This book was very well written. The details in the action scenes and in all the parts of the story were very vivid. I could see them clearly in my mind. I loved that this was a retelling in a way of The Count of Monte Cristo. Can’t wait to read it again.

I really enjoyed Emily Varga's take on The Count of Monte Cristo - even more with an angry, vicious female protagonist and the Pakistani cultural influence! I was expecting a wild ride and that's exactly what I got - definitely a YA to read.

For She is Wrath is a YA Pakistani retelling of the Count of Monte Cristo. It is filled with betrayal, revenge, plotting, and a good dose of romance. I have never read The Count of Monte Cristo so I can’t speak to how this retelling compares to the original classic, it does make me want to read it for the first time though!

I thought this was a really fun and quick read. My only complaint about it would be that it felt like the end was rushed and many things were resolved far too quickly. The beginning of this book really shines. I also enjoyed how the book utilized the flashbacks to tell the backstory. I would recommend to anyone who enjoys a good YA fantasy. I’m hoping to see more books from this author in the future! Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Thrown into prison for a crime she didn’t commit, all Dania can think about is getting revenge on the people who put her there. But first she needs to escape. For she is wrath is a Pakistani inspired count of Monte Cristo retelling, with a sword wielding female main character who is a total badass. This book has everything you could want in a fantasy book. romance, friendship, magic and plenty of action. I really enjoyed it and I would definitely recommend.

Varga retells The Count of Monte Cristo in a fantasy East Asian setting, but you definitely don't need to know anything about the original to enjoy this fast-paced adventure. Dania is wrongfully sent to prison, where she finds an ally and manages to escape to get revenge. Adopting a new identity and working with dangerous magics, she learns that not everything is as it seemed when she was arrested, and her choices for action become kaleidoscopic. I loved the relationship between Dania and Noor, the woman who escapes prison with her and aids her in her quest for revenge, and found Dania's conflicting feelings towards her former lover, now a ruler, compelling. The detail in the world-building is excellent, the pacing is good, and the characters develop over the course of the novel. Good for middle grades and up.

May I introduce Dania, a YA romantasy heroine with brain cells!

The Count of Monte Cristo is one of the few classic novels I haven't read, so I went into For She Is Wrath completely blind. I didn't know what beats to expect or what familiar faces to watch for. For She Is Wrath has enough story to stand on its own with no familiarity of The Count of Monte Cristo. I just read the wiki article, and I see the beats now, but Varga has created a plot and setting where the re-telling beats feel organic, natural, and make sense.

To be completely honest, I struggled with the first 30% of For She Is Wrath. The part of Dania which is thirsting for vengeance is warring with the logical part of herself. I had a really hard time building momentum as Dania continued to question the right path for herself. I feel like I picked up who the people Dania felt had wronged her very quickly and the first 30% seemed a little repetitive. I'm not sure if the intent was to show the depth of her hatred for these people, but I didn't quite feel that.

"I watched you when you came back, you were someone who could light this world on fire, who could make it yours."

However, when Dania arrives at the capital and starts executing her plan for revenge, the brain cells really start shining. She puts together fantastic, simple, achievable plots for her revenge. She evaluates the risks of the situation, changes her plans accordingly, and overcomes obstacles that appear in her path. She's met with emotional situations and she reacts. Dania is one of the most fleshed out characters I have read in a while, there are so many facets to her personality. She's calculating and wanting revenge, but she is also grieving, but she is also heart-broken, but she is also a friend. I highlighted a bunch of her snarky lines.

"I'd gladly give my head for a good cause. And it seems like ridding you from the world would be a fantastic benefit to everyone."

Varga also does a fantastic job with having the reader question Dania's sanity. The djinn treasure is addictive - it can give its user immense power, but it can also drive them mad. The portrayal of addiction and the effect it has on Dania's choices is quite delicately done. Combined with the "Before" chapters that are woven through the book, it leads the reader to doubt and question Dania's choices on her path to revenge. The selection and details in the "Before" chapters were very well done to show specific details that echoed the current timeline and just unsettle the reader just right.

I don't know if I'm required because this is romantasy, but the spice level is fade-to-black.

"But most of all, for me, because even though I'd escaped prison, it felt remarkably like I was still there."

Promising vengeance, this Pakistani retelling of The Count of Monte Cristo is quick, action-packed, and full of drama. Dania has been stuck in prison for a crime she did not commit, framed by the boy she loved. When the perfect opportunity for escape manifests in the form of an unlikely ally, Dania takes her opportunity to avenge all that she has lost, even if it means pushing her own morals to the limits.

Varga had the tough job of condensing an intricate, 1000+ page revenge plot into a 400 page YA fantasy novel, all while giving it her own unique spin with South Asian magic and a gender-flipped heroine. The story cuts between Dania's past with Mazin, her past lover and now enemy, and Dania's present schemes. With this cast of characters, Varga asks the audience what price is worth paying, by your own hand or by the blood of others, for vengeance. The characters foil each other nicely, and Dania's brute-force personality sends her flying through the pages. I especially enjoy the change made to include a certain character who exits the story pretty early on in the original novel. Certain beats did feel repetitive, especially as the length of the book necessitated a fair amount of showing versus telling. The revenge schemes are on the simpler side, trapped by the confines of needing to fit into one book, but the dance of Dania and Mazin, as they navigate the aftermath of his betrayal, kept me hooked. Lovers to enemies—let's get some more of that, please!

For She Is Wrath delivers on its promise of delightful revenge, interwoven with the will-they-won't-they of a lovers-to-enemies subplot. I'd recommend it to anyone who wants a fast-paced action-adventure story where karma always collects its due.

Really enjoyed this re-imagined gender-swapped version of the Count of Monte Cristo. Dania is one kickass heroine and though, like her inspiration, there are times you want to reach into this book and shake her, she's an incredibly well-developed character that you can't help rooting for, even when you know she's making some really bad decisions. The world she inhabits is rich and lush and some of the descriptions of magic were simply divine (and quite grotesque at times, just warning you now). The use of chapters to tell the backstory interwoven with the current day action worked really well with this story and as more of the blanks get filled in, you do understand, though probably may not agree, with how all the characters get the climax of the story. There is a bit of the miscommunication trope, which is one of my least favorite tropes of all time and really ends up with massive consequences here, but the plot works through it pretty well so it didn't annoy too much (especially since if you are paying attention, you probably have a lot of things figured out before you get to the ending but there is one doozy of a twist to the villain I did not see coming). Wholeheartedly adored this read!

For She Is Wrath follows the life of Detective Ellie O'Conner, a determined and flawed protagonist grappling with personal demons while pursuing justice in a gritty urban landscape. Varga skillfully weaves together intricate plot threads, combining pulse-pounding action with deep psychological insight into the characters. As Ellie delves deeper into a complex web of crime and corruption, the lines between right and wrong blur, challenging both her professional ethics and personal convictions. Fans of dark, atmospheric thrillers will find themselves engrossed in this compelling tale of crime, redemption, and the cost of vengeance.

SO GOOD! Ok so I have to admit I’ve never read The Count of Monte Cristo but I adored this book. The setting and magic was amazing. The enemies to lovers was chefs kiss, loved it.

Thank you NetGalley and Wednesday Books for providing me with an e-arc in exchange for an honest review.

3/5 stars

As a revenge book I felt like this was missing some of the cut throat revenge aspects. It was a little too cozy fantasy for me? I expected more political intrigue and cut throat decisions. I feel like the end was just too clean and easy.

I enjoyed the writing for this book. The author did a good job fleshing out the story and characters. The magic system was unique and not overly complicated. I do think the before chapters might have been better more as a prologue or intro to the book. As it did explain why she was mad and wanted revenge.

I enjoyed learning about Dania and her past. Mazin was her first love and the betrayal cut deep. I think what annoyed me is that she didn’t think it through of like maybe it wasn’t him? It was just too easy to be framed. Dania and Noors friendship was my favorite part. I loved learning more about Noor and seeing her personality. It was nice for Dania to have a friend finally.

I feel like we know very little about Mazin. We got tidbits from him growing up around Dania. Other than that we don’t know his hobbies or really anything else about him besides his sister. I think it would have felt deeper if we had seen some more romantic moments between her and Mazin.

Overall this was an easy read and I enjoyed following Dania on her path to revenge. The author set up the book nicely to follow Noor next which sounds intriguing.

At what point, if any, is the cost to obtain revenge on those who have betrayed you greater than the reward that vengeance would bring? That is the question facing Dani in "For She is Wrath." Dani's father is a master bladesmith who taught her to fight with swords, daggers, and other weapons. Her combination of innate talent and training has made her a deadly foe. It has also attracted the attention of Mazin, the ward of Emperor Vahid, and eventually Mazin becomes a training partner, then friend, then so much more. However, when Dani is falsely accused of murder and treason, Mazin does not come to her rescue but rather gives the order for her arrest. Dani is shipped off to a prison run by a sadistic warden who enjoys torturing prisoners.

A year into her incarceration, and shortly after her latest failed escape attempt, Dani meets a fellow prisoner, Noor, who is also trying to escape. Noor has been trying to dig her way out of the prison, but she made a wrong turn and ended up breaking through the floor of Dani's cell, much to their mutual surprise. Noor has spent more than three years in prison because the emperor and the warden believe she knows where her chieftain, Souma, hid his treasure, which includes a large quantity of zoraat, the magical seeds, obtained from a djinn, that are the source of Emperor Vahid's power, which has no intention of sharing. Noor does know where to find the treasure, and also knows how to mix the zoraat properly so it can be used for its intended purposes. Noor and Dani will work together to escape the prison and then seek revenge on those who wronged them, starting with those wronged Dani and ending with the emperor, who wronged them both, and who is a tyrant.

However, what Dani finds upon escape from prison is not what she expected. The person she most hoped to be reunited with is dead, betrayed by a greedy "friend." Dani, in disguise, will also unexpectedly meet Mazin before she is ready, which will complicate things, as her feelings toward Mazin are conflicted. Some parts of their plan work wonderfully but other parts do not go as intended, and unexpected events/interventions will increase the stakes. Dani will be offered a "bargain" that will seemingly guarantee the revenge she seeks but will almost certainly cost her everything in return.

The story contains a mix of Indian, southeast Asian, and Arabic elements in the clothing, weapons, food, customs, societal structure, mythology (djinns), etc. The characters, especially Dani, Mazin, and Noor are complex and well developed. There are numerous surprises in the story, including who was really behind the murder for which Dani was framed and why the murder occurred. Vengeance is a motivating factor for multiple characters, but those who have attempted to obtain revenge found it is not as satisfying as expected, and that it came with unexpected costs.

This novel is more than a romance. It is a story about revenge and how it can consume you. It is a story about the greed for power and how it can take over even good intentions. It is a story about the power of love and of friendship. I enjoyed the addition of a culture unknown to me - the sprinkling of which in no way hampered my enjoyment or understanding of the story. For She Is Wrath was a quick read for me and it is one I would recommend if you enjoy reading reading fantasy with a touch of romance.

A fantastical story that keeps you guessing. What price are you willing to pay to avenge a loss? Were you betrayed or were others trying to save you? Do you save a friend or just walk away? Will the love of your life recognize you beyond time and appearance? Find these answers and more in this magical adaptation of The Count of Monte Cristo. I highly recommend this book for lovers of magic, adventure, love, and finding what's really important in life.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of this book! While I haven't yet had the chance to read the Count of Monte Cristo, this dynamic retelling had my attention throughout and honestly made me want to go back and read the classic. A YA fantasy romance where the romance isn't super trope-y and there are twists around every corner. It's hard to find, but this book does it. I will say there were points were I wasn't totally onboard and found myself bored with the characters from time to time, but overall very enjoyable.

A fantastic story about revenge and how it's nothing but a vicious cycle, Was not expecting the twist villain. I liked this much better than another Count of Monte Cristo inspired book I read earlier this year. This one was more cohesive and it was easier to fall into the world.

<i><b>This was who I would become in front of him. A sweet, beautiful confection. And when he bit into the honeyed sugar, it would be poison filling his mouth.</b></i>



⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Due to the nature of this situation my review will be short and remain my thoughts of this novel. This will be my only review.

<b>I do not condone the behavior and racial discrimination that this publisher employs. I’m very disappointed in them for not addressing this to the public and instead ignoring this situation. All we ask is accountability.</b>


I did enjoy this novel by Emily and how she was able to create this beautiful Palestinian romantic fantasy retelling of The Count of Monte Cristo.

I loved the protagonist seeking revenge for the people who betrayed her. Her vengeance was so strong it almost took over her until she soon learns redemption would save herself from her darkness and not wanting the Zoraat seeds to take control of her like how it took over people she knew and loved.

<b>Thank you so much Emily Varga, and NetGalley for the chance to read and review this e-arc in exchange for an honest review! All thoughts and opinions remain my own.</b>

It was the title that had me look into the synopsis of this book, and the revenge promised in its pages that kept me reading. Dania is a character that moves mountains, contains power in her every thought, and possesses a single-minded drive that makes her an incredible, and incredibly flawed, protagonist. It pulls no punches as a retelling of a classic revenge story, but brings in plenty of twists perfect for the brutal world of Varga's own creation. Sprinkle in a bit of magic, and you've got an amazing read.

You'll root for Dania, and question her morality. You see the grayness of the world she can't but also how she ends up making the choices she does. If you're anything like me, you will be frustrated, nervous, and angry throughout the book, agree with more moderate characters, and curse Dania's decisions, but cheer on her actions as often as you can in the meantime (but, to be like me, you must root for fictional women's wrongs). Overall, Varga manages to paint a frustratingly believable, dark novel with enough glimmers of light to keep you devouring its pages.

Review to be posted to @madthoreads on Instagram 10/08/24

Thank you to Wednesday Books & Netgalley for this book, all opinions are my own.

A strong debut! I enjoyed diving into this story, it is definitely a lush fantasy with some unique characters.

A good bulk of this story deals with revenge, and righting wrongs. The main character was falsely accused of murder, and once she escapes prison she is determined to burn it all down - sparing no one. She does this along with her friend Noor, who has her own reasons for bringing down the empire as well. These two worked well together, and while there were times I felt like Dani led a very one-sided relationship, they needed each other to see this plot through.

I enjoyed the duo timelines, it made the betrayals feel that much more hurtful, but I was also left hoping Dani and Maz would work things out in the end! And the end? Phew, there were more twists than I was expecting, and some unassuming characters really shine toward the end of the story! Dani made some strong decisions in the name of toppling her enemies, but everything turned out okay in the end.

Overall, this is a story with a strong female lead that is not afraid to right her wrongs, with some magic sprinkled in. The story was entertaining and I enjoyed the characters in it, and I was invested in seeing how everything would play out. This was a strong debut, and I would not be surprised to see some special editions of this book pop up on/around the pub date this October!
Content warnings: imprisonment, torture, death, loss of a loved one, drug use, violence, addition, emotional abuse

This book promises a sweeping, Pakistani romantic fantasy retelling of The Count of Monte Cristo, but unfortunately, it fails to deliver on its intriguing premise. Instead, readers are subjected to a monotonous journey that feels more like a chore than an adventure.

The story follows Dania, framed for a crime she didn't commit, as she seeks vengeance against Mazin, the boy she once loved. Despite the potentially thrilling setup, the narrative quickly becomes bogged down by its own repetitiveness. The plot circles the same points, with little to no advancement, making it a struggle to stay engaged. Each turn feels predictable, sapping any excitement from Dania's quest.

The characters, too, leave much to be desired. Dania's motivations are clear, but her personality lacks depth, making it difficult to root for her. Mazin, the supposed love interest and antagonist, is equally bland, devoid of any redeeming qualities that might have made their complex relationship compelling. The supporting cast is similarly one-dimensional, with interactions that feel forced and unconvincing.

While the book's setting and the inclusion of dark magic and a djinn treasure could have added a layer of richness to the story, these elements are underutilized, serving only as background noise to an otherwise uninspired plot. The pacing is sluggish, with the tension between Dania and Mazin failing to ignite the narrative in any meaningful way.

Ultimately, this is a disappointing read that squanders its potential with repetitive storytelling and a cast of unlikable characters. For those seeking a thrilling, romantic fantasy, this book regrettably misses the mark.