If you like dark, detailed fantasy worlds and intricate, clever plotting, then The Failures is a must read. If you’re less sold on its type of grand fantasy, then the slower, at times uneven, pacing might put you off.

With the sky broken and darkness closing in, the fate of The Wanderlands rests at the feet of a caged Giant. The fantasy world-building—a successful blend of grimdark, epic, and dystopian (with a dash of gearpunk)—more than matches the strength of this premise. The Wanderlands has an incredibly rich history and an intricate array of forces and mechanisms that govern it. Evocative writing brings it all to life, the darkness palpable as its monsters and insanity close in. You experience the world alongside a cast of varied and dynamic characters as they circle the Giant— that leads to the final destruction of The Wanderlands or its salvation.

Unfortunately, the journey does sputter and drag in moments. The plot is sprawling, and it simply takes time to assemble all the pieces together. Additionally, the characters’ story arcs are quite different from coming of age, to revenge, to adventure, to political intrigue. And, while it is very fun finding all the clever hints and trying to fit the narratives together, I enjoyed some much more than others. Less subjectively, to juggle all the plotlines, the story will sometimes unnecessarily cut away from the climax of one narrative to focus on a slow point in another. The prose often compounds this drag, repeating information more than necessary and, while often beautiful, using three sentences to describe what could be said in one.

Still, if you wonder whether the plot knows where it’s going, I can assure you that it absolutely does. Nearly everything is purposeful, coming together masterfully (even if, as a caveat, much of the effects won’t be felt until the sequel). Best of all? It feels like only the surface of The Wanderlands has been uncovered. The sequel promises to be even better.

Thank you to NetGalley and DAW for the ARC.

When I first started reading this novel I wasn't sure I would enjoy it. Boy was I wrong. This novel defies genre. It is a mix of fantasy, sci-fi and steampunk. It contains a wide range of characters and a cyclical story style that leaves you piecing together the timeline of the story as you go. The characters are so well written and thought out that each one leaves a mark on you. They are deep and compelling. The world itself is ornate, detailed and fascinating. It's hard to say who the main characters are, Is it the Killers? The brothers? The Wise? or the Cold? A mad god has sent dreams to the fools and children of the wanderlands. She wants items and has a goal in sight. To bring back the sun her goals must be realized. But other forces in the worlds are against her. Are they working for the Dark? or trying to save civilization as it exists, barely clinging to the sides and inner halls of the Mountain. Who will win? Who will fail? What does failing mean in this world and who really wants what is best for the survivors of the Fall? Damn this book has everything.

This review is a copy of the transcript of my video review on The Failures

Review copy provided by the publisher—DAW Books—in exchange for an honest review.

4.5/5 stars

The Failures is an extremely ambitious, mind-bending, and meticulously constructed debut novel.

“If we are truly just cogs, and part of some great machine, then it must run poorly indeed.”


Finding a new epic fantasy debut from a new author in traditional publishing is relatively rare. At the time of this review, traditional publishing seems to prefer cozy fantasy and romantasy most. But even if the state of publishing is favoring epic fantasy, a debut as twisted, ambitious, and rewarding as The Failures by Benjamin Liar would still be a once-in-a-blue-moon moment. The Failures was never in my radar. I didn’t even know about this book until I received an email from Matt Bialer, the literary agent of Patrick Rothfuss, Tad Williams, and many other authors, including Benjamin Liar. Bialer asked me to put The Failures on my list of books to watch out for in 2024 because he and DAW Books believed reading this book felt like encountering The Name of the Wind for the first time again. The Name of the Wind is one of my favorite books of all time, and although The Failures is very different from The Name of the Wind, hearing that kind of statement from Rothfuss's agent and publisher means there was no way I could pass this up. Additionally, two of my favorite authors, Tad Williams and Christopher Ruocchio, sang their echoing praise for this book. And I am in awe of the huge scope Liar prepared for this book and trilogy.

“Any utopia founded on the assumption that people will suddenly stop being selfish, irrational monkeys is a fool’s dream.”


The official premise says it nicely. The Failures is the first book in The Wanderlands trilogy by Benjamin Liar. It is a genre-breaking blend of post-apocalyptic sci-fi and epic fantasy about a scattered group of unlikely heroes traveling across their broken mechanical planet to stave off eternal darkness.

The Wanderlands—A vast machine made for reasons unknown—was broken long ago.

First went the sky, splintering and cracking, and then very slowly, the whole machine—the whole world—began to go dark. Following the summons of a strange dream, a scattering of adventurers, degenerates, and children find themselves drawn toward the same place: the vast underground Keep. They will discover there that they have been called for a purpose—and that purpose could be the destruction of everything they love.

For below the Keep, imprisoned in the greatest cage ever built by magicians and gods, lies the buried Giant: Kindaedystrin. It is the most powerful of its kind, and its purpose is the annihilation of all civilization. But any kind of power, no matter how terrible, is precious in the dimming Wanderlands, and those that crave it are making their moves.

All machines can be broken, and the final cracks are spreading. It will take only the careless actions of two cheerful monsters to tip the Wanderlands towards an endless dark...or help it find its way back to the light.

“This is a story about the end of the world; this is a story about monsters. From such small origins come such calamity; from such humble beginnings are born such dire endings. May the Mother have mercy on them for their innocence. And for what they did, for what they caused to happen, may the Twins rake the flesh from their bones until the end of all time.”


Where should I begin reviewing a book like The Failures? It is difficult to choose where to start; I can tell you right from the first chapter, I was instantly reminded of FromSoftware’s Dark Souls series, one of my favorite series of games of all time. The utility of bonfire in the land of absolute darkness in the first chapter, and then having this as a recurring implementation in the unconventional narrative throughout the whole book, made The Failures far from what I would categorize as accessible for new readers of the genre. It is relatively demanding. The narrative doesn’t hold your hand. Terminologies and the story structure require your attention, and the book will shift the gears of your mind to work, keep asking questions, and solve answers on its own. For those of you who feel that new epic fantasy, lately and as seldom as they’re published now, tend to handhold the readers too much, The Failures is the book for you.

“A child should possess three qualities in abundance: Wonder, Curiosity, and Mischief. The child should pursue these qualities constantly, and for as long as they are able, for this is the purpose and sole responsibility of Childhood. When the child becomes an adult, of course, these qualities become the most dangerous sort of liability.”


Every chapter, terminology, and revelation I learned from understanding the subtleties and contexts astonished me repeatedly. When you think about it, the premise of the entire novel, as I said earlier, for the lack of a better word, is so badass in premise and execution. Liar’s intricate world-building is, without a doubt, one of the primary strengths of The Failures. Having a story taking place in a land of darkness where light is precious, and then the existence of a complex and massive city hidden underneath an insanely vast mountain with a supposedly extinct giant with the capability of destroying or saving the world made The Failures a unique reading experience. When I was reading the book, I kept thinking... there’s no way this kind of novel and world-building is conjured in the span of a year or two. And I was proven right when I read the acknowledgment at the end of the book. Benjamin Liar said the conception of the world behind The Failures began 30 years ago. And I am not surprised by this. Arcane energies, automata, the behemoth, possibly multiple worlds, ancient weapons, portal-forged swords, mysterious characters with legendary deeds, and many more. The rich world-building, history, and plotting behind The Failures with the theme of darkness and light, redemption, family, ambition, and friendship is rigorous and mind-blowing. Something worth doing is worth your time doing well, and Liar ascertained that.

“Like all stories about the end of the world, it is hard to know where to start, and doubly so with stories about The Monsters. Do we start when Gun met Jackie? Or, perhaps, when they got the sword, the piece of dumb steel that would play such an oversized part in such great events? Do we instead travel back to when Gun first had the dream, the dream of darkness and a Giant, and of a shining, silvery sword? Do we, perhaps, attempt to relate the unremarkable story of Gun’s childhood, in an effort to tease out reasons behind what he did? Must we peer at the young face of Jackie Aimes to see if we can find the seed of the creature she would become?”


Mysteries were constantly evoked from every POV chapter, and Liar ramps up the storytelling quality with more answers AND questions with every page. With new answers I gained, new questions spurred in my mind. This is owed to how intriguing and engaging the storylines were. From my experience, I wouldn’t categorize The Failures as a character-driven novel. And that is usually an issue for me. The narrative is told through the perspective of several POV characters, and there is an omniscient tone and execution to the storytelling. Some parts of the narration slightly reminded me of reading The Grace of Kings by Ken Liu. This puts the characters at risk of feeling distant. Thankfully, the tone and focus of the narrative are always centered on the main character within the group of POV. Plotting is one of the most significant aspects of The Failures. The story is divided into several groups of characters. First, we have the perspective of Sophie Vesachai and her companions, The Killers. Despite being foul-mouthed, reckless, and rude, Sophie’s deep protectiveness and faith toward her group of friends—such as Bear, Trik, etc—named The Killers was really good. Like Sophie, we readers are trying to find the answers to many questions in the story together. I wouldn’t dub The Killers as my favorite storyline, though.

“Trust, unlike love, is a deliberate exercise of will. You can’t help who you love. But you sure as hell can choose who you trust. Even if, as is sometimes the case, you happen to love them.”


My favorite storylines in The Failures are the perspectives of The Monsters, The Convox/Cabal, and The Lost Boys. And every one of them has their respective feel and strengths. The Monsters, the tale of Gunnar Anderson and Jackie, felt more post-apocalyptic than the other. But the darkness and stakes in their story felt powerful and palpable. Their decision and careless actions with their sword and walking sticks in the face of deadly automata and overwhelming darkness will be crucial to the state of The Wanderlands. I was always excited to be back reading Gunnar and Jackie's story. It felt like I was reading the prose version of Tsutomu Nihei's work—the mangaka responsible for Blame! and Knights of Sidonia.

“First, I may be good or I may be bad, but I’m a lot more likely to be both. Like, for instance, every single other creature that ever lived. Thinking you know what someone will do just because you think they’re ‘good’ or ‘bad’ is a quick way to lose at the game you’re playing. Good people do appalling things for good reasons, and bad people do good things for selfish reasons and every combination between.


And I guess, in a way, the same can also be applied to The Lost Boys, which is essentially a coming-of-age story of James and Chris D’Essan under the tutelage of Alvarez. Coming-of-age is always one of my favorite tropes in science and fantasy, and it was easy for me to get used to their story. The themes of brotherhood, the death of innocence, and childhood are explored heavily here.

“His brother loved learning things, loved it more than anything else in the world, and this made him James’ natural enemy. Chris—and James could still hardly believe it was true—read books for fun.”


Finally, we have the first POV chapter of the novel, The Convox or The Cabal. It would not be far-fetched to say this is like witnessing the perspective and scheming of the main villains—Winter, Candle, West, D’alle, Primary Gray—of The Failures. I wish I could talk about the best aspects of these POV chapters in more detail, but there is a bit of an issue in trying to explain their magnificence as spoiler-free as possible fully. The Failures is one of those circumstances where I believe the less you know about these characters, the better your reading experience will be. But rest assured, it is all brilliant. Although they might feel disjointed at first, intentionally, all of their tales are gradually leading toward a grand convergence.

“Names are important things, defining things; magical things. The man who currently calls himself West has had many names. They are like lenses through which he projects himself. There is power in names, power over hearts, channels for the mind. “


Actually... There is one more POV chapter in The Failures. The Deadsmith. Your miles may vary, but unfortunately, The Deadsmith is the only POV character that did not click with me. Not as much as the previous four I mentioned. Even though similar to them, The Deadsmith story converged eventually as well; it is too bad I found only the last two chapters of his storyline engaging enough to enjoy. The convergence also did not feel as satisfying as how the narrative converged in the other four POV chapters. This was the only criticism I had with the book. But again, this is a very personal take. I am sure other readers will feel differently about this.

“Point being, you little stubborn sum-bitch, that you can take some dirt and you can make the most incredible things in the world, but it takes work. It takes sacrifice. It takes time, and it takes commitment. It takes wisdom.”


Overall, I was thoroughly impressed. I have no doubt rereading The Failures by Benjamin Liar will be an entirely new adventure from reading it for the first time. If the pleasure of the first time reading the novel is in decoding how the twisted labyrinth fits together, the second time reading with all the knowledge acquired will be to have a deeper understanding of the author’s vision and storytelling. I have already highlighted more than 40 well-written passages for my perusals next time.

“Only a fool steps over an unexpected weight of silver because they are hoping to find gold.”


The Failures is a complex, ambitious, and madness of a puzzle designed carefully. It was as if this debut novel was penned by a veteran author in the SFF genre. Story and chronology structure-wise, the closest popular science fantasy book I can think of is The Fifth Season by N.K. Jemisin and Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell. Blame! by Tsutomu Nihei is the closest vibe and tone I felt from reading The Failures. As the author mentioned at the end of the book, he borrowed elements from so many giant literary authors in the SFF genre, such as Tad Williams, Ursula K. Le Guin, Dan Simmons, Stephen King, Bujold, Glen Cook, Stephen Donaldson, China Mieville, Tsutomu Nihei, and more. Through them, Liar became the incredible architect who renovated The Failures into his own distinct work of art. It is a novel 30 years in the making, and the ending of The Failures exhibited that the endgame has only just begun. Multiple plot threads have converged. And the fate of the Wanderlands will be decided in the remaining books of the trilogy. I, for one, am excited to have this kind of ambitious debut still being published by a new author. And I definitely will read the sequels whenever they are ready.

“There’s no more time for secrets, or false names, or subterfuge. It’s time that we know each other’s stories; the long and painful and uncomfortable stories of how we ended up in the Keep, here at the end— and beginning—of everything.”


You can order this book from: Amazon | Blackwells (Free International shipping)

The quotes in this review were taken from an ARC and are subject to change upon publication.

You can find this and the rest of my reviews at Novel Notions | I also have a Booktube channel

Fools on the mountain

Benjamin Liar's (a pseudonym, of course) debut novel The Failures is a big book, the first novel in the planned Wanderlands Trilogy. It has been a long time in the making. In the author's note "A Round of Applause, A Round of Shots", he tells us

"I started writing— not this book, exactly, but exploring the place that I would eventually name The Wanderlands— over thirty years ago."*

The Wanderlands are a dark and broken world without a sky. Most of the story concerns the actions of five people or groups of people:

The Lost Boys
The Convox/Cabal
The Monsters
The Deadsmith
The Killers

Most chapters have two titles. The first is one of the five above, telling you who the chapter will be about. Then there is a second title that refers to the events about to be recounted. In addition to these chapters, there are five chapters named "An Aside: ..." -- these are (very welcome) brief infodumps about the history of the Wanderlands.

<spoiler>The chapters are not in temporal order. Events separated by many years often occur in adjacent chapters. The order in which I have listed them is roughly their temporal order, as well as I could work it out.</spoiler>

The title is nowhere explained. You will, however, quickly guess where it comes from. These people are losers. They're losers in different ways. Some are kids who never grew up, some will remind you of Bruce Springsteen's song "Glory Days", and some -- these are the most pathetic -- believe themselves to be gods and puppeteers, directing the fates of all the lesser beings who surround them. The events take place on top of, around, and under a huge mountain. Aside from the mountain we see only a little of the Wanderlands.

The Failures is a world-building story. By the time you reach the end, you will have some grasp of what the Wanderlands are, how a part of them works, and what is likely to come. There is more than a hint that one day some of the Failures may be Glorious. I will certainly read the whole trilogy.

Thanks to NetGalley and DAW for an advance reader copy of The Failures. Release date 2-Jul-2024.

*Quotes are from an advance reader copy and may change before publication. This review will be corrected if necessary on the release date.

Unfortunately I just didn't enjoy this one the way I hoped I would. The characters all seemed a bit too edgy, to the point where it all felt somewhat forced. Also the story itself is kind of muddled, I never really connected or knew what was going on half the time. I tried I really tried but some books are just going to be misses and this one definitely qualified as a miss for me. Thank you to the publisher for approving my request and I wish I could have given this a better verdict.

unfortunately i could not get into this one and had to DNF. i’m not sure if there was too much world building or if i just wasn’t in the right headspace to get into this, but it wasn’t for me. the premise is so cool and original and the writing is great, just not my vibe right now. will def try to pick this up again later though!

This is a delightful book that throws the reader into a intriguing world and allows the reader to slowly figure out and understand what is going on. It was a little difficult at first but after a while the thrill of piecing everything together was part of the charm of this book. One hint (that some might helpful) is that this story alternates between a few different storylines and characters in various locations. One might assume that everything is going on at the same time but that is not the case; some of the storylines happens decades apart.

This is a story that is difficult to explain to others what it’s about. My best attempt is that it involves a wide cast character including: a secret cabal, a roughneck gang, “monsters”, and children. They are all being lead by various motivations to find these magical artifacts to eventually free/kill a Giant/world destroyer that is located under a massive mountain. I found myself entertained by this story and am very much looking forward to see what happens next!

This book gives you apocalyptic world staged in a mountain. The way he built and explain this world is so amazing and I can’t wait for future books with this series. The book can be a little difficult to follow if you don’t focus on the storyline and what’s happening but overall 10/10

I went into this book not knowing nothing except the premise and let me tell you this book blew me away the characters the World building this is something fresh that I feel that people are going to love I can't wait till it comes out and I can physically buy it and do a reread it sometime this year great start can't wait to read more