Member Reviews

I was lucky to receive a digital ARC of this book from NetGalley and also see a print edition from my local library. In this middle grade graphic novel, Marcus feels pressure to play soccer. Izzy struggles to fit in and find true friends. The two are paired together for gym class and must perform a swing dance together. While their initial attempt is a disaster, the gym teacher gives them a chance to redeem their grade through talk Jen hit site participation. This book has some painfully accurate representation of middle school bullying, awkwardness, social drama, academic and familial pressure, and more. There were a lot of cringe-inducing foot-in-mouth moments but again probably on par with eighth grade interactions. Thankfully, the story ends on a positive gender-bending note of friendship and acceptance. The book is very readable with strong illustrations and coloring.

Was this review helpful?

Meeker, Audrey. Swing. Feiwel & Friends 2024, 978-1250864048. $14.99. 256p. Grades 4-8

Description: Marcus McAllister wants to fit in even when he feels like an outsider. He constantly tries to live up to his brother on the soccer field even though he doesn’t enjoy the sport.
Izzy Briggs could not care less about fitting in. She was born to stand out with her bold fashion choices and personality, so when she is partnered with Marcus McAllister for the swing dancing extra credit project in Gym she is less than enthused. Can these two learn to swing dance together and earn the extra credit they need to pass the class

Thoughts: As a whole this book was really enjoyable. I enjoyed that it highlighted gender roles and how Izzy was the “lead” in the swing dancing. I also really loved that the book highlighted toxic friendships when Marcus was being bullied by his “friend”, Ted.

Graphic Novel; Realistic Fiction; 741.5

Tags: Fitting in, Bullying, Relationship Skills, Self Awareness, Gender Issues, Trust, Soccer, Swing Dancing, Friendship

Was this review helpful?

Sweet book about how being true to yourself can sometimes be difficult. Unlikely alliances form in order to get a good class grade. It can be hard to choose between fitting in and being yourself. Thank you Macmillan Children's Publishing Group | Feiwel & Friends for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A story about two middle school students who ended up doing swing dancing with each other for gym class; however because of their poor performance in class, they had to participate at the talent show as a negotiation with the gym teacher in order to pass the class. Izzy, a strong girl who has a lot of self-confidence and is aware of what she likes and dislikes, was very patient with Marcus as he battles between satisfying his parents’ expectations of him and pleasing Ted in being part of the soccer team to be better than their older brothers. This entire book was definitely written under the perspective of middle school students and the challenges they face like bullying, peer pressure, and self-identity. Overall, the ending does conclude that being true to oneself is above all else!

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me an advanced copy for review!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to #NetGalley, Audrey Meeker, and the publisher of the book for the eARC copy in exchange for an honest review.

Marcus is so desperate to fit in that he's playing soccer just because his best friend Ted is. Izzy wants to stand out and tries to with her smarts and the way she dresses.
Things get bad though when she and Marcus are paired together for their dance unit in gym class. They do so badly their grade is at risk. Their only hope is to perform the swing routine in the talent show to receive a passing grade and extra credit. They accept but Izzy has one condition: she gets to lead the dance. Will they be able to get through the talend show in one piece?

A great middle grade graphic novel about doing what makes you happy and the pressures of friends.

Was this review helpful?

Really fantastic middle grade graphic novel! I like the exploration of likes and dislikes the way the characters reactions and family interactions were handled honestly. My only hang up is I would’ve liked to see the bully get his due on page that would’ve been really cathartic. Thanks to NetGalley for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

Marcus and Izzy have found themselves in a tough spot. They did not perform their swing dance well in gym class, so they have to perform it again during the school's talent show for extra credit. Marcus finds himself stuck between Izzy and dancing and his friend Ted and soccer. Izzy just wants to be herself. 'Swing' does not shy away from the hard, complicated feelings that come for Marcus and Izzy as they navigate friendship, self confidence, and middle school. This book is well-rounded and deserves a spot on every library's shelf.

Was this review helpful?

Swing by Audrey Meeker is a beautifully crafted story that captures the essence of youthful love and the complexities of growing up. I was drawn in by the rich characters and their emotional journeys, which felt both authentic and relatable. The way Meeker weaves themes of friendship, self-discovery, and the power of music made this book a truly enjoyable read that I couldn’t put down!

Was this review helpful?

I only enjoy contemporary middle grades when they are unique, or fun, or in graphic novel edition. This one is all three!
At the beginning it felt full of cliches: the boy who is almost bullied into playing soccer, the girl who has changed style over the summer, the bully who pretends to be a friend and makes fun of everyone… but the PE teacher suggesting dance in the first few pages is what kept me hooked!

Was this review helpful?

Middle school is tough; its a time when kids are trying to figure out who they are and who everyone around them thinks they should be. Marcus doesn't want to play soccer anymore, but his family and teammates expect him to give his all, just like his brother. Izzy wants to be herself - into drama and design, dressing in black, dying her hair, etc. But her mom has plans for her and expects nothing but the best. And her classmates label her the weird girl. When these two are thrown together for a school dance project, they just need to work together long enough to pass the class. Can they get past everyone else's expectations and see they have more in common than they thought?

Was this review helpful?

To fit in, Marcus plays soccer with his rude friend Ted, even though he dislikes the sport. However, when he is paired with Izzy—a girl known for her bold fashion choices—for a gym assignment on dance, their lack of trust leads them to fail the assignment completely. To pass gym class, they must perform their dance routine during the talent show. Throughout this experience, Marcus learns the importance of being true to himself and discovering his passions.
I absolutely adored this book to the point that I couldn't put it down and finished it in a single sitting. The protagonist, Marcus, comes across as an everyday guy, yearning for genuine friendships and striving to blend in with the crowd. In stark contrast stands Izzy, who exudes boldness and is determined to make her mark. While Marcus's demeanor is quite unremarkable, Izzy’s personality is a whirlwind of energy, often bordering on being a control freak. Their opposing traits create a delightful tension that enriches the narrative.
However, I must admit I found Ted rather off-putting. His rudeness and air of superiority made it hard to warm up to him. On a brighter note, the artwork throughout the book bursts with vivid colors, perfectly mirroring the lighthearted tone of the story. Every page had me chuckling, leaving me in high spirits.
Overall, I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone in search of a charming and heartfelt friendship tale.

Was this review helpful?

What a cute middle grade graphic novel! Izzy wants to stand out, while Marcus wants to blend in. When Izzy and Marcus are paired together in gym class, their clashing outlooks seem impossible to overcome. As the pair learns to work together, they also learn the value of friendship and spending their time on people and activities that they enjoy. I'll definitely be adding this to my classroom library!

Was this review helpful?

Marcus plays soccer though he hates it; Izzy loves designing clothes and has decided that she doesn’t care if anyone likes what she wears or not.

The two are thrown together because they are not doing well in P.E., and to keep their grades up they must learn a swing dance, and do it for the talent show, and place. If they can do that, they can bring their grades back up.

Thank you Netgalley, the author and publisher for the ARC - my 12 year old really enjoyed this book!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley, Macmillan Children’s Publishing Group, and Audrey Meeker for the opportunity to read this e-ARC!

Marcus plays soccer in the shadow of his superstar athelete older brother. Izzy is a hard-working student under the pressure of her mom.

They get paired up in gym class on the first day of 8th grade to perform a swing dancing routine in the class, but when it goes horribly wrong, they need extra credit to boost their grade. Their new assignment: prepare a routine for the school talent show.

Marcus struggles with trying to please his parents and a relentless "friend" who doesn't really act like a friend should. Izzy struggles against the pressure from her mom who doesn't understand that she wants to be a fashion designer.

The two find each other at a time when they need support from outside influences and help each other stand up for what they need.

This was a quick read, but relatable with peer pressure and parent pressure that middle schoolers face. And I love that it introduces swing dancing!

Was this review helpful?

"Swing" by Audrey Meeker is a great graphic novel featuring Marcus and Izzy who are paired to do swing dancing for a gym project. Navigating social pressures of middle school by either trying to fit in or stand out, this is an unlikely pairing. I really appreciated Audrey Meeker's writing and illustration. This book captures many aspects of middle school including trying to follow one's passions, pressure from sports, issues of bullies and dealing with family expectations. Although this book was tense at time, I enjoyed it and appreciated Meeker's message. Thanks to Macmillan Children's Publishing Group and NetGalley for the eARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was cute and fun! A story about the pressures that come from sports, school, family, and the struggle to fit in. I liked that both of the main characters stayed pretty awkward the whole time, they didn't just instantly get cool when they realized they could be friends.

Was this review helpful?

Marcus is trying so hard not to disappoint anyone that he keeps disappointing himself. Izzy is his partner in dancing, but Marcus thinks he needs to do soccer more, and he can't do both. I loved how much he learned about himself and how much better it is to express his real personality. Thanks to NetGalley for letting me read this sweet and heartfelt teen graphic novel

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautiful graphic novel, not only artistically but message wise. There is so much pressure as a teen trying to figure out where you fit. Trying to fulfill everyone expectations can be exhausting, especially when you are not doing things that fill you with joy. Sometimes though it feels like your joy has to take a back seat if you are going to make your parents or peers happy. I love that both Marcus and Izzy are both on their own journeys one to fit in and the other to stand out. I think that the progression of this story is perfection and one that will resonate with kids. That Marcus realizes that standing out is not always bad by the end of the book is just everything. So many times boys really get pigeon holed and Marcus breaks that mold and I appreciate that he does it with such grace. Thank you so much to Macmillan Children's Publishing Group, Feiwel & Friends, and Netgalley for allowing me to read an advance copy of this title.

Was this review helpful?

This book was great! Believable characters- not too heavy- but a good portryal of middle school pressures. I will be adding this to my school library collection for sure!

Was this review helpful?

Marcus doesn't want to disappoint anyone, even though that means he has to bear something he doesn't like. Izzy, on the other hand, is too confident with her bold fashion choice that her schoolmates bullied her until she has no friend left.
they met at the gym class and paired together to perform swing dance routine. it went disastrous. rough start, but there they friendship began.

i think it's a beautiful story, not an easy topic but delivered with such fun and heartwarming way. i loved it

Was this review helpful?