I enjoyed The Reappearance of Rachel Price, but it wasn’t Holly Jackson’s best work. The premise was intriguing, and there were some solid twists, but it lacked the same gripping intensity and sharp storytelling that made her previous books stand out. The pacing felt uneven at times, and while the mystery kept me engaged, it didn’t have the same edge-of-your-seat tension I was hoping for. That said, Jackson’s writing is still strong, and fans of her work will likely find it an enjoyable read—it just didn’t quite reach the high bar set by her past books.

Holly Jackson delivers another immersive and suspenseful read with The Reappearance of Rachel Price, a book that had me hooked from the very first page. Her atmospheric writing style kept me captivated, making it impossible to stop thinking about the story even when I wasn’t reading. Annabel "Bel" Price is a standout protagonist—witty, smart, and fiercely independent, with layers of depth that make her both relatable and compelling. Jackson masterfully weaves together a complex mystery filled with well-placed clues, interviews, and documentary-style notes that keep readers engaged and constantly second-guessing their theories. While I did predict one of the major twists, which left me slightly underwhelmed, another unexpected revelation completely caught me off guard and pulled me back into the thrill of the mystery. With minimal romance but plenty of sharp banter, this book prioritizes its gripping plot and intricate character development, making it an absolute must-read for thriller fans. 4 stars!

This book had been on my tbr for a long time. I tried to read it last year, but I just couldn’t get into it. I ended up listening to the audiobook version recently. I like Holly Jackson’s writing, but this was not my favorite book of hers.

The story felt too long and drawn out. I think I would have enjoyed it more if it was not as long. I didn’t really like the main character’s personality. She seemed rude and moody throughout the book.

The premise is pretty wild. A lot happens that is very unbelievable. The ending was crazy. I did enjoy the mystery.

Overall, this was just okay. I do enjoy the author’s writing, so I am interested in reading her other books.

Sixteen years ago, Rachel Price disappeared. Bel Price was a toddler, and the only witness. She only has vague memories of the day, but none of them are useful. Rachel is presumed dead and the case comes back to light when the family agrees to become the subject of a true crime documentary.

But then Rachel Price reappears, and the entire story is turned upside down. Rachel's story seems a little far-fetched, and Bel isn't sure she can trust her mother. Bel sets out to learn where Rachel really was all those years.

Holly Jackson outdid herself on this book. I wasn't as impressed with Five Survive, and I hoped that A Good Girl's Guide to Murder wouldn't be an anomaly. Luckily, I get to say that this book had me on the edge of my seat the ENTIRE time I read it. I'm not too deep into the true crime genre, but I love a good mystery/thriller. I highly recommend this book to people who love reading mysteries with complicated family dynamics and leading heroines with a chip on their shoulder.

I was unable to finish this book. What I read was interesting. It is on my TBR list still and I will probably finish it eventually, especially since there is now a series on Netflix.

I have never been let down by a Holly Jackson book! Just when I thought I had it, I was hit with a plot twist. More than once! I was sitting on the edge of my seat biting at my nails the whole time. Rachel disappeared 16 years ago and left her child in the backseat of her car. Bel, he daughter has grown up dealing with the consequences that followed after. Like her father being charged with Rachel's murder. But clearly that's not the case because she's back!

Very fast paced and the ending did it for me. The ending was great! Definitely kept me guessing throughout this book until the end.

I love everything Holly Jackson writes, so when I saw this one come available I HAD to have it!
The Reappearance of Rachel Price follows our main character Bel as she navigates being the center of a media frenzy focusing on the disappearance and reemergence of her mother, Rachel.
So much happens in this book, and I was HOOKED from the very beginning. The documentary plot is written in a captivating manner and would make for an excellent Netflix show! I thoroughly enjoyed unraveling the mystery, figuring out Rachel’s motives, and who to ultimately root for in the novel.

I recommend if you love solving puzzles and mysteries 👍👍🕵️🧩

Such a good book! I was on the edge of my seat and didn't know what direction it was taking at any point.

Thanks to Holly Jackson, Random House, and Netgalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review!

Twists & turns! Loved the adventure and would reccomend this to many people young & old! The characters were not perfect and felt very real. Enjoyed learning "the truth" as the story grew.

In my opinion, it was too long and predictable. I also didn’t care for the main character. But I finished and can see some people loving this one.

Holly Jackson never disappoints!!! This wasn’t what I was expecting at all and I loved every second of it. Couldn’t put it down. Plot twist was scary good!

It took me a little while to get into this book. I think all the hype kind of ruined it for me. I was expecting something different or something...more. But regardless it was still a good book. If you are going in with no expectations, then this is perfect for you but if you know the author then it felt different and almost rushed to me

Holly Jackson, best known for her A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder series, takes a bold turn into new territory with The Reappearance of Rachel Price. This standalone novel showcases Jackson’s trademark skill for weaving intricate suspense with deep emotional exploration, though it might surprise fans expecting another YA thriller in the same vein. The Reappearance of Rachel Price is a slow-burn psychological mystery that explores the fallout of a long-buried secret. The inclusion of the documentary film crew made the pacing more fun, while the propulsive ending was a fun ride!

This book is filled with twists and turns that keeps you guessing until the very end!

Holly Jackson just knows how to write a good mystery and The Reappearance of Rachel Price is no different! The story follows Bel, an 18 year old, whose mother went missing 16 years ago. Bel’s family agrees to be a part of a documentary about the disappearance of her mother. However, while in the midst of filming, Bel’s mother returns home. Suspicious of her mother reappearance, Bel starts taking a closer look at what happened 16 years ago.

The book does take a bit to pick up at the beginning, but once it does, it does not slow down. There are so many twists and turns and new clues that change the entire narrative of the story. I really enjoyed the way author was able to write these characters. One moment your rooting for them and then the next you are looking at their motives and seeing them in a different light. The mystery does take some time to unravel, but the build up was worth the wait. Everything was planned perfectly.

Thank you to Random House Children’s and NetGalley for giving me an ARC copy of the book. All opinions are my own.

This was my first Holly Jackson book and I immediately started reading her others once I was done. The suspense in the story made this one I couldn’t put down and I loved the twists at the end!

If Holly writes it I will read it. I was a little iffy at first but after the first 20% this really drew me in and the twist had my jaw in the floor.

The Reappearance of Rachel Price by Holly Jackson is a captivating thriller that delivers everything fans of the genre crave: suspense, secrets, and unexpected twists. Jackson masterfully weaves a tale of mystery surrounding Rachel Price’s sudden return after years of being presumed dead, keeping readers hooked with its unreliable characters and haunting atmosphere.

The narrative is compelling, and the slow unraveling of truths kept me engaged throughout. Jackson’s sharp writing and ability to build tension make it hard to put the book down. While some plot points feel slightly predictable or stretched at times, the emotional depth and strong character work more than make up for it.

Overall, this is an absorbing read with enough surprises to satisfy both loyal fans of Holly Jackson and newcomers to her work.

Thank you Random House Children’s and NetGalley for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.

Anything Holly Jackson writes, i truly enjoy! Thank you publishers for the ARC. I loved that the main character agreed to be a part of a true crime documentary because the novel read just like a true crime podcast/documentary. I was immediately hooked on the story and could not put the book down!

The twists & turns were great. Believability of the characters kept me reading, trying to decide what was what. I went back & forth between 3 and 4 stars but landed on 4. At times, I felt like it dragged but overall I enjoyed the read.