Member Reviews

This book was gripping and hard to put down. It didn't feel like everything else you see out there, it felt very fresh. I really enjoyed this book!

Was this review helpful?

Once again Larson does it again. The research was phenomenal. Fort Sumter, Lincoln and the civil war what a trifecta.

Was this review helpful?

This book was classic Larson. So well researched and lots of little known tidbits about the start of the Civil War and Lincoln. I will read anything Larson writes and this one did not disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

Erik Larson, as always, has written non-fiction that reads like fiction.
This historical rendition of Lincoln's election and the beginnings of the Civil War are so well written. His descriptions of what transpired between the numerous divergent personalities that set the stage for the horror of a divided nation are so impressive.
Larson is a distinctive storyteller. Straight and factual history becomes an absorbing tale. His accounting of President Lincoln and his travails made him emerge alive from the pages. It was a bit disconcerting to see present day history reflected in his writing.
First-rate writing as always!

Was this review helpful?

As always Larson has produced a well researched, readable work of nonfiction. A go to author! I will recommend thus book to all my patrons who love history.

Was this review helpful?

I will start by saying this author is a heck of a researcher. 5 stars for that; but..... dude! 500+ pages of Fort Sumter? First they tried to starve them out, then shoot them out, and finally they just set fire to the whole thing and....done. Also Lincoln at the edge of the Civil War....wanted to hear more about freeing slaves but had to keep reading about the fort. Just not for me.

Was this review helpful?

Superlative! Erik Larson takes something we all know - the Civil War started with the firing upon Fort Sumter by Confederate forces - and makes us think about WHY that was, about the many events and decisions large and small leading up to that. Moreover, Erik Larson demonstrates why history isn't about facts and dates but about PEOPLE, sometimes heroic, sometimes villainous, but always HUMAN, in all our complexity and contradictions. Lastly, while there was perhaps a certain inevitability to the Civil War, including the outbreak of hostilities at Fort Sumter, the reality is that there are MANY roads that could have been taken, and Larson is great at making us think about all the ways history could have gone instead of how it did. Highly recommend.

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a digital ARC of this book in exchange for my honest opinions.

Was this review helpful?

I rarely rate books with a five star, but, Erik Larson has written another marvelous book! He is such a storyteller even if it’s nonfiction! His research is amazing and I always learn something new! This book about the loss of Fort Sumter and the beginning of the Civil War is a captivating read! The personal accounts of the key players supplement the story! I am proud to add this Erik Larson’s new book to my collection!

Was this review helpful?

This book is another home run for Erik Larson, one of my favorite authors. He has a way of making history interesting. Life is a story by itself but it takes a special author to make it fun to read. I started with his two books Devil in the White City and Issac’s Storm. Read those two as well as this one. He researches his facts so well that you don’t have to wonder if the events are true. Some would say this book covered a short period in Lincolns life that no one talks or knows much about. It’s very interesting and easy to read. Grab a copy and when you read it, you will enjoy it and come away smarter! #netgalley #eriklarson #theDemonofUnrest

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for the Arc! Erik Larson is such a big name writer and anytime I see his work I just have to grab it and read it! I'm also a huge Abe Lincoln fan, so win - win. I always fear when reading a book about slavery that is written by a white man that it will also be from the "white" perspective, and I was thankfully impressed by the research that went into this book. There were so many fresh revelations and characters that left an impression. Highly entertaining.

Was this review helpful?

Erik Larson has again written an amazing book about a subject we are all so familiar with, and makes it new and exciting to learn about. He gives details and background about the Civil War, how things began to smolder years before, and about specific people and events in the North and South that fueled the conflict leading to the secession of the southern states -- details that are not common knowledge.

Larson is an avid researcher and goes into such detail that the reader feels what it was like to live during that time; when each American had to make a decision and take a stand for what they believed in. And they had to live with those consequences, one of which was a horrific war.

This is an amazing tale of American history and is told in such a way that, though you know what is going to happen and how it is going to end, you don’t want to put the book down. And now through Larson’s marvelous presentation you feel like you know much more about how it all happened.

This is a fascinating telling of a dark time in history that all need to know. I highly recommend it!

I’d like to thank NetGalley, Erik Larson, and Crown Publishing for the advanced reader's copy in exchange for my unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

Erik Larson has done it again. His depth of research and his style of writing make every topic deeply compelling. I wasn’t sure this one would suck me in the way so many others have but from start to finish, it was excellent. Even the additional stories and factoids in his end notes were fascinating. Must read!

Was this review helpful?

The only reason I haven't ranked this book higher is that it was not as good as Erik Larso's other books. However, Larson proves once again that he is an incredible author. History comes alive under his pen, especially in this piece. I have always struggled with military history but this book made so much sense. This is perhaps the best Civil War book I have ever read.

Was this review helpful?

Erik Larson's new book The Demon of Unrest: A Saga of Hubris, Heartbreak, and Heroism at the Dawn of the Civil War tells the story of what happened between Abraham Lincoln's election and the Civil War's first shots.

Larson uses diaries and the details of the time to tell the story in a very human and suspenseful way that engages readers. I learned a lot, but it didn't feel like reading a history book. Highly recommend and you won't miss the similarities to our world today.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. The Demon of Unrest is available now.

Was this review helpful?

Erik Larson delivers another masterful work with "The Demon of Unrest." This book delves into the crucial five months between Abraham Lincoln's election and the onset of the Civil War, a period rife with tension, uncertainty, and pivotal decisions that shaped American history.

Larson's storytelling prowess is evident as he meticulously reconstructs the chaotic months from November 1860 to April 1861. The book begins with Lincoln's unexpected victory in a bitterly contested presidential race, a result that exacerbated the already deep divisions within the country. Southern states, driven by the issue of slavery, began to secede, pushing the nation towards an inevitable conflict.

One of the most intriguing aspects of the book is Larson's portrayal of Mary Boykin Chesnut, the wife of a prominent planter. Her conflicted views on marriage and slavery offer a nuanced perspective on the societal norms of the time. Additionally, Larson paints a vivid picture of Abraham Lincoln, struggling to navigate the treacherous political landscape while dealing with his manipulative Secretary of State, William Seward.

The book excels in capturing the atmosphere of impending doom that pervaded the nation during this period. Larson highlights the tragic errors, miscommunications, and inflamed egos that contributed to the escalating crisis. His portrayal of Lincoln as a leader overwhelmed by the enormity of the challenges he faced adds a human dimension to the historical figure. In addition, Larson's use of primary sources, including diaries, secret communications, slave ledgers, and plantation records, lends authenticity and depth to the narrative. His ability to weave these sources into a cohesive and gripping story is (as always) highly impressive.

Was this review helpful?

When it comes to history, it’s hard to conjure a more capable author than Erik Larson. I’ve thought this for some time, but his Churchill biography, The Splendid and the Vile (2020) cemented this impression. I am therefore gushingly grateful to NetGalley and Crown Books for the review copy. I would have paid full cover price for this book if that was the only way that I could get it—or the only way that I could get it soon.

This book focuses on Fort Sumter, the Federal fort off the coast of South Carolina that became the catalyst for the opening guns of the American Civil War. The Southern states that seceded from the US, or that attempted to do so, believed themselves entitled to seize the forts, munitions, and indeed, every single ounce of American property located within the borders of their states—and although Fort Sumter and the lesser, partially constructed forts around it were on islands rather than inside the state’s boundaries, they expected to annex those, too.

Meanwhile, as most know, Major Robert Anderson was the fort’s commander, and he desperately wanted orders from Washington. The period following Lincoln’s election, up until he actually took office, was a critical one, but President Buchanan was determined to postpone any official acts until he could hand the responsibility to someone else. He didn’t want his legacy marred by the beginning of a civil war, or indeed, by any sort of noteworthy strife whatsoever, and so he mostly just hid from everyone. Representatives from South Carolina—would-be ambassadors that came to conduct international business—were turned away without official recognition, and that’s about the only worthwhile thing the guy did. And during this fraught period, Anderson and those he commanded waited tensely to learn whether they would be ordered to evacuate, or to defend the fort.

They waited a long damn time; too long.

This is a complex story and an interesting one, and so there are many historical characters discussed, but the primary three that take center stage are Major Anderson; Edmund Ruffin, a South Carolinian firebreather, stoking the fires of secession; and Mary Chesnut, the highly literate wife of a member of the ruling elite. Others of importance are, of course, President Lincoln; Allan Pinkerton, the head of the notorious Pinkerton Agency, which is tasked with keeping Lincoln alive; and a Southern power broker named Hammond, with whom the story begins.

In starting the narrative by discussing Hammond, Ruffin, and Chesnut, Larson gives us a fascinating window into the minds of the South Carolinian ruling elite, known among themselves as “the chivalry.” They style themselves as if they were characters from out of Arthurian legends, placing their own somewhat bizarre code of honor above every other possible principle, and beyond matters of simple practicality. I’ve always been fascinated by the way that leaders of morally bankrupt causes arrange their thoughts and rationales so that they can look at themselves in the mirror every morning and like what they see, and nobody can explain it quite the way Larson can. Everything is crystal clear and meticulously documented. I’m a stickler for documentation, and so although I feel a little silly doing so for someone of his stature, I pull two of his sources, Battle Cry of Freedom, by James McPherson, and Mary Chesnut’s Civil War, which is the diary she wrote leading up to and during the war, from my own shelves, and turn to the pages indicated in a couple of the notes. There they are, just where Larson said they’d be! This may not impress you, but it makes me ridiculously happy.

The story commences with Hammond, a wealthy planter with a highly elastic moral code. There’s a fair amount of trigger worthy material here—though the term had not been coined yet, he was a sexual predator of the highest order, and delighted in writing about the things he did to his nieces. Although this information, drawn from primary sources, does its job by letting us know exactly what kind of person helped shape the rebellion, it’s hard to stomach, and I advise readers that can’t stand it to either skim or skip these passages, because one can easily understand the majority of the text without them.

Once upon a time, this reviewer taught about the American Civil War to teens, and yet I learn a hefty amount of new information. In particular, I find the depiction of Anderson illuminating. I have never seen such a well rendered portrait of him before.

I could discuss this book all day, and very nearly have done so, but the reader will do far better to get the book itself. Highly recommended, this may well be the best nonfiction book of 2024.

Was this review helpful?

I've been captivated by Erik Larson's research and storytelling on historical events since I picked up Isaac's Storm years ago. Every time I see there's a new release coming, I have the book on pre-order ASAP. The books add context and personality to historic events, and I wish history in schools was taught using books like this versus the dry textbooks in current use. I loved Demon of Unrest, and I'm sure many other readers will feel the same way.

I read this book in pretty much ever format, ebook, physical book, and audiobook. It's engaging in any format. Some of the quotes from the characters were eerie, in the aftermath of January 6th and the current political turmoil. It was a prescient reminder that we are actively living in historical events that will be dissected and examined decades and centuries later. For some, it can be unimaginable that a country would go to war with itself, and Larson's book walks through events that led to the Civil War.

Lincoln's role and response to the evolving political atmosphere was actually a much lower presence than I would have expected, and the book shows how events had already been set into motion for the country to tear itself apart. Erik Larson has a way with words, and helps the reader to understand both the cultural and political events that primed the country for the war, as well as painted very descriptive pictures of living conditions. The code to which Southern men were expected to adhere to, and how this code led to significant events that would shape the path to war was really interesting, as I had some idea of the attitudes and ideals men were supposed to participate in at the time, however this book did an amazing job at helping the reader to really fully understand the role it played. The end of the book acknowledges that each historical event when written about may have a new angle, because there are so many stories to tell and only a few that get written. Overall, I loved the book and would highly recommend.

Please be advised I received an Advance Readers Copy (ARC) from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Good use of Larson’s usual split-screen technique. Union and Confederacy blunder toward a war that was deemed inevitable (by rabid secessionists, at least) and yet almost feels that it could have been averted had more people been paying attention.

Was this review helpful?

Take a shot whenever it says "honor". Hammond is a shit dude. I like Erik Larson. I love history. I enjoy all of his books, this one included. As I read I realized I don't know much about the Civil War, no more than the basics that is. Could've done with less judging Lincoln on his spelling. There was no dictionary and all phonetic

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this eARC.

Erik Larson’s latest historical masterpiece, The Demon of Unrest: A Saga of Hubris, Heartbreak, and Heroism at the Dawn of the Civil War, is a gripping narrative that plunges readers into the tumultuous months leading up to the American Civil War.

Known for his meticulous research and compelling storytelling, Larson once again delivers a page-turner that is both educational and enthralling.

Set against the backdrop of a nation on the brink of division, Larson’s narrative focuses on the five critical months between Abraham Lincoln’s election and the Confederate attack on Fort Sumter. This period, marked by political missteps, personal tragedies, and escalating tensions, is brought to life through Larson’s vivid prose and keen eye for detail.

At the heart of the story are three central figures: Major Robert Anderson, the conflicted commander of Fort Sumter; Edmund Ruffin, a fervent secessionist; and Mary Boykin Chesnut, a Southern woman torn between her loyalties and her conscience. Through their eyes, Larson paints a complex picture of a nation grappling with its identity and future.

One of the standout aspects of The Demon of Unrest is Larson’s ability to humanize historical events. He delves into the personal lives and motivations of his characters, making their struggles and decisions relatable to modern readers. This approach not only enhances the narrative but also provides a deeper understanding of the era’s social and political dynamics.

Larson’s use of primary sources, including diaries, letters, and official documents, adds authenticity to the narrative. His meticulous attention to detail ensures that readers are not only entertained but also educated about this pivotal period in American history. The book’s pacing is reminiscent of a thriller, with each chapter building tension and anticipation.

In The Demon of Unrest, Larson also explores the broader themes of hubris and heroism. He examines how personal ambitions and egos influenced the course of history, often with tragic consequences. Yet, amidst the chaos and conflict, acts of bravery and resilience shine through, offering a glimmer of hope and humanity.

The Demon of Unrest is a masterful blend of history and storytelling. Larson’s ability to weave together complex historical events with personal narratives makes this book a must-read for history enthusiasts and casual readers. It is a poignant reminder of the fragility of democracy and the enduring impact of individual actions on the course of history.

Whether you’re a Civil War buff or simply a lover of well-crafted narratives, The Demon of Unrest is a book that will captivate and enlighten you. Erik Larson has once again proven why he is one of the most respected voices in historical non-fiction.

Was this review helpful?