
Member Reviews

Thank you @netgalley for this gifted e-Arc. Review ahead!
I read this with the Romance Book Club @inkwoodnj, and TBH after hearing it was super spicy a n d about the PR boxgate I wasn’t feeling really confident that I’d like it. I had only read, I Kissed Shara Wheeler, (YA novel) by @casey.mcquiston to this point. While I really liked that one, I expected this would be a very different story than that.
I was sort of charmed by this, though. I thought Theo was an especially layered character and found myself wondering how much Casey had written themselves into writing them. The spice wasn’t /as spicy as I expected and there was plenty of plot in this second chance romance. I loved all of the Anthony Bourdain references, and for once the traveling trope worked for me. I’d take a star of for all of the massive miscommunication and the quasi break up (iykyk), but overall really solid recommend from me.
🖤 Where has been your favorite place that you’ve traveled and why?
Idc where I am tbh, but give me a book, a cocktail and either a pool or a beach and I’m good 👌
#thepairing #caseymcquiston #nonbinarypositivity #romancereads #anthonybourdain #netgalleyreads #bookreviewer #bookblogger #bookstagram #bookthoughts #earc

(3.5 stars rounded down to 3). The Pairing by Casey McQuiston focuses on Kit and Theo, two bisexual exes who end up coincidentally booking the same European food and wine tour using a return voucher, just four years after they broke up en route to the same food and wine tour they had booked together. The book follows the next three weeks of their trip as they navigate the heartache and unresolved pain they had buried for so long, desperately seeking the closure they never received.
Kit’s perspective in the second half of the book was far more enjoyable for me. I found it to be more insightful and interesting and I felt as if I could actually understand the inner workings of his mind. Oh how deeply and vastly he loved Theo. On the other hand, I quickly found Theo’s perspective to be irritating, as they make a habit of running away from their problems and proceed to hook up with every living and breathing person in Europe. I was annoyed by how 28 year olds can be so emotionally stunted and continue to blame the world around them for all their problems. I also found myself frustrated by Theo’s nepo baby complex and wanting to cosplay as poor - people who don’t come from generational wealth and are actually forced to create names for themselves entirely on their own would kill for the money and resources Theo had access to and simply decided they were too good to use because of their misguided pride. Both MCs were fairly unlikable (especially Theo), I was not rooting for them to get back together, and frankly found myself not caring whether or not they did. And even more disappointingly, the side characters were so one dimensional, uncharacteristically so for CMQ.
Despite this, I love love and I loved how Kit and Theo found their way back into each other’s gravitational pull, despite my hesitations about whether they are actually good for each other. I adored the food and wine and gorgeous scene descriptions and the general acts of love and friendship that existed in this story. BRB as I research food and wine tours in Europe.
Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin’s Press for this ARC!

i was worried about whether i would like this because after loving red white and royal blue, i have felt progressively less into cmcq's books. but i really liked this one. it was funny and caring and definitely the sluttiest book i have ever read--which i say having read a 37-book/story polyam kink community romance series last year. this definitely takes the cake. loved that.

This book is basically the definition of hedonism. Food, alcohol, sex, love. The relationship between Kit and Theo - the history there - was interesting. However, I felt like I cared more about the places they visited and was more interested in the descriptions of the food they ate than the success of the relationship between the two of them. Which wouldn't be a problem if this weren't a romance.
Mostly this book made me want to go on a tour of western Europe. I didn't care much for either of the MCs.
This book is the definition of horny to be honest. But other than that it doesn't have enough going for it.

The Pairing by Casey McQuiston is a delightful blend of humor, heart, and delicious food. The book follows two exes, Theo and Kit, as they navigate their complicated relationship on a European food and wine tour.
McQuiston has a knack for creating relatable characters with witty banter and endearing flaws. Theo and Kit's dynamic is both charming and frustrating, making their journey towards reconciliation all the more compelling. The author's vivid descriptions of food and wine add a sensual element to the story, making it a feast for the senses as well as the heart.
While the plot is predictable at times, it's the characters and their interactions that truly shine. The book's exploration of friendship, love, and self-discovery is both heartwarming and thought-provoking. If you're looking for a fun and heartwarming read with a dash of romance, The Pairing is definitely worth checking out.

3.5/5 Stars
Theo and Kit are exes and haven't seen each other in over four years after a messy break up. They accidently book the same European food and wine tour, and challenge each other to a hook up competition.
I liked how the first half of the book was from Theo's POV and the second half was from Kit. It allowed for us to see inside both of their heads, and learn more about how they were feeling towards one another. I think both of them went through a lot of growth through out the story, and I liked watching them reconnect with one another. I do think the reasoning behind the breakup was a bit weak once it was revealed. Their issues could have been resolved in literally one conversation with each other. I also thought that the hook-up competition got very repetitive very quickly. I did really like the setting of the European countries and all the food they were getting to taste left my mouth watering, it all sounded so delicious.
Not my favourite of Casey's books, but still an enjoyable read!

This is my second read by Casey Mcquiston and I loved it just as much as red white and royal blue. I thought this was well written and a funny and compelling story

This book is lush with descriptions. It was a great read over the summer. A story with ex’s who wind up on the same trip across Europe, it’s the perfect second chance romance setup. This setup makes the chapters fly by and allow you natural stops between trip stops.
The descriptions of the food and wine is delicious. It almost makes you feel the tastes. But the romance is HORNY! It’s great. The sex and gender identity is at the core of this story. It leaves you feeling warm and gooey and you root for them.

I had a lot of fun with this one! tbh a lot of the places they visited are very unfamiliar to me so a lot of the places and descriptions kind of went over my head lol. same with the food/wine...
I thought the dual pov was beautifully done - normally I'm not a fan of that but here it really mattered. overall, very fun and full of interesting characters (I'll miss you, Fabrizio), more nsfw than I expected, and sooo very romantic! got me smilin' and kickin' reading about these two

4 ⭐️
Casey McQuiston has absolutely done it again. Everything that rubbed me the wrong way in Red, White & Royal Blue was done 1000x better in The Pairing. It’s adult, it’s LGBTQ, it’s in EUROPE and it’s steamy 🌶️
At times the pacing felt off and the chapters felt too long, but that’s a small price to pay to gain 10 pounds from the descriptions of the French and Italian food and the love I felt for every character.
Fabrizio, the Callums, Theo and Kit will stay with me for a long time. I don’t even know how she made me love EVERY character. Every bite of food, every sip of wine, every adventure and every kiss were just brilliantly well written.

okay solid 3.5 for lovely gender representation and chaotic mind validation
but i coulda read a history textbook or a tour guide pamphlet abt all these stops and food and wines and art history
the descriptions were DENSE to the point that i lost the plot often
AND OMFG THESE MFS WERE HORNY WTHHHHHHHHH
casey said smut 3.5/5 but i feel like it’s at LEAST a 4 for quantity alone holy shit
i’m glad i read it but it wasn’t the easiest thing to get through and RW&RB stands far superior imo
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!!

This was a fun, hot romance starring characters we don't usually see in romance stories. There is a lot of time spent on the food Kit and Theo eat so foodies will love this book. I found Kit and Theo's relationship, especially with their acceptance of each other, flaws and all. I didn't love this one as much as McQuiston's other books but this was a great summer read.

This one just missed the mark for me.
Idk if it was the miscommunication.
Idk if it tried to be too sexy.
I'm not sure, I just couldn't get into it like I have done in the past with Casey books.

I loved taking a tour across Europe with these two characters but thought this would've been an amazing friends to lovers story instead of second chance romance. I also really liked Kits POV a lot more than Theo's

I adored this book! I absolutely loved the main characters Kit and Theo and I think this book would make a fabulous vacation read. I definitely want to take Kit and Theo’s trip and taste all the delicious food and wine! I also loved the fact that there wasn’t a third act breakup - really nice to see a slightly different romance novel structure that still qualifies as a romance and has a happily ever after! Also, this was the first romance novel to have me cry happy tears at the end: I found Kit and Theo’s love story to be unbelievably beautiful!
I am taking a star off for three reason: 1) this book is long. I think it needed a better editor to tighten up the plot and chop at least fifty pages. The sex competition was fun at first but became extremely repetitive as the novel progressed and dragged the plot out towards the end. 2) The reason for Kit and Theo’s initial breakup was lackluster. I think it’s really hard to write a second chance romance with a convincing initial break up because you don’t want the reader to hate either character for their previous actions. However, having Kit and Theo break up over essentially a miscommunication felt lame. 3) The side characters felt two dimensional and like a compilation of European stereotypes. This wasn’t awful, just enough to take me out of the story.
“The Paring” was a wonderful summer read with great bi and non-binary representation. Casey McQuiston will continue to be an auto buy author for me!
Thanks so much to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Griffin for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Two bisexual exes are forced to confront their unresolved feelings when they both accidentally book the same European food and wine tour. What starts as a casual hookup competition to prove they’re over each other quickly turns into something much more complicated—and much more romantic.
Theo and Kit have a long history: childhood best friends, mutual crushes, lovers, and now estranged exes after a bitter breakup. Four years have passed since their dream trip to Europe was derailed by their sudden split, but now, with their old tour voucher about to expire, both independently decide to take the trip—solo. What they don’t expect is to find each other on the same tour bus, embarking on a three-week journey through the most romantic destinations in France, Spain, and Italy.
Determined to show they’ve moved on, Theo and Kit make a wager: whoever can hook up with the tour’s hot Italian guide first wins. But as they indulge in the stunning sights, incredible cuisine, and intoxicating wines of Europe, the sparks that first brought them together start to reignite. Soon, the competition isn’t about anyone else—it’s about proving to themselves that what they had might not be over after all.
Casey McQuiston once again delivers a delightful, heartfelt, and sexy rom-com that explores complex emotions, second chances, and the messy nature of love. *The Pairing* is filled with witty banter, mouth-watering descriptions of food and wine, and steamy, romantic tension as Theo and Kit navigate their way through Europe—and their tangled feelings for each other. The backdrop of vibrant European cities adds a rich, immersive atmosphere to their slow-burn romance.
The chemistry between Theo and Kit is palpable, with McQuiston skillfully blending humor, passion, and poignant moments of reflection on love, loss, and self-discovery. Fans of McQuiston's previous works will find the same signature charm and queer joy, while also relishing in the fresh dynamics of a bisexual second-chance romance.
Tropes
- Second-Chance Romance
- Enemies-to-Lovers (with a twist)
- Forced Proximity
- Queer Joy
The Pairing is a joyful, swoon-worthy rom-com packed with humor, heart, and heat. Casey McQuiston fans will savor this delicious blend of romance, travel, and emotional depth, making it a must-read for anyone looking for a feel-good story about second chances and rekindled love.

I’m not sure I understand the relationship between our two main characters. I get that they’re in their 20’s…that things are still being figured out…but why is miscommunication even happening?! There is too much history to not ask questions.
Crazy, toxic relationship woes aside. I enjoyed this book for its representation and exploration of food, wine, and friends! I liked the unconventional vulnerability as it reminds the reader that even strong willed people can find love and understanding. Ultimately, it made me want to simplify my life to only enjoy good food, good wine, and good books.
Thank you NetGalley, Macmillan Audio, St Martin’s Press, and author Casey McQuiston for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

I am so sorry but I am just not the right reader for this one. It was a bit too "open door" romance for my liking and I had a really hard time connecting with the characters. I did find myself wanting to take this amazing trip they were on and eat all the yummy food and drinks! But overall, this just isn't for me.

Casey McQuiston is an author I will return to again and again. Like returning home, their books bring me immense comfort. This was a lovely rekindling romance brimming with yearning and enduring love.

A great second-chance exes to lovers read. My first Casey McQuinston novel and I will definitely be reading more!