I hate to say this but I think this was a last shot for Lucy Foley for me. I absolutely love the Hunting Game and since that one they have all kind of been blah.

Midnight Feast is about a 15 year mystery and one woman’s plot to reveal that mystery at any cost. The plot wasn’t bad, and the pacing was good. The author has a gift for describing locations. If it wasn’t for the snooty people, murder, and crazy, dramatic people, I’d want to visit.

I didn’t like most of the characters and couldn’t relate to any of them. I also prefer to steer away from pagan-filled books. It’s just a personal preference. All in all the book had a lot of positive parts.

I received this ARC from NetGalley for my honest review.

First of all, I received this as an e-ARC so thank you Harper Collins and Lucy Foley. This will be a more critical review so if you do not like to read critical/negative reviews, this is your warning.

This book was not terrible by any means. It had an interesting plot but the execution did not quite meet the mark. From the very beginning, the book jarringly jumps from pov to pov, from far past to recent past to present and back, completely disorienting me so I had no idea what was going on and not in a good way. It took me quite a while to understand what was happening and the motivations of each character.

The villain is predictable. You see it coming a mile away. I hope that wasn't intended to be a mystery because that failed miserably. This is read kind of like a party island mystery where you're introduced to five to ten different characters and you learn who they are over time, however there is also a time jumping element including diary entries that make it far too confusing.

The twist at the end was far too CONVENIENT to be believable. A little bit of it would have been fine but the author went overboard, making me questions the laws of statistics. There is no way it would have happened to work out so perfectly. Just not possible.

That being said, I did not hate the book. It was still mildly entertaining and it was not a struggle to get through. What helped was listening to the audiobook which has a cast of voice actors for each character, which I love! It was kind of fun to read and I don't regret it at all, but it was just not something to write home about. It wasn't bad and it wasn't good. To paraphrase Emma Skies, it was a book.

The Midnight Feast by Lucy Foley is an atmospheric read that expertly blends mystery and suspense. Set in an isolated location, the story pulls you into its world from the first page, with well-drawn characters and a plot that keeps you guessing.

Foley’s writing is engaging, and her ability to build tension and keep readers on edge is impressive. The atmosphere she creates, particularly through the setting, eerie undertones, and multiple points of view, is what makes the book stand out. Each chapter reveals more layers, keeping the pace steady and making it difficult to put down.

The characters are well-developed, with motivations that feel believable, though there were moments where a few of them could have been explored further. That said, the story is strong enough to make up for this minor flaw, and the ending is satisfying, if a bit predictable. It’s the perfect read for fans of psychological thrillers.

Overall, The Midnight Feast is a captivating, well-paced novel that will keep you intrigued and entertained from start to finish. It’s a perfect choice for those who enjoy atmospheric mysteries with rich character dynamics.

Thank you William Morrow and NetGalley for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.

Lucy Foley's books just FEEL good, somehow. This one was no exception! I loved the setting and the vibe.

AMAZING. No notes, my favorite Lucy Foley ever. I think this should be on the top of anyone's Lucy favorites!

The Midnight Feast by Lucy Foley was an enthralling and entertaining read from start to finish. Set against the picturesque Dorset coast, the novel centers on the grand opening of The Manor, a luxurious wellness retreat owned by Francesca Meadows. Foley masterfully crafts an atmosphere thick with tension, as the opulence of The Manor starkly contrasts with the unease of the local community.

The narrative unfolds through multiple perspectives, each adding depth to the intricate plot. The dual timelines seamlessly weave together past and present, gradually revealing long-buried secrets and simmering resentments. Foley’s portrayal of the enigmatic group known as “The Birds” adds a layer of mystique, intertwining local folklore with the unfolding drama.

What I found particularly compelling was Foley’s critique of the commercialization of wellness culture. Through Francesca’s character, the novel delves into the commodification of ancient practices, highlighting the tension between genuine spirituality and its monetized counterparts. This theme is explored with nuance, prompting reflection on the authenticity of modern wellness trends.


Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Lucy foleys books are hit or miss for me. The premise of this one sounded good but there were a lot. Of characters POVs in the beginning and it was a bit hard to follow. I made it to the end but this was not my favorite by her.

The Midnight Feast by Lucy Foley had me hooked from the very first page. The luxurious setting of The Manor made for the perfect setting for a thriller/who-dun-it. As the book starts, you can feel the dark secrets of the past slowly creeping in. The cultish undertones definitely added a unique twist, although at times, I felt like the plot dragged a little.

That said, the twist at the end? I actually gasped out loud! The way everything wrapped up was satisfying, and it made all the slow-burn moments worth it. If you're a fan of suspenseful, atmospheric thrillers with a dose of mystery and a shocking conclusion, The Midnight Feast is definitely worth reading. It’s a bit slow at times, but the ending more than makes up for it.

Unfortunately, this one didn't really do it for me. The premise and setting were both very interesting,but there were far too many characters to keep track of and I found it grating. I wanted the folklore aspect to be expanded and more central.

This thriller was able to give me all the heebie jeebies. This book expertly took ‘give people the creeps’ and ran with it.

I appreciated the twists and turns and while a few may have been a little more predictable, the ending was one I didn’t expect. This author definitely kept me on my toes and I love that from a thriller novel as most are usually reasonably easy to figure out.

✨ Midnight Feast ✨

I do not read a lot of thrillers, but I really enjoy Lucy Foley's books. When I had a chance to read The Midnight Feast, I jumped on it! This was a wild ride. I was completely creeped out and the moment I thought I had it all figured out...nope, think again! There was a little much of an emphasis on "The Birds" and took me a bit to get into it, but I got into it by the end.

📚 Book: ⭐️⭐️⭐️.5

Thank you so much to Lucy Foley and William Morrow for the gifted arc.

A great mystery/thriller vacation read! You can always count on multiple povs and the characterization of the setting with Lucy Foley, but this story added time jumps which were at times confusing to follow. I really loved the folklore elements (the birds!) and the way she continues to explore themes of class and moral ambiguity in every novel. Will definitely be recommending this one!

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for gifting me this advanced reader copy.

Lucy foley is such a hit or miss author for me and unfortunately this one was a miss. I just don’t think her writing style and plots really work for me.

this story surrounds a group of rich people who are surrounded by a mysterious forest and mysterious birds. Like so many birds. The plot was very lackluster and I had a hard time staying interested in it.

This is considered a thriller but honestly there’s no thrilling aspects to it. Sometimes books surround annoying rich people is fun. This was not one of those times. They truly were just annoying.

But that being said just because I didn’t enjoy this book doesn’t mean others won’t love it! I know this story could work really well for others.

I was excited to read the new Lucy Foley thriller, and this book did not disappoint. It is set in a historical country house turned wellness retreat for the ultra wealthy. The story jumps from several points of view and several of the characters have hidden connections to this place buried in their past. This book was full of twists and turns I wasn't expecting, and it was a fun read.

This is a typical Lucy Foley book, several storylines, a lot of back and forth in the timeline, and lots of twists. I did feel like this one was a little harder to follow than the others, but still enjoyed it!

Posted on GR & StoryGraph 12/16

Thanks to NetGalley for an ARC of this book. I love Lucy Foley's books, and this one is just as good. It has mystery, intrigue, hidden identities, and secret societies. If you enjot mystery and thrillers you should read this one.

It’s the opening night of The Manor, a hot, new luxury resort, and everything is perfect— until it isn't. Local folklore warned something bad would happen, and now the past comes back to crash the party. Fans of The White Lotus will love this whodunnit, told through altering viewpoints and time periods.

This was a bit of a hard book to get into as you are introduced to so many characters right away and then realize many of them have more than one name. However, if you can make it to about the 50% mark things start to come together and make sense. Justice is served to the person in this story who most deserved it and families were brought back together. It was heart-warming at the end.

“I received a free copy of this book via NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving a review.”

My favorite part about this book was the “Old Birds” pun at the end.

My least favorite part was everything else.

But I have loved all her other books!!☹️🤷🏻‍♀️