Mel and Cole have gotten a divorce. Cole has gone off and moved to an island to start a new life as a park ranger. Cole wanted kids. Mel and Cole tried IVF, but it didn't work out
Cole doesn't like having sex the traditional way. He would rather play like he's a burglar where he breaks into the home and even puts his hand over their mouth with intercourse
On the island, he meets Lenny, who lives in the cottage on the beach.
At the same time, some women who are marching for women's rights have disappeared
Is Cole the person he says he is. A good guy? Is the divorce really Mel's fault? Or does Cole have more underlying things that are hidden beyond what can be seen

I’m deliberately leaving my review vague and including the synopsis above. This is defiantly one that the less you know before going in the better. One of the Good Guys is brilliantly written, I loved it … I know there have been mixed reviews, and after reading it, I can understand the controversy - made me love it more!

In its essence it’s a modern tale of how women are treated by stupid men, and to be fair, visa versa … it’s about about prejudices, gender bias, stereotypes and complex relationships. All the characters are unlikable (although, I think that’s the point) and while it’s a slow burn to begin with, it’s a book that demands your attention. I honestly couldn’t put it down.

It’s thought provoking, it’s bold, it’s clever and it’s creatively entertaining.
4.5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫

“But the truth is, men who want to protect women should never be trusted because we only feel the impulse to protect the things we think of as weaker than ourselves.”

Many thanks to the wonderful team @macm for a #gifted copy 💌 Thanks to @dreamscape for an ALC 🎧 - the full cast of narrators was brilliantly executed.

This book, "One of the Good Guys" by Araminta Hall, stirred up a lot of emotions for me, although I'm still figuring out how I feel about it. The story revolves around "good guy" Cole, his soon-to-be ex-wife Melanie, and his encounters with an artist named Leonora.

The narrative offers different viewpoints with time jumps and mixed media, which added to the unfolding of the story. While some reviewers may have anticipated the direction of the book, I found the twists to be genuinely surprising.

It's tough to discuss without spoilers and be aware that it delves into controversial topics. While I understand the author's intentions, some elements felt a bit overwhelming. The ending was particularly powerful, making it a great choice for book club discussions. This book combines mystery with literary fiction, and I suggest checking for potential triggers before reading.

I listened to this and was loved the experience, especially the variations in narration that included emails, phone calls, and more!

Thank you to Netgalley and Gillian Flynn Books for the audiobook!

This book is the epitome of book club fiction - a topic that will get people fired up!

This book centres around all the ways that ‘nice guys’ still cause harm to women. It served its purpose in getting me irritated. I would listen to it on my drive to work, and then spend my day extra annoyed with all the ways I had to compensate for male incompetence in my day. Hall did a great job of writing this guy who on paper seemed to be doing the right thing, but was blind to all the ways he was forcing his version of right on his wife.

I enjoyed the first section, but didn’t love how it went after that. As an audio, the narrators did a great job of bringing all the multimedia to life, however it was just too much. It felt like Hall was trying to cover every angle and possible counterargument. I personally enjoy books where the author has their own take, and brings that theme to life, rather than sticking to all the buzz words. Also, as women we are perfectly aware of the issues and don’t need the reminder, what we need is a way to create change!

This is a quick read if you are interested and want to be part of the convo, but just be prepared to spend that time feeling very annoyed!

Thank you to NetGalley, Dreamscape Select and Gillian Flynn Books for an ARC of this book, out as of January 9th, 2024.

3.5 stars

Actual Rating: 2.5⭐

This book has a unique format, there’s transcript of a recorder, news reporter and also reddit and twitter posts which makes the listening experience felt different than other audiobooks I’ve listened to before.

The topics brought up in this book are important and very thought-provoking. While I do agree of some of the arguments, but there are some that I didn’t agree as well.
I wasn’t a huge fan of the characters but it’s fascinating to listen to Cole and Mel’s POV as they talks about their marriage. They go through the same event but both of them feel and view things differently.

The narrators did a great job because I feel like I’m actually listening to the news and podcasts. The walk-through exhibit was a great touch, I can feel the dark and tense atmosphere through Lennie's art.
However, I had difficulties in differentiating between the two female narrators as Lennie and Mel. I got confused because I didn’t know which POV I’m listening to until I listened to it further.

This one is slightly personal but I wish the narrators spoke aloud the number of chapter so I know when a chapter ended because I felt annoyed when I had to paused it in a middle of a chapter. When I resumed it later, I got confused of what they’re talking about.

I really want to like this one but I felt disappointed since it wasn’t what I expected it to be.
I thought the focus would be on the two missing girls mentioned on the blurb but as I listened further into this book, it’s not. The mystery is barely there and the big reveal about what happened to those girls fell flat and weird.

This book sounds promising and has the potential to be a good one but I didn’t fully enjoy the whole execution. Some parts felt slow and excessive for me.
This book didn’t work out for me, but it might be a good one to be read in a book club so you could discuss some of the issue brought up in this psychological thriller book.

I received an advanced audiobook copy for free through Netgalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

This was an interesting book about someone who was perceived as one of the good guys had many twists and turns but they were easy to follow it was well written and the narrated was very good I would recommend the book for anyone who enjoys mystery

One of the Good Guys, written by Araminta Hall, is a book that explores the themes of trust, deception, and complex relationships. The story revolves around the consequences of keeping secrets and how they can impact individuals and their relationships with others. As the story progresses, the reader is introduced to three different characters, each providing their perspective. While Cole and Mel's story was understandable, given their history, Leonora's involvement with the couple was quite odd. Despite understanding her motives and the "cause" she was fighting for, it was inappropriate to involve Cole in her "art" in the way she did. Cole's actions were creepy, and they turned public opinion against Leonora, making Cole a victim and more desirable to women.

I must say that I had higher expectations from the plot, and I anticipated a more satisfying and conclusive ending. Although the novel had a decent start, the sudden and incomplete conclusion failed to meet my expectations, and it left me feeling disappointed.

Thank you, NetGalley, for the free advanced copy of the novel. I received it in exchange for my honest review.

This is a queasy messy offering from Araminta Hall that is certain to divide readers, none of the characters are even remotely likeable, and all are wrong, with extreme self serving agendas and machinations that made me deeply uncomfortable. I listened to this on audio, approximately 8 hours long, narrated ably by the cast of Elliot Fitzpatrick, Olivia Vinall and Helen Keeley, immersing the reader in the dark and unsettling storytelling. Cole has recently relocated to the south as a wildlife ranger on the coast, escaping the city and his failed marriage to Mel, hoping for new beginnings, revelling in wild swimming and outdoor living. As we are introduced to him, he gives off the air of being one of the good guys, polite and respectful of what women want, a man who went over and beyond for Mel in his marriage.

However, you do get a strong sense that all is not quite right, but what? We then have Mel's account, going briefly back through the years until the marriage turned toxic. Who do we believe in this he says, she says? Close to where he now lives, there is cottage dramatically close to the cliff edge, in which resides reclusive, working class artist, Leonara/Lennie, a woman that Cole becomes close to. At the same time, there is a controversial publicised fundraising protest walk by Mollie and Phoebe, aimed at highlighting the everyday violence and dangers women face from men. The two women go missing, last seen by Cole, triggering a massive search for them. Through escalating tensions, we are deluged by the judgements and trolling on social media, laying bare disturbing aspects of how many in society view women.

Did I enjoy reading this? I am afraid I did not, normally a novel drawing attention to the inbalance in the power structures that women face is one I would applaud, particularly when it examines attitudes perceived to be held by the 'good guys', but this went too far, stepping into murky, unethical, and for me, unacceptable territory to makes its points, thereby compromising the points it made. However, it succeeds in raising the much needed important themes, raising sufficient issues and controversies to get the topics discussed, such as in bookclubs etc.. I recommend this psychological thriller to other readers interested in , and particularly point to the audio. Many thanks to Dreamscape Select for the ALC.

I really enjoyed this book, especially all the mixed media sources in the second half of the book. That was a very bold and entertaining way to progress with the storyline.
Didn't really come to like any of the characters, but I don't think it's a problem, because they were all radical and desperate to reach their goals. The narrators did a bloody brilliant job.
Thank you for the ALC for Netgalley, the writer and the publisher.

I really struggled this one. It just seemed like a political push. As a female, i appreciate the acknowledgement of the struggles of female issues and all that but it was just overboard too. I think more subtly would have made it more enjoyable.

I went back and finished. I had initially planned to DNF this. But i got to part 2 and there was a pov shift. Which i was grateful for!!

I really appreciate what this book was trying to do. It was very female forward and i agree with a lot of things that were discussed here.

The ending was a little surprising and im unsure how i feel about it. But i i liked it much more after leaving Coles pov.

This is one of those books that’ll stick with you for a while. A thriller brimming with truth. Women, afraid for a multitude of reasons and men who are oblivious to their part in causing the fear. Narcissism, gaslighting, and selfishness are three things Cole does well but, of course, he doesn’t see it that way. Thankfully, there are some women in his life who are happy to show him.

Clever, twisty, and pertinent, this is definitely one to add to your list! Especially if you are in a book club or have a group of friends you enjoy reading with. I promise you, there will be much to discuss!

The audiobook narrated by Elliot Fitzpatrick, Olivia Vinall, and Helen Keeley immediately pulled me in and it was easy to binge this one in a day! The short chapters and multiple points of view on top of the relatable plot make for a binge-worthy read!

***This review, expressing my honest opinion, is voluntary, and I extend my gratitude to Dreamscape Select, Gillian Flynn Books, and NetGalley for providing the Audio-ARC***

This book delves into the intricate dynamics of gender relationships, with a particular focus on how men interact with women. Navigating through the complexities of this theme, especially in the polarized landscape of conflicting perspectives, proves challenging. Despite its vast scope, the book exhibits some commendable qualities.

As a thriller, the initial half, narrated from Cole's perspective, captivates with its insightful portrayal of his mindset. Witnessing the rationale behind his actions is eye-opening, evoking both sympathy and discomfort. Mel's viewpoint, offered in brief glimpses throughout the years, effectively illustrates the evolution of their relationship. Although the eventual revelations from her perspective weren't surprising, the anticipation for what lay ahead was palpable.

The narrative takes a slower turn when two activist women disappear, leading to a somewhat less engaging final section. The inundation of social media posts and news articles, while emphasizing the polarized discussions, may have been excessive. However, the conclusion skillfully brings together different viewpoints, providing a satisfying resolution to the raised questions.

If you're curious about the intricacies of how individuals perceive themselves as 'good guys' or wish to explore a world filled with hatred and prejudices, this book is worth a read. A trigger warning for detailed descriptions of IVF treatments is advised. 'One of the Good Guys' might not be my favorite of the year, but it stands out as a thought-provoking and visionary piece.

What sets it apart is the nuanced portrayal of imperfect characters who challenge moral boundaries. Each character's voice resonates strongly, making it difficult to align with any one perspective. The narrative not only presents multiple viewpoints but also integrates forums, news coverage, talk shows, and social media posts, adding a realistic layer.

The author fearlessly tackles issues such as misogyny, consent, BDSM, sex shaming, feminism, and violence against women in an authentic manner, avoiding clichés. The narrative authentically reflects the fears that even strong women may harbor, especially when facing perceived loss.

The plot revolves around Cole, who considers himself a 'good guy.' Recently separated from his wife, the story explores the aftermath of a seemingly violent act and its connection to two missing activists. Cole's perspective is complemented by Mel's, shedding light on their dysfunctional relationship.

This book was much more than a thrilling story and complex relationship dynamic. Thoroughly enjoyed this, the beginning took a little while to fully invest in but the rest of the book had me hooked.

Imagine a story in which you think all the women characters are unlikable, and you’re both right and wrong simultaneously. Think the characters were so polar to prove a point here.

Little gem quotes hide in the plot of this book, and while the end “twist” was a little over the top, I thought the total package was worth a slightly higher star rating.

Thank you to NetGalley, Dreamscape Select, and Gillian Flynn Books for the audio ARC!

“There is so much to fear, as a woman, but what people think of you, shouldn’t be one of them”
Damn… wtf did I just listen to?!
Definitely go audio over print for this one, you will not be disappointed.
Although you will think that several times throughout the book. As a survivor, there’s are moments this book hits too close to home. As a woman, there are times you want to rage at everyone and everything in this book. BUT it is by design and a beautiful one at that.

This book is everything the title promises and so much more. I went in blind … and I think you should too!!

“When Bruce Banner becomes the incredible Hulk, we tell ourselves he doesn’t mean to be violent. Men like that just feel too much. They’re just sensitive. Amazing how different those words feel when applied to a man.”

This book was.. SO good. The way the author incorporates issues for women’s rights in such a real life way, with mystery, murder, and a twist.. it was great. The first 30% was tough for me to get through, but once I got to the second POV, I was hooked. I don’t think that’s a fault of the book, I think it feeds into the overall point. The problem lies with a small percentage of men, but some of the most scary one are those men who truly think they are good caring people who nothing is their fault. I loved the point of this book and the conversations it will start. This fits our climate perfectly, in the year of Taylor swift and the Barbie movie.

The narrators were fantastic as well. I loved all of the added in sound effects for the news, podcasts, everything.

Thank you to NetGalley, Dreamscape Select, and Araminta Hall for an audio-arc! I’m excited to read more from you!

Engaging, entertaining, and timely. A recommended purchase for collections where crime and thrillers are popular.

This audiobook was a great audiobook. The narrator did a wonderful job, narrating the story and bringing the characters personality to life. I was intrigued and bought into the book from the very beginning.

One of the Good Guys by Araminta Hall was such a pleasant surprise! I did not expect to like it quite as much as I did! It has a pretty unique story and a difficult, timely, important set of current issues discussed in the book. It's been a few days since I've listened to it and I'm still thinking about it, to be honest. I am still torn between the 2 sides of the story. I definitely recommend reading or listening to the book. I think it'll be a hit!

Thank you Dreamscape Select, Gillian Flynn Books and NetGalley for providing me with an early copy of this audiobook.

Thank you @dreamscape_media @netgalley for the #gifted copy of this audiobook!

This book was such a unique way to talk about the differences between men and women in society. We all know women need to be more alert, careful their drinks aren’t drugged, careful to not put themselves in a position to be raped, careful to not be in a dark parking lot at night, or even having to put up with being cat called, gaslighted, or groped. All of these things happen day in and day out in this world and it feels so normalized. I absolutely thought this book covered some deep topics in such a unique fashion and it will for sure be one that will stick with me.

What it’s about:
The story follows two groups of people. Two missing girls who just happen to be activists for women’s rights. As the mystery unfolds around these women we meet a married couple trying to get a divorce. This author portrays the husband Cole as one of the good guys. He wants babies, offers to stay home and take care of them, orders his wife’s favorite food, just wants to love her and take care of her. Ya know, he’s one of the good guys! So when she walks out on him and wants a divorce, we as readers are left scratching our heads. Why is this lady so harsh? Why is she being so mean? It’s a good lesson to hold your judgment until the end! 👀 If you’re looking for the perfect book to read for book club and discuss THIS IS THAT BOOK! It would make for the perfect discussion.

If I hadt to sum up this story in one word I would choose disturbing.
Cole tries hard to be the ideal husband for Mel. So when when their marriage crumbles, it leaves him devastated. Seeking solace, he takes over a position as a wildlife ranger on the south coast, where he gets to know the artist Lennie. Can she be the soulmate he searches for?
The story gets into action when when two women participating in a "Walk for Women," a protest against gender violence, go missing in the area, placing Cole and Lennie in the midst of a unfolding story.

The second part of the story is told in a bit of a different way, which I enjoyed a lot after I got used to it.

This is a well-crafted psychological thriller with a satisfying ending narrated by Elliot Fitzpatrick; Olivia Vinall; Helen Keeley

Thank you #NetGalley #Dreamscape Select, Gillian Flynn Books for this audiobook