Member Reviews

Certainly we can see what this one is trying to accomplish. We're addressing childhood anxiety and not feeling seen or heard. It's important that Isabel's problems are real. She is being mistreated and no one seems to hear her concerns. Isabel does what we always tell kids to do when they have a problem - report it to a trusted adult. And as too often happens in real life, her concerns are dismissed. The conflicts and motivations are rather over-simplified but the writing is accessible.

Was this review helpful?

In Sally Pla’s INVISIBLE ISABEL, Isabel feels like no one sees her at home or at school. Her anxiety manifests in the form of “worry-moths” fluttering in her stomach. The combination of a new student at school who bullies Isabel and her concerns about pleasing her teacher and an impending important test at school only makes the fluttering worse. She tries to get her mom’s attention, but in a large, bustling family, she finds her concerns brushed off. A health crisis finally brings Isabel’s feelings to a head and helps Isabel and those around her to get what she needs to calm her anxieties.
With its novel in verse format and accompanying illustrations, Invisible Isabel addresses the complex content of neurodiversity and anxiety in a way that is easily accessible for middle grade readers. This beautifully written novel will serve as a mirror for some readers and a window for others.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an eARC of the book to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

My heart hurt for sweet Isabel whose “worry moths” cause her to feel sick so often. Her mom dismisses her bellyaches and tells her she is too sensitive. She aches to be like the Monica girls instead of feeling invisible. It’s a great book to show what it is like to be neurodivergent.

Was this review helpful?

Invisible Isabel is lovely book for younger Elementary readers. It is going to generate loads of empathy for less socially gifted kids and I look forward to sharing it with my students.

Was this review helpful?

What a thoughful, eye=opening, empathy-building novel-in-verse! I love how accessible this story is to multiple age groups - short, easy to read, but still carrying the heft of a good story. While the synopsis of this book might feel familiar (quiet, neurodivergent girl learns to let herself be seen; mean girl learns empathy and kindness), the telling is fresh and unique. The contrast between Isabel's boisterous family and her need for a quiet space; the imaginative way that Isabel views the world and especially her own struggles; the honesty that accompanies the revelation of Isabel's neurodivergence. Isabel's age is not stated in the book other than that she is in elementary school. This is great because young readers can bring their own interpretations to the book. This is a book that will help neurotypical kids understand their ND friends and classmates better, and will help ND readers feel seen.

Was this review helpful?

Isabel is feeling like no one notices her. She has a big, loving family, but often feels overlooked. At school, a new girl, Monica, has been bullying her and her teacher is often impatient and doesn't seem to notice anything good about Isabel. Isabel worries about things, so much that she gets stomach aches a lot and when the big test comes around, Isabel's stomach hurts so bad, but her mom insists that she goes to school. It turns out, the stomach ache isn't just about anxiety and her new doctor has some really great problem solving strategies to help her get rid of some of the worries. This is a really great portrayal of anxiety and what it feels like. It also shows how sometimes parents and teachers aren't really listening to kids as carefully as they might. A lot of kids are going to feel seen with a story like this.

Was this review helpful?

I have an Isabel in my house, literally and figuratively. I am such a fan of books that begin exploring the true range of people's emotional states. I loved the way the author talked about anxiety with worry-moths. And Isabel has worry-moths for so many things. But when she starts having health issues, shy Isabel has to speak up to get the care she needs and her family learns ways to make her feel more comfortable in their often chaotic house. Such a lovely story.

Was this review helpful?

A phenomenal book by Sally J. Pla! The world needs Isabel’s story. Every parent and teacher should read this book (and all the kids too)! Isabel is struggling with anxiety, sensitivity to sound and overwhelming situations, and connecting with her classmates. This book will help kids feel less alone, give kids and families strategies for support, and it also helps normalize (and explain) evaluations that can help figure out how best to support kids. This book will be eye opening for kids going through similar situations and help other kids empathize with their peers who may be struggling. It's truly a must read for all! An outstanding book by an outstanding human!

Was this review helpful?

Isabel Beane is a preteen girl that experiences the world in a different way than her friends. She worries about many things that causes her stomach to hurt and that she calls worry moths. She has had the same group of friends since kindergarten that accept her as she is, but when a new girl comes to her school, she, Monica, convinces Isabel’s friends to ignore her and act like she is invisible. The adults in her life never listen to her and just tell her to “get over it, it’s all in her head”. Until one day, her pain is real and she ends up in surgery with appendicitis. During this time, her mom listens to her worries and her very kind doctor, the dad to the new girl, explains to her that she has a neurodivergent brain that is extra sensitive.
As a speech pathologist, I really rooted for Isabel. But I was very disappointed with the adults in her life that chose to ignore her needs. As it all worked out in the end, early intervention to help children on the spectrum is so critical to their overall emotional development.
I think this book does a great job of explaining Isabel’s differences and her needs when she gets overstimulated. I also like how the kids started talking about their own stemming behaviors as it is true, we all do something to help calm us.
I would like to thanks #netgalley and #harpercollinspublisher for the advanced ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Isabel is a neurodivergent girl living in a loud, hectic family. She is being bullying at school by Monica and would like to desperately like to be one of Monica’s friends. . She complains of stomach aches that her mother brushes aside until it gets bad at school. The doctor treating Isabel is none other than Monica’s father. Follow Isabel as she tries to cope with issues at home and at school.

This is a definite must for libraries and middle grade classrooms! It is a definite read for everyone for 4/5th grade up and adult. I highly recommend this book!!

Was this review helpful?

"Invisible Isabel" is a middle grade novel in verse by Sally J. Pla with illustrations by Tania de Regil. Isabel Beane sometimes feels invisible in her house that she shares with her parents and 5 boisterous siblings. At school being invisible is a strategy she employs to try and seem less different, more attentive, and less fidgety. She tries to explain to her parents how she worries a lot, and how that worry causes stomachaches. The description of Isabel's anxiety as manifesting itself like "worry-moths" is really powerful. She worries about disappointing her stern teacher, Mrs. Pickel, especially now that they have started preparing for a big standardized test. One of those worries is her lack of friendships at school, This year a new popular girl, Monica, has created a clique which actively excludes her. Pla includes chapters that illuminate Monica's home life, shedding light on why she is angry and how that anger leads to meanness against Isabel. When Isabel has to go to the hospital for emergency surgery, Monica and Isabel's paths are brought together which results in important changes for both girls. Isabel is a wonderful portrayal of a young girl with neurodiversity, who learns to speak up for herself and ask for what she needs. As a teacher one of my favorite scenes is when the other children in Isabel's class are making her get well cards and they realize that are really seeing her for the first time. I recommend this book for school libraries, classroom collections, and home bookshelves. It is beautifully written and illustrated and also quite moving.

Was this review helpful?

Another excellent book by Pla showing Isabel as a neuro-divergent girl who is experiencing some bullying from Monica at school and some stomach pains that her mom brushes aside. When the stomach issues become serious and Isabel is hospitalized, the doctor treating Isabel volunteers his daughter, Monica, to bring Isabel her schoolwork. Isabel tells the doctor her worries and when Isabel and Monica talk, Monica apologizes. Back at school Isabel meets with a counselor where she is given some accommodations to help her anxiety.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the e-ARC of this middle grade novel. This sweet story tells of Isabel who is struggling as a neurodivergent kid in a class and family who haven't yet learned how to support her challenges. I liked the story, and the way her divergence was treated in the end. This is perfect for lower middle grade readers and up.

Was this review helpful?

Sally J. Pla has given us a beautiful story about being different. Isabelle is a character you can’t help but root for and while I wanted to shake both her parents, her friends and her er teacher at different points, Pla empowers her characters to change, to be seen, to be heard, to forgive and to love in authentic ways.

Was this review helpful?

This was a sweet and encouraging book about a neurodivergent girl named Isabel. There are some difficult topics such as bullying and mental health issues but this could provide a good way for a parent or a friend to discuss these issues. I was not a huge fan of the artwork but it didn't take away from the book.

Was this review helpful?