Member Reviews

I am having a hard time writing this review, not because the book is not worth reading but because it uses what I consider unnecessary expletives as if they are the norm. Even in this book where so many of the people are just not nice people, I find it impossible to believe that a famous, established author like Karin Slaughter needs 174 of one specific expletive to be spoken by almost every character including all of the "good guys".

Moving on from that, it really is a book in two halves. First half seems to be leading to an expected conclusion and the end of the book. Then, suddenly, everything moves up a notch or two and the second half then takes the blinkers off and things definitely turn out to be a lot more complicated than the first part suggested.

Expletives aside, this is a very nicely crafted tale which kept me engrossed to the last page, even though my hunch as to "who dun it" proved correct.

Was this review helpful?

Excellant thriller from Karin Slaughter. Will Trent and Sara Linton are looking to enjoy their honeymoon at a secluded mountain top retreat. But when one of the family running the retreat is found murdered you know it will be anything but the honeymoon they planned., The murderer could be any of the MacAlpine family - the victim said everyone on the mountain had a reason to want her dead,, and that is before they even consider the other guests. Pacy and dynamic this is top quality thriller writing.

Was this review helpful?

This is why we lied had a captivating start, straight in to the thick of it all.
Sara and Will are looking forward to their honeymoon, Will surprises Sara with a nice secluded lodge miles from anywhere, both working in law enforcement they decided to adopt new jobs to get away from it all for a week. What they didn’t bank on was a blood curdling scream dragging the truth about their profession out in the open. It’s in their blood though and seeing the reaction to the murder of the lodge manager Mercy McAlpine the duo get to work at trying to solve the case. With so many suspects will they ever learn the truth?

This book was exactly what I was expecting from Karin Slaughter, it was well written with the suspense built beautifully. I felt like all the characters were developed well, allowing me to really understand them.

I really enjoyed this read and cannot wait to read another from her collection. I will be recommending this book.

Thank you NetGalley for the advanced reading copy.

Was this review helpful?

This is only the second book I’ve read in the Will Trent series but I really like how accessible they are even if you haven’t read all the previous books.
I really enjoyed the story behind this one and the characters where really interesting however I did feel it was dragged out in parts and could have done to be just a bit shorter.
Overall a great story just a tad too descriptive in parts.

Was this review helpful?

I guessed the ending way too early on and it kind of ruined the rest of the book for me.

This is a very slow burn so if, like me, you’re not the biggest fan of thrillers that take too long to get to the point, this might not be your cup of tea.

I still enjoyed the writing style and the plot but this is definitely not my favourite book by this author.

Was this review helpful?

She’s done it again!!!

Karin Slaughter is nothing short of a genius. Just when you think, surely her books can not get any better, she smashes the next one out of the park.

The detail and research Slaughter must put into her books is outstanding.

Massive five stars.

Was this review helpful?

Before I start the review, I just need to say, WOW!

This is Why We Lied is the latest in the long running Will Trent and Sara Linton series. I know the characters, having read some of the series, but I am not fully up to date with it. This didn’t matter in the slightest, this book works wonderfully well as a gripping, dark standalone.

The McAlpine family have proudly run their lodge for 7 generations. They are a ‘close’ family, but the tensions within this unusual family dynamic run deep.
Will and Sara are on their honeymoon, yes, they’ve got married. They are staying at an idyllic, secluded, luxury cabin, set in thousands of acres of trees. It sounds blissful, a perfect setting for them to unwind from their stressful careers, and start their married life. Until late at night, they hear a scream, followed by a harrowing plea for help.

The characters are so well crafted and portrayed, that some made my skin itch, others increased my blood pressure to an unhealthy level, while a few I wanted to scoop up and protect from the world.
This is Why We Lied is compulsive, gripping and very intense. It is a story of long held secrets, guilt for some, and judgement by others; of small town gossip tainting lives, of never being able to escape once the die is cast.

I have to give a specific mention to the conclusion of the book, obviously without giving away any spoilers. The denouement is so horrifying and shocking. The use of the dual timeline, allows us to see the events, and feel the intensity of the emotions, alongside poor Mercy.
For me, This is Why We Lied, is a 5⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️➕ read/listen, her best book; a must read for thriller lovers.

Was this review helpful?

Yet another entertaining read from author, Karen Slaughter.

The amazing thing for me was that almost all the characters (goodies and baddies) had such traumatised lives! I wonder if that is a reflection of society nowadays. In comparison I have a lot to be grateful for!

The plot was incredibly complex and evolved at a natural pace as we found out more about the characters and their relationship. I felt incredibly sorry for Mercy. I could hardly understand the progressive hardships she faced while growing up before getting in involved in a toxic relationship! Poor Mercy!

It is also worth mentioning the location! It showed that despite being idyllic the isolation brought its own problems!

All in all another successful book involving Will Trent and Sara Linton on their honeymoon. Can I nominate Sara for a knighthood or sainthood! An amazing role model!

Was this review helpful?

Another good book in this series, which I enjoyed but maybe not as much as the previous ones I have read. Set in a remote hillside locate Will and his new bride escape to a honeymoon retreat, only to be faced by his old nemesis Dave, bringing back difficult memories from their shared childhood in care.

The story of the death of Mercy and the horrific life she led with abuse, incest, rape and murder was at times a very difficult read. The writing is gripping and you cannot fail to want to read to the end but I was disturbed by some of the outcomes and skipped through some of the end wrapping up parts and they were quiet graphic.

A good read but may be triggering for those susceptible to abuse within a family and care setting.

Thanks to Netgalley, the publisher and the author for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

It's the first time I've read a book by Karin Slaughter. To be honest, I was a bit disappointed plot-wise, as you half expect Miss Marple or Poirot to pop out mid page in the true sense of an Agatha Christie plot. Because that's what the plot of this book basically is - a dozen people stuck in a train, or a castle, or a house on the med.....in this case a holiday camp......all with the motive to kill one poor soul, who then gets killed, then classic whodunnit. So plot-wise, very far from original.

I did enjoy the read. Character development is very good, so I felt I understood some of the main characters. But I'd need to read something else by this very famous author to see if there are other books with more original plot lines.

Was this review helpful?

An idyllic mountain retreat for the wealthy hides a multitude of secrets within the family that runs it, Will & Sara arrive for their honeymoon as tensions are bubble surface and Mercy McAlpine (the daughter who runs it) is murdered on their first night. As Will, Sara and the GBI team investigate her murder they uncover so much more.

I didn't realise this was the 2nd book in the series, it reads brilliantly as a stand alone story but has made me want to read the first book.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for allowing me to read This is Why We Lied.

Was this review helpful?

This book was ok but half way through I was starting to get bored and wasn’t bothered about who had killed Mercy. It did pick up towards the end and I liked the big reveal. Thanks to NetGalley for my ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I have read another book in this series and enjoyed it, this one was OK. The main issue that I had with it, was that it was too long and too wordy. I like description about people and surroundings but in this book it got repetitive. The crimes are committed in an isolated camp, so the suspect must still be around. There are plenty of motives and the family running the camp are fairly disfunctional, with the local Sheriff in their pocket. The first murder is quite soon in the book, so there doesn't seem to be much interaction between Will and Sara once their investigation got going.
Quite a lot of triggers here too including child abuse, rape and extremely mixed up family relationships. It was a chore to finish the book and the plot was quite stretched out and confusing so it took some thinking about what was relevant and what not.
Thanks to Net Galley for the ARC , not a bad read, but have read better

Was this review helpful?

Just love this Will Trent series.
Many thanks to NetGalley UK, HarperCollins UK and Headline Books for this ARC which came at exactly the right time for me as I was reading book number 11 at the time I saw this available to request.
Will and Sarah are on their honeymoon in the mountains when things quickly go wrong and they find themselves with quite literally a murder on their hands. There is also a side story relating to Will’s childhood which was an excellent addition and compliments the storyline.
I feel like I’ve missed out on their wedding, though there is reference to it at the start of the book, but I love these characters so much, I hope there are further details to come in future books.
The twists and turns at the end were many and unexpected.
A great read. Already looking forward to Book 13.
This Is Why We Lied will be published on 20th August 24.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely fantastic as expected from Karin Slaughter. Fast paced with plenty of tension and twists I couldn’t put this down until I finished.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the ARC in return for my honest and unbiased opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Karin Slaughter does it again. It lived up to the hype and of course i will read anything this author writes.

Great read, Great Suspense, Great Character build. I could write a review all day of her novels.

Thanks NetGalley for letting me read and review.

Was this review helpful?

Will and Sara are on their honeymoon enjoying a cabin stay close to a location from Will's past. Of course as its these two they soon find themselves caught up in a murder. There's a lot of anger and secrets at this idyllic site but what is the truth and who killed Mercy.

Wow what a ride this was. You just don't know who did what until the end. I think I figured it out just before Will did and what a genius twist that was. This is the newest installment in the series and definitely one of the best ones. I was hooked from the start. Plus I'm a sucker for the relationship between Will and Sara. I love how healthy and sweet it is in this one. They have some great moments and brilliant lines together. The ending was so good especially the very last few lines. A brilliant addition to the series. Karin Slaughter is a go to reader for me and I always look forward to her new stories. A dark and twisted thriller.

Was this review helpful?

This was a twisty tail of a murder in the mountains. An entire cast of unlikable characters, coupled with Tragic life choices by the murder victim.

I enjoyed this story, and was intrigued when I heard had that there would be another murder, and wondered what was going on, and why nobody seemed to care.
I believe this book was too long as I was beginning to lose interest before I reached halfway, however it was well written and The story fleshed out the character as well.
Thanks to #NetGalley For the opportunity to have read this book ahead of publication and exchange for an honest review. Apologies for the late review.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book - it really lived up to the expectations. Thank you to the writer, publisher, and NetGalley for allowing me to review this book.

Was this review helpful?

Just when I was thinking "not another abusive family" scenario Ms Slaughter comes up with this brilliant book including some really nasty family members. Not only that Will Trent, a GBI Investigator and his wife Sara a medical examiner. are on their honeymoon in a mountain lodge with other lodges nearby, some occupied.

The lodge complex is managed by Mercy McAlpine and the whole secretive family are involved in the business all of whom are not the nicest people! What a story unfolds with the murder of Mercy! Will takes over the investigation leaving the honeymoon to one side..

No more spoilers as the more Will uncovers, the twists and turns unfold in typical Ms Slaughter fashion.

Loved it!

Thanks to Net Galley and Harper Collins UK for the chance to read and review a brilliant murder mystery.

Was this review helpful?