Member Reviews

Highly entertaining and a bit bonkers. Catalina is a lovable, hilarious, and chaotic lead and it was a pleasure to spend time with her.

Thank you very much to Random House and NetGalley for the opportunity to read a copy.

Was this review helpful?

The story is as complex as it is engaging. The author weaves past and present in an immersive way. I was with Catalina when she told us about her Ecuadorean family and their life in the US, when she interned for a magazine Queens, when she sought love among her classmates at Harvard, when she fought for her family. It was entertaining and compelling. I liked the style because it seemed to realistically portray the mindset of a young Latina.

Was this review helpful?

How can a book be so sad yet so funny! This author has a new fan.

I can’t say this enough, this book was so fun to read. Catalina is the star of this story, her narrative felt so real. She was chaotic, an unreliable narrator, a bit of a hot mess, and I loved it. This book does tackle difficult topics like grief and the immigrant experience in America, yet I found myself chuckling throughout. Well worth the read!

Thank you to NetGalley and One World for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

When Catalina begins at Harvard, she isn't sure what to expect - I wasn't either, being unfamiliar with Cornejo Villavicencio. A semi-autobiographical story enfolds as we follow the funniest, wittiest and most real college student I ever met! Catalina is undocumented. Her college is aware, but she keeps the secret close. It defines her as she thinks about almost every moment in every interaction of her life. Wouldn't you? She could be deported at any moment.

Living through Catalina's four years at Harvard were a breath of fresh air that I didn't know I needed. I loved her story, her realness and her sometimes crazy interactions. This story is not just about an undocumented and brilliant young woman - this story in many ways is about all undocumented young people as well as all young women! Grab this story, you won't be disappointed. Now to grad the UNAMERICANS next!
#KarlaCornejoVillavicencio #Randomhouse #catalina

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful book with deep insight into the anxieties and daily life of over 11 million people in the USA. This book is a very important reminder that immigrants matter and should be able to life with dignity and justice even if they aren't perfect. Karla managed to translate raw emotion of the frustration of a young person going through seeing the government shut down their opportunity to have one less hoop to jump through.

Was this review helpful?

Catalina explores themes like love, grief, depression, loneliness, perfectionism in a way that i connected to deeply.
i am not an immigrant but i am latina and the family dynamics are very well portrayed and the experiences
the beauty of this book is that she is an unreliable narrator and as a reader there was mystery to the story, she was flawed and sometimes had these trains of thought that went on but they’re so interesting and vulnerable that i just had to keep on reading even sometimes forgetting where in the story i was
it was an emotional book but surprisingly an easy read, the prose was fast paced and well written
there was a sentiment of nostalgia, regret and hope throughout the book that i enjoyed a lot

Was this review helpful?

Catalina by Karla Cornejo Villavicencio is a novel about a young undocumented immigrant from Ecuador who is admitted to Harvard University. The book covers her senior year, a time when she is struggling with the contrast between the elitist ivory tower and her life at home with grandparents who are also undocumented immigrants. This book challenged my thinking and captured my heart in the very best way.

I highly recommend this book. The writing is beautiful and accessible. I enjoyed getting to know Catalina from the first chapter of the book and I really hope that there will be a sequel.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing for an advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

DNF - I made my way through a decent portion of this book but, ultimately, I wasn't enjoying it. I liked the idea & I have many people to whom I would recommend but, for me it wasn't anything that drew me in or made me hungry to devour it in its entirety. I'm not sure why that is. Parts of the writing felt dry & rather more poised than I think was natural for the character so the story left me feeling as though it was stilted. Again, others will like this but, it just wasn't for me.

Was this review helpful?

I have been excited about this book since I first heard about it. If you know me, you know that my favorite book of all time is The Idiot by Elif Batuman, so Catalina was right up my alley. I really enjoyed the humor and Catalina's strange encounters at Harvard. There are so many generalizations about Latin America and undocumented immigrants that this book subverts, addresses head on, and humorously explores. This book read like a big whirlwind, but slowed down in the third act for me. I wish the end was a bit more fleshed out, but I enjoyed Catalina's voice so much I didn't mind all that much in the end. Overall, I am so glad I read this and I laughed out loud quite a few times.

Was this review helpful?

Karla Cornejo Villavicencio's "The Undocumented Americans" is one of my all-time favorite books, so I was so thrilled to read her fiction debut, especially since it was a campus novel.
Catalina is one of the most specific, well-developed characters I've read; I could picture her easily. I loved her sense of humor and reading the novel from her perspective. And Cornejo Villavicencio has an incredible sense of setting as the novel moved between Cambridge and Queens. That said, I did sometimes wish that there was more connection between the plot points -- this was a rare book that I felt could be longer because I would have loved to hear more from Catalina.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Random House Publishing Group - Random House, One World via NetGalley for providing me with this ARC! There were many ways I felt connected to this novel, particularly the depiction of how it feels to be a woman of color at an elite academic institution. The author weaved her commentary into the prose beautifully. There were aspects of this book I was more invested in than others, but overall it was a well balanced book that I enjoyed reading, especially from this author whose work I’ve read before.

Was this review helpful?

As a white woman reader, Catalina opened my eyes on the everyday world of others. The heavy baggage and legacies that some carry on a daily basis while we go on with our life. The life changing hurricane that is immigration and the ramifications of the laws. What about those the system forgot?

The story of that young woman of color, from modest origins, making her way through the elitist environment that is Harvard and the empty caring words and actions is eye opening. How often do we just give to a cause to make ourselves feel good and forget about it the next second. The other brings heavy subjects like generational trauma, abandonnent and identity quest.

This book, while short, hits right where it needs to. The journey of Catalina as she discovers her true self and try to break free from her past and the expectations of others was touching. We all go through that phase in life. But who does it when everything is on the line?

Was this review helpful?

There’s a gripping vulnerability to this book that isn’t lost amidst how funny the storytelling frequently is. The main character in this is absolutely chaotic in a way that is incredibly amusing, adds to the plot, but doesn’t distract from the commentary being made. This book felt nostalgic, frequently an amalgam of love, grief, longing, and humor. I don’t share any of the defining experiences that the main character goes through, but reading this book felt like a glimpse into the complicated emotions that such experiences might have brought about. I appreciated how plain the writing makes it that there is nuance to every feeling that Catalina has towards the circumstances of her existence. Every line of this book made me feel something, be it shock, outrage, sadness, amusement, or bewilderment. There were many topics addressed and parts of this book that were very heavy and emotional, and the author did a wonderful job of writing them so that they weren’t jarring or a screeching halt to the tone of the book, but rather simply another part of Catalina and her life for the reader to embrace.

None of the characters were definable by any one thing. They didn’t feel like archetypes and they evoked a multitude of emotions throughout the book. Even characters that I thought would act or respond to a situation in a certain way consistently surprised me. This book’s characters felt like real, unpredictable people, who were at times harsher, less shallow, or more easygoing than expected.

There were times when I felt that the timeline of the story was a bit confusing. Especially at the beginning of the book, things jump around a lot throughout the course of Catalina’s life, and I had a hard time pinning down what year it was when the story being told took place and determining if the story was being told by Catalina while was in her senior year or in retrospect by an older version of herself.

The story told was impressively complex and poignant; the fairly short number of pages it was written in do nothing to lessen its impact. The shifts in the narration take only as much time as necessary for clarity—it is a fast-paced story that I found impossible to be bored with. This is definitely outside of the genres and types of books that I normally read, but I’m genuinely so glad that I read it.

Thank you to Random House Publishing Groups & NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this ebook in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely gorgeous lit fic. It’s shockingly short though, NetGalley had it as <200 pages, so keep that in mind. Thanks for the arc

Was this review helpful?

Funny, smart, wry, and witty. "Catalina" is destined to become a campus-novel classic. It was a pleasure to spend time in the world of this novel.

Was this review helpful?