Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you NetGalley for the ARC of This is Why We Lied by Karin Slaughter in return for my honest review. This is the next instalment in the Will Trent and Sara Linton series although you can read this as a standalone I would highly recommend reading all the books in this series you defiantly won’t be disappointed.
I was so excited to read this as I love all of Karin Slaughters books and this one did not disappoint.
While on their honeymoon Will and Sara find themselves investigating a murder, there are lots of really interesting characters, a few red herrings and plot twists, this is a well thought out closed room thriller.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks for the ARC copy. Another fantastic installment in the Will Trent series.

Will and Sara have finally got married and found the happiness we’ve all been routing for for them. However even they can’t get away with a romantic honeymoon on a mountain getaway. The strange McAlpine family own the retreat and the amount of secrets they hold just keep coming as one of them is murdered. Not one to let justice go unserved Will can’t rest until , with the help of Sara Faith and Amanda, the murderer is arrested.

This one took a while for me to get into if I’m honest but once it did it was non stop. If, like me, you’ve read and loved this series this is another 5 star addition to the series and I can’t wait for the next.

Was this review helpful?

This books is an incredible thriller that’s perfect for summer reading. It follows Willl and Sara as they start their honeymoon well but it turns into a murder investigation. Who is involved? The motives soon become clear and this is the best thriller I’ve read in a long time!

Was this review helpful?

#ThisIsWhyWeLied #NetGalley I love this series and this book did not dissappoint. It had me hooked from the very first chapter. Although part of a series, it can be read as a stand alone but I think the reader would get more enjoyment knowing more of the back stories of Will, Sara, Amanda, Faith etc. This book had so much going on and so many twists and turns that it kept me turning the pages VERY late into the night!! I can't wait for the next installment in this series. A very well deserved 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

This was a little slower paced than I’d have liked and I felt like there was a lot going on aside from the whodunnit - maybe this is part of the series, I’m coming in on book12 but I felt it took away from the flow a bit. It was dark and I liked the plot but the reveal felt a little flat and overall it felt like a longer than necessary read unfortunately!

Was this review helpful?

This is a typical Will Trent book with a locked room twist and I loved it!
Will and Sara have gone to the mountains for a getaway. This cabin resort has been in the McAlpine family for generations with Mercy McAlpine taking the reins after her fathers accident. Mercy has worked hard to turn her life around after years of abuse, drugs and alcohol. She just wants the best for her son.
On the first night, Will discovers Mercy in the water with multiple stab wounds. Most of the people there have a motive - so who killed Mercy?

A locked room mystery by one of my favourite authors in my favourite book series… yes please! I have been a fan of Slaughter for years now so I know what to expect. The start of the book is slower paced but this is to set the scene and get to know the other characters. But the pace does pick up and boy, is it a whirlwind of twists and she keeps you guessing until near the end as to who killed Mercy.
Her family are toxic, full of secrets and betrayal, and you can’t help but sympathise with Mercy and her life choices. The inclusion of Mercy’s letters to her son broke my heart and my emotions swayed between anger and disgust for her family, sadness for how some of the characters grew up and of course, love for Will and Sara.

Was this review helpful?

Oooh, I’ve missed Will and Sara - Will Trent is definitely one of my all time favourite leading men. And I mean, what’s a honeymoon without at least one dead body?

Ms Slaughter, as always you have played it perfectly, This is Why We Lied is a perfect blend of taught writing, great characters, super twisty plot and oodles of heart.

Thanks to Netgalley for providing an advanced book and audiobook in exchange for an honest review. It is the best way to immerse yourself in a book to be able to read and listen to it, the narration is excellent and breathes new life into the experience. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

This book sees return of Will Trent and Sara Linton, who while on honeymoon find themselves investigating a murder at McAlpine Family Lodge.
Starts slow but develops into a well paced thriller, horrific murder with countless suspects. Would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Once again, the author has delivered another nail biting, stomach churning read.
A house and cabins in a remote location, hard to get to. A totally dysfunctional family owning and running the place with paying guests.
A murder, a cover-up, what has Will Trent and his wife walked into?
I could not put it down!

Was this review helpful?

I previously enjoyed False Witness by Karin Slaughter so I was excited to read her latest book – This Is Why We Lied. I didn’t realise this was part of the Will Trent series when I requested it (number 12 in fact!), so this is my first read in this series.

I love that Karin Slaughter is such an assured author, you can be certain that any read of hers is well plotted, pacey and with a gripping plot. This Is Why We Lied is no exception - Will and Sara are on their honeymoon and find themselves in the midst of an investigation. Mercy is found dead in her own secluded resort - there’s no end of suspects as her family all resent her for various reasons, but who has the most to gain?

This Is Why We Lied is a classic locked room mystery, there’s a large cast of characters, all well defined with various motivations and a lot of red herrings in there for good measure. Just when you think you have it figured out, a curve ball is thrown in which has you questioning everything again! There’s perhaps a bit of an influx of characters which can be hard to get your head around – the family is large and then there are all of the guests, as well as a lot of investigators who come in to try and solve the case. Some of this might be easier if you’ve read other Will Trent stories as you’ll know the investigation team already. The book does work as a standalone for those who haven’t read any of the other books in the series, but if you have then there’s a lot of backstory and character development that happens as well.

The narrative alternates between Will, Sara, Faith and Amanda, with some letters from Mercy thrown in as well. This helps to keep the pace high throughout and I raced through the book to see what would happen next. I actually didn’t see the twist coming and it is very shocking!

Overall, This Is Why We Lied is another masterclass in crime thriller writing from Karin Slaughter. Thank you to NetGalley & Harper Collins UK – Harper Fiction for the chance to read the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I can’t never get enough of the Will Trent and Sara Linton series and in this twelfth book they are at last married (how long have I been waiting for this?!). And, for their honeymoon, Will chose a luxury cabin in a remote family-run resort in the mountains a few hours from Atlanta. But what was supposed to be a relaxing week of romance, hiking, yoga, fishing, and canoeing is interrupted on the first night when the resort manager, Mercy McAlpine, is found stabbed by the lake. With no easy access to the resort, the family and the other guests are all suspects and it seems that they are all keeping secrets. And since leading the investigation is an incompetent sheriff influenced by years of prejudices against the victim, Will and Sara call his partner Faith and his boss Amanda for help.

Let me start by saying that this is not an easy read. It’s gripping and suspenseful and immersive, but it’s not for the light-hearted. There are themes of abuse, assault, alcohol and drug abuse, and toxic family relationships. The story is told from many perspectives, including the victim as we relive her last day and discover the events that led to her murder. For Will, the investigation is more personal than usual as one of the suspects is someone from his past and brings back up memories of his childhood and the mother he never met. He’s backed by three strong-minded and resolute women. His partner Faith who doesn’t think twice about giving up her much awaited week off to help him; his boss Amanda who would rather he enjoyed his honeymoon; and his now-wife Sara, who supports him in everything, even when he dangerously jumps in a river to save someone. I love these two characters. They are adorable together and, after many years of problems, miscommunications, and past loves coming between them, they are happy together (murder aside, of course).

This Is Why We Lied is another intense and incredible novel by Karin Slaughter (she can’t ever do wrong). A remote location, murder, dysfunctional family, and secrets and many many twists will keep you glued to the page until the very end!

Was this review helpful?

I've read and loved the entire Will Trent series, but the last few books just haven't been as good as they could have been. I enjoyed this one more than book 11, since this one was finally focused on an investigation again rather than personal drama, but it still isn't the best Karin Slaughter can do.

The first half was super slow, the structure was kind of weird and confusing with the chapters in the past and then the letters and a little hard to follow. The plot picked up in the second half, it was very typically Slaughter's style and I always enjoy her endings and plot twists. Overall it turned out to be a fine book but this series should end soon, there's not much more to say.

Was this review helpful?

Where does Karin Slaughter get her ideas from? Yet another brilliant, thrilling, gripping murder mystery that was written in such an easy flowing style. A family owning and working together at a remote mountain resort, none of them with any redeeming features, in fact totally dislikeable, are all under suspicion when one of the family are found brutally murdered. As their back stories are revealed we see they are very dysfunctional family and almost everyone of them is under suspicion. Unfortunately for them, Will and his new wife Sarah are honeymooning there and having discovered the body Will quickly springs in to action to mobilise the relevant team, much to the annoyance of the local officer.
A fabulous page turning read, quite sad at times as the past is exposed and the murderer revealed.

Was this review helpful?

Though this is the twelfth book in the Will Trent series, this could easily be read as a standalone murder-mystery.

However if you’ve read the previous eleven it will make so much sense that Sara and Will were never going to get a normal honeymoon!

The story centres around the McAlpine family who are as complex as they are cruel. The author has a gift for creating broken characters to love and I felt an immediate affinity for Mercy.

I really did enjoy figuring out each mystery just before the author revealed them but the reality was I was blindly following cleverly placed breadcrumbs and kept being surprised!

The denouement was, as always, a masterpiece. A twisted, gory, harrowing masterpiece which is everything I’ve come to expect from a Karin Slaughter novel.

Thank you to NetGalley and HarperCollinsUK for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Darkly exhilarating and exhilaratingly dark, This is Why We Lied is another thrilling instalment in Karin Slaughter's Will Trent series. Even if you haven't read the entire series, this book stands strong on its own, making it accessible for newcomers.

Slaughter excels at peeling back the layers of her characters, exposing the darkest corners of their lives. While I managed to guess the culprit early on, the motive behind the murder was a shocking twist that kept me hooked. The book is packed with gut-wrenching moments and Slaughter’s signature ability to deliver surprise after surprise.

For fans of dark, multilayered thrillers that delve into the depths of human depravity, This is Why We Lied is a must-read. Karin Slaughter has crafted another page-turner that will leave you reeling and eagerly anticipating her next masterpiece.

Was this review helpful?

GBI Agent Will Trent and medical examiner Sara Linton are finally married and on their honeymoon. Will chose the venue and organised the bookings so it’s a surprise to Sara when their destination is a Georgia wilderness mountain lodge instead of an exotic beach or overseas location.

Sara is more than happy with Will’s choice when she sees their accommodation. A gorgeous cottage complete with mod cons in a serene, idyllic setting with stunning views from every room. With only four other couples booked in for the week, a range of activities from yoga to hiking, canoeing and fishing and a gourmet chef preparing delicious meals, their week should be blissful and relaxing. However, when screams are heard in the night and Will finds a woman brutally stabbed at the side of the lake, they realise this is not going to be the break they both needed so much.

The wilderness lodge has been in the McAlpine family for generations. The current patriarch, one of the nastiest and most unpleasant of men, Cecil McAlpine is wheelchair bound after an accident on a hiking trail and the lodge has since been successfully managed by his daughter Mercy McAlpine, despite his open disdain for her. It is Mercy who Will finds, rapidly bleeding out from multiple wounds. She had a very humiliating row with her teenage son Jon at dinner that night in front of all the guests and with her last breaths asks Will to tell him that she loves him and ask him to forgive her.

Will and Sara are shocked when they break the news of Mercy’s death to the McAlpines, who barely seem upset and care only for the business they could lose over cancelled bookings. The more Will finds out about the family and the way they have all treated Mercy in the past, the more toxic he realises they are. She has suffered abuse, violence and contempt all her life from people who should have loved and protected her. Her story is so tragic and sad that it’s difficult not to feel heartbroken for her.

With the local sheriff seemingly disinterested in finding Mercy’s killer and a raging storm destroying communications and the only road to the lodge, Will reaches out to his GBI boss, Amanda and his partner Faith who arrive to take control of the investigation. Together they uncover a history of hidden crimes and shocking lies perpetuated by the family and abetted by the local sheriff and his predecessor. With multiple suspects, including the other guests as well as the McAlpine family, it all makes for a gripping and intensely dark locked room thriller.

Was this review helpful?

I've read some Karin Slaughter but not a lot of Will Trent. I don't feel like I have missed anything but there is a bit of a spoiler for someone who has watched the first two seasons of the show without reading more than a couple of the early books. A lot is going on here. But there is a grit to the story that does not gloss over anything. The characters often have horrible trauma. It was a study in how different people react to those traumas. I really want to go back and read the books I have missed now.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for my copy of this e-arc!

Literally no idea where to start except I think this book is 5 stars? It’s twisty, immersive, descriptive and captivating. I read it in 2 sittings. I couldn’t stop reading, I didn’t want to put it down at all.

The whole plot is fast paced, you’re always guessing what might happen and who done it. You just keep getting bits of the clues and you keep thinking it’s this or that when you get another clue to divert you!

Amazing story writing and telling, every detail was perfectly placed for an amazing reading experience. A truly amazing time I had with this book and I did not expect the end at all, if it was guessed - props to you!

A must-read!

Was this review helpful?

This Is Why We Lied by Karin Slaughter is the twelfth in the series featuring Will Trent, but also features his (new) wife Sara Linton - who of course has starred in a couple of Slaughter's series. Here the pair have just gotten hitched and Will decided to take Sara to a remote glamping spot - one he yearned to visit as a child in a foster care group home nearby. Of course they stumble into some family drama and when there's a murder on their first night the pair feel duty-bound to seek justice for the victim.

As the backcover blurb indicates there are a few lies on offer here, one of which comes compliments of Sara and Will who have lied to the hosts about their professions... given the usual responses they're met with. But there are many other secrets festering as well and Will is confronted by his past (again) as he crosses paths with a bully from the foster home who was kinda adopted by the family who own the lodge and its grounds.

This is a really clever whodunnit. I was kinda sad about the victim as Mercy was one of the few likeable characters amongst the host family and other guests. As usual Slaughter adds in some surprises in this novel which also features hefty family baggage and tragic legacies that are passed down through generations when they should be thwarted at the first opportunity.

Was this review helpful?

Who doesn’t love Will Trent …

Why we lied sees his return to investigate the murder of Mercy McAlpine the daughter of a socialite who whilst staying at the secluded McAlpine lodge threatens to reveal all the secrets she keeps of the other guests staying …

Another great crime solving mystery - and we see Will marrying Sarah ( finally ) same racing against the clock to find the killer pace - just brilliant

Thank you @netgalley !

Was this review helpful?