For fans of The Wishing Game and The Chronicles of Narnia comes this ambitious fairy tale of a book.
For me, I thought the first part of the book revved up and really moved me to want to read about men going back in to the woods where they were once lost. You knew once there, something magical was to come. Sadly the second half of the book just didn’t grab me in the same way. I think those who grew up enjoying stories of fairies, knights and princesses will enjoy it, but for as much as I truly enjoyed The Wishing Game, this novel was not for me. Still I give it 3*

What a fun fantasy read. The Lost Story was such an easy enjoyable read, I read it in less than 24 hours. This Narnia inspired fairy tale features love, friendships, magical realism, found family, both literal and actual, and all sorts of magical creatures.

The character development was so nicely done, I loved all four of the main characters, and the Narnia inspired world building was wonderfully written.

This is one of those books that you just hope to see made into a movie one day, all the fantasy elements are so imaginative, you know it will make a beautiful movie.

Highly recommend for anyone who is looking for a fantasy book with childlike imaginative details. Not a children’s book though, more geared towards upper YA and adult.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for sending me a copy in exchange for an honest review.

The Lost Story is a fun adventure with a really interesting magical world and a few bizarre elements. The plot read a little wonky to me; it felt like we reached the climax early and then wound down for many pages. I was surprised to see strong LGBTQIA representation, so that would have to be the reader’s thing. I would classify this as more YA with adult themes rather than women’s fiction. Overall, I was glad to be introduced to a new fantasy and I would read more from Meg Shaffer just for her worldbuilding.

Thank you to Random House - Ballentine Books and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Normally magic isn't my thing, but Meg Shaffer does it beautifully! This book completely swept me out of this realm and into the Forrest with our characters. I couldn't get enough!

“All books are magic. An object that can take you to another world without even leaving your room? A story written by a stranger and yet it seems they wrote it just for you or to you? Loving and having people made out of ink and paper, not flesh and blood? Yes, books are magic. Maybe even the strongest magic there is.”

This story was magical. The world of Shanandoah (spelled this way for a reason) was whimsical, magical, heartfelt, inspiring, and funny. This book deals with a minor theme of abuse, but more than that it deals with love, friendship, and finding your place in this world (or another, if you’re lucky).

The only thing that caught me off guard was the LGBTQ storyline, and only because the synopsis compares this book to the Chronicles of Narnia by C.S. Lewis. And while the worlds are actually very similar, I think it caught me off guard because Lewis was a renowned Christian author, and the comparison to his stories is what drew me into this book initially. So I was not prepared! But even though LGBTQ fiction/romance would not be my normal taste of genre, I did love the couple and their story in this book ◡̈

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC of this book! The Lost Story is expected to come out in July 2024.

MEG. She be writing my favorite books lately. I love this magical realism, I loved that there wasn't 15 chapters of world building and names I can't even begin to pronounce. This novel felt so wholesome, truly just like playing pretend as a child. It had everything a good fairytale should.

I had to give up on this book...the premise is very interesting and draws you in but the writing, especially dialogue, is awful...I read The Wishing Game by this author and I was able to make it through that but the same qualms I had with that book are still present in her second book. I don't know anything about Meg Shaffer but she gives her main characters some odd traits and it doesn't sit well with me.

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

☆☆☆☆☆

"All books are magic... A story written by a stranger and yet it seems they wrote it just for you or to you? ... Yes, books are magic. Maybe the strongest magic there is."

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Synopsis: Emilie is searching for her long-lost sister that she recently learned about after the passing of her mother. To find her, she turns to missing-person extraordinaire, Jeremy Cox. Fifteen years earlier, he and his best friend, Rafe, went missing in Red Crow State Park and after six months, emerged, unharmed and changes. No one knows what happened to them, Rafe doesn't remember, but Jeremy does. And they weren't missing... they were transported to a world of magic and dreams. And Jeremy thinks that this is where Emilie's sister might be. But before they can go and find her, he'll have to convince Rafe, eho he hasn't talked to in years. And both of them will need to confront their pasts and their feeling for each other.
-
-
After The Wishing Game, The Lost Story was at the top of my to-read list, and I am so excited I got the chance to read this. Meg Shaffer has this unique way of making magic real, feeling like you can reach out and grab it, be immersed in it. And it's not just in the fantastical, necessarily, even with the actual fantasy world of The Lost Story. The magic is found in the small moments, the connections and memories we form in our childhood and throughout our journeys. Even among the pain and in-between the hardships, there can be beauty and lifelines that give us hope, even if we don't recognize it in the moment.
-
All the characters are on very real journeys, Emilie's one of discovering purpose, finding and creating connection when she thinks she's all alone. She becomes so intent on finding her sister after her mother passes, thinking that it's the only family she's got left. For Jeremy and Rafe, it's about rediscovering who they are, for themselves, and to each other. They must confront their past and rekindle their love. And only when all three of our characters have made strides in their personal journeys are they then able to make progress on their search.

I realize that I'm being vague in many ways with this review and only talking about
feelings, but I think that's a testament to Meg Shaffer's writing, that it has me
reflecting, not just reading.

The Lost Story is very much an ode to fairytales, as well as a deconstruction. It's whimsical, beautiful, and heartfelt. And it's a love letter to the power of stories and connection.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.

If you enjoyed The Wishing Game then this book is for you. The Author is wonderful at creating worlds for the adult book lovers that thrust them back into a child like world. You can tell this was heavily inspired by Narnia and The Wizard of Oz.

4/5 stars

This was such a fun, magical, and whimsical story. I was a Narnia kid and can’t help but love anything inspired by it. If you love found family, LGBTQ+ rep, stories about stories, and fantastical kingdoms, you’ll love this!

This was a story I wasn't expecting. If you're into magical worlds and hidden (yet not), love affairs, friendship, and what the power of that love can do, this book would be for you. Getting lost in the world of Shenandoah brought back all the memories of Narnia. This gives hope that secret lands still exist and gives hope that we will always find our way back to those we love.

Things I liked:
- Other/magical world
- Romance, but not over-the-top
- Secrecy
- Feels like there could be a sequel
- The storyteller's interjections were enough without being obnoxious

Thanks, NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Meg Shaffer sure knows how to tell a story! This was magical, set in a place of breathtaking detail and enchanting landscapes. At times, it reminded me of the beauty of the Robin Wiliams movie, What Dreams May Come. I did enjoy this book, especially the characters, but her first book, The Wishing Game was even better (IMO).

Many years ago, there were two boys who were lost in the woods. Eventually they were found, one remembers what happened and the other does not. In the present day, a woman is searching for her long lost sister. Only these two boys (now men) can help her. “The Lost Story” captured my attention and I was engrossed throughout the entire tale.

For those who love:
📖 Mysteries
📖 Cold Cases
📖 Fairy Tales
📖 Contemporary Fantasy
📖 Quests

Many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC.

Meg Shaffer's debut novel was in my top 3 of 2023, so I was so excited to get a sneak peek at this one!
Narnia inspired, Stevie Nicks references, found family, this book is perfect fairytale for us adults who still believe in them!
Two boys go missing and return mysteriously 6 months later, and it's not until 15 years later that what truly happened to them in revealed. I really enjoyed getting lost in the fairytale world of Shanandoah.
Meg Shaffer is officially an auto-buy author!

There was so much to love in this well written, ambitious fairy tale for adults. It feels nostalgic, and I was swept up in the magical adventure. “Some day you will be old enough to start reading fairy tales again.” C.S. Lewis
The novel features Jeremy and Rafe, who were mysteriously lost in the woods of West Virginia for 6 months as young boys. They must return to the enchanted world 15 years later to help Emilie find her lost sister. Through various obstacles they discover everything that they’ve each lost. This book was simply a joy to read. Congratulations to the author on another fantastic achievement. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Ballantine for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

A brief disclaimer: I don't automatically and always object to 15-year-olds (or possibly 16-year-olds) falling in love and having a sexual relationship, as Rafe and Jeremy implicitly did in The Lost Story's past, but I'm aware that many people feel otherwise, so fair warning that if you're one of them, then this book may not be for you.

With that out of the way:

I can adduce flaws, lots of flaws. There's the framing device -- I was willing to go with it, but it's clunky, no getting around that.

The most glaring difficulty, though, is that while I'll grant Rafe and Jeremy sufficient discernment and autonomy to have had a serious love relationship at 15/16, I'm a lot more skeptical about that love enduring over a 15-year separation during which one of them has been stripped of conscious memory of their time in the magical land of Shanandoah [sic].

. . . On the other hand, great, enduring, depthless loves are the stuff of legend, and once you're in a portal fantasy, it's the stuff of legend you're working with. So although when I step back from The Lost Story, I balk, while I was reading I was entirely immersed in that relationship and longing for its restoration. You'd think the incredible aspects would be undermined by the entirely realistic aspects, to wit that neither of them was "faithful" during their separation, but for me it was the opposite -- that grounding in the world we live in helped me believe in their bond.

Fantasy worlds often come with a side of stilted dialogue and overall pious humorlessness; thankfully, this one doesn't. Emilie, whose search for her lost sister sets the present-day plot in motion, has no governor on her mouth whatsoever, and Jeremy is a courageous knight but also, as he's the first to acknowledge, an asshole, so it's a good thing Rafe dishes the assholery right back.

Ah, Rafe. Note the "child abuse" tag. His history of abuse at his father's hands is a central element of the plot. A spoiler here to discuss that abuse and how their relationship ends up: [spoiler-tagged on Goodreads, redacted here]. But all this may or may not land for a reader whose history too closely resembles Rafe's and who doesn't have a fantasy-world closure for that history.

About "Shanandoah," its name and its other cornball features (like the queen being named Skya): I had my suspicions early on about how that world had come to be, and they proved correct. If you find Shanandoah off-putting but you're otherwise enjoying yourself, maybe stick with the book and see what you think when the explanation appears. I was less happy about something The Lost Story shares with the Narnia books: not Christianity, but the apparent premise that there exists a "Creator." The references to this presumptive deity are fleeting and they show up late, plus which this book is devoid of the Narnia books' hostility toward the pleasures of this world, including, obviously, the pleasures of sex. But I could've done without.

tl;dr: In some respects, this book is a mess. But. But, but, but ... I was enthralled and deeply invested in Emilie's quest and in the relationship between Rafe and Jeremy, and also I leaked steadily during the last few chapters and over the partly happy, partly bittersweet ending. So five stars, especially for keeping me engaged over the course of several days arguing with Verizon tech support over a subtly defective new phone.

Thanks to Ballantine and NetGalley for the ARC; behold my honest review.

The description of this book was perfection. The book however, fell flat. First of all it was an extremely dialogue driven novel, with a lot of back and forth banter and no real going anywhere. I was looking forward to a Narnia like adventure and they didn't even get adventurin' til the book was halfway over. Then, it was just rushed. I just had extremely high hopes for this book of and it disappointed me.

I loved seeing some of the quirky, magical elements/vibes that I enjoyed in "The Wishing Game". I was excited to visit a Narnia-like land and the overall premise of the book. However, I didn't care for the relationships between the four main characters. They were a bit underdeveloped and it seemed like the book was trying to cover too much ground in too little time. It read like a middle-grade/teen story, except for the innuendo and sexual references, so that felt jarring to me. It relied pretty heavily on the C.S. Lewis connection, which felt a bit "easy" to me.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House/Ballantine Books for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Meg Shaffer writes such magical, creative stories. Between The Wishing Game and The Lost Story, I've become absolutely hooked on her storytelling ability. The Lost Story is a more teen/adult version of the Chronicles of Narnia, complete with a magical hidden kingdom. I loved Rafe, Jeremy, and Emilie as characters, and felt that they all were properly three-dimensional; however, the drama and danger of Shanandoah didn't quite seem dramatic enough given the setup. Anyway, it was still a very enjoyable book, and I'll be reading any other creative, magical stories Meg Shaffer publishes in the future!

The first third of this book had me hooked but after the characters moved to the secondary world, I lost interest. I love fantasy and was so excited for this title. It is a good read, but just seem to lose it's edge after the fantasy aspect was introduced. The characters were enjoyable and the writing well done.