the Adirondacks could allow you to edge closer to the modern age, since wifi and cell coverage really didn't arrive until later and is still patchy in some areas).

Only towards the end is there anything new. There was one thing I picked up on early and expected to be The Answer to Bear's disappearance - I was wrong. It does come into play later, in a way I didn't expect. So one point for that!

eARC provided by publisher via Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

Talk about slow burn. It takes a good chunk to get a handle on everyone and I will be recommending physical over audio for that reason. Rich people behaving badly and a long history but feels over told in a way and I found it predictable and a little flat in the end. Definitely not as compelling of a read as her last which I found more emotional. I lacked an investment in the story and outcome.

Was this review helpful?

My third Liz Moore book, and I continue to amazed. Her characters are complex and nuanced. I was on the edge of my seat throughout the book. The book’s setting and time periods felt so real. The story felt like a powerful tale of a time when women had little control over their lives - Judyta, Alice, Barbara, TJ, Tracy - all living and surviving within the constraints society put on them and trying to find their way.

Was this review helpful?

When a camper goes missing from her bunk in the Adirondacks in 1975, secrets from the past and present are unearthed. 13-year-old Barbara Van Laar has gone missing, and unlike the other campers, her family owns the summer camp. 14 years prior, her brother, Bear, was also missing from the grounds and never found. Is someone targeting the family, or is the cause something more sinister?

The God of the Woods wasn't exactly what I was expecting it to be, and because of this, I loved it more. My one issue was it was somewhat difficult to track the multiple timelines, as the ARC e-file made the year of each chapter hard to decipher.

Thank you NetGalley and and Penguin Group Riverhead for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

This is a book by a new-to-me author that I found hard to put down. The story has stayed with me ever since finishing it some weeks ago.

I enjoy dual timeline stories as this was. The characters and descriptions of the beautiful surroundings were very well developed. The author kept you in suspense with both timelines very good book!

I received the book from the publisher via net galley in exchange for an honest review. Four stars.

Was this review helpful?

This was probably my most anticipated book of the year and I can confidently say it will end up in my top three. There are quite a few characters and timelines, but Moore does a great job keeping the reader in the loop, skillfully weaving the different stories together. Part family drama, part mystery, the novel centers around the disappearance of Barbara from her family’s camp in the Adirondaks. This event dredges up painful memories of her older brother Bear, who vanished fourteen years earlier. I was utterly captivated, losing myself entirely in the setting and its complicated characters; finishing the book felt like emerging from another world. Long Bright River was a favorite, and a book I can still recall with surprising detail. And somehow she did it again, and this one might be even better.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars! Really enjoyed this book! Loved the double mystery/timeline aspect of this book. The twists were perfectly spread out and I enjoyed the overall pace of the book. Really well written. The only part that kind of confused me was I was getting the female character POVs mixed up and I was reading on Kindle so the bold dates didnt stand out so sometime I would get confused with the timeline for certain characters. Overall really enjoyed this!

Was this review helpful?

1975 A girl disappeared from a renowned summer camp. There are two mysteries as her brother disappeared before she was born. There is a slow burn of suspects and secrets that evolves into a Read that was above average. The rich and the help are examined as the search continues and the brothers case is reopened. Things are not always what they seem. this includes people and places. A thorough investigation allows for many twists and turns.

Copy provided by the publisher and Netgalley

Was this review helpful?

This book...I don't even know what to say. It was so dang slow, no like really, painfully slow. But I couldn't put it down. Every slow-@$$ page, I said, "ok, well, just one more." 400+ pages later, here I am: confused, but I understand, happy but traumatized, vindicated yet betrayed...

It gives The Girl With a Dragon Tattoo vibes, and they are filming a season of True Detective on the set of Dirty Dancing. I don't know what you want from me.

I don't even know if I liked it, but I definitely can't give it fewer than 5 stars. Did I like any of the characters? Maybe, but then they do something awful, sneaky, or stupid. How do you even summarize this book? Okay, let's see, 🤔 The God of the Woods is Why Women Choose the Bear is a narrative form. It will dredge up every awkward, hurtful, loathsome feeling you've ever felt since you were 12 years old, make you look it dead in the eye, and then have it walk away smiling. But it is a great reminder that men are awful (not all men 😒).

Was this review helpful?

This was just so damn good. I love a case that is compelling, keeps you hooked and has humanity at the heart of it.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?