Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for granting me free access to the advanced digital copy of this book.

big fan of this book and the author, second in a related seiries, the period of time is built very well, loved all the cast of characters throughout

This year was the year of baseball romances and You Should Be So Lucky is at the top of my list. I love historical romances but there's not enough midcentury ones but Cat Sebastian never misses and she provided us with what we needed. This is an instant rec for anyone who loves baseball, journalism, and historical or queer romances.

I don't usually love historical fiction but this book was great! The setting was so fun to be a part of.

Thank you to Netgalley and the Publishing Company for this Advanced Readers Copy of You Should Be So Lucky by Cat Sebastian!

The second book in the Midcentury NYC series by Cat Sebastian. You Should Be So Lucky..... and this book could be so much better.

Wow, this is a delightful and heartwarming historical romance that whisks readers back to the vibrant and ever-changing landscape of 1980s London. From the moment I delved into this captivating tale, I was immediately drawn to the charming and endearing characters, Alex and Charlie. Their chemistry is palpable on every page, igniting a spark that keeps the reader engaged from beginning to end.

Sebastian's vivid storytelling brings the era to life, capturing the fashion, music, and social dynamics of the time with stunning accuracy. The author's attention to detail is impeccable, transporting readers to a bygone era while simultaneously exploring timeless themes of love, identity, and social class.

What truly sets this novel apart is its exploration of themes of class, privilege, and the fluidity of sexuality. Sebastian handles these sensitive topics with grace and sensitivity, creating a nuanced and authentic portrayal of the characters' experiences. The author's ability to balance humor, romance, and heartfelt emotion is truly impressive, leaving me with a warm and fuzzy feeling long after I finished the book.

If you're a fan of historical romance with a touch of contemporary flair, You Should Be So Lucky is an absolute must-read. It's a love letter to the 80s, a celebration of love in all its forms, and a reminder that love can conquer all.

This is one of my favorite romances I’ve ever read.
The slowburn
The emotion
The writing
Everything is beautifully well done.
Mark and Eddie absolutely captured my heart and made 400 pages feel like 100. This book could have gone on and on and I would have continued forever. Theres just the right amount of baseball, journalism, and love. I recommend to absolutely anyone.

Cat Sebastian is amazing. Another achingly romantic read with two outstanding characters. Maybe a little on the wordier side, but still so good.

Yet another winner by Cat Sebastian. This book was like a warm hug for my heart!! I couldn't put it down. I loved these characters and the portrayal of grief. It really pulled on my heart and had me longing for these characters to finally be happy.

Absolutely love anything by Cat Sebastian, and this is no exception. Will make you blush, cry, and laugh.

I thought this was very good and I will have to add this to the shop shelves. Thank you for the chance for us to review.

I LOVED this book. I am such a big fan of Cat Sebastian. I have read every single one of their books and this one is absolutely up there with my favorites. I love the specific world that this book is set in. I love the resilience of the queer community, even in times and environments that may not be so welcoming.

I really enjoyed the midcentury baseball feel of this story and found the characters entertaining.

Eddie is young, fun loving, and anxious when it comes to his baseball performance. He is incredibly friendly and doesn’t seem to know when to stop talking, something that can get him in trouble from time to time. But he can also keep a secret, namely that he’s gay.

Mark is anti-social, depressed and kind of grumpy, but it’s mostly from grief over his partner’s death and the fact that no one knew what they meant to each other. Mark is open with his sexuality with those he is close to and doesn’t want to be anyone’s secret again.

Eddie and Mark are perfect for each other. Their relationship is slow burn, starting purely professional, before turning to friendship, then more. Eddie is all in, but Mark worries about potential damage to Eddie’s career.

The people in Eddie and Mark’s life are all pretty great. Mark’s family disowned him when he came out to them, but he has found family in his friends, including an aging sports writer who knows (and keeps) their secret. Eddie’s support comes from an unexpected source and a close relationship with his mother.

Baseball is central to the story, which was a plus for this baseball fan.

Disclaimer: I received an eARC through Net Galley on behalf of the publisher for review consideration. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

I absolutely love this book so much. The characters, the story, the love. Will absolutely be thinking of this book for a very long time coming.

I was really expired to be starting on this one. I love baseball romance, and I loved the cover. But the characters didn't jive well. I felt no connection and that ruined the romance for me.

Many thanks to Net Galley and Avon and Harper Voyager for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I just love Cat Sebastian! She is able to create such authentic queer characters and give them a voice in a time that they were essentially voiceless. This particular series is my favorite of hers and I can't wait to see where she takes it next. You Should Be So Lucky is in my top ten of 2024.

You should Be So Lucky was such a sweet, tender story. And for someone who absolutely loves baseball, this was the perfect background for me! I enjoyed that a baseball player and a reporter--usually both just doing their jobs and coming together to be interviewed or ask questions--find something in each other. i truly enjoyed this book, and finished it feeling all the feels. I can't wait for more from Cat Sebastian!

Pretty much everything Cat Sebastian writes is utterly fantastic, and You Should Be So Lucky is no exception. I love that it's set during a time period not usually explored in the romance genre, and even as someone who knows nothing about baseball I was able to thoroughly enjoy it. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a slow-burn, grumpy-sunshine historical romance.

True rating: 3.5
I will start with saying that I perhaps came into this story with unreasonably high expectations based on how much I loved We Could Be So Good.
This book was very well-written (as always with Cat Sebastian) and the historical setting and references felt very authentic. I'm not an avid baseball fan, so I can't speak to how authentic the historical representation of the sport was, but I can say I enjoyed reading about baseball in the 1960s; It felt very nostalgic.
Mark and Eddie's relationship was really fun to follow. There is so much depth automatically added to queer romance when it's historical and set in a time when being out and open wasn't an option. I enjoyed their slow-burn romance along with the rich community that surrounded them throughout.

Slow burn
Found family
Historical romance (1960s NYC)
Queer romance
Nostalgia

I'd definitely recommend this book for all historical sports romance fans!
Thank you to the author, Avon and Harper Voyager, and NetGalley for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.