i have heard so much about ava reid and her books, and having just gotten hooked on nicola griffith’s hild and already down to clown with the bard, i thought this might be right up my alley. i wanted to find a complexity in lady “out damn spot!” macbeth. unfortunately, this took some turns that i did not expect, and more unfortunately, was at the expense of lady macbeth’s characterization. somehow, we spend the majority of our time with her and her depth barely submerges past the kiddie pool and is replaced by fantasy elements that don’t give any more insight into her personality or reasoning behind her choices. there were some consistently telling-not-showing platitudes to remind the reader that women do in fact suffer from the societies built to venerate patriarchy that felt like commentary that was perfectly obvious through the plot points already. the creative liberties taken here didn’t do it for me, sorry.

Thank you to Netgalley and Random House publishing for providing an ARC in exchange for this review.

My first five star read of the year!! Ava Reid writes a brutal retelling of Macbeth, punctuated by the brutal realities of war, love, and womanhood. Interwoven with these ideas, Reid flawlessly creates a story where the fourth witch is our Lady, who uses that as her mechanism towards power in her unforgiving, violent reality. At times, this book was horrifying simply because Reid did not shy away from Macbeth and his cruelty. I absolutely adored this book and will be screaming about it for months to come.

Took me a bit longer to get through than expected, especially since it’s my second ava reid book, so don’t think this will be like her first book if you’re going in for something similar. Very harrowing and dark retelling (loosely) of Macbeth. I love the story of Macbeth so this was an interesting surprise for me. I may have to reread it again to get a better understanding, because I feel like I might have missed some things, but Lady Macbeth herself was truly an incredible character to recreate from Ava’s writing style.

This book is a beautiful take on Lady Macbeth’s story that sucks you in immediately. The world building and storytelling puts you right into her shoes, and the pacing is fast and engaging.

I couldn’t put this one down and finished it in one day. If you liked Circe by Madeline Miller you’ll love Lady Macbeth.

Thank you Netgalley and Del Rey publishing for this lovely ARC. I was excited to receive the ARC for Lady Macbeth.. I enjoy Shakespeare and loved how cunning, ruthless, and ambitious she was. I loved how she defined her actions and she called the shots. so I looked forward to Ava Reid’s interpretation of lady Macbeth as an even Stronger young adult coming into her power. I adore Ava Reid and found the cover gorgeous. I also loved how She finally had a name, Roscille. This is where I have to end the positives unfortunately. I really couldn’t reconcile Roscille as lady Macbeth. I found her annoying, irritating, grating, and , even more bothersome, xenophobic . I adore Ava Reid and will continue to read her other books. I just think taking a character as iconic as Lady Macbeth needed a craftier more ruthless pen.

A falter for Ava Reid in her bibliography which I otherwise love. Please don't write the next feminist-billed reimagining of a classical heroine that in actuality just disenfranchises her in a different painful way than the original narrative.

Rounded up from 4.5 stars!

Lady Macbeth has always been one of my favorite literary characters and Ava Reid with this book is fast becoming one of my favorite authors.
This retelling of Macbeth is through the eyes of young Roscille, who is newly married off from her home as a Lady in France to the harsh lands of Glammis in Scotland. We see through her eyes the metamorphosis from her being this naive girl Roscille who is trying to survive using the only thing she has, her mind, to becoming Lady Macbeth, the dagger in Macbeths hand.
This has all of the feminine rage and beautiful prose that we have come to expect from Ava Reid. She did a great job at taking one of Shakespeares biggest villains and making her human, while also showing that, again, humans are usually the biggest monsters of us all.
Thank you so much to netgalley and the publisher for letting me read this ARC!

I have mixed feelings about "Lady Macbeth" by Ava Reid. On the one hand, I appreciate the attempt at reimagining Shakespeare's classic, but on the other hand…why is she a teenager? Several aspects fell short for me. 


The writing style fluctuated between bland and overly embellished, making it difficult to immerse myself in the story entirely. The characters lacked likability, and the predictable twists made it challenging to stay engaged.

Despite its flaws, "Lady Macbeth" offers an intriguing reinterpretation of a classic story but fails to deliver a truly captivating experience.

This might just simply not be for me. I don’t really know much about the original shakespeare macbeth besides the very general bare minimum plot. that being said this book still works. I appreciated Reid's atmospheric writing and the way she spun her own tale around the classic, however I found myself struggling to fully engage with the story and its characters. If you’re looking for a very cunning, strong female character, I don’t think Roscille is it.

I feel like I’ve been waiting for a book like this to come into my life an change it completely not only was I not able to put this book down but I was madly in love with everything in it

I was given access to this book through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
I’m giving this 3.5 rounding up. The rage? amazing. but it did feel like the pacing was very off. I loved A study in Drowning, so i was super excited to read this one. I like Rocille, I think she is an interesting character with many layers to her. But the idea of Macbeth and his men felt very flat, the only one who had dimension was Lisander. The pacing felt too fast and too slow all at once somehow? I genuinely don’t know how to describe it? And some of the plot points felt vague, which made the twists later feel weak overall. Did I still like this book? Yes. But I don’t know how much I would recommend it for someone looking for something that ties in with the actual Scottish Play.

I’ll be honest that I did not care for this. I’m confused as to how this was a “feminist retelling” when it removed all of Lady Macbeth’s agency that she had in the original play? Instead of a middle aged woman who convinces her husband to follow the witches’ prophecy (which he wants to do anyway, she just has to give him a little push), we get a teenage girl who constantly talks about how smart she is but then ends up just being carried along by the events of the book. Lady Macbeth is a great literary female character because she is willing to do what needs to be done. This version just wants to hook up with a shapeshifter.

I also did not understand the hatred of Scottish people in this book. The author portrays every single one as a savage beast, despite the fact that they’re all kind of nice? It really leaned into the worst type of historical stereotypes of Scots and it was disappointing and, frankly, kind of offensive. I was really looking forward to this because I loved A Study in Drowning but I did not enjoy this at all. My library will still be purchasing a copy.

Ava Reid’s retelling of MacBeth follows Roscille, Lady MacBeth, as she is introduced to a new world through marriage in Scotland.

I would like to start by saying I have never seen or read the original Macbeth but I have a google answers knowledge of the storyline.

I liked the beginning of this book. It wrapped me in its cold arms. I think Ava Reid has a way of writing that makes you say “oh!” In wonder and disgust one right after the other. She delivered beautifully gothic prose in this story. I enjoyed the beginnings of romance between lasander and Roscille. If this book would have continued down that same path it would have easily been 4 stars.

I should have DNFd this book.

I actually had a lot of issues with this book. I feel bad being so negative because I was so looking forward to this book! I feel like the synopsis gives the impression that she is cunning and witty and going to manipulate and girlboss her way to the top. She doesn’t. To start, Roscille is described in the beginning of the novel as being wise and decisive and able to read people. I was excited about this book through the first few chapters because I wanted her to use her witt. She does not use her wit. She really just complains. A lot. Most of it is about men. It seems to be a “feminist” retelling but it is the “men bad, women good!” variety. The trouble is that pretty much all the men seem pretty alright. It’s really annoying because we’re supposed to hate Macbeth, who seems genuinely good until the last 1/4 or so of the book. We are supposed to feel like Roscille is being forced to be a certain way by all these brutish men, but she is actively making decisions for herself based on how she feels a woman is supposed to act. She is saying “ugh these men make decisions for women and define them to suit themselves, that’s awful! Now off to actively allow these men to mold my decision for me and define me to suit themselves!” When she gets to the castle she loses any semblance of ambition and character. She immediately decides MacBeth is dumb and only wants a pretty wife to objectify and abuse. She is surprised when he doesn’t do this but still holds fast to that idea. Every character is brutish and brainless, big and scarred and ugly. The only characters that weren’t, weren’t fully Scottish. That seemed sour to me. Pretty much every character was one note and stayed one note the whole book. The only intrigue I had was when the royal family was introduced. Also I think we were made to believe that MacBeth was beginning to ascend into madness, but it didn’t show. I assume this because he had a wound that he refused treatment for and it was brought up pretty much constantly for the last 1/4. If you’re going to talk about something so much, give it good reason. My final grievance is how much certain words and phrases are said, “ignominy” “chafed” and “bloodied sheets and bloodied thighs” are just three easy examples that come to mind.

This book was at its best when Roscille was actually thinking and not just complaining about the awful terrible Scottish, and the awful terrible men, and the awful terrible world that forces woman to be with awful terrible men.

Thank you to NetGalley and Del Ray for the arc of this book.

This book... This book is a top five read of all time for me. Every page is breathtaking to read, and the journey of Roscille is full of the heartbreak, and rage, and relentless hope that we as women have all felt in our lives. It is a masterpiece that so accurately and beautifully depicts feminine rage, struggle, and vengeance. It takes a play centered around the madness of a man and peels back layers upon layers to give a striking commentary that has such dedication to historical accuracy and respect for the original work. This piece will sit with me for a long, long time, and for that I am so grateful to Ava for her writing. I have never felt so seen, so heard, and so raw as I did reading this, and reconciling with my own fears about womanhood and the violence of the patriarchal world around me. I cried with her, I raged with her, and I rejoiced with her, in her end.

This is a must read. This is a piece of art that is so evocative of the feminine experience that it's my first choice for those in need of learning. I think everyone should read this book, just to learn, to feel, and to grow.

Truly breathtaking, and exquisite, and all the fantastic praises I can think of to offer to Ava Read.

Brava.

Disclaimer: While I read Macbeth in a high school English class over 10 years ago, I only remember the very general plot and barely any of Lady Macbeth's role in the original play. As such, this review is written based on how well I feel this book stands on its own. Apologies to any hard core Shakespeare fans.

Roscille is a young French girl who is sent to Scotland to marry Macbeth. Throughout her life Roscille has been told that she is cursed, a witch, and can enchant men just through her gaze. Veiled, scared, and alone, she tries to adjust to her new life as the only woman in the castle. Thrust into a tense political environment, Roscille finds herself being used as a pawn by the other characters, all of whom think that they can both utilize her "power" and take advantage of her femininity. As she learns secrets about her new husband's rule and the lore of her new country, Roscille begins to discover just what her status can truly give her and how she can take advantage of those who discount her. Macbeth is not a hero, he is a man craving power and is willing to take whatever steps he needs to gain it.

Reid's writing is atmospheric and dramatic and does an excellent job of helping the reader visualize the dreary castle and Roscille's feelings of isolation. The first quarter of the book moves pretty slowly and it took me a while to get pulled in. The part with the dragon was...strange (the story could have done without this and the plot would be unaffected). As someone who is not a Shakespeare aficionado, Lady Macbeth recalled enough of the bard's work without requiring me to pull up SparkNotes to remind myself of the characters. Overall, Reid did an excellent job of putting her own twist on a classic without relying on the source material to carry the plot.

Ava Reid has done it again with this haunting yet beautiful gothic inspired story. I can honestly say that I have never been more enthralled, disgusted, and entranced by a story all at the same time.
I am unfamiliar with Macbeth but was completely captivated by the story of Lady Macbeth and her disastrous choices that led to the death of so many people. The start of her tragic life, being trained by her father as a spy, sold by the same man only to be dehumanized and the dagger in the hand of a brutal husband.
This vicious story of vengeance had me up way too late to finish the story, and boy oh boy was it a good story indeed.

Ava’s ability to intertwine magic systems with her style of verse leaves me bewitched every time.

As a fan of Ava's writing and coming off of just finishing ASID, I GASPED when I saw that I was approved for this arc (thank you NetGalley!).

Ava's signature story telling is front and center in this Macbeth reimagining. The words and phrases they are able to spin to create this world is truly a talent.
While I personally enjoyed this book and asked the question "What if" about Lady Macbeth, I will say, if you are a Shakespeare enthusiast/purist, this book is not for you.
But if you are interested in reading a tale inspired by Shakespeare's most controversial play, this book is for you.

This was one of my most anticipated reads. I was so thankful for the arc. I just love Ava Reid’s writing.

While I wouldn’t say this was the fastest read and I had to be in the mood to pick it up, every time I did I was enthralled. This book has it all…tension, pain, witches, mind games, scheming.

Overall this was a great retelling and I recommend picking it up.

“Lady Macbeth” is about a young seventeen year old girl, named Roscille- who is cursed with witch powers! She is sent to Scotland by her father to wed a great warrior, Lord Macbeth. It is unknown territory to her as she sets on her journey before she assumes her infamous role, focusing on her resilience and cunning in the face of adversity among men!

This is book was AMAZING and Ava Reid is a genius in putting a spin on this original play! You don’t have to know the play to understand this novel! Reid explores themes of power, greed, ambition and the conditions in humanity, offering the readers a refreshing outlook on this old tale! My favorite aspect that Reid highlights in the book is the empowerment in women! I love the strong female characters in her novels and the storytelling!

Each chapter had me at edge of my seat and I couldn’t put the book down with its heart-pounding plot! If you’re into dark, thrilling and breathtaking suspense- give this novel a shot! You won’t regret it! “HAIL, LADY MACBETH!”

Big THANKS to NetGalley and Random House Publishing for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Yikes. This was not good. Lady Macbeth was my second attempt at an Ava Reid novel (having DNFed the first). There were a lot of problems I had with this book. First was the writing. Some scenes felt like excerpts out of a middle schoolers attempt at a novel (bland and horrendously written), while others were trying so hard to mimic beautiful Shakespearian language but were so overdone that it was cringey. Second were the characters. Not a single one was likeable, and I hated every one of them. Third were the "twists" and "reveals", which were so predictable it pains me to call them that. I could go on, but I won't. The only thing saving this book from a one star was the fact that I was able to finished it (which was in part due to the fact that it was only 200 pages), although I wanted to DNF this book almost every ten pages.