Member Reviews

First, thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday books for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book in exchange for a review!

What The Woods Took is a book that I was very much looking forward to, and I’m happy to say it definitely lived up to the hype I had for it! I think this premise is incredibly solid, and the characters are excellently crafted and were what really drew me into the story. The atmosphere of this book is also very well done, delivering on the creepy/scary setting and vibes I was hoping for. In particular, the development both intra- and interpersonally within our main cast of characters was great, and I think the main highlight of this book.

I did find myself wishing that this book had leaned more into the horror elements and atmosphere. Because this book is YA rather than adult, I think that what we got is suitable for the target audience but I still found myself wishing for more on that front. These kids’ situation is an incredibly horrifying one and I had hoped that would be leaned into a bit more than it was. While I had a great time with this book, it felt like there was something missing. Whether it’s that the horror is a bit more shallow than I’d expected, that I didn’t quite connect emotional with all the characters as deeply as I think I was supposed to, or something else I don’t know. But I did leave feeling a tad bit unsatisfied just because I found myself wanting more.

Overall, this book was still very very good with great development of these characters and excellent setting/plot. I think bringing more light to these types of wilderness rehab programs is also incredibly important, as their awful history has been coming to light in the public consciousness in recent years. Have the real life kids who were subjected to these programs forced to fight shape shifting monsters? Probably not, but they still face such horrifying experiences and it’s necessary to understand what those kids go through.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the arc of this book! I really enjoyed the spooky atmosphere that this book creates. I was on edge while reading, and I was so curious about what the monsters would end up being. My only qualm with this was how fast the romantic relationships moved- it kind of seemed out of the blue. The creepiness level was perfect for teens though!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to net galley for sending this one my way. This one was a spooky wild ride. Was kind of a slow burn but worth it. Love anything told from multiple POVs. If you like spooky summer camp vibes this one’s for you. 4⭐️

Was this review helpful?

I was hooked by chapter 3. It's just so creepy!

Rating: 4.25 ⭐️

"She knows she's a problem the way she knows her hair is brown and the sky is blue. She knows that she's a problem, but for once in her life, she wants to be her own problem."

What the Woods Took follows Devin as she is taken from her bed in the middle of the night to go to a wilderness therapy program. She and four other "troubled teens" are dropped off in the Idaho woods with two counselors set on changing their destructive ways. However, everything is not as it seems as they slowly become aware of inhuman faces peering out at them from between the trees...

I wish this book came out this month, because it's the perfect spooky season read! 🎃

What The Woods Took is very uncanny valley. And I loved it. For me, nothing scares me or creeps me out more than something that almost looks human. And an inhuman SMILE? I never recover from that.

One aspect I didn't like for a majority of the book, however, was Sheridan, one of the other "troubled teens." I could not stand her. I don't want to give away any spoilers, but I will say I begrudgingly grew to tolerate her and that the characters' arcs and interactions with one another are never anything less than complex.

Overall, I very much recommend this book if you're in the mood for something spooky. Keep an eye out for when it releases December 10th!

Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for providing me early access to What The Woods Took in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me the opportunity to read this as an ARC. I received a digital copy and so wish I had received a physical one now that I’ve finished it.

I devoured this. I started this at 1am and that was a mistake of colossal proportions. I just finished it and it’s about 5:30am.

Now, I’m not a horror reader, nor have I ever had nightmares inspired by any book, but there was something eerie about laying on my side, reading this book on my phone, and having a pitch black window showing off absolutely nothing just beyond my hand. I had to lower the blinds.

Gould does not over-detail what exists within the woods and I feel that’s one of the strengths. There is no oversaturation of excessive detail and that is a massive breath of fresh air in these modern book times.

My only grievances are with the… extinguishing (terrible pun intended) of one relationship, and the ignition (terrible pun intended 2.0) of another. The first made sad in that there was this really neat dynamic we could have seen and explored and I was down for it. The second was just too fast and I didn’t care for it. But it wasn’t enough of an issue for me to remove a star. (Although I think an exploration into the first would still be a fascinating read)

If you want a dark tinged story about teenagers getting into fights, learning to overcome fears, learning to trust, and growing up in a rather absurd yet delightful way, this is for you.

Was this review helpful?

I’m not sure exactly what it was but this book didn’t fully deliver for me. I wanted to connect with the characters more deeply than I did. I think the book wanted to be character driven but it just wasn’t. I will say that the characters did all feel very authentically like teenagers.

The monsters are horrifying but I’m not sure the trauma they are meant to represent comes across fully. There were plenty of things that were upsetting about the book and invoked feelings of horror; but the emotional impact wasn’t there for me.

I also was rooting for the romance but it again fell a little flat.

As an editor, I’m not sure what I would have tweaked to make this work better. I am inclined to think it just read this at a bad time & that’s why it came up short. Or the inevitable comparisons to The Dead and the Dark left What the Woods Took in the dust.

Was this review helpful?

Devlin is awakened in the middle of the night to find herself being kidnapped into a wilderness rehabilitation program for teens. Stuck in the middle of nowhere with a bunch of kids with various issues and two "counselors" tasked with forcing them on a weeks-long hike, she isn't exactly eager to open up about all the things that piss her off - especially not with Sheridan, who has even more of a chip on her shoulder. But then they enter a part of the woods that is far too quiet, and the first night, both counselors go missing. The group must work together to survive... but none of them are the type who wants to cooperate.

Once I got past a bit of confusion as the POV (3rd person limited) switched between Devlin and Ollie, I really enjoyed this novel. What they encounter in the forest was a unique kind of creature that seemed perfectly designed to unsettle these kids with their traumatic pasts. There wasn't a huge reveal of Devlin's past as I was expecting; even though bits of her past are unearthed, the main thrust of the story is everyone learning to trust each other without knowing all the details. This made it hard for the reader to know what was real to the point where I was second-guessing everyone up until the end. I expected a final scare, but that was the only tiny disappointment I had.

Was this review helpful?

Full disclosure: I went to one of these programs, so I was ready to be picky. I had no need to worry. This is a great book, accurate, scary, touching. Highly recommended. Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

The woods can be creepy enough. But throw in a bunch of teens stolen from their homes in the middle of the night for wilderness therapy and creatures that want to eat them, and you have a horror book that you don't want to put down.

This book not only had terror and suspense but also family dynamics and dysfunction, past trauma, and a little romance.

4.5 stars rounded up to 5⭐️

As always,I would like to thank Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me to have an advanced ebook copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This story follows a group of teens while at a wilderness camp for kids with behavioral issues. when I started it, i wasn’t expecting it to go the parnormal route, but I’m really glad it did. it helped bring life to the story. i really enjoyed this book.
The only thing I didn’t like was how the author put a note about wilderness camps, and this story almost paints it in a more positive light. Some of the characters talk about the growth this made them have. Any real story I’ve read or heard of these camps is a lot worse than what these kids were supposed to do, and I hate that it takes away from that. That caused me to take a star away.

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for the arc. All thoughts and feelings are my own.

Was this review helpful?

What the Woods Took is a gripping survival thriller that plunges readers into a nightmarish wilderness where the dangers are as psychological as they are physical. Devin Green is abducted from her home and dropped into the Idaho woods with a group of troubled teens, all under the guise of an experimental therapy program. As the counselors urge them to change their self-destructive ways through a grueling fifty-day hike, Devin is focused on one goal: escape. But as eerie, inhuman figures begin to haunt the woods, and the counselors vanish without a trace, survival becomes the only option. The campers must rely on one another, despite growing tensions and secrets they’re hiding from each other. The ominous presence lurking in the forest and the unraveling group dynamics create an intense, atmospheric read that keeps you questioning who or what is truly the threat.

Filled with suspense, What the Woods Took explores themes of trust, survival, and facing inner demons while navigating the dangers of both the natural world and human nature. The eerie setting, complex characters, and chilling twists make this a must-read for fans of psychological thrillers and dark, atmospheric mysteries.

Thank you to the publisher, author and Netgalley for an arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

In "What the Woods Took," Devin Green is abducted and taken to the woods. Once she arrives she realizes she and a group of other troubled teens have been enrolled in an experimental therapy program. Along with 2 counselors, the group must complete a 50-day hike while working through their behavioral and mental issues. Intent on finding a way out, Devin and the group began having spooky hallucinations and dreams. Once the counselors disappear the group finds themselves in danger and trying to survive the woods alone.

This book was a lot of fun! It leans more toward thriller than horror, but the unsettling supernatural elements kept me on edge. I'll be thinking about this one for a while.

Was this review helpful?

A breathtaking exploration of teenage trauma and the troubled teen industry, WTWT absolutely shook me to my core. Courtney deftly uses horror metaphors to depict various traumas that haunt the characters, and the result is spooky and utterly gut-wrenching. The sapphic enemies to lovers dynamic is done so incredibly well – one of the best I've read in recent memory. If I could give this 6 stars for my angel girl Sheridan who has never done anything wrong in her life, I would.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Wednesday Books and Netgalley for this eARC, these opinions are my own. Devin wakes up to people in room who drag her out to a wilderness survival camp. One of those camps that they send troubled youth to. There are with others, some she gets along with some she doesn’t, she’ll spend the next 50 days surviving in the woods. But are they really safe amongst the trees? With people seeing things, people disappearing, and the creepy forest vibes, can they survive? Courtney Gould captured the creepy intense vibe perfectly! As a read you’ll feel all the spooky vibes of being alone in a forest, the feelings of isolation! It definitely has you on edge while reading! The characters are also fantastic and you’ll enjoy the growth and connection between the characters, even as they figure out who they can trust and who has secrets! Great read if your looking for that intense thrill vibe!

Was this review helpful?

4.5 ⭐️
This was great!! It has all the reasons why sending your teen away just because they are “troubled” is wrong. It really has that thrilling feeling as you feel the emotions the mc is feeling. It was greatly written and I can wait to read more from the author!

#NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This was one of the most interesting plots I've read all year so far. I was expecting a pretty typical recovery program outing in the woods with a horror twist. I was not expecting a more sci-fi feel with shapeshifters. This added a whole new element of scary with characters mimicking people close to the victims they chose. This is the second book I've read from this author and it seems her writing just keeps improving. I couldn't predict what was to come in the story and that kept me reading. The only thing I wish was that the natural form of the mimics was described in greater detail as I had a difficult time picturing what they may have looked like. All in all, good story for those who love thrillers. You won't know what's coming.

Was this review helpful?

This is an account of survival, a tale of monstrous encounters, but above all, a narrative of discovering a sense of belonging within an unexpected group.

Well done.

Was this review helpful?

Devin’s story begins with a literal bang as she wakes up to find strangers in her bedroom, only to be dragged off to the middle of the Idaho woods. It’s such a jarring, unsettling beginning that had me immediately wondering what was going on and who I could trust.

What really stood out for me was the atmosphere. The author’s description of the remote forest setting made it easy to feel just as lost and isolated as the teens. I could almost hear the rustling of leaves and feel the unease creeping in as the group realized they were on their own. And the strange visions in the trees? That was a beautifully creepy touch that made me want to keep reading to see what was real and what was just in their heads.

The characters were definitely a highlight. Devin’s determination and courage made her an easy protagonist to root for, and I loved Ollie’s quieter strength and introspection. Both had distinct voices, and I felt deeply connected to their struggles. The way they clashed and came together with the other teens—especially with the abrasive, tough-as-nails Sheridan—felt authentic. Watching them try to figure out who they could trust and who was hiding secrets was so satisfying.

This book isn’t just a survival story; it’s also about growth, friendship, and overcoming trauma. The author handled those tough themes with so much care, and I could feel the raw emotions through the pages. By the end, I was so invested that I found myself wanting more. I’m really looking forward to whatever the author has in store next!

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Courtney Gould for providing me with a complimentary digital ARC for What the Woods Took coming out December 10, 2024. The honest opinions expressed in this review are my own.

I’ve read another book by this author. Her plots are really interesting to me. I really love horror books and she usually features creepy elements. I really loved the set up of this book. It’s compared to Yellowjackets and Girl, Interrupted. I love both of those! I think it look a little time to get into the book. I loved the horror survival aspects of the book. I think some things were a little slow for me. I would’ve liked a little more horror and scary things. I’d definitely read more books by this author!

I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys survival stories!

Was this review helpful?

CREEPY LESBIAN HORROR LOVERS GATHER ROUND!!!! If you want a true enemies to lovers book in a creepy, gross setting where the woods may or may not be deadly and most of the characters are lgbt? This is the book for you. I had chills after reading a few disturbing scenes! Please check content warnings as it can be dark at times. Other than that, I beg you, if you need a totally eerie, wild, body horror ride with a cute lesbian romance read it!!!

Was this review helpful?