Olivia Brannon’s deepest desire is to become a respected purveyor of antiquities, or antiquarian. Like an archaeologist, she imagines visiting distant lands to find rare and valuable items to procure for her vast clientele. And she would then provide a good living for herself and Laura, her younger sister. Were this 2024, the obstacles would prove minimal to someone with talent, like the lovely Miss Brannon. But she lives in 1820s London. This is a man's occupation.

Sarah E. Ladd’s The Cloverton Charade is an entertaining Regency-era mystery romance with a study in the differences between the coming-of-age experiences of young men and women. The conflicts explored are more than mere fiction. Women had few avenues for their lives. Most young ladies did not have a career. The most they could anticipate for themselves is life as a mother and a wife. And there’s nothing wrong with that. But Olivia wanted to be like her mother who had the added advantage of joining her father, Edward Brannon, on trips to seek out antiquities. They traveled to China, India, and Egypt. But mother died from diphtheria on a sea voyage to Italy. As a result, Edward believed travel too much for delicate females, so his daughters have always lived in their small sphere of London.

But this didn't stop Olivia from dreaming of a different life. She grew up learning about the trade of dealing in antiquities. Her father had a partner, another antiquarian, Timothy Avery. Their wives and children were close as well. When they had a falling out, they severed the relationship and became rivals. Mr. Brannon secured the deal of helping wealthy Francis Milton obtain his massive Chinoiserie Collection for their estate, Cloverton Hall, decorative items that depicted Chinese and Japanese motifs. (The name Milton sounded familiar. Perhaps a nod to Milton in the North of Elizabeth Gaskell's North & South fame?)

When the story opens in the prologue, 14-year-old Olivia runs into 17-year-old Lucas Avery. They both see a beautiful vase Olivia's father obtained for the Miltons. This scene will play out once more later in the story like a biblical type-scene, an event that recurs and is expected to unfold in a certain manner. When he died, Edward Brannon left his business in the hands of Uncle Thomas. Thomas doesn’t have the same level of excitement and interest as now 22-year-old Olivia. For the most part, he leaves the business in the seemingly capable hands of his second-in-command, Russell Crane. Olivia tries to do more than function as an assistant, but Uncle Thomas despite recognizing her knowledge, says she is “not an agent of Brannon Antiquities.”

But widowed Mrs. Agnes Milton offers the opportunity for Olivia to step into action as an agent and flex her antiquarian skill set. (Mrs. Milton has no desire to engage Thomas' services.) Mrs. Milton asks Olivia to evaluate her personal collection of antiques. She sets up the one part of the charade of the story. Olivia will pose as Mrs. Milton's friend and companion at nephew George Wainbridge’s House Party. He and his sister Isabella have asked Mrs. Milton to host this welcome-to-our-lovely-estate party in Yorkshire.

Olivia resonates with Mrs. Milton's desire to find financial autonomy with the sale of her collection. After all, she wants financial autonomy and self-sufficiency, not just for herself, but also to care for her sister Laura, 16. They can get out from under stifling Uncle Thomas and live. Plus, she understands grief and the desire to hold on to objects that remind us of a loved one who has died. Despite her misgivings about the ruse, Olivia has always wanted to step into her father's shoes. She agrees to help, so Mrs. Milton in return provides her modiste to prepare Olivia to play the role so she can evaluate the collection without raising suspicion.

George Wainbridge, the Miltons' nephew, inherited Cloverton and its properties, including Windhurst Manor on the estate. As long as he allows Mrs. Milton to live out her days at Cloverton, George will keep Windhurst, the only property earning an income. But Cloverton needs financial assistance. (I found this great blog post here about money concerns as a man of wealth and property back then.) Just like Mrs. Milton, George needs an antiquarian to evaluate the Chinoiserie collection in secret. Through a mutual acquaintance, William Tate, Lucas Avery is invited to join George at the Cloverton House Party and evaluate the famous Milton Chinoiserie collection.

The stage is set. The charade begins. The single ladies arrive with their chaperones. The men arrive with their valets ready for dancing, sport, port, and leisure...at least I think they drank port. They drank something anyway. (Probably smoked cigars, too. I know William Tate used snuff, too. Not a great habit. Surprise, surprise, even ladies indulged in this activity.)

A mystery unfolds as two people in trade navigate a world of wealth and privilege where everyone wears a mask for self-preservation, for keeping up with societal expectations, …or for committing a crime.

I’ll leave it there. I wrote in my notes that the first time Lucas and Olivia finally talk after seeing each other at Cloverton Hall took what felt like forever, leading to much suspense. Ladd is so great at that. And her descriptive scene-writing activated the theater of my mind. I needed no help imagining this opulent estate with so many antiquities, as well as the natural beauty of Yorkshire surrounding Cloverton Hall. I wanted to be Olivia and stay in the Blue Room…mostly because blue is my favorite color. The fact that Mrs. Milton can just barge in at any time since it’s attached to her suite...hmm, not so much.

The Cloverton Charade is a story with a mask-and-mirror theme. Olivia has only heard tales of London Seasons and house parties. She has a chance to wear the mask and play the role of a woman of wealth. In her disguise, she stares in the mirror and sees a stranger. She looks at the others around her as mirrors. She start to see what she lacks. The young ladies see Olivia as a mirror: their competition. They think she’s looking for a wealthy husband. To the men, Olivia indeed is this enchanting stranger. She doesn’t behave like most young women. She doesn’t play an instrument or sing. She doesn’t sew nor does she have needlework. She doesn’t draw or paint. Jane Austen’s Elizabeth Bennet in Pride & Prejudice came to mind. Lady Catherine interrogates poor Elizabeth Bennet in front of everyone at dinner about her lack of education most gentlemen’s daughters receive from governesses or tutors.

Olivia can only take off the mask with Lucas Avery. They share a past, a love for antiquities, and so much more. She does have a heart-to-heart eventually with Miss Wainbridge and learns that everyone wears a mask in this world as a wealthy member of the ton. No one feels safe to live an authentic existence. True friendship is rare.

I enjoyed this third book in Ladd’s Houses of Yorkshire collection that can be read as a standalone novel. She is one of my favorite writers of historical fiction in that she is a fine storyteller and teaches history through story, while also including faith-based answers to problems that fit every era. Thank you to Thomas Nelson for allowing me to receive a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed are completely my own.

Alicia and Lucas were the perfect rivals turned allies. I love that Alicia doesn't let others treat her as less in the business just because she's a woman. Sarah E Ladd did a great job making the book super entertaining and grabbing your attention from the very beginning. Such a fun book.

This book was so great! Full of mystery and especially fascinating antiquities, it was absolutely intriguing and romantic and delightful. I loved how Olivia and Lucas knew each other at some point as young people and then met again in this charade that they had to play in order to meet their goals. Olivia is a woman with incredible intelligence and cleverness when it comes to understanding the world of antiquities at this time, but she is a woman. She's expected to live the life of a young lady and leave her dreams behind in order to marry well. Lucas is struggling to bring stability and growth to his late father's business in antiquities. They are both discreetly invited to help in assessing the renowned Cloverton Hall collection.
As they both discover that there are counterfeits amongst the real pieces, they don't know who they can trust and eventually have to depend on each other to solve the mystery. I just loved how they come to know each other better and fall in love, as they work together to figure out what is truly happening at Cloverton Hall. Both Olivia and Lucas are such genuine and deep characters that want to do what is right and good. This was a perfect romance and mystery!

I received a copy of this book from Netgally, and all opinions are my own.

The Cloverton Charade by Sarah E. Ladd is a simple Regency novel that fans of this time period will enjoy spending time with. Ladd does a wonderful job of describing Cloverton and all the attendees to the parties that place at this Regency estate. She really invites readers into the setting and allows the readers to wonder and dance away the evening. As for the plot, the synopsis promised more. Reading this first sentence in the synopsis, “A long-held family feud reignites when two rival antiquities brokers arrive at the same house party in Regency England,” I was expecting a more of a rivalry that would break out and cause some issues to the plot, but it really does not affect the story that much. The antiques really do not come until investigation until about sixty percent into the novel. I wanted more of a mystery. As for the heroine and hero, they have a past since it is their families that are part of the rivalry that happened ten years ago. Their romance was quick, and they did not show any emotions toward each other for majority of the book. Overall, The Cloverton Charade by Sarah E. Ladd left me feeling like it was a blah- okay book. Not too great; Not too bad. Just there.

I received a complimentary copy of The Cloverton Charade by Sarah E. Ladd from Thomas Nelson Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.

This is a review for The Cloverton Charade by Sarah Ladd, and I received this copy for my review from NetGalley. I have been waiting for this book since I first heard it was coming out, as Sarah Ladd is one of my favorite authors, of whom I have all.her books! This book was so worth the wait, as I absolutely loved this story! It is set in the Regency era in Yorkshire, England, in 1810. The story begins with Olivia Brannon, the daughter of a very successful art dealer, whose father passes away, but who has taught Olivia the business, but sadly, upon her father's death, the business goes to her uncle who sees Olivia as more of a hired hand instead of letting her be a part of ongoing, successful business she should've inherited herself. She is allowed to help with the collection business, along with her friend Russell, but they both work for her uncle, who does not like to share the business with anyone!

Olivia is asked by the wife of one of her father's major collector clients, Mrs. Milton of Cloverton Hall to come and assess her husband's extensive collection, which she adores, because it is her one link to her beloved husband who has recently passed away. Since her husband has died, she needs to find out the collection's true monetary value quickly, so she goes to Olivia, whose father helped Mr. Milton purchase his collection. Olivia is thrilled that Mrs. Milton has come to her, but she is sworn to secrecy by Mrs. Milton, who invites Olivia, for appearance sake, to Cloverton Hall to secretly assess her husband's collection, which leads Olivia to get a glimpse into a life of luxury amongst the rich, but all isn't as it seems.

Since Mrs. Milton's husband has just died, and their nephew, George Wainbridge, will inherit Cloverton Hall, which is financially in trouble, so George also has ideas of selling his uncle's collection, which he doesn't care about in the slightest, but sees it only as a means to keep his estate running, but his aunt is standing in his way. George also needs to get the collection assessed to find out the value, so he hires the son of the arch rival of Olivia's father, Lucas Avery, who Olivia used to count as a close friend until their fathers, both art collectors and partners, had a falling out. Olivia was taught to avoid the Averys at all costs, but finds herself thrown together with Lucas at Cloverton Hall, both who are asked to asses its famous collection, but for two family rivals! Lucas and Olivia must decide to either stay enemies, or work together, but get caught up in a family feud that will lead them down a mysterious road of robbery, forgery and betrayal, but I won't spoil it!!!

This book engaged me from the first page, and was so well written, with amazing characters, and a plot that literally made me keep turning the pages because I was so engrossed! The ending led to a place that I least expected, and as I can't stand a book where I can figure out the plot, this book was awesome! It is right up there with the quality of books I have grown to love from this author! This regency era book is a very interesting and engaging art collection mystery that includes a hint of romance, and I loved it! So another 5 star book from Sarah Ladd, and I highly, highly recommend it!!!

What a sweet story and fun mystery! Maybe I didn't read the description well enough, because the mystery caught me off guard! But I ended up loving it! This book has a gentle pace, and a non-stress inducing conflict, which is just my style! Add in a strong female lead and a love story with an HEA, and you just have the whole sweet historical fiction romantic mystery package! Thank you to NetGalley for my arc! All opinions are my own!

The Cloverton Charade by Sarah E. Ladd is a captivating, unconventional, tale set in Regency England. I really enjoyed the character Olivia and her ability to appraise antiques. While she is a woman and cannot fully walk in her expertise to support her family’s business, she can discretely help a wealthy widow. Olivia is poised and educated, but she is not a classically trained gentlewoman who can impress others at a house party. Thankfully, she is there a companion to the eccentric widow and finds an ally in Lucas. There is something amiss as Olivia and Lucas realize they are both there to appraise the same collection and not all the items are what they seem. Rather than turn against each other, I enjoyed watching them come together and complement one another. The mystery was well paced and while not completely unpredictable, it was well done and held my attention all the way through. I love the attention to dialogue and character development.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher via NetGalley and all opinions expressed are solely my own, freely given.

I always love the author's book and this one was no surprise in that department.

House parties are a common setting in Regency novels, but this one's different: the party provides the perfect excuse for Alicia and Lucas to perform their work. They have both been hired separately to evaluate collections of antiques that could prove pivotal for each own's businesses. Of course, they recognize each other and know what they're really there for, even if the other guests are ignorant of the true reasons.

I liked how this premise set up the perfect setting for Alicia and Lucas to spend time together, appreciate the other's talents, and develop a friendship that only grows. The antiquities and forgery aspects were truly interesting, as it was the way Alicia and Lucas discovered what was going on.

Highly recommend this one. You don't have to read the series in order but it adds to the enjoyment.

I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.

In this clean regency story, Olivia and Lucas are rival antique dealers competing, albeit undercover, for a large chinoiserie porcelain collection commission. They both arrive to a large house party and discover a few strange things about the collection in question. They team up to solve the mystery, and find they enjoy one another's company more than expected in the process.

I've read several of Sarah Ladd's books, my favorites being The Heiress of Winterwood, and In the Shelter of Hollythorne House. Her books, including this title, are usually clean regency historical fiction storylines with a mix of mystery and chaste romance. I enjoy the authentic historical details she always adds into her books, and her atmospheric wording.

Unfortunately, this book was a miss for me. The first half of the book had scant plot development, and the pacing of the narrative structure felt really off and meandering. It was hard to remember all the names of the characters at the house party, and in the end it felt like too many people and not enough depth for anyone.

I didn't connect to the FMC or MMC, but I liked the fact that neither one was super-rich, which is frequently a regency plot line. The FMC and MMC were both likable characters, I just wished I could have connected to them more. I've never read a book about antiques before, and I appreciate that the author uses new ideas in her storylines.

Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson Fiction. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

"The Cloverton Charade" is a romance set in 1818 in England. Olivia's father taught her to be a competent antiquities dealer. But when he died, he left the entire business to his partner, her uncle, and she's now dependent on him. He resents her superior knowledge and won't even consider her as an employee of the business. When a recent widow asks Olivia to secretly assess her personal antiquities collection, Olivia hopes she'll prove her value and be allowed into the business. She has no desire to marry, just travel the world doing antiquities business (which, frankly, was an unrealistic hope considering the time period, even if she might be accepted locally).

I found it odd that Olivia's father left nothing for his daughters and that the rich man who died with at last two estates didn't leave anything for his wife. Usually the rich left the widow at least an allowance and a place to live for her lifetime, but this one basically gave everything (even unentailed property) to a nephew that he knew would have to be forced to promise to take care of the widow. This neglect of the men to provide for their women in their wills left me feeling like this was a fantasy rather than historical, but the story was generally enjoyable.

Lucas appreciated Olivia's knowledge and asked to consult with her. She liked feeling like she was appreciated for who she was and for her knowledge. He supported her goals and admired her beauty. Along the way, he uncovered a bunch of counterfeits in the antiquities he evaluated, and she helped uncover who was replacing the true items with fakes. There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this not-very-historical romance.

A great book about 2 protagonists in the world of antiquities who come together at Cloverton unexpectedly.

Olivia and Averys family had a falling out which put them at odds with each other. They are both trying to make their name I the world of antiquities. They work together to uncover the mystery around fakes at Cloverton.

A clean historical read, with some intrigue, but falls short on the development of the romance.

I went back-and-forth between giving this four stars and five stars. It was so very well written. There were many characters who were very well drawn and realistic for the times. There was very interesting and detailed information about the field of antiquities, and how various aspects of it worked. And there definitely was an intriguing mystery.

The two main characters, Lucas and Alicia, have some history from their childhood and teen years when their fathers were partners, but had a bad falling out.

They both wind up at a house party where they have been invited as guests who are also there to evaluate the valuable artifacts. Lucas is there on the invitation of the new heir and owner of the house. Alicia is there under the auspices of the aunt whose husband was the primary collector of everything and who wants to ensure that her own private artifacts are not claimed by her nephew.

Both Lucas and Alicia are shocked to see one another there, but they keep the knowledge of their former acquaintance private. They are both likable characters and, as they become aware of some counterfeit pieces, they begin to work together to resolve the mystery.

As others have said, this particular story seems to be more an historical fiction and less a romance. In fact, the romance didn’t really begin to develop until very near the end of the book. However, it was a very well written and interesting book, and I would rate it somewhere between four and five stars.

I was thankful to receive an ARC copy of this from NetGalley, and all the opinions above are my own.

A book by Sarah Ladd never disappoints and this one is no exception. The writing is excellent and the storyline is interesting. I would sometimes get lost in all the antiquities descriptions but it is still very interesting. I loved the mystery and romance that was included in this story as well.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

I usually enjoy Ladd's stories, but I struggled with this one. It didn't feel like true Christian fiction; it's just a clean story. I hate instant love stories: barely together the whole book, but in love at the end. I liked Olivia - she's a good heroine. Overall the story seems a bit oddly paced and I had a hard time connecting.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Wanting to become THE antiques dealer she knows she is she accepts an appraisal that set forth a future that may not have the consequences she desires. He is trying to set free a reputation not of his making. Can they together solve the mystery?
I really liked this novel. it has a strong woman trying to make it in a mans world even up against her own uncle. Add. Little romance and you have a sure fire way to win over a crowd, or a reader.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with guidelines.

First - thank you Thomas Nelson Fiction this ARC of The Cloverton Charade.

Great little series who a bit of a who dunnit feel. I really like the characters and how they grew in their friendship despite an uncomfortable situation.

I did see some foreshadowing for a bit in the middle - no give away - but was pleased with gen novel from start to finish. I nice cozy read.

I enjoy Sarah E Ladd’s works and have read a number of her books already

I just reviewed The Cloverton Charade by Sarah E. Ladd. #TheClovertonCharade #NetGalley

3.5/4
I definitely appreciate the author's careful research into the terms and antiques involved in this story, it tends to be glaringly obvious when they don't, and in this case it felt like the knowledge was genuine.

If I had to pick a few bones, the length/pacing occasionally felt long and a bit dragged at times. I would have also like to have spent more time building the relationship between Lucas and Olivia. It felt a bit like we just needed to accept them as a couple over believing it or watching it grow.

Overall an enjoyable read even though I'm more of an open door romance reader 😀

Thanks NetGalley for this ARC.

In this third installment of the Houses of Yorkshire series, the lovely Olivia Brannon's unconventional interest in antiquities, developed through her father's business, convinces her to accept an invitation that could change her future forever - the chance to evaluate a private collection housed at Cloverton Hall. She arrives to find that Lucas Avery, who was once an old friend but is now her adversary, has his own antiquities work at Cloverton that put her efforts at risk. When the two of them stumble upon a dangerous plot, they must decide whether to risk their future by working together to uncover the truth.

This book combines swoony romance, fascinating history, and fabulous character-building, all in one cozy mystery package. I highly recommend it!

Olivia Brannon is a passionate expert in the field of antiquities. But as a woman in regency England, she is held back from pursuing her dream to be a respected antiquities broker, while both propriety and a lack of fortune prevent her from traveling to distant lands as she also desires.

An underappreciated resource in the antiquities business her uncle inherited from her father, Olivia jumps when a rare opportunity comes her way. The widow of a longtime client of her father’s desires her collection to be appraised, but because her husband’s estate was entailed to a nephew, it needs to be under the guise of entertaining a house guest for a country party. Agnes Milton hires Olivia, even going so far as to furnish her with a posh wardrobe for the ruse.

At Cloverton Hall, however, Olivia encounters much more than she expects. One thing is the shallow, snobbish attitude of the other young women at the party, rivals in the ‘game’ of the marriage market. And rather than quietly fade into the background, Olivia’s unexpected presence and her lack of typical ladies’ pursuits makes her more intriguing to all. Including Lucas Avery, son of her father’s business rival and former friend. Both Lucas and Olivia are shocked to see each other again and both come bearing secrets, for Lucas has been hired by the nephew, Wainbridge, to appraise his uncle’s collection. When Lucas and Olivia discover counterfeit pieces, it sets in motion unexpected events that draw them closer to each other and to discovering the truth.

Olivia’s character was refreshingly real and stood up for herself and her ideals firmly but quietly, which I loved. I enjoyed this book very much.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Overall the story was interesting enough to keep me turning the pages. I just had a hard time connecting with the story at times. Sometimes it took its times but then it made other parts short lived and details sparse. Wish there had been more focus on Lucas and Olivia. I feel like it was insta love at the end of the book vibes because their encounters were so brief prior to. I was also disappointed that it is listed as Christian fiction on goodreads yet there wasn't an ounce of such in the book outside of closed door and clean language, it was just stated somebody cursed with no curse word. Also there was a lot of focus on alcohol intake and observation of such by the mfc as she didn't know what to make of dealing with talking to intoxicated people. It just felt unnecessary. Overall my favorite in this Trilogy was as they were presented. One being my favorite "The Letter From Briarton Park"
Thank you netgalley for allowing me to read. This is my honest opinion.