I uploaded my review to Goodreads and will upload it to Amazon on publication day.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Ava Reid for providing me with a complimentary digital ARC for Lady Macbeth coming out August 13, 2024. The honest opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Macbeth is one of my favorites of Shakespeare, so I was excited for this reimagining. This is the first book I’ve read by this author. I thought the writing was very poetic and I loved the fairy tale vibes. However, I couldn’t really get into the story. Lady Macbeth wasn’t quite what I imagined. I thought the hate on Scottish people was a little odd considering Macbeth is Scottish. There were some action filled parts and I liked a lot of it, but I don’t think I quite vibed with the book. I would check out other books by this author!

I will start off by saying I skimmed Macbeth in high school (I did a little dabbling in truancy ok) but I did revisit it while reading this. So I wasn’t going into it with any fierce loyalties to the characters or major plot points. It is important to note this is a reimagining, not a retelling. The prose itself was really enjoyable, but I just at no point really cared what happened to anyone. So overall, I liked this author's writing style, this one just didn't hit the mark for me. Roscille’s character kind of baffled me. The ending felt rushed, and I cannot say why without spoiling. I wouldn’t really call this feminist, either. The characterization of Scotland/ Scottish people was… interesting to say the least.


Thank you to Netgalley and Del Rey for an ARC in exchange for an honest review

It’s always an honor to have the chance for an early read on @netgalley and especially when it’s @avasreid ‘s latest. Her retelling of The Scottish Play, titled LADY MACBETH is feminist gothic fantasy as only Ava Reid can deliver. Her writing is as exquisite as ever, and her willingness to go deep into the casting of women in history in the role of the villain or witch is complicated, dark, and as uncomfortable as it must be to do her topic justice. This book was an absolute page turner, and I couldn’t put it down.

Really liked this one!! I’m in love with Ava Reid and I need everything she’s ever written injected into my body.

Let me start by prefacing that I am not at all familiar with Macbeth. I did not run into it at all during high school, and never considered reading it for pleasure. Just not typically my thing.

But… a retelling with a strictly female POV? I’m on board!

I did watch a little explainer video on Macbeth when I knew I received this ARC, so I wasn’t completely clueless on the plot. Not sure if the story would’ve been better or worse with extra context (if I had actually read the original), but I really liked my experience and how refreshing this felt.

The first 2-3 parts felt a bit slow, but were necessary to set up a few different plot points. You could feel the characters inadvertently setting themselves up for failure or misfortune every step of the way. But even as Lady Macbeth was unknowingly hindering her future self, you couldn’t help but root for her and know that she’d be able to handle it and work her way through.

I wasn’t expecting any sort of big fantasy element, but I’m happy to say my expectations were exceeded just a little bit haha it did feel slightly random, but I loved it 🥰

The light romance was also a pleasant surprise, and I can’t wait to reread this knowing how things play out there.

And all the commentary on being a woman my god in 👏🏼 love 👏🏼 I have so many different things highlighted and I just want to paste the quotes all over my walls. This was such an empowering, but quick story and I feel very grateful that I was given the chance to read it early 😊

DNF @ 30%. This book is beautifully written and perhaps even has a interesting plot. But it's not Lady Macbeth and it's not feminist, so it's completely failed to deliver what I was expecting and what I wanted from this novel. I'm quite tired with "feminist retellings" of classic figures that make them beautiful and waifish and without agency in front of their brutish, powerful men. Reducing Lady Macbeth's influence, her love for her husband, and her viciously ambitious nature does not make her any more feminist. And making her, the Scottish play's all important Lady, French is just a bafflingly stupid choice. I really enjoy Reid's writing and, if this were it's own story, it might even hold the potential to be a good story. But as a reworking of Macbeth it just doesn't work. If you want to write about retellings with waifish French women, perhaps try Jean Racine, not the Bard?

3.5 stars rounded to 4.

Read if you like:
- macbeth
- women’s wrongs
- female rage

Let me just say, it’s been a while since I’ve read/seen/thought about Macbeth. So, I pretty much went into this book blind, besides knowing there are witches involved.

I enjoyed this book, though I wouldn’t say it’s a strong retelling. Reid presents us with a dark, gothic story entwined with magic and demonstrates the struggle of a woman who is essentially forced to become who we all know is Lady Macbeth. I had expected Roscille to be a strong, powerful, determined woman, but time and time again we see her beaten down by men. Despite having her agency stripped away, she is able to use her cleverness and her ‘witchcraft’ to her advantage. Reid’s beautiful prose fully immerses you in the vastly dark and magical world that our protagonist lives in. However, I really wish a certain character had been introduced earlier in the book - it would have made the ending much more rewarding.

If you’re in the mood for a darker story, that can be violent at times, then this may be the book for you.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing - Ballentine / Del Rey for a free digital copy of this book. This is my honest review. Publication date: August 13, 2024.

Lady Macbeth retells and revamps the story of…I mean, guess. Lady Macbeth, or Roscille of Breizh, is married off to Macbeth, Thane of Glammis, in medieval Scotland at seventeen years of age. She’s known in her home court for her ethereal, supernatural beauty: her silver hair, unbelievably pale skin, and eyes so capable of ensorcelling that she wears a veil to protect the men around her. She’s called witch-touched, and the men around her fear her for it. Moving to Scotland is a dramatic change: Roscille’s handmaiden is removed from her and presumably killed, the castle is high on a cliff’s edge over a cold sea in constant turmoil, and the landscape and court are equally cold and barren. Macbeth of Glammis is an imposing figure, both in notoriety and physical stature, treating Roscille gently at first, but as his power and ambition grow, feeding off each other, he becomes more violent towards her and his fellow Scotsmen.

As the focus of the Macbeth tale has changed, so have the major themes. The original explores ambition and manipulation: Shakespeare’s Lady Macbeth is known in literature for her maturity and uncontested wielding of her power over her husband, and her eventual madness. Reid’s Roscille embodies the ermine of the French court, a naïf thrown alone into a culture and role only familiar for the violence enacted upon the women in the space. And this is the theme of this telling: the eternal and inevitable violence and abuse men do to women, and the ways in which women bear these mistreatments. The witches of the play become Les Lavandières, or the washerwomen, who Macbeth keeps at his disposal for his prophecies. Duncane’s sons become more prominent players, and Macduff is relegated to a handful of paragraphs offscreen.

Reid’s Lady Macbeth is atmospheric and tense, drawn with cold, harsh lines and ragged texture. Roscille is torn between her naïveté and the role thrust upon her as wife and queen, and she finds herself similarly torn between love for another man and service to her husband and country. Attempts at petty grabs for agency are rebuked and punished, and only once she is disposed of entirely does she grasp the power she’s been able to wield the whole time. I enjoyed the atmosphere of the novel and the incorporation of additional supernatural elements that would have been present in the folk tales of the period—the setting is used to its fullest extent. The twists on Les Lavandières and Banqhuo and Fléance’s roles were used to expand upon Macbeth’s character, as for the first half of the novel he spends so much time offscreen. The confluence of cultures—French, Breizh, English, Norse, and Scottish—fleshed out the sprawling politics behind and beyond this Scottish clan.

The nature of adaptation and retelling, however, is that it inherently draws comparison to the source material. Trading the Lady Macbeth for this child in a hostile environment is a bold move, as is the highlighting of more minor or entirely off-page characters, such as Duncane’s sons and the Banqhuo line. I love a clever, manipulative royal, but Roscille was constantly thwarted and punished for the only power she had, which does fall in line with the theme of men’s violence towards women. I do believe I would have found the novel more enjoyable as its own work, divorced from the cultural weight of Shakespeare’s Lady Macbeth—I found myself continually questioning why Reid chose that character to tell this story. Truly, I think Roscille could have been an Ophelia or a Desdemona and would have borne equal similarity to her source. I’d recommend Reid’s Lady Macbeth for those seeking an atmospheric tragedy, political medieval fantasy, or those who want to explore Lady Macbeth’s growth from a porcelain naïf to the Lady Macbeth of Shakespeare’s first act.

Thank you Random House Publishing Group for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Thanks you Del Rey/ Penguin for this arc in exchange for an honest review

2.5 stars sorry :(

- Scotish( apparently innacuratly)
- M/F romance
- Magic
- War
- Forbidden romance

Warning there is mention and fade to black scenes of Grape

This book I was really excited for after A Study In Drowning I loved that book so much, however I just felt meh reading this and it just wasn't what I want it to be.

I did enjoy the aspect of her magic only affecting men, good touch and I enjoyed the dark and rainy feel to the book.

I have been told there is incorrect spelllings and Scotland facts, but I will leave their accuracys up to our lovely Scotish reviewers.

I can see there will be an audience for this book but sadly it was not me.

Ava Reid's Lady MacBeth is one of my most anticipated reads of the year. She is a master at crafting a story full of imagery, atmosphere and thought provoking themes. It is safe to say that if you have enjoyed her previous work, you will also appreciate this book. If you find her critical representation of patriarchal violence heavy handed, then this book will also not be for you. While "A Study in Drowning" remains my favorite of her works, this reimagining of Lady MacBeth is full of metaphor and lyrical prose designed to maximize the effect of her character's plight and the cruelness of the world.

The main critique I have encountered from those who felt disappointed by this novel are that our FMC is no Shakespearean Lady MacBeth. Instead of the ambitious and manipulative lady in the play. I recently listened to Judi Dench discussing the complexity of the character. Shakespeare's Lady Macbeth controls her destiny (or at least believes she can) by controlling her husband. There is an affection for him, but also the recognition that her fortune is dependent on his own success.

Here we find a very different character. One cast asside by her father, used as a pawn for his own gain (as most medieval noble women war) to appease a potential adversary. She arrives in Scotland unprepared for life away from court and finding herself alone and vulnerable. I do understand how this representation is an obstacle for many, but I also can see why Reid chooses show a world where the Lady Macbeth we have come to know is untenable in this time and place. Instead, she must find strength and power in a very different way, by finding herself outside of the many identities the men in her life allow her to hold. The outline of the original story is there, but it's impact is quite different. Not one of tortured guilt, but of survival.

For me it was a profound and intense reading experience, and one that will keep me thinking for a while to come.

Thanks to Del Ray for access to an e ARC of this book for review purposes.

Absolutely breathtaking. I went in with zero knowledge of Macbeth. All I knew was I do not get Shakespeare no matter how it’s written. However Ava turned this story into her own in the most eloquent way. Without leaving me behind. She incorporated I think the best of Shakespeare with a modern twist without losing the identity or integrity of the plot. It was well focused, paced, and character driven. I really do wish more people would write like this because it is STUNNING!!

Real Rating: 2.5 / 5 Stars

This is the first Ava Reid novel I’ve disliked, and I’ve read her entire backlist.

Up until Lady Macbeth, Ava Reid had a flawless track record with me. There are very few fantasy authors who can match her when it comes to beautiful prose matched with fantastical worldbuilding. Her love of powerful female protagonists is always a huge bonus for me, too.

It’s not that Lady Macbeth lacks beautiful prose, because there is beautiful prose in this book. It’s not as plentiful as in Reid’s other books, but there is a sparseness to this book that I feel might be part and parcel of the overall aesthetic for the story and so it might be on purpose. The worldbuilding is fantastic, actually, but I have a feeling it probably doesn’t feel like it if you aren’t familiar with a lot of aspects of medieval Europe. Reid definitely made a choice to write this without simplifying anything for readers who might want things explained more plainly to them.

Where I came up short in this book was in the protagonist and just the book as a whole.

I understand where the author was coming from and (likely) where she was trying to get to with Lady Macbeth and this story. Most of what I came away with was about lost girlhoods, weaponizing female beauty, fetishizing certain types of women, men taking credit for a woman’s labor, men blaming women for their shortcomings, male anger and pride, man’s sense of entitlement, misogyny, how scared men are of the idea of women having the least amount of power, and how everyone has a breaking point. Even the most docile-behaving women. The issue I had is the story managed to touch lightly on all of these things but somehow also seemed to never get to the point about any of them. It skimmed lightly over all of these talking points like it was a buffet and ended up with an overloaded plate full of unresolved issues.

This is where my overall disappointment comes into play: It was just so scattershot. Have a sip of daddy issues. Take a nibble of my love for animals. I’m into being queen. I’m not into being queen. I’m cunning but I’m not. I’m not just a girl but I’m totally just a girl. Here’s some beautiful prose, but here’s a whole lot of boring.

It’s an inconsistent book with an inconsistent protagonist and an inconsistent plot. I’d like to say I don’t regret finishing it, but I do. I wish I had DNFd it. But I thought I owed Ava Reid the finish.

I was provided a copy of this title by Netgalley and the author. All thoughts, opinions, views, and ideas expressed herein are mine and mine alone. All reviews three stars or under do not appear on my social media. Thank you.

File Under: Fantasy/Romantasy/Historical Fantasy/Literary Fiction/Standalone Novel

Wow. Sometimes you can judge a book by its cover, and this is one of them. Dark, atmospheric, and cold, we follow our protagonist as she fights not only misogyny in her time (what’s new) but also fights for her survival.

This is my favorite Ava Reid book to date. However, all her books do feel the same to me with slightly different characters/plots. And I mean SLIGHTLY. There is still the same kind of instalovey/falling in love with feminine men/villainizing arm hair/unredeeming men using women/annoying or unlikable mc to look forward to (or to not).

I understand that doesn’t seem like the best of things, but the girlies who like Ava Reid KNOW*. Sometimes you just need a grotesque pretty little gothic fantasy to ick you out and remind you life could be worse. And she knocks it out every time. Out of all of hers to date, I recommend this one the most. I do wish (like all her other works) that there was more feminine rage, and if it’s not obvious, I read this more for the fact it was by Ava Reid than my (limited) memory of Macbeth.

*know to check trigger warnings before reading any of her books

This is my second read by Ava Read and I have fallen in love with her eloquent writing. This story is one of suppression, murder and heartbreak. Lady Macbeth had a life that was never her own. She tried to make the best of her decision and have little amounts of control however at the end of the day this is a time period where women are valued for nothing except their ability to be able to pleasure a man, give them a son or be a slave to them. Every man (besides the prince lol) was an arrogant pos and I just want them all to meet a gruesome demise. I have limited knowledge of the source material of this book however this is the only recounting that I need to read. Great pacing, great characters and great discussion can be had from this book.

4.5 stars rounded up

“You are the creature I made you,”

Thank you to netgalley and Del Rey for this arc in exchange for an honest review.

Lady Macbeth is a beautifully crafted tale about women and the power they hold, even when it seems as if they hold none at all- even in a world where men seem to clutch most power in their blood soaked, dirty hands.

It is a tale about transformation , womanhood and vengeance. It is about wickedness and discovering that true monsters may come in every form, especially in the form of ordinary men in their quest for power and the lust they have for violence snd bloodshed. It asks: what if the monsters who haunt your dreams are real? True violence, true horrors, the stuff of nightmares.

This story begins with a slow start, it quickly builds up from an eerie sort of quiet to a full blown, raging storm. The prose is eerie, atmospheric and the gorgeous sentences will stencil themselves into your brain never to be forgotten.

Alrhough Lady Macbeth is inspired by the play Macbeth by Shakespeare this book is an entire different entity. Shakespeare’s work acts as building blocks to the tale that is woven in this book. This is not a retelling but rather a different take on the same characters. While I read a little bit of Macbeth in high school, I ultimately never finished it but I am eager to do so after finishing this, to see how they differ and to see how it inspired Ava Reid to compose this variation.

This book holds notable mentions of witchcraft, curses, sins, magic, old folklore and tales of horror. While reading, I did a deep dive into the origination of these myths learning that the story of Macbeth also features three witches, sprouting the theory of witches and evil beings coming in threes. Shakespeare originally got this inspiration from pre-christian mythology and greek mythology. As an avid lover of all things witchy and horror it was interesting to learn that so many features of my favorite movies, books and other forms of media were inspired by this. (Ie: hocus pocus, the weird sisters from herculus, charmed, the chilling adventures of sabrina) as well as where the line “double double toil and trouble” originates. The list goes on and on as Macbeth holds an inspiration over modern media as we know it.

Lady Macbeth is our protagonist but she is neither good or evil. She is somewhere in between struggling with the consequences of her actions. She is constantly fighting for balance, and battling between her own choices and actions trying to decide which parts of herself to hide away or reveal. She must embrace all of herself or none at all. Her world is not black and white and neither is she; it is a murky, foggy gray. It is the unpredictable waves crashing against the cliffside that haunts her dreams at night: it is the blood she ultimately sheds even when she is not the one doing the actual killing. Macbeth refers to her “as the dagger in his hand” and this could not be more true as he wields her as a weapon of sorts, as she grasps for the role she beings to play in his chaos and quest for power.
She can sense her end coming or it is truly just the beginning? Of power, violence - the adjustment period between girlhood and womanhood, of powerless to powertul, the full transformstion of Roscile to Lady Macbeth; becoming who she was always meant to be.


In her journey of good and evil, she is the only one who can determine the outcome and the path she will eventually find herself on.


While it holds so many notable themes, death seems to be the most notable of all, becoming its own character; given its own lifeline and heartbeat. All of these things make this a difficult book to put down as it sucks you in. One you will be dying to consume every drop of. It is a gory, wild ride with dreamy atmospheric writing that will suck you right into this world. It is unforgettable and nightmarish in the best way.

This was my first read by Ava Reid, it definitely won’t be my last and I’m excited to pick up her other works in the future.

“Sometimes no words are as eloquent as the spilling of blood.”

Thank you to Ava Reid and Del Rey via NetGalley for the eARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Wow. Wow. Wow. I am in awe of this book. I want to mention that I’ve never read the original play, so my knowledge of the story was next to nothing. I knew Lady Macbeth was conniving and a villain… and that’s basically it. This story veers drastically away from the original play (I now know the plot), so if you love Macbeth or were hoping for a novel about the villainous Lady Macbeth, then I’d look elsewhere.

I found this story captivating and the main character fascinating. The plot was heavy and veers into some pretty dark stuff. But I was so invested in Roscille (Lady Macbeth) that I ate it up in the need to find out how her story ends. If you’re looking for a book that is witchy, set in 11th century Scotland, and full of schemes, then I’d recommend you read this!

Blood-soaked female rage written in luscious and haunting prose. This is the story of a 17 year old witch-cursed girl who is determined to be something other than a man's plaything. Manipulation, revenge, and madness. I could not put it down. My only complaint is that the ending felt rushed. This is the best Shakespearean retelling I've read in a long time

This was a really compelling read.It was faced paced and it was very hard to put down.It absolutely had me hooked from the first few pages.I thought the characters of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth were fascinating and the story itself definitely deserves a sequel.If you like dark fantasy, good story telling, medieval settings and a touch of witches and dragons this one's for you.

There was a lot to love in Ava Reid's Lady Macbeth. First, Reid's prose is technically at its finest, with haunting, stark sentences that lend to the tale's gothic feel. The building of tension especially towards the end was riveting. I would have liked to see more demonstrable change in Lady Macbeth's character as it was often referenced that she was evolving, but the reader isn't really show how. The characterization of Macbeth and the other Scots also leaves something to be desired and was a bit oversimplified at the least and perhaps xenophobic and exaggerated at most (I was a bit disorientated to see all the Scots seemed to be brutes while the only "good" male character was half-English? seemed to be a strange choice). Despite this, I was still drawn completely in to Reid's world and continue to be a huge fan of her work. If this is the beginning of a new more direction in Reid's oeuvre I'm excited to see what's next.

LADY MACBETH by Ava Reid (releasing August 13) was a well-written historical fantasy I thoroughly enjoyed. The author’s prose was lush and haunting. As one might assume by the title, this is a reimagining of Lady Macbeth from Shakespeare’s Macbeth. In this version she is Roscille, a 17-year-old Frenchwoman with eyes that can turn a man mad, thus she must always wear a veil. The book starts with her arranged political marriage to Lord Macbeth. She begins as a frightened young lady in a place different from that which she is used to, now married to a man she knows nothing about. However, despite her youthful innocence she is shrewd and calculating, and it’s fascinating to see Macbeth from her point of view. As she grows into herself and gains confidence in her new surroundings, she tries to outwit the men in her life who treat her as a pawn.

Thank you to NetGalley and DelRey books for an advanced copy of this book.

i adore a shakespeare retelling and macbeth is a personal favorite, so when an author i already adore says she’s doing macbeth from lady macbeth’s perspective, i’m sat. roscille’s development throughout the story is just perfect - i love that it simultaneously grants her power but also shows just how much she is confined by the men in power around her and her struggles to navigate that. the prose is lovely and so descriptive and the ending is just… incredible. a very high four and a half stars.