3.5 stars rounded up. This was a fun, fast-paced mystery thriller. I liked the characters and friendships in this one. I could picture the story being made into a movie.

It's always fun reading books with a lot of suspects. I actually didn't guess the killer in this one. It's not the most original plot but I did like this one overall. It's an entertaining quick read.

I read an ARC of this book from NetGalley. All comments are my own.

I was very excited going into this story but it all just fell flat. The cover was what really made me read the book. Probably shouldn’t read a book based on the cover.

The plot was a bit interesting don’t get me wrong, like I was interested to figure out who was the killer. The pacing of the book and the writing were both fine but it didn’t just grip me to just continue reading, I took so many breaks in the day reading this book due to not actually caring about the build up.

The explanations to what happened felt so flat. There was so many things that weren’t explained or if it was it wasn’t explained well enough. The killer felt like it was a last minute decision reveal. Also didn’t really liked how they took to discovering the killer, like they just picked some people that seemed suspicious and went with it.

Bett felt underdeveloped, like the author just write her there for the plot, she’s felt so bland. She has no characteristics, the only one she has is being the murderer daughter. Being the murderer daughter was her whole personality, she stayed in the past and didn’t even think about the future. Like for example whenever someone mentioned her mum she quickly shut down and stopped talking to that person ever again. Eugenia on the other hand was also just there, like I just don’t get the point of her being there. There friendship also felt so forced, like Eugenia saves her at a party and they decided to have a sleepover and suddenly Bett accepts the request of finding out the killer after not even being there for two hours.

Overall this was just okay, like the whole plot is interesting but I just don’t think it was done well enough with characters being so bland and having no knowledge of anything they’re doing.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this arc in exchange for an honest review.

Enjoyable plot and characters.
Lots of mystery and although I solved it before the end, the killer wasn't immediately oobvious.
Well written and thought out characters, although I found the main character a bit too much at times.

If you like murder mysteries, family secrets and amateur detectives who are better at their jobs than the police force, you should give this a read!

Thank you to netgalley for the free ARC. This is my unbiased opinion.

Dead Girls Talking was a very cute and sweet murder mystery following 2 girls who didnt start out and friends, but allowed the friendship to grow throughout the book.
I thought that the "murder" part was so cool and unique, however the "mystery" wasnt really there for me. At times I wast really interested and just thought that there wasnt enough added to the story to give it that WOW.
I enjoyed the way Bettina was written and found her a strong main character.

Thank you so much for allowing me to read this book!

I really need the YA genre to stop making every adult a useless moron just so some plucky teens can unmask the killer and save the day. it's causing me physical pain at this point.

So much of Eugenia's and Bett's "investigation" didn't make much sense to me. They said it couldn't be the trucker who killed Melissa because of the old matchbook. But they didn't think twice about suspecting Xavier, who's even younger than the trucker. Why was the matchbook even at the scene? The killer just happened to have this decade old matchbook lying around and then dropped it at the crime scene? Did they drop it on purpose or..?

Eugenia and Bett figured it must be a serial killer but made completely different suspect lists for each victim, googled their way through "how to solve a crime," trampled on an active crime scene, and in the end never even guessed at who the killer was. It felt like Bettina was getting drunk at least as much as she was going around harassing people with questions that ended up being pointless, since they never once suspected the actual killer.

This has an interesting premise and a great cover, but unfortunately I didn't find the story to be a very engaging or enjoyable read.

DNF @ 20%
Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC!

Unfortunately I was just not feeling this one. Right off the bat, I did not vibe with the MC, which, to me, is the most important part of a book, because the main character is the one you follow the story with. Furthermore, I just did not care to find out who the real killer is; I didn't feel any intrigue around the mystery.

to say im disappointed in this is a understatement. first i would like to say is i was very excited about this. when I first seen the cover i knew i had to read it, then i read the description and was over the moon. lately I’ve been into young adult murder mysteries/ thrillers (I’ve recently read a ya series and fell in love with it) so i knew what i was getting myself into when reading this (or so i thought)

I understand young adult is targeted towards a younger audience but I enjoy a good young adult book from time to time.

Now I had a couple problems with this book.

first the writing style (yes I understand it’s ya) felt really mediocre even for the genre, when I say this I mean one page it’ll be good and then out of nowhere they throw in words that could’ve been replaced with a simpler word rather than a big complicated word whereas a younger audience would get confused by it. (even I found myself confused😭)

Second there was a scene towards the beginning where the main character was having a sexual encounter with someone and it didn’t feel right to read it in a young adult novel. The scene wasn’t very explicit but it still felt like it was too much for it to be in this.

Third: this is very fast paced. Don’t get me wrong I love a good fast paced book here and there but I felt like we just got thrown into this with no buildup or anything. One page there’s a body and the next she’s making friends with the other main character and trying to discover the killer.

Fourth: honestly all the characters felt like they were just there 🧍🏻‍♀️and what I mean by that is that they didn’t feel real, they felt undeveloped and had no emotions or anything. The mc’s “love interest” was boring and felt he was just there to add nothing to this story except being a “mysterious bad boy” who is interested in the mc’s mothers death.
The second mc Eugina was literally the best character and still she gave us nothing 😀. Her relationship with the mc Bettina was so random? I understand being in high school and not knowing some of your classmates even though you’ve been going to the same school for years but how they became friends was thrown at me out of nowhere.
In the beginning Eugina is giving and presentation in class and Bettina makes a comment basically bullying her and the class laughs and next thing you know Bettina is inviting her to a party and boom they form a friendship and start looking into the murders because you know Eugina is the morticians daughter 😀

There’s also many plot holes in the story that we never get an answer too and the story felt unfinished.

I could keep going on and on about this book and everything I didn’t like about it but I will spoil the story.
Maybe it’s because im older and the genre isn’t targeted towards me and that’s why I didn’t like it? I hope anyone who does pick this up in the future enjoys its more than I did.

thank you netgalley and the publisher for sending me a free copy in exchange for an honest review!!

I really enjoyed this story! it was an amazing ya thriller/mystery and I really liked the way the story turned! there were a few moments where I couldn't really understand what they were doing and I was kind of annoyed at them but if you keep in mind that the characters are teenagers and its a fiction book it doesn't hurt the story! I would definitely recommend it!

(thank you netgalley for this arc-copy)

Thank you NetGalley for giving me early access to this book.

I really liked the premise of this book. Ultimately I think it missed the mark. The FMC was a bit annoying. At the end of the day, she was an upper class white girl. It was kind of hard to see sympathy in her plights outside obviously the murder of her mother. Obviously I could have missed the point entirely. The “approach to justice and female anger” was painted in the relationships the FMC has with men but that’s also where it stopped until we got to our killer. I think there was a opportunity to work more commentary.

The plot was…oddly worked. Once we get to the end it’s a reveal of the truth and the why but no explanation to the how? None of the stuff she did prior seemed to matter/influence then climax of the story which was finding out who is behind it all. All in all, the premise was great but I think this one just fell a little flat.

It took me a bit to get into this story. Bettina has a pretty rough exterior she has grown up being the girl whose father is a convicted killer.
The characters especially Bettina, aren't easy to like. However, as the story progressed I did like her friendship with Eugenia. They are an unlikely duo, but seemed to fit.

When Bettina stumbles across a young woman dead in the woods, and the body is eerily similar to that of her mother Bettina starts to question whether he is the killer. As she and Euginia start digging into her father's conviction things begin to jump out that maybe the police and her grandparents are hiding something.

I enjoyed seeing Bettina realize that things aren't as black and white as she always thought, and make a good friend. The twists and turns this story took were surprising and kept me guessing.

Dead Girls Talking" is a riveting thriller that expertly intertwines a compelling murder mystery with poignant explorations of justice, trauma, and female empowerment. This novel captivates from the very first page, maintaining a relentless pace that keeps readers on the edge of their seats until the very end.


The story centers around Bettina, known as Bett, who has lived under the dark shadow of her father's alleged crime—murdering her mother a decade ago. This gruesome event has permeated her life, becoming fodder for podcasts, murder tours, and an eagerly awaited docuseries. However, a series of copycat murders shakes her belief in her father's guilt, prompting her to reconsider the facts. To uncover the truth, Bett teams up with Eugenia, a bookish goth girl and the mortician's daughter, who is just as misunderstood and intriguing as the mysteries they seek to solve. Together, they dive into an investigation that challenges everything Bett thought she knew, revealing a killer alarmingly close to home.

"Dead Girls Talking" delves into significant issues, such as the societal obsession with true crime, the quest for justice, and the simmering anger that can accompany unresolved trauma. Peterson's writing is both sharp and evocative, creating a wire-taut atmosphere that enhances the novel's suspense. Her wicked sense of humor provides a perfect counterbalance to the story's darker elements, making for a truly engaging read.

This novel stands out not only for its thrilling plot but also for its insightful commentary on larger societal issues. It’s gritty and propulsive, with enough twists to keep even the most seasoned mystery readers guessing. Peterson's ability to combine humor with a serious exploration of justice and female rage sets this book apart in the crowded thriller genre.

I would rate "Dead Girls Talking" a solid 4 out of 5 stars. It’s an engrossing and thought-provoking read that effectively combines a gripping mystery with deeper thematic content. Fans of true crime and strong female leads will find much to love in this novel. The slight deduction is only because a few plot points felt a bit predictable, but overall, it’s a standout thriller that I highly recommend.

One of my reading goals for this year was to read more different genres. I never really read mysteries or thrillers, but really wanted to read some more. The only other mystery I read before was the Good Girls Guido to Murder series and I would definitely recommend Dead Girls Talking to fans of GGGTM.

Dead Girls Talking is about Bettina and how her dad allegedly murdered her mom. Everyone is convinced that it was him, until more young girls get murdered the same way, ages after the first death and while he's still in prison. Is a copycat killer on its way, or is Bett's dad back?

It took me some time to get into the story. A lot of the characters got me really frustrated, and it annoyed me a lot that apparently nobody can do their job properly. It was still interesting to read and see how Bett's and Eugenia's friendship developed and how they tried to murder the mystery.

Some scenes felt a bit unnecessary and Bett and Eugenia judged the other people really fast without any real evidence.

The writing was okay and I had a lot of fun reading the story and tying to figure out who the murder was.

I gave the book 3.5 stars. Thank you to Netgalley and Holiday House for this EARC!

"Dead Girls Talking" delves into the gripping tale of Bettina's father, who stands accused of her mother's murder, amidst a series of similar killings in Wolf Ridge. The central question looms: Did her father truly commit the crime?

The narrative unfolds through the perspectives of two key characters: Bett, the daughter grappling with her father's alleged actions, and Eugenia, the mortician's daughter. Together, they embark on a quest to unravel the town's unsettling mystery.

One notable drawback of the novel lies in its underdeveloped characters, including the protagonist Bett, who feels disappointingly one-dimensional. In a genre reliant on nuanced characterizations to drive suspense, this limitation detracts from the believability of potential plot twists.

Similarly, the execution of plot twists falls short, with theories presented in a cursory manner lacking depth and substantiation. This weakens the impact of the narrative's pivotal moments, relying too heavily on blind trust rather than credible groundwork.

While comparisons to other works can be divisive, "Dead Girls Talking" seems to echo elements of "A Good Girl's Guide to Murder," raising questions of originality. However, where the novel shines is in its meticulously crafted plot, where every detail serves a purpose, and the pacing remains consistently gripping, delivering a truly unputdownable mystery experience.

In conclusion, while "Dead Girls Talking" may not fully satisfy those seeking complex characters and well-executed plot twists, its meticulously plotted narrative and brisk pacing still make it a worthwhile read for mystery enthusiasts.

Everybody needs a Eugenia in their life 🩵

Holy shit, what was that? This book kept me guessing until the end. The author did an amazing job with this story and the development of the characters. I was so frustrated with that chief of police (Bigsby) 😭 I didn’t saw that plottwist coming and didnt expect to be so invested in this story.
This book reminded me why I love reading mystery/thriller books! I’m really excited to read more by this author, this book deserves all the hype!!
Thank you Netgalley and Holiday House / Peachtree / Pixel + Ink for this arc and for reminding me why I love this genre so much 🫶🏻

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC! I was looking forward to reading this book and it definitely lived up to my expectations. The characters were fun and well-rounded and I loved the storyline! I would recommend this for any thriller/true crime fans!

I PRIDE myself in knowing/ being able to predict the endings of the mystery and or thriller books I read and Dead Girls Talking TOOK ME OUT.

It had me so strong in my wrong about who was responsible for the deaths in the story. I’m telling you, when you think you’ve got it figured out, you don’t. I love love LOVED this book and I’m already excited to re-read it to see what clues I missed. I also hope there might be a sequel in the future…

Perfect for readers who enjoy YA fiction and fans of Frieda McFadden and Noelle W. Ihli

Dead Girls Talking is scheduled for release June 18th, 2024 and will be a physical must buy for me.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author and the publisher for an arc of this book. All opinions are my own.

This was a really fast-paced and interesting mystery book. While I was suspicious, I couldn't guess the ending and that is always a plus for me! The writing was good and I really liked the main character and the other key characters as well. Overall, the mystery pulled me in and I enjoyed the investigation.

I really recommend this to YA mystery lovers looking for a quick and fun read!

★ ★ ★ • 3

What first drew me to this book was definitely the cover, but the summary and the sapphic mystery components definitely sounded promising. That said… I unfortunately did not find myself enjoying this book very much.

I didn’t have problems with the storyline itself, but the writing did at times feel overly immature regardless of Dead Girls Talking being a young adult novel. Which then in turn made it hard to like or even care about the events in the plot as well as the characters. In addition to that, the ending was somewhat abrupt and overall underwhelming. I finished the book, but it’s not something I’d reread or recommend.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC for review!

"Violence seems to be a language all men speak."


perfect YA crime solving novel with a non-glamorizing look at true crime 🙏 it hit all the marks, from stupid teenage behavior to plot progression and ultimately the crime solved, though it was partly pretty predictable. Eugenia was kind of cliché yet the best character of the book, "women help women" 👑


[review posted on goodreads]

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the digital copy.


TRIGGER WARNINGS: violence, domestic abuse, murder, blood, alcohol and drug use by minors.


Bett has been trying to escape the attention her mother's murder by her father has brought upon her all her life, and as the tenth anniversary of Prudence McGrath's death approaches, things can only get worse - she doesn't even have anyone to confide in because she ended her friendship with Natalie when Nat's mother, to save the financial situation of her own bar, decided to create a macabre tour of Prudence's last days and places. According to Lydia, it is to honor Prudie's memory, but for Bett it is only exploitation of her pain.

And then the prosecutor who had handled the trial of her father - who she herself helped send to prison with her testimony at the age of six - commits suicide and her grandparents want her to stay absolutely away from the funeral and the widow. As if that wasn't enough, another body of another girl turns up in town - a girl very similar to Bett's mother, killed in the exact same way and it is Bett who finds her.

But no one in Wolf Ridge seems to take this girl's death seriously - girls and women in general in Wolf Ridge seem to be considered less than zero, as something replaceable at any moment. The only other person who takes the matter to heart is Eugenia Cline, the undertaker's daughter, who proposes to Bett a hunt for the killer - and if this killer is not a copycat, the prospect that the real killer has always been out free confronts Bett with the possibility that her father was always as innocent as he has claimed for the past decade and that's something Bett isn't ready to accept.

The investigations bring Bett and Eugenia closer and closer to danger and the number of bodies increases and perhaps Bett even risks being the next victim...


"Dead Girls Talking" has a good narrative structure and a good pace, which I would have enjoyed more if I hadn't been in reader's block and hadn't had to stop reading for days on end due to work commitments. But even when I couldn't move forward with the story, I kept thinking about it.

Bett has a rich family and this has always bothered others, although she has never abused her privileges and above all she has never asked for it. She lives in a bubble created by her overprotective grandparents, not only because of what happened to her mother but precisely because they want to prevent Bett from ruining her future by finding herself a "poor guy" like Prudence had done with Trapper. I admit that I therefore despised Bett's grandparents a lot, always snotty with everyone who doesn't belong to the same social class as them and several times they made me suspect that they were hiding something that they didn't want Bett to know.

The novel, however, focuses a lot on the aspect of friendship and female solidarity, on how women should support and protect each other - be there for each other and form a common front in the face of a mentality that sees them only as a body of to dispose of as you wish.

Bett and Eugenia examine several suspects, but in fact no one stands out more than the others - and Trapper may or may not be innocent, but we know for sure from Bett's memories and the testimonies of others that his marriage to Prudence was not a bed of roses, that they argued a lot and that he was also violent.

The discovery of the murderer is quite surprising, but when you then look back and put the pieces together, you realize that many things were right under our noses. But the ending isn't all roses either because justice is never perfect and Bett and Eugenia have proof that you can invoke all the female solidarity you want, but revenge and jealousy and psychological manipulation will always get the better of common sense. The real serial killer will be put behind bars, but it's not the perfect ending that all the victims in this story deserved - and we have plenty of lives ruined whether permanently or not here.

"Dead Girls Talking" is not a novel that focuses so much on wanting to scare the reader with plot twists, but rather wants to make him reflect on what lies behind and at the basis of every relationship and how easy it is to be manipulated and used by someone else who only looks after their own interests, not caring about everything and everyone and any consequences.